Name Your Poison

When I read about the idea that the Obama Administration was considering changing course and backing Assad in Syria my immediate reaction was

Which of the following choices is the worst course of action?

  1. Back the rebels, Assad is defeated and replaced by an Islamist regime.
  2. Back the rebels but Assad remains.
  3. Back Assad and Assad defeats the rebels quickly.
  4. Back Assad and Assad defeats the rebels slowly.
  5. Back the rebels, Assad remains, and then you back Assad.
  6. Wait for the whole thing to blow over.

You may propose other alternatives. Note that I don’t include an alternative for Assad being removed and replaced by a liberal democratic government because that was not going to happen in any event.

What would the best course of action have been?

15 comments

The Hollowing Out of Chicago

There’s a Sun-Times article on income inequality in Chicago I found interesting. Apparently, Chicago is becoming much less equal in terms of incomes fast:

Journalism professor Darnell Little and his Medill Data Project at Northwestern University crunched census income data for the Chicago Sun-Times and found that the wealth gap is widening faster in Chicago than in the suburbs or in the state and country in general.

Statistically speaking, the best way to gauge wealth distribution is a measure called the Gini index. It’s a scale from 0 to 100 in which 0 represents total, utopian equality — i.e., each of us is paid the same amount of money — and 100 means one person is hoarding every last penny.

In 1990, Chicago registered 44.9 on the Gini index. That suggested an only slightly greater level of disparity in the city than for Illinois as a whole, which recorded a score of 44.3 that year.

Jump to 2012, the most recent year for which federal income data is available on a city and county level. Chicago had risen sharply to 51.9 on the income-inequality scale — far worse than the 46.5 for the entire state and 47.1 for the country.

They also found that the city of Chicago was much more unequal than its collar counties were.

I think a little perspective is called for. The reality is that income inequality in Chicago is pretty comparable to that in other large cities. Chicago’s .5286 (according to the linked results) are better than New York’s .5381 and worse than Los Angeles’s .5235 but not drastically so. Probably within margin of error. The least equal cities are Atlanta, New Orleans, and Miami.

If you look at these results with flinty, steadfast gaze, I think the results suggest to us that high Gini coefficients are correlated with black population. Our largest cities are becoming places for the white rich and the black poor. This is the problem that has been dogging us since the end of the Golden Age of the civil rights movement 40 years ago. What can we do to improve the situations of poor blacks? Most of what we’ve done over that period hasn’t reached the poor. The single most positive thing we’ve done has been welfare reform and that’s something the Obama Administration has been trying to reverse.

19 comments

Feeding the PBGC Kitty

It’s been a while since I’ve complained about the Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation, the federal program under which people whose pension plans have gone belly up continue to be paid some sort of pension. It’s another of those public/private hybrids I complained about recently. In a recent editorial the editors of the Wall Street Journal warn that the PBGC may need the next big federal bailout:

Labor unions like to promote their generous defined-benefit pensions. Yet when these benefits prove unsustainable, workers can lose their jobs and retirement savings. The kicker is that taxpayers may soon be tapped to perpetuate this double fraud.

That’s the main take-away from a new report by the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC), which insures multi-employer pension plans for 10.4 million workers and retirees. The federal agency projects that its deficit for multi-employer plans will balloon to $49.6 billion by 2023 from $8.3 billion. Last year the PBGC forecasted a deficit of $26.2 billion in 2022, and its upward revision reflects the increasing likelihood that more plans will become insolvent and sooner.

Of all of the possible solutions for solving the PBGC’s money problems paying its shortfalls out of the general fund must surely be the worst.

I don’t think the PBGC should exist at all. It’s the rankest sort of corporate welfare, right up there with the Export-Import Bank. It enables companies that are so inclined to underfund their pensions and pay less than the legitimate cost of insuring the funds to underwrite them.

Additionally, it’s manifestly unjust. It forces people who have no pensions to pay for the pensions, largely through their payroll taxes, of those who do.

If you can’t bear to abolish the PBGC, my second proposal would be changing it into a real insurance plan in which premiums are proportion to costs and risks. That would at least be a disincentive for the corporate misbehaviors I mention above. Another possibility would be to limit payouts under the PBGC to what premiums bring in. If it’s good enough for Social Security, why isn’t it good enough for private pensions?

The very last thing we should do is continually stoke the PBGC with money.

5 comments

The Rule of Lawyers

Over the last week or so I have read an enormous amount of (mostly hyperventilating) commentary about the Supreme Court’s decision in the Hobby Lobby case. In all of the verbiage I have not encountered an explanation of how you’d arrive at any other decision without setting aside black letter law. Here’s the relevant language of the Religious Freedom Restoration Act:

SEC. 3. FREE EXERCISE OF RELIGION PROTECTED.

