Post Mortem

The autopsy on Michael Brown, the Ferguson teenager whose shooting has sparked more than a week of demonstrations, riots, and tens of thousands of words of commentary does not appear to me to be consistent with a “fleeing felon” scenario:

“There were at least six entry wounds, there might have been seven, but we’ll have to correlate that with what was found in the first autopsy,” he said. The first autopsy was conducted by the St. Louis County Medical Examiner’s office. The U.S. Justice Department announced Sunday that it ordered its own autopsy.

(Ferguson update: Missouri governor deploys National Guard after clashes).

Dr. Baden said all of the gunshots were fired toward the front of Mr. Brown’s body. The results of the autopsy were first reported by the New York Times.

but with one of self-defense on the part of the police officer. It sounds to me as though either the officer is a pretty good shot or a very bad one.

I think the whole story is very sad with lots of blame and recriminations to go around however I wonder if those who’ve hinged their views on the image of a fleeing unarmed teen will be chastened by the autopsy’s findings. I’m guessing not.

For those who believe that the sad events were completely fomented by a mostly-black population and a mostly-white police force, what do you think should change? Keep in mind that until 2000 Ferguson was mostly white and it is only now mostly black. Do you think that:

  1. The population of Ferguson should have been mandated to remain white, consistent with its white police force.
  2. The police force should have been mandated to be mostly black consistent with the population it was now serving despite work rules governing hiring and firing.
  3. Some other solution and if so what?
39 comments

Serious Business

Indian journalist Brij Khindaria posts on how serious the situation in Iraq is. Here’s the meat of his post

Obama is misled if he imagines that Kurdish and Iraqi soldiers, aided by a few US advisors and warplanes, can prevent the self-proclaimed Caliph from firmly establishing the Islamic State stretching from Lebanon, through Syria to Iraq.

Air raids can stop IS fighters from gaining territory but dislodging and destroying them requires boots on the ground. The key question is, “Will local boots be enough?” Don’t hold your breath.

Meanwhile, former French foreign minister Dominique de Villepin points out (translation here at worldmeets.us) that ISIS is not the U. S.’s problem alone:

The borders of the Sykes-Picot era have been swept away. Post-colonial and Cold War political models are obsolete. Shiites and Sunnis are confronting one another and minorities are exposed to ethnic cleansing in all its forms. In a word, Islamism is to Islam what fascism was to the national ideal in Europe – a monstrous double, out of control, riding on the back of the archaic and modernity, imaginary archaic and medieval ideas communicated as propaganda through the latest technology. It will take the Middle East another generation to achieve its own peaceable modernity, but until then it needs to be on guard to nihilist temptations and civilizational suicide. We are at the dawn of a decisive moment when the region swings to one side or the other. Our role is to help it as best we can to choose life over death.

The foremost political issue here, as always, is unity and the law that the international community should embody. Force is only a stopgap to prevent the worst. It must be timely. And be aware that this is what the jihadists want to ennoble their fight and radicalize people against the West which is still suspected either of crusades, or colonialism.

While our European allies may think of the situation in terms of the “Pottery Barn rule”, they have more at stake than we do in Iraq. Their trade with Iraq is greater than ours and a caliphate stretching from the Bosporus to the Hindu Kush would threaten them more than it would us.

India, similarly, has much at stake. Their trade with Iraq is only a little less than ours and the putative caliphate would be at their backdoor.

We’re not alone and we shouldn’t act as though we were alone. But it does mean that the Europeans and other stakeholders need to act.

4 comments

The Real Fear

The real things we should be afraid of in the ongoing Ebola outbreak are that it will cause the fragile healthcare systems in West Africa to collapse under its weight and that it will spread to Nigeria:

Last week, my brilliant Council on Foreign Relations colleague John Campbell, former U.S. ambassador to Nigeria, warned that spread of the virus inside Lagos — which has a population of 22 million — would instantly transform this situation into a worldwide crisis, thanks to the chaos, size, density, and mobility of not only that city but dozens of others in the enormous, oil-rich nation. Add to the Nigerian scenario civil war, national elections, Boko Haram terrorists, and a countrywide doctors’ strike — all of which are real and current — and you have a scenario so overwrought and frightening that I could not have concocted it even when I advised screenwriter Scott Burns on his Contagion script.

Inside the United States, politicians, gadflies, and much of the media are focused on wildly experimental drugs and vaccines, and equally wild notions of “keeping the virus out” by barring travelers and “screening at airports.”

Let’s be clear: Absolutely no drug or vaccine has been proven effective against the Ebola virus in human beings. To date, only one person — Dr. Kent Brantly — has apparently recovered after receiving one of the three prominent putative drugs, and there is no proof that the drug was key to his improvement. None of the potential vaccines has even undergone Phase One safety trials in humans, though at least two are scheduled to enter that stage before December of this year. And Phase One is the swiftest, easiest part of new vaccine trials — the two stages of clinical trials aimed at proving that vaccines actually work will be difficult, if not impossible, to ethically and safely execute. If one of the vaccines is ready to be used in Africa sometime in 2015, the measure will be executed without prior evidence that it can work, which in turn will require massive public education to ensure that people who receive the vaccination do not change their behaviors in ways that might put them in contact with Ebola — because they mistakenly believe they are immune to the virus.

