Not Kidding

I think this is a point not mentioned frequently enough. Many of us are sufficiently secularist that we think that people having religious objections to something is just a pose.

But that’s not the case. There are many, many people in the world who have actual religious principles and religious scruples. It doesn’t matter if they’re wrong, ignorant, misinformed, etc. They’re not kidding and that’s the reality on the ground.

8 comments

Bouncing Back

You might want to check out this interview with Singapore’s prime minister at Politico. I wish more Americans and, especially, American politicians were as optimistic about America’s prospects as he is. Here’s the conclusion:

SG: When you go around to Beijing and the other capitals in the region, what are they misunderstanding about the United States? I think there is a question about whether China is betting on American decline, for example.

PM: Many of them don’t realize how resilient the United States is, and they think that after the global financial crisis, you are done for, and well, suitable obsequies will be spoken, and then a new power will rise. But I’ve told them that is not so and it’s a very resilient country and it has tremendous energy and creativity and drive, and it’s going to bounce back. It may be now tired of wars and battles, but it will come back; it has done so before. I think there’s also a perception in China particularly that America is trying to circumscribe it, restrict it, even contain it from taking its rightful place in the world. I don’t think any American leader wants to do that.

14 comments

What Do You Want Judges to Do?

The outrage du jour is over the Supreme Court’s decision in the Hobby Lobby case which James Taranto summarizes here:

The majority, in a decision by Justice Samuel Alito held that Hobby Lobby and two other companies need not comply with the ObamaCare birth-control mandate, to which their owners object on religious grounds.

The plaintiffs in these cases did not claim their First Amendment rights had been violated; such a claim, as we noted in March, would almost certainly have been precluded by the 1990 case of Employment Division v. Smith. But Congress responded to that case by enacting RFRA, which mandates the courts apply “strict scrutiny” to government policies as enforced against litigants who object on religious grounds.

In order to meet strict scrutiny, the government must show both that the policy is justified by a “compelling” interest and that it is the “least restrictive means” of furthering that interest. At least five justices seemed to agree that the interest in assuring cost-free access to the abortifacient contraceptives in question is “compelling”: the four dissenters and Justice Anthony Kennedy, who in a concurring opinion wrote: “It is important to confirm that a premise of the Court’s opinion is its assumption that the HHS regulation at issue here furthers a legitimate and compelling interest in the health of female employees.”

In their acerbic response the editors of the New York Times get the law and the facts wrong from the first sentence:

The Supreme Court’s deeply dismaying decision on Monday in the Hobby Lobby case swept aside accepted principles of corporate law and religious liberty to grant owners of closely held, for-profit companies an unprecedented right to impose their religious views on employees.

As I mentioned when the case was first accepted by the Court, that closely-held private corporations serve as alter egos of their owners is the prevailing view in corporate law and this case is only controversial in its subject matter rather than its outcome.

I have read the majority decision and Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s dissent. If I understand Justice Ginsburg’s position, it hinges on corporations not being mentioned in the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993 (which I’ve also read). Justice Ginsburg’s view strikes me as novel. If it were applied, say, to the First Amendment, it would mean that freedom of the press does not apply to the New York Times Company, the Tribune Company, or News Corp., all for-profit corporations. I think that RFRA, enacted by a Democratic House and Senate and signed into law by a Democratic president, means what its plain language says: it’s a limitation on the power of legislatures and executives to craft laws or regulations that limit the free exercise of religion without a compelling interest and only then by the least restrictive means. Since there are plenty of approaches the Obama Administration could exercise to achieve the same goal including compelling insurance companies to include contraceptives at no additional charge, clearly compelling employers is not the least restrictive means.

In my view any ire should be directed, as usual, against the Congress rather than against the Court and the remedy that foes of the Hobby Lobby decision should be seeking should be revisions in RFRA. The editors of the Washington Post come closer to that stance:

If this is the sort of balancing that the Supreme Court will conduct, Congress should change the law. The Constitution generally does not require religious exceptions to generally applicable laws. The ruling relied on the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, a statute that does not mention corporations and that lawmakers could easily narrow. They should not only guarantee contraception coverage but also repair the federal government’s ability to provide for wholly legitimate common goods such as public health and marketplace regulation.

Eugene Volokh defends the decision:

Likewise, the Hobby Lobby owners drew a line: Providing health insurance — including through their closely held corporation — that covers what they see as tools for homicide is sinful complicity with sin. Providing salaries that employees may use to buy the same tools or hiring employees who use those tools is not.

Many of us might draw the line elsewhere (even if we agreed with the judgment that the potentially implantation-preventing contraceptives are sinful). But it is for the owners of Hobby Lobby to draw the line and not for the courts to second-guess it. Perhaps there is a compelling interest that justifies the substantial burden that the law imposes on the owners — more on that later — but courts cannot say that the burden is insubstantial simply because they think the complicity is too attenuated.

