Death of a Patient

Thomas Eric Duncan has died:

Thomas Eric Duncan, the first person ever diagnosed with Ebola in the United States, died Wednesday morning, according to the hospital in Dallas that had been treating him.

Duncan’s death came eight days after his diagnosis, which set off a panicked search for anyone who may have had contact with him and sparked new fears over how ready hospitals and government agencies are for any additional Ebola cases in the country. He died at 7:51 a.m., Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital said.

Ebola is a deadly disease, killing half or more of those who contract it. Attributing recoveries to palliative care received in U. S. hospitals or experimental therapies administered is premature to say the least. Many will die; some will recover.

What must be noted from Mr. Duncan’s experience and that of the Spanish nurse who contracted Ebola is that doctors and nurses make mistakes. They make mistakes even when lives are in the balance. Even when their own lives and those of their loved ones are in the balance. Any protocol that depends on perfect compliance is doomed to failure whether it’s applied in the United States or in Liberia.

If we wish to mitigate the risk of an Ebola outbreak beyond West Africa, relying on protocols that require perfect adherence is a forlorn hope.

7 comments

Actuarial Valuation Drift

I found this post on a little-remarked upon feature of the PPACA very interesting. Apparently, the structures established by the law create a repeating condition of ferment in healthcare plans:

But at least grandfathering cancellations are time-limited; once grandfathered policies are gone, the problem is over. But metallic-tier cancellations will be a permanent fixture, re-emerging every year.

Here’s why: Under the ACA, insurers must restrict individual and small-group policies to four narrow tiers of “actuarial value” (AV) — the average percentage of medical expenses a plan pays. The ranges are bronze (58 to 62 percent), silver (68 to 72 percent), gold (78 to 82 percent), and platinum (88 to 92 percent).

[…]

With narrow tiers, AV drift forces insurers to either cancel policies or undergo considerable effort to push them back into compliance. Adjustments may render policies unprofitable. “Fixing” a plan means a new actuarial analysis and a costly, time-consuming process of submitting the amended plan to state and local officials for approval.

In other words under the law health insurance plans have short shelf lives. For some, this ongoing creation of new plans is a feature of the PPACA. For most people who don’t make picking insurance plans a life’s work it’s likely to become a blamed nuisance.

7 comments

Changing Objectives

If you do not will the means, you cannot will the ends. That is the message from the editors of the Washington Post on the president’s current bombing campaign against the “Islamic State”:

TWO MONTHS after the United States began airstrikes in Iraq, and two weeks after they were extended into Syria, the forces of the Islamic State are still advancing. Last week they captured the Iraqi towns of Hit and Kubaisa, northwest of Baghdad. On Tuesday they appeared close to overrunning Kobane, a strategic city on the border between Syria and Turkey that is populated by Kurds. The enemy victories are happening in spite of U.S. and allied airstrikes and resistance from local forces. They suggest that the U.S. air campaign is failing to achieve the minimal aim of stopping the expansion of the Islamic State — much less “degrading” and “destroying” it.

Why can’t the U.S.-led coalition prevent a ragtag insurgent army from overrunning large towns? The answers speak to the limitations imposed on the military campaign by President Obama as well as the continuing political complications of fighting the Islamic State. Military analysts point out that U.S. strikes on Islamic State forces around Kobane have come late and in small handfuls — not enough, as of Tuesday, to turn back thousands of fighters armed with tanks and artillery. In contrast with the successful 2002 air campaign against the Taliban in Afghanistan, U.S. pilots cannot rely on Special Forces spotters to identify targets. Mr. Obama has ruled out such ground personnel despite requests from military commanders.

They conclude:

The restrictions Mr. Obama has imposed on his commanders are not compatible with the objectives he has asked them to achieve.

The editors of the Wall Street Journal concur:

The Turks and friendly Arab are looking for American leadership in Kobani and beyond. The Syrian city needs weapons and fuel supplies, a more intense bombing campaign, and maybe U.S. Special Forces to end the ISIS siege. This early crisis in the Obama campaign exposes flaws in his strategy that will continue to undermine the military effort and the anti-ISIS regional alliance.

No successful war plan is static, and Mr. Obama needs to adjust his now if he wants to stop a massacre in Kobani and the continuing march of ISIS.

To clarify my own views on the campaign, I believe that our interests in opposing the “Islamic State” do not at this time reach the level of war, that the means by which the president has elected to oppose it are insufficient to achieve his stated goals, but the real goals—domestic political ones—have already been accomplished. I don’t believe the president will adjust the tactics being used to put more Americans in harm’s way. That would undermine those domestic objectives. I think it’s far more likely that he will reframe his objectives to lower expectations, blaming the Turks, Syrians, Iraqis, and, probably, the Republicans.

I’m not pro-war. I’m anti-bluster. I think that setting objectives you cannot hope to achieve by the means you are willing to utilize undermines the U. S. deterrent.