The former concern is already dangerously close to happening:

At the same congressional hearing, Dr. Frank Glover, a medical missionary who partners with SIM, a Christian missions organization, and the president of SHIELD, a U.S.-based NGO in Africa, warned that Liberia had fewer than 200 doctors struggling to meet the health needs of 4 million people before the epidemic. “After the outbreak that number went down to about 50 doctors involved in clinical care,” said Glover.

I myself have received emails from physicians in these countries, describing the complete collapse of all non-Ebola care, from unassisted deliveries to untended auto accident injuries. People aren’t just dying of the virus, but from every imaginable medical issue a system of care usually faces.

Liberia, population 3.5 million, for example has a single medical school with another in the planning stages. Each doctor or nurse there that dies of Ebola is not just a tragedy but a disaster. We are complicit in the desperate condition of African healthcare by tempting African physicians away from their home countries to the fleshpots of western medicine and Western volunteer organizations are completely inadequate to make up the difference.

11 comments

Missouri, Fleeing Felons, and Present Law

There’s an informative contribution to the discussion of the events unfolding in Ferguson, Missouri from Robert Verbruggen at RealClearPolicy. You can read the relatively brief post yourself but here’s a summary:

  • The Ferguson police officer whose killing of a young man was the spark that set off the days of demonstrations and riots was apparently acting within Missouri state law and official guidelines.
  • The state law and guidelines are an implementation of the “fleeing felon” rule.
  • The “fleeing felon” rule was deemed unconstitutional 30 years ago in Tennessee v. Garner.

The point here is that it’s quite possible that a criminal suit brought against the police officer in Missouri would fail but would prevail in the federal court of appeals.

42 comments

The House Divided

There are apparently two different federal government views of the Islamic State of Iraq and Syria, that of the White House and that of the intelligence departments:

The Obama administration’s Iraq policy seems premised on the idea that the terrorist Islamic State is so toxic that it will be self-limiting and ultimately self-defeating. But that’s not the view of U.S. intelligence officials.

In a briefing for journalists Thursday, a panel of five U.S. intelligence officials summed up their assessment of an organization that has shown a remarkable durability because it is “patient,” “well-organized,” “opportunistic” and “flexible.” Under the leadership of Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, the group has rebounded from about 1,500 fighters in 2010 to more than 10,000 today — becoming a global jihadist organization that communicates in many languages.

Given the Islamic State’s stated intentions we had better hope that the White House is right and, indeed, our intelligence services’ track records in the region haven’t been particularly good for some time.

My own view, as I’ve mentioned any number of times before, is that as long as we’re content with security theater rather than security and are unwilling to disrupt the critical success factors that lead to the attacks on 9/11 we’ll continue to be as vulnerable as we were on 9/10/2001. As we learned it doesn’t take a lot of people or money to launch a disruptive, punishing attack and ISIS has both.

262 comments

The Disappearing Continent

I was aware of how many people in Europe take their vacations during the month of August but I hadn’t realized it was like this. It’s practically impossible to get anything done with European companies during the month. There’s nobody home.

51 comments

In What Belief System?

There’s apparently a twisted sort of commemoration to Robin Williams making the rounds, a frame from the Disney cartoon, Aladdin, of the jinni being freed from the lamp with the caption, “You’re free, Jinni!” It’s a clear allusion to Mr. Williams’s voiceover of the jinni, with the implication that suicide is freeing. I heard one psychiatrist complaining “Why are they making my job more difficult?”

That piqued my curiosity. In what belief system would suicide be considered freeing? If you don’t believe in an afterlife, death is not freeing. It is oblivion. That’s not freedom it’s just nothing. An end. Except for those who are left behind with pain, disbelief, and, maybe, guilt.

I don’t believe it would be considered freeing in Hinduism which teaches reincarnation. I’m no expert on Hindu metaphysics but my understanding is that they believe that we are born and reborn until we are freed from the circle of birth and death by a genuine understanding of the nature of things, referred to as moká¹£a. When you have attained moká¹£a, you would be completely at peace. Therefore suicide is ipso facto evidence that you have not attained moká¹£a and are, consequently, not at peace, and not freed from the circle of birth and death. Since they also belief that your actions in this life affect your next life, I see no way that suicide would be seen as freeing by Hindus.

Many Christians believe that suicide is a sin worthy of eternal damnation, the opposite of freeing. I can imagine circumstances under which that might not be the case but it would nonetheless produce a term in Purgatory, for those Christians who believe in progress after death (one of the oldest Christian beliefs, attested from the First Century onwards).

I don’t condemn suicide. It is not for me to condemn. I think it is always sad and painful.