And this position should look especially sensible, I think, given how wide an array of judgments our own American legal system has on the subject of complicity.

As might be expected the bitter argument in the blogosphere has revolved around the policy rather than the law. I don’t want to get into the policy here. The deeper questions are about the nature of law and what we expect judges to do.

If laws are the minimum standards of acceptable behavior and limited in their scope and applicability to their plain language, precedent, and the common law, then we should want judges who will try to discern that. If, on the other hand, laws are blank canvases on which our policy preferences are to be written, we want judges who will pursue those preferences zealously and are able to mask their advocacy as justicion.

The question that underpins the deeper questions is how can people with different beliefs, values, and preferences live together? There are two competing strategies. Either we can learn tolerance and forbearance or we can use compulsion.

47 comments

How and How Not to Redistribute Wealth

I wasn’t nearly as outraged by Casey Mulligan’s Wall Street Journal op-ed characterizing the late recession as the “Redistribution Recession” as I expected to be:

There were new mortgage-assistance programs. People who owed more on their mortgage than their house was worth could have their mortgage payments set at a so-called affordable level—in government-speak, that means that you pay full price for your house only if you have a job and earn money.

There were new rules for consumer bankruptcy, with special emphasis on the amount that consumers were earning after their debts were cleared.

All of these programs have in common that they, like taxes, reduce incentives to work and earn. The cornerstone of “The Redistribution Recession” is to quantify the sum total of these incentives and their changes over time. That’s what I call the marginal tax rate, by which I mean the extra taxes paid, and subsidies forgone, as the result of working. Waves of new programs increased the typical marginal tax rate from 40% to 48% in two years.

There is a real demand for this kind of redistribution. Helping people who are unemployed or with low incomes is intrinsically valuable. We like doing it, and we like knowing that a system of help is there if we need it.

I have a great deal of sympathy with the redistribution of income. However, I have the old-fashioned idea that we should redistribute from the rich to the poor rather than from the rich and almost rich to other people who are rich or almost rich or, worse, redistribution from the poor to the rich or almost rich which together form the bulk of the redistribution we have today.

That’s always been one of the conundrums of indebtedness relief, for example. It would redistribute from one group of the rich and almost rich to a different group of the rich and almost rich.

1 comment

Cycles

Robert Samuelson urges us to change the focus of our attention from the business cycle to the financial cycle:

The Great Recession has inflicted enduring economic damage. Business investment has lagged; many workers have dropped out of the labor force. By early 2014, calculates the BIS, U.S. gross domestic product — the economy’s output — was 13 percent below where it would have been if pre-crisis growth trends had continued. In Britain, the gap was 19 percent; in France, 12 percent; even Germany had a shortfall, 3 percent.

Conventional business-cycle analysis didn’t anticipate these steep losses. It also missed other features of the post-crisis economy. Unlike earlier recessions, countercyclical policies — especially low interest rates by the Fed and other government central banks — have only modestly helped recovery. Low rates fail if borrowers don’t want to borrow or lenders don’t want to lend.

It is flabbergasting to me that we could adopt a whole set of policies including housing and transportation policies, immigration policies, trade policies, and inheritance policies, all of which tend to benefit the upper middle class and wealthiest at the expense of the poor and struggling working people and be surprised when incomes are increasingly concentrated in fewer hands. A century ago the poor and the rich lived side by side, inheritance taxes made it harder for the rich to transfer their wealth to their children, imported goods were a tiny fraction of what we consumed, and poorly run or profligate businesses were allowed to fail.

Nowadays the upper middle class rarely see the poor, people with advanced degrees almost invariably marry other people with advanced degrees, and we subsidize banks and large companies. How far we’ve advanced@!

2 comments

Don’t Know Much About History

While I’m in a historical frame of mind, I should mention that I don’t think you can understand the early Baby Boomers very well if you don’t pick up some knowledge of the student radicalism of the 1960s. I find Hillary Clinton’s rather humorous scramble to be a “woman of the people” despite being a member of the top .5% of income earners is most easily understandable in that light.

If you’re not familiar with the phrase the “vanguard of the proletariat”, it refers to an idea from Marxist theory that the most class conscious and politically advanced members of the working class would form a vanguard that would lead the way to world revolution. We don’t just wear blue jeans today because they’re comfortable or because they look nice. We wear them to show solidarity with the workers and identify with them and, coincidentally, so that middle class college students could establish their bona fides as the vanguard of the proletariat.

That’s not to say that I think that Hillary Clinton is a Marxist. Far from it. She’s no more a Marxist than any of the rest of us are (I’ve got a post around here somewhere titled “We Are All Marxists Now”—all industrial or post-industrial economies are mixed economies and objectivists’ imaginings not withstanding I don’t think you can have a modern economy that’s not a mixed economy). But she came of age during a period in which a sort of romantic Marxism was the dominant strain thought among the young smart set, an attitude that’s come right down to today in the form of the image of Che Guevara you still see everywhere.

