Which Side Are You On?

I’m a bit surprised by Anne-Marie Slaughter’s New York Times op-ed. In it she urges the president not only to use military force in Iraq against the ISIS terrorists but to expand hat use into Syria:

President Obama should be asking the same question in Iraq and Syria. What course of action will be best, in the short and the long term, for the Iraqi and Syrian people? What course of action will be most likely to stop the violence and misery they experience on a daily basis? What course of action will give them the best chance of peace, prosperity and a decent government?

The answer to those questions may well involve the use of force on a limited but immediate basis, in both countries. Enough force to remind all parties that we can, from the air, see and retaliate against not only Al Qaeda members, whom our drones track for months, but also any individuals guilty of mass atrocities and crimes against humanity. Enough force to compel governments and rebels alike to the negotiating table. And enough force to create a breathing space in which decent leaders can begin to consolidate power.

Here is the part that puzzles me:

This is not merely a humanitarian calculation. It is a strategic calculation. One that, if the president had been prepared to make it two years ago, could have stopped the carnage spreading today in Syria and in Iraq.

I don’t know that anyone has been urging action against both the Assad regime and the rebels. My recollection is that they’ve been urging us to support “moderate rebels” against the regime as though the various groups were completely discrete and there were a litmus test for distinguishing between the moderates and immoderates.

On the other hand if our main priority had been preventing the rise of radical Islamist militants like ISIS we’d’ve supported the Assad regime.

Update

As is not entirely surprising, the editors of the New York Times sound a similar note:

If Mr. Obama decides to take military action, he must make it clear that it would not be done to support Mr. Maliki’s government, but to disrupt the militants’ momentum while the Iraqi Army regroups.

In the meantime, the administration has to develop better intelligence on the militants’ movements. It plans to provide more weapons to the Iraqi Army, even though major units disintegrated as the militants swept through northern Iraq. American officials say there are still capable Iraqi units to build on, but that seems a risky bet.

Whatever action Mr. Obama takes, it must be grounded in a larger political strategy that considers the full spectrum of sectarian dangers that are roiling the region. On Monday night, militants reached Baquba, about 40 miles north of Baghdad, before being turned back. In a horrific show of sectarian reprisal, 44 Sunni prisoners held in a Baquba police station, controlled by the Shiite-led government, were killed by the police as the Sunni militants attacked the station.

9 comments

Life in a Dog Pack: Kara Meets the Snow

There is nothing that quite compares with the incredible joy with which a Samoyed greets the snow. It is her element. She was born for it. The cold was so bitter during Kara’s earliest puppyhood that we have every reason to believe that the first time she went out-of-doors was when she came to us.

It may be due to that that Kara’s attitude towards the out-of-doors is different from that of our other Samoyeds. She likes it, of course, but she doesn’t crave it the way our others do. She likes being indoors nearly as well.

The world is so big and I am so small. It doesn’t stand a chance.

Outdoor plumbing in the winter time isn’t as cozy as it sounds.

I’m not sure what she’s going after in this picture.

Everything is so interesting. What is that peeking out through the snow? And is it edible?

It’s always nice to have someone to look up to. Especially when that person has an extremely interesting toy.

5 comments

What Would Make Hillary (Not) Run?

Tom Bevan presents five reasons that Hillary Clinton will not run for president:

  • She’s a poor campaigner
  • Her desire to be president might not be great enough
  • It won’t be a coronation
  • Obama is leaving a mess
  • The country is hungry for change

Rather than making an argument as to why she won’t run, I think that Mr. Bevan is actually making a better case for why if she runs she won’t win.

I think a better argument was made a while ago and which I took note of at the time, that this whole fan dance has been a cynical ploy for making money.

Quite to the contrary, I think that a taste for the presidency is an appetite that doesn’t go away and she’s had it for some time. Remember too, the notions of risk and reward required to seek and gain high political office are very different than yours or mine. Politicians are constitutionally optimistic, not inclined to consider costs, and inclined to over-estimate their own abilities. I wouldn’t be at all surprised if Mitt Romney ran again.

20 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

All Things Pass

There’s more than one way of thinking about how events in Iraq will unfold.

5 comments

Best Most Expensive Care Anywhere

The century-old Commonwealth Fund has published its findings comparing the U. S. healthcare system with those of other OECD countries:

The United States health care system is the most expensive in the world, but this report and prior editions consistently show the U.S. underperforms relative to other countries on most dimensions of performance. Among the 11 nations studied in this report—Australia, Canada, France, Germany, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Sweden, Switzerland, the United Kingdom, and the United States—the U.S. ranks last, as it did in the 2010, 2007, 2006, and 2004 editions of Mirror, Mirror. Most troubling, the U.S. fails to achieve better health outcomes than the other countries, and as shown in the earlier editions, the U.S. is last or near last on dimensions of access, efficiency, and equity. In this edition of Mirror, Mirror, the United Kingdom ranks first, followed closely by Switzerland (Exhibit ES-1).

Read it and weep. Even more importantly from my point of view the second-worst system is Canada’s while the third-worst is France’s. Since Canada is the OECD country that most closely resembles ours culturally and from a lifestyle standpoint, I think that’s a significant finding, suggesting that even if we were to adopt, say, a single-payer system that would be merely the beginning of the reforms that would be needed here if we truly want to have the best of class healthcare system to which we aspire.

It won’t be enough to change who writes the checks. Under the circumstances we might want to consider figuring out what we’re doing wrong and what policies would foster the other changes we’d need to make. The politically-impossible change to a single-payer system could turn out to be the least of our problems.