Under what belief system would suicide be freeing?

32 comments

Policy and Change

Sprinkled through a vast amount of breast-beating and finger-pointing about the events unfolding in Ferguson, Missouri, I’ve found a few good things. ThinkProgress has a good backgrounder on the housing policies that have contributed to the very segregated housing situation in St. Louis and its environs. Segregated housing creates an environment of mutual distrust. People don’t understand each other and they just don’t have the experience to “read” each other.

Megan McArdle points to rapid demographic change as a contributing factor to the problems there:

The answer, after digging into some census data, seems to be massive demographic change. In 1990, the city of Ferguson had 5,589 black citizens and 16,454 white citizens, making it about three-quarters white. By 2000, blacks were a slim majority of the population. And as of 2010, they made up 69 percent of the city, and it seems likely that trajectory has continued over the last four years. This may be part of the “Great Inversion” that seems to be taking place in St. Louis; as the white population begins to reverse its 1950s-era migration to the suburbs, the black population is migrating out toward the suburbs.

The critical message here is that change and rigid public employee work rules are a bad combination. The area in which I spent my early childhood in St. Louis was considerably south and east of Ferguson. Even then that neighborhood was changing and its residents have been almost exclusively black for most of the last half century. Until recently Ferguson, as I’ve mentioned before, was a white, blue collar, some would say red-necked near-in suburb.

In a number of ways the best thing I’ve is from the editors of the Wall Street Journal:

There is little question that some young law-abiding black men are viewed suspiciously by some cops and the motivation may sometimes be race. It is also true that young black men—or rather, young men—commit crimes, often violent and whose victims are also mostly black. Instead of applying a predetermined racial template to every episode, both problems should be treated with the seriousness they deserve, which means judging each case on the merits.

Reality is contingent and fact-specific. That is why the U.S. criminal justice system respects due process and requires the government to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Attorney General Eric Holder, the FBI and the U.S. Attorney in St. Louis are conducting an independent investigation of Brown’s shooting, which will be a tonic to the extent they are fair and impartial.

Ferguson may now show that racial healing and comity are possible even amid great strain. That task belongs above all to the citizens of Ferguson, and it won’t be made any easier if it is exploited by national actors who are able to pack up and leave once the rioting stops.

These are people that we’re writing about and, consequently, they should be treated as ends rather than means. Doing otherwise is immoral. Let’s see what can be done about the problems, learn the lessons, and move forward without depersonalizing any of the parties involved.

11 comments

Where You From?

There’s an interesting article in the New York Times tracing the migrations to and from states in the United States state by state. There are graphics from each state and I have, er, sampled graphics for my native state of Missouri (above) and my home state of Illinois (below).

There are some interesting distinctions between the two states. For example, in the year of my birth and through most of my youth the percentage of those born outside the United States living in Missouri was very small—less than 5%—while the same figure in Illinois was double that or more. I suspect that if you could take that statistic down to the county level you’d find most of the foreign-born in Illinois then living in Cook County and its collar counties. My point here is that this presents a very different life experience.

Another example is the larger percentage of people moving from southern states to Missouri compared with Illinois. I suspect if you coujld drill that down to the county level you’d find most of those southern immigrants in the far southern part of the state, the part bordering Arkansas and Kentucky.

52 comments

Playing the Outfield

The process of catching a fly ball in baseball isn’t one of placing yourself where the ball is. It’s a complex problem of figuring out where the ball will be, reconciled with the time it will take you to get there, and having the athletic prowess to do that. That’s why crafting good policy is difficult, too. The problems you’re trying to solve don’t stand still while you’re trying to solve them.

That’s the kernel of truth in Dr. Scott Atlas’s criticism of the PPACA: the very existence of the law will change the structure of the healthcare and insurance systems it’s intended to reform in ways that its authors could not, cannot, and will not be able to predict. That has several implications. First, the longer the implementation and enforcement of the law are postponed, the greater the gap between the system it was designed for and the system that will exist will be. And, more importantly from my perspective, it assumes continuing refinement of the law over time at a faster pace than our system of government can manage.

However, there are plenty of untruths and half-truths in his op-ed as well. For example, I think the only way the PPACA can be characterized as “a halfway move toward the single-payer model” is if other payers are withdrawing themselves at an appreciable rate. To my eye that doesn’t seem to be happening, at least not yet.

Nonetheless, it’s true that healthcare costs are rising everywhere, not just here, even under single-payer systems and fully socialized systems which Dr. Scott jumbles in his op-ed.

I have some questions. I think it’s clear that the future of healthcare financing is some combination of public and private. What’s the right balance and how is it achieved? Where will the ball be when we can get there?

Also, what is the role of the U. S. system of healthcare and insurance in increasing costs outside the U. S.? If you say “there isn’t any”, you’re asserting that the cost of training and paying providers is irrelevant to costs, a remarkable assertion, or that providers are not portable which is simply false.

3 comments