0 comments

Country, Identity, and Language

We don’t know very much about classical antiquity despite living in its ruins. Most of what we think we know is from romantic reconstructions dating from the early modern era.

However, I don’t think we can know even that if we don’t recognize the interrelationships amoung country, identity, and language in antiquity. “Egypt” is where Egyptian was spoken and it was spoken by Egyptians. “Rome” is where Latin was spoken and it was spoken by Romans. “Gaul” is where Gaulish was spoken and it was spoken by Gauls.

We can be pretty confident that Picts and Scots spoke different languages because the Romans distinguished between them and they would have made that distinction based on the language they spoke. My guess would be that the ancient Scots spoken a Goidelic language (like Irish or Scots Gaelic) while the Picts spoken a Brythonic language (like Welsh or Cornish) but that’s just a guess since we have no attestations of the Pictish language. It might have been a linguistic isolate (like Basque).

Now go back and read the Hebrew Bible. You’ll get a very different impression about stories, like say the “captivity in Egypt”. Just as a side note to the best of my knowledge the earliest attestation we have of Hebrew is that it was apparently spoken in a Persian fort about 2,500 years ago in Upper Egypt.

7 comments

Risks, Priorities, and Empowerment

Francis “End of History” Fukuyama cautions us that in concerning ourselves too much with ISIS we’re not paying enough attention to “more menacing foes”:

The focus of today’s debate ought to be: how should we prioritise the threats facing us and how bad are the most serious? This year we have seen a fast-moving sequence of events, from Russia’s annexation of Crimea to China’s assertion of sovereignty over the South and East China seas to the collapse of the Iraqi government’s power. Authoritarian forces are on the move.

It is on this point that US President Barack Obama’s foreign policy speech at the West Point military academy in May was wrong-headed. It laid out various abstract criteria for the use of force (actions must be “proportional and effective and just”; where no direct threat to US interests exists, “the threshold for military action must be higher”). It is hard to disagree. But he went on to state that the only direct threat we face is terrorism. He said virtually nothing about long-term responses to the two other big challenges to world order: Russia and China. There was great fanfare surrounding the US “pivot” towards Asia – one of the most important initiatives of Mr Obama’s first term – but he did not mention the word once.

Despite the recent successes of the Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant (known as Isis), I would argue that terrorism is actually the least consequential of these challenges in terms of core US interests. What we are witnessing in Iraq and Syria is the slow spread of a Sunni-Shia war, with local forces acting as proxies for Saudi Arabia and Iran. It is a humanitarian crisis in the making. However, we could barely contain sectarian hatreds when we occupied Iraq with 150,000 troops; it is hard to see how we can act decisively now.

Identifying priorities and establishing subpriorities is always good advice. Is potential risk or actual risk a higher priority? The reality of the last forty years is that the only foes that have done us any serious harm have been violent radical Islamists (in Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, in African embassies, and here in the United States) while neither Russia nor China has touched us.

To be sure Russia and China have national interests of their own and I would expect them to pursue them. Both countries are large enough and powerful enough that their neighbors will inevitably be nervous and changing that is beyond our power. Other than nervous neighbors what national interest of ours do Russia or China threaten? Dr. Fukuyama alludes to a case but doesn’t really make one.

Russia and China both have large militaries but they are more intended to be used domestically or in their near abroads than against us. It is their nuclear arsenals that we should be most concerned about which is why nuclear deterrence still matters.

Our long-time grand strategy has consisted in promoting freedom of trade and of the sea lanes and I think I’d add the free exchange of information to that. Transnational corporations may threaten those interests more than Russia or China do and perhaps they should be added to the list. Not to mention the U. S. government itself.

While I don’t lie awake nights worrying about the threat posed by violent radical Islamists, I think that dismissing them as a few primitive savages in the desert is a grave error. After all, a few dozen Saudis, Egyptians, and Gulf Arabs with a budget of a couple of hundred thousand dollar managed to kill 3,000 people and do hundreds of billions of dollars worth of damage. How many people could a thousand with a budget of a billion dollars kill?

Equating destructive power with size or productive capacity is mid-20th century thinking. It is woefully obsolete.

If there is a thrust to world history it has been in the direction of personal empowerment. Since 1945 it has been the case that one country could destroy the entire world, something never the case before. Today one individual can be as powerful as an army of a millennium ago and with the developments in desktop manufacturing, genetic engineering, and nanotechnology that will only be exacerbated in the years to come.

Personal empowerment is a jinn we cannot return to its bottle, at least not without bringing the modern economy crashing down around our ears. It’s not something that we can successfully oppose with armies or even armed drones—another example of that personal empowerment and something we should be expect to be used against us sooner rather than later.