1 comment

Outcomes in Hong Kong

What’s the most likely resolution of the demonstrationss in Hong Kong? I can imagine:

  • Tiananmen II. The CCP puts the hammer down.
  • The CCP agrees to the demonstrators’ demands.
  • Nothing. The demonstrations become a more-or-less permanent aspect of Hong Kong life.
  • The demonstrators give up.

I don’t have any real insights into what the outcome is likely to be although I think that the first and third are probably the most likely.

4 comments

At Last

I’ve finally read something that comports with my view of what ails the U. S. economy (hat tip: Commentary) Economist Peter Morici explains it here. The reasons he lists are:

  1. Poorly Enforced Trade Agreements
  2. Misguided Energy Policies
  3. Burdensome Government Regulations and Taxes
  4. Corruption and Monopolies
  5. Disincentives to Work, Poorly Run Universities and Immigration

To these I would add tax and other policies that reduce the incentives for American businesses to invest capital here in the United States. Our basic problem is not that consumers aren’t spending enough. It’s that we’re too highly dependent on consumer spending for economic growth—much more so than Europe or China.

10 comments

How Republicans Could Lose the Senate

Stuart Rothenberg lays out the actions by which Democrats could hold on to the Senate:

  • Localize the elections. The more the midterms are about the president and his policies (or the Senate leadership for that matter) the worse things will be for Democrats in the “battleground states”. In those states the president’s taking an active role energizes Republicans and independents while Democrats are lukewarm about him. In a low turnout election whose voters turn out is all-important.
  • The ground game. If Democrats can register more voters and get them to vote it could make a big difference. As the percentage of registrations rises, that’s a strategy with a shelf-life and it may already be less effective than it once was.
  • Outspend the Republicans. Contrary to mythology, Democrats are highly dependent on large donors and those donors, especially public sector labor unions, have been spending as though there is not tomorrow because, as it works out, there is no tomorrow.

Finally, there’s what is ultimately uncontrollable—the news. If unfolding events break in a way favorable to Democrats it could make the difference in a close election. That’s the greatest longshot of all and I hope that Democrats aren’t relying on it.

1 comment

Handicapping the Illinois Governor’s Race

It’s just three weeks until the general election and I honestly don’t know who will prevail in the Illinois governor’s race, the incumbent Democratic Gov. Pat Quinn or the challenger, wealthy Republican businessman Bruce Rauner.

On the one hand I don’t see how the same policies that have dug Illinois into the hole in which we now find ourselves will eventually succeed if we just persist at them long enough. On the other hand Rauner’s proposals consist largely of Underpants Gnome schemes and the reality is that his campaign is predicated on his not being Pat Quinn.

I think whatever happens it will be close and it will be largely dependent on turnout. If Cook County doesn’t turn out for Quinn, he’s in trouble. My guess is that there will be record-breaking low turnout just as there was in the primaries.

6 comments

Talking Turkey

You know I wonder how long it will take before the cognoscenti in Washington figure out that the Islamist regime running Turkey today is on the other side in the fight against the “Islamic State”?

4 comments

Wanted Solvent or Insolvent

The Wall Street Journal is amused that, being unable to ignore the report from whistle-blower Carmen Segarra and the reports based on her tapes from the radio program This American Life, journalists have just discovered regulatory capture:

The financial scandal du jour involves leaked audio recordings that purport to show that regulators at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York were soft on Goldman Sachs . Say it ain’t so.

The news is being treated as shocking by journalists who claim to be hard-headed students of financial markets. One especially impressionable columnist calls it “a jaw-dropping story about Wall Street regulation.” The real scandal here is the excessive faith that liberal journalists and politicians continue to put in financial regulation. The media pack is discovering regulatory capture—a mere 43 years after George Stigler published his landmark paper on the concept.

The editors of the WSJ, sadly, don’t propose a solution to the problem. Eliminating regulation, presumably their preference, will not happen. Banks need bank regulations as much as non-bankers do.

I’ve proposed my solutions before. We need to increase fines on miscreant banks to a level where breaking the law isn’t considered an acceptable risk any more. We need to pay large bounties to whistle-blowers. And, most of all, we need to cultivate an adversarial relationship between bankers and regulators. There needs to be a career path for a young lawyer, economist, or accountant in which fame and fortune can be achieved that doesn’t run through the banks and that, indeed, makes you poisonous to banks. I think regulators should be allowed to keep a percentage of fines. It would at least align incentives.

4 comments

Goings-On

Last weekend we went to Minneapolis for a family wedding—one of my nephews married his long-time girlfriend, a genuinely lovely girl. I couldn’t be happier for them. It was a joyous occasion but exhausting.

If you’ve never been to Minneapolis, it’s a bit like a Midwestern version of the TV show Portlandia. Very organic, artisanal, etc. Alternatively, Garrison Keillor has been explaining what Minneapolis is like on the radio for the last 30 some-odd years.

It was a whirlwind visit. We flew in on Saturday, took a few minutes to drop in to the shop in St. Paul from which we regularly buy our tea mailorder, checked into the hotel, went to the wedding and reception, went back to the hotel, collapsed, woke the next morning, checked out of the hotel, got onto a plane, and flew back.

3 comments