(a) IN GENERAL. — Government shall not substantially burden a person’s exercise of religion even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability, except as provided in subsection (b).

(b) EXCEPTION. — Government may burden a person’s exercise of religion only if it demonstrates that application of the burden to the person —

(1) furthers a compelling governmental interest; and

(2) is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest.

(c) JUDICIAL RELIEF. — A person whose religious exercise has been substantially burdened in violation of this section may assert that violation as a claim or defense in a judicial proceeding and obtain appropriate relief against a government. Standing to assert a claim or defense under this section shall be governed by the general rules of standing under article III of the Constitution.

and here’s the relevant language of the “Dictionary Act”, the federal statute that governs how words are used in federal law:

…the words “person” and “whoever” include corporations, companies, associations, firms, partnerships, societies, and joint stock companies, as well as individuals;…

I suppose one might argue that either RFRA or the Dictionary Act were unconstitutional. I haven’t read any but the most half-hearted attempts at doing that, mostly suggesting that the argument could be made without making it. I would welcome being directed to such an argument. My suspicion, however, is that opponents of the decision object to it on policy grounds rather than legal ones and were hoping that the Court would carry the water for the Obama Administration and find some pretext for affirming a regulation that goes beyond what was enacted into law.

Which brings me to Michael Barone’s most recent column. In the column Mr. Barone deconstructs the Obama Administration’s actions in light of its Supreme Court losses, especially the cases in which it’s been defeated unanimously. He sees the administration as hostile to religion:

One thing is abundantly clear, namely that this administration has a crabbed view of the First Amendment right of free exercise of religion. That is apparent not only in June’s 5-4 decision ruling in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby that the Obamacare contraception mandate is trumped by the Religious Freedom Restoration Act.

It’s even clearer in the 2012 Hosanna-Tabor Church v. EEOC case, in which the Court unanimously said that churches have the right to select their own clergy. The administration’s position, that government could decide who counts as clergy, was described as “amazing” by Justice (and former Obama solicitor general) Elena Kagan.

freedom of speech:

The First Amendment freedom of speech is not highly valued by the administration either. In McCullen v. Coakley, decided last month, all nine justices overturned the Massachusetts law, supported by the administration, outlawing protests within 35 feet of an abortion clinic.

property rights:

Property rights are also disfavored by the Obama administration. A unanimous court said the Fifth Amendment requires compensation when the government repeatedly floods its land in Arkansas Game & Fish Commission v. U.S. in 2012.

That year, the court in Sackett v. EPA also unanimously ruled that landowners could sue without risking a $75,000 per day fine to challenge a government order blocking construction in a supposed wetland.

And in 2013, the court in Horne v. USDA ruled that raisin farmers could sue for damages from confiscation of hundreds of pounds of raisins without first paying a $483,000 fine.

and the Fourth Amendment’s protections against unreasonable search and seizure:

Nor is the Obama administration particularly respectful of the Fourth Amendment prohibition of unreasonable searches and seizures. In 2012, a unanimous Court in U.S. v. Jones rejected its contention that the government could attach a GPS tracking device to a car without a warrant.

That was followed by last month’s Riley v. California, in which a unanimous Court rejected the position, supported by the Obama Justice Department, that police could search without a warrant the cellphone of a person under arrest. Chief Justice John Roberts pointed out that smartphones contain much more personal information than the crumpled cigarette package whose seizure the Court upheld in 1973.

A unanimous Supreme Court has also rejected Obama administration prosecutions that went beyond the letter of the law, including double taxation of a firm that paid foreign tax (PPL Corp. v. IRS, 2012), an extension of the statute of limitation against securities fraud (Gabelli v. SEC, 2012) and the “boundless reading” (in Chief Justice Roberts’ words) of a statute implementing the Chemical Weapons Treaty to prosecute a woman who sprayed toxic chemicals on objects likely to be touched by her husband’s paramour (Bond v. US, 2014).

I disagree. I don’t believe that the Obama Administration has any particular aversion to freedom of religion or speech or private property or freedom from unreasonable searches and seizures. I think the administration’s position has a very different source and it’s one I’ve been trying to explain for some time.

I think it’s a difference of opinion over just what “the rule of law” means. There are some people who believe the written law, augmented by precedent and the common law, constitutes the whole of the law. There are others who believe in what I what term “the rule of lawyers”.

Under that rubric you identify your political or policy objectives, impose a regulation that implements them, craft a legal argument to support the regulation, and shop around for a friendly judge who’ll affirm it for you.

I don’t think that’s what most of us think of as the rule or law but I think it’s the operating principle behind a lot of the administration’s actions. Implement the policy, heedless of the law, and fill in the rest later. And it’s equally clear that many of the president’s supporters hail that approach.