6 comments

Buying an E-Reader

Last week I bought an e-reader. I had a very specific reason. In connection with my new gig I recognized it would be prudent to read up on some subjects on which I’m presently a bit fuzzy which in turn entails buying and reading quite a number of relatively expensive books. Those books are available at significantly lower cost in electronic format.

Now buying something like this is a much more personal choice than you might think and the reality is that there is no one right answer. What looks fine to you might not look fine to me and vice versa.

After studying, reviewing, testing, and conferring on every e-reader and tablet I could put my hands on I finally decided (somewhat to my surprise) on the Kindle Fire HDX.

I found the ordinary Kindle e-readers completely unusable. I just couldn’t see them. I liked the top-of-the-line Nook but, sadly, the titles I wanted weren’t available in Nook format. The top-of-the-line Samsung tablet, too, was unusable. The text was just too blurry for my terrible vision.

It finally came down to the Apple iPad vs. the Kindle Fire HDX 8.9″. They were very close but the Kindle’s combination of size, weight, and clarity of text were the determining factors for me. Its screen has the highest points-per-inch of any screen on the market of comparable size and viewed purely as an e-reader that made the difference to me. I’ve already probably saved the purchase price of the gadget in purchased books. Not to mention the space.

5 comments

Two Summaries and an Assessment

Here’s a summary of Mohammed el-Erian’s summary of the IMF’s report on the state of the U. S. economy:

  • Growth this year will be 2% or below
  • Growth for the foreseeable future will be 2% or below
  • Interest rates will stay low for a protracted period

Now here’s the assessment. If your financial plans include a portfolio that’s growing at 8% or faster, you might want to reconsider your plans. I’m talking to you, public pension plans.

16 comments

The Leader of the Band

Former colonial plenipotentiary Paul Bremer takes to the pages of the Wall Street Journal to make a pitch for securing the outcome that his boss dreamed of and bungled:

The withdrawal of all American forces has now had its predictable results.

First, our departure meant that the Iraqis lost a lot of immediate on-the-ground intelligence, a vital need for any effective military force. Second, though Iraqi military leaders publicly and privately stated that their national forces were not yet ready to defend the country, American training of those forces was cut back.

Finally, America lost considerable influence over political events in Iraq. Our military presence always had an important political dimension. It was symbolic of our intent to help Iraqis stay the course in rebuilding their country. Removing Saddam Hussein upended a thousand years of Sunni domination in the lands of Mesopotamia. It takes hard work and a long time after such a political revolution for stability to return. No amount of clever diplomacy could substitute for our continued military presence.

In an op-ed full of debateable assertions, viz:

America’s core interest remains a stable, united and democratic Iraq. But American regional interests are broader. At stake now is the century-old political structure of the entire region, with huge consequences for our friends and allies there.

he does include one sobering fact:

It is time for both American political parties to cease their ritualistic incantations of “no boots on the ground,” which is not the same as “no combat forces.” Of course Americans are reluctant to re-engage in Iraq. Yet it is President Obama’s unhappy duty to educate them about the risks to our interests posed by the unfolding drama in Iraq.

If doing what was politically popular or easy were the limits of presidential responsibility, we wouldn’t need a president at all. Sometimes presidential leadership calls for more than figuring out which way the band is going and getting out in front of it but in figuring out which way the band should go and convincing its members to go in that direction. Education and persuasion are among the roles and powers of the president.

I continue to urge the course of action I’ve advocated for some time: the president should outline what he believes our interests in the region are clearly, persuade the American people that his views are the correct ones, and then pursue those objectives with determination. That may be as Amb. Bremer puts it an “unhappy duty” but it’s his duty nonetheless.

4 comments

The Disconnect

If we have no interest in Iraq and there’s nothing we can do there, why is this news?

BAGHDAD — Wielding the threat of sectarian slaughter, Sunni Islamist militants claimed on Sunday that they had massacred hundreds of captive Shiite members of Iraq’s security forces, posting grisly pictures of a mass execution in Tikrit as evidence and warning of more killing to come.

The possible mass killing came as militants cemented control of the city of Tal Afar, west of Mosul, after two days of fierce clashes with Iraqi troops, residents and senior security officials said. The city came under mortar attack, sending residents fleeing toward Sinjar in the north, which is under control of Kurdish pesh merga troops. Residents said the militants freed dozens of prisoners.

Even as anecdotal reports of extrajudicial killings around the country seemed to bear out the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria’s intent to kill Shiites wherever it could, Iraqi officials and some human rights groups cautioned that the militants’ claim to have killed 1,700 soldiers in Tikrit could not be immediately verified.

The NYT is transparently attempting to drum up fervor for U. S. military intervention under a “responsibility to protect”.

19 comments

Flawed by Design

Touching on the question I asked yesterday, there’s a somewhat cerebral reaction to the problems in Iraq and Afghanistan that I think is worth considering. I’m concerned that the U. S. is doing something I’ve seen quite a lot of as a consultant and which I never do. It’s designing itself into the operational model for Iraq and Afghanistan.

In the case of Afghanistan in particular there is no way, repeat no way that the country has or will have the ability to defend its own borders for the foreseeable future. It’s a country with a GDP of $18 billion (about $670 per person) for goodness sake. With that sort of GDP a large landlocked country can’t even afford enough soldiers to do the job let alone an air force.

Basically, we’ve designed the U. S. military into the Afghanistan operational model.

The model is flawed by design. Removing the U. S. from the equation means we have no interest in whether Afghanistan can defend its border or who sets up shop there. If we have no interest in who sets up shop there, what have we been doing there for the last six years? For the last decade? Why did we invade?

4 comments