To mitigate the risks that empowerment poses we’re either going to need to start ignoring mass casualties, something that shows few signs of happening, or consider our policies more critically, with flinty-eyed objectivity. Since so many fabulously wealthy individuals, companies, and other institutions depend on Things As They Are for their riches and power, the likelihood of our doing that seems to me vanishingly small.

For more on personal empowerment and superempowerment see

The Super Empowered Individual
Zenpundit on the Super-Empowered Individual
The Boston Bombers and Superempowerment

19 comments

A Monkey Wrench in Immigration Reform

The sudden influx of unaccompanied minors into the United States from south of the border is complicating the president’s plans to reform immigration by any means necessary:

Absent the current crisis at the border with Mexico, Obama might have made his next step a big one. Activists have been pressuring him to extend protection from deportation to a larger class of undocumented immigrants, building on his Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals policy, which made it possible for undocumented immigrants who arrived as children to gain a legal foothold in the U.S.

But since October, more than 52,000 unaccompanied children, most of them from Central America, have wound up in the care of the U.S. government. An additional 39,000 mothers with children have crossed the border into U.S. custody over the same period.

The influx has changed the political calculations. The White House is still off balance, but even more awkwardly than before. Unlike the presence of 11 million or so undocumented immigrants in the U.S., most of whom have been here for many years, the children’s crisis both began, and escalated, entirely under Obama’s administration.

Republicans, suddenly blessed with a fact that fits their pre-packaged narrative of a lawless president overseeing a besieged border, have what they’ve long lacked: ammunition. Like his colleagues, House Judiciary Committee Chairman Bob Goodlatte has achieved nothing on immigration. Now, however, he has 52,000 reasons why nothing can be done. He’ll be traveling to the Rio Grande Valley next week to lambaste the administration for allowing the children’s crusade to overrun Texas.

Presumably, we need these youthful migrants to start new businesses here in the United States. The news reports on this development have conjured up images of rosy-cheeked urchins but the reality appears to be a bit more complicated. A sizeable percentage of the unaccompanied minors are teenage males and there have been reports some of them are gang members.

I repeat the point I’ve made about this in the past. The missing link in this discussion is the government of Mexico. According to the reports the preponderance of these young people aren’t Mexicans but from farther south, i.e. Guatemala, El Salvador, Honduras, maybe even Colombia. They’re crossing more than a thousand miles of Mexico to arrive at our border. I find it incredible that could take place in the numbers being reported without the Mexican government being aware of it and maybe even complicit in it. This report from The Economist, for example, suggests that Mexico is deporting these kids into the United States rather than repatriating them.

9 comments

Fanatically Supporting Education

The Chicago Board of Education is laying off more than 1,000 teachers and school staff:

Chicago Public Schools officials told 550 teachers and 600 more school staff Thursday that they’re out of a job.

The number of dreaded phone calls being made by principals is based on how many kids CPS officials project will show up on the first day next fall.

“The staffing changes are driven most directly by declining student enrollment,” CPS CEO Barbara Byrd-Bennett said in a conference call with reporters.

This follows on the heels of thousands being fired last year with thousands more the year before. To some extent this is an annual ritual—they lay off 1,000, 600 are hired back.

But it’s part of a pattern that’s been going on for a decade. As I’ve documented before, education spending in Chicago continues to increase even as the number of students being educated shrinks. If the extra money were being spent on more teachers and schools, it would be one thing but it’s not. It’s being spent on former teachers and more staff being paid higher wages.

I think it was George Santayana who defined fanatacism as redoubling your efforts when you have forgotten your aim. Using that gauge I think it’s fair to say that here in Chicago we support the schools fanatically.

On a related topic, Karen Lewis, president of the Chicago Teachers Union is being reported to be seriously considering running for mayor:

Chicago Teachers Union President Karen Lewis said Thursday she is “seriously thinking” about mounting a formal challenge to Rahm Emanuel.

“I’m a little sick of the mayor and I don’t see anyone stepping up,” Lewis told the Chicago Sun-Times by telephone Thursday evening. “I am seriously thinking about it.”

She denied a WMAQ-Channel 5 report that she has met with election lawyers about her own campaign possibilities, saying she has spoken with attorneys about CTU members who are running for office.

Lewis has made no bones about wanting to oust Emanuel, with whom she’s sparred since he took office in 2011 and who supposedly shouted, “F – – – you, Lewis” in an early meeting with her.

The mayor doesn’t really need to worry about losing the campaign contributions the CTU represents—much of his election funding comes from outside Chicago. However, opposition from a serious opponent might well present a problem. It might cut into the time he’d otherwise be devoting to getting whatever Democratic candidate is running in 2016 elected.

4 comments