My own view is that, if you can’t get the votes to pass the laws you want or repeal the laws you don’t want, don’t rely on compliant judges to do your work for you. That can cut both ways.

10 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

“Government is the word we use for the things we choose to do together”*

*for certain values of the words “we”, “choose”, and “together”.

The words in the quote that comprises the title of this post were said by Barney Frank and, with the caveats in my footnote and apparently unlike Heather Wilhelm, I agree with it.

But those are substantial caveats. For example, when a law is enacted by the votes of one half plus one of the members of the House, many of whom were elected by narrow majorities of the 30% of the eligible voters who actually voted, I don’t think there’s a meaningful “we” to speak of, particularly if those who voted “aye” by and large hailed from large cities within eyeshot of the ocean. Silence may signify assent legally but it doesn’t imply agreement, support, or commitment. When the president veers away from the requirements of the law in a desperate attempt at getting something done despite the objections of a recalcitrant Congress that further dilutes any idea of “we”.

When most of my neighbors and I turn out to shovel our front steps, sidewalks, and street and those of our elderly neighbors following a big now, that’s something we choose to do together. It makes us feel good about ourselves and about each other. We have cleared walks and street. It’s something we choose to do together. If we were to break into the homes of those who didn’t turn out with us, drag them from their beds, and put shovels in their hands, shovelling would no longer be something we chose to do together. It would be something that some of us chose and which was imposed on others.

Or if we hired a snowplow (something the neighborhood association does, indeed, do) to plow our streets it might be practical but it wouldn’t be something we chose to do together. It would be something we chose to have done together.

There’s more consensus among the people on my block than in my neighborhood, more consensus in my neighborhood than in my ward, more consensus in my ward than in the city, in the city than in the state, and in the state than in the country. IMO that increasingly attenuated consensus confers decreasing legitimacy. Once upon a time we generally felt that the federal government should leave most things other than the common currency, the military, and foreign policy to the states. That was a recognition of the decreasing legitimacy, support, and commitment that decreasing consensus and distance bring. That practice is no more.

46 comments

What Are the Odds?

What do you are the odds that in 30 years Facebook won’t exist but Mark Zuckerberg’s fortune will? I think the odds are very good, indeed.

5 comments

Reversion to Trend

John Cochran’s Wall Street Journal op-ed complaining about the “Johnny One-Note” prescription of some Keynesians (particularly folk Keynesians) opens with this paragraph:

Output per capita fell almost 10 percentage points below trend in the 2008 recession. It has since grown at less than 1.5%, and lost more ground relative to trend. Cumulative losses are many trillions of dollars, and growing. And the latest GDP report disappoints again, declining in the first quarter.

Now let’s stop right there. I’m broadly sympathetic to what comes next—that when your model fails you need to adjust your model, that the assumptions in the model which lead to the inadequate stimulus package of 2009 were absurdly wrong, and more measures based on the same assumptions will be just as inadequate—but I’d go farther. What makes him think that trend prior to 2008 was anything but an illusion? I think that our persistent (and IMO endemic) slow growth has been the case since 1992-1993 when China pegged the yuan to the dollar, we received an enormous flood of low-priced Chinese goods, the American economy was hollowed out, and every sector but those that were in bubbles (technology, housing) or directly subsidized by the government, e.g. education and healthcare, languished.

IMO the last six years haven’t been bucking the trend. They’ve been a reversion to trend.

Onwards:

If you look hard at New-Keynesian models, however, this diagnosis and these policy predictions are fragile. There are many ways to generate the models’ predictions for GDP, employment and inflation from their underlying assumptions about how people behave. Some predict outsize multipliers and revive the broken-window fallacy. Others generate normal policy predictions—small multipliers and costly broken windows. None produces our steady low-inflation slump as a “demand” failure.

These problems are recognized, and now academics such as Brown University’s Gauti Eggertsson and Neil Mehrotra are busy tweaking the models to address them. Good. But models that someone might get to work in the future are not ready to drive trillions of dollars of public expenditure.

I think that’s obviously right but, sadly, while correctly characterizing the past it doesn’t show a way forward. He goes on to critique Brad DeLong, Lawrence Summers, etc. for wanting to return to Keynes’s actual policy prescriptions. In my view their basic mistake is in not wanting to return to them enough since they continue to long for a federal government that’s a consumer of last resort rather than Keynes’s view of the central government as the employer of last resort.

His prescription:

In the alternative view, a lack of “demand” is no longer the problem. Financial observers now worry about “reach for yield” and “asset bubbles.” House prices are up. Inflation is steady. The Federal Reserve evidently agrees, since it is talking about taper and exit, not more stimulus. Even super-Keynesians note that five years of slump have let physical and human capital decay, which “demand” will not quickly reverse. But we are stuck in low gear. Though unemployment rates are returning to normal, many people are not even looking for work.

Where, instead, are the problems? John Taylor, Stanford’s Nick Bloom and Chicago Booth’s Steve Davis see the uncertainty induced by seat-of-the-pants policy at fault. Who wants to hire, lend or invest when the next stroke of the presidential pen or Justice Department witch hunt can undo all the hard work? Ed Prescott emphasizes large distorting taxes and intrusive regulations. The University of Chicago’s Casey Mulligan deconstructs the unintended disincentives of social programs. And so forth. These problems did not cause the recession. But they are worse now, and they can impede recovery and retard growth.

I agree with that as far as it goes but, again sadly, it doesn’t go far enough. Even if by some miracle all of the issues complained about above were remedied, we’d still be left with the fundamental problems that we import too much, export too little, and don’t produce enough of what we consume.

But even getting to that point will be insurmountably difficult. Those who have become accustomed to subsidies including bankers, teachers, doctors, consumers of healthcare, and consumers of cheap imported goods will not relinquish their subsidies cheerfully.

18 comments

The Failure of the Hybrids

Judging from its slug, “‘Hobby Lobby’ and ‘Harris’ offer the same lessons”, I was prepared to disagree vehemently with Charles Lane’s latest column but after reading it I found I was in broad agreement with his basic point:

Conservatives are hailing the Supreme Court’s 5 to 4 rulings in Burwell v. Hobby Lobby and Harris v. Quinn as victories for liberty, religious in the former case and associational in the latter. Liberals say what the decisions have in common is the obliteration of worker rights.

I agree that the cases teach a similar lesson but would summarize it differently: Oh, what a tangled web we weave when first we channel government-subsidized social benefits through corporations and unions.

I think I would go farther. From Fannie Mae to Freddie Mac to the Federal Reserve to employer-provided healthcare insurance, an overarching theme of the last half dozen or so years has been the failure of public/private hybrids in fulfilling their basic mandates. That’s not to say they haven’t served any purposes whatever. They’ve enriched a few in the process of satisfying portions of their mandates. But they’ve sacrificed other portions of their mandates to the parts that most clearly bolster the continued enrichment of the few. In the Federal Reserve’s case under their care the largest banks have survived along with the enormous wages they pay while the smaller banks and employment (the ignored half of the Federal Reserve’s mandate) have been sacrificed.

There’s nothing wrong with ensuring that people have healthcare insurance or home loans or that banks are underwritten. Doing so with institutions that are part public and part private has been revealed to be inherently corrupting.

3 comments

The Breeding Ground

Michael Malone muses over why technological innovation is slowing:

For more than a half-century, big technology companies have led the way in inventing revolutionary products and services, from calculators to smartphones. Startups, meanwhile, have built upon those creations with innovations like peripheral devices and software applications. This was as true for the IBM 360 computer as it was for the Apple
iPhone.

But something fundamental has shifted in Silicon Valley. The emblematic event was Facebook’s February acquisition of the mobile messaging startup
WhatsApp for an astounding $19 billion. WhatsApp was barely five years old and had 55 employees. The question from one end of Silicon Valley to the other was: What possessed Facebook to spend that kind of money?

Surely there must be a method to Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s apparent madness. In fact, a strategy is emerging: In 2012, the social media giant bought Instagram for $1 billion. The number of Facebook users grew less than 4% last year, but the number of Instagram users jumped 23%. Millennials are getting bored with the website and abandoning the platform in far greater numbers than their parents—the kiss of death—are joining.

So Mr. Zuckerberg has two options: radically transform his current product (no small matter with the drag of 1.3 billion users), or buy the Next Big Thing. And the next one. Then the one after that.

It may prove a brilliant strategy. But it also means that Facebook, one of the most innovative companies of the past decade, now depends on purchasing the inventiveness of others.

If you want the volume of innovation that existed when Apple and Microsoft were founded, you should think about what’s changed since Apple and Microsoft were founded. We’re not subsidizing technology the way we used to. We’re importing most of the technological products that people buy. We’re importing numbers of foreign technology workers to push wages here down.

We’ve broadened intellectual property law considerably, giving established firms the weapons to crush upstarts and creating industries of intellectual property pirates.

Capital investment and the willingness to wait for it to bear fruit aren’t what they were then.

And, most of all, there are technology giants like Microsoft and Apple, ready to strangle start-ups in their cribs and people like Larry Ellison who buys companies just for the products, firing all of their employees.

The breeding ground for technological innovation is gone. Why are we surprised?

44 comments