Taking as his point of departure the same Paul Krugman column that was a point of departure for me yesterday, James Taranto makes a similar response to mine:
Left-liberal commentators are characteristically apoplectic, but few if any dispute the plaintiffs’ central contention: that the language of the statute does limit the subsidies to taxpayers who purchase policies on state exchanges. Today’s column by former Enron adviser Paul Krugman—who asserts that “the court shocked many observers†by taking the case—goes through all the alternative arguments and adds a new one that is particularly imaginative and revealing.
The column’s title, “Death by Typo,†signals two of the arguments. The oft-heard claim that the statutory provision is a mere “typo†is frivolous. “There is a specific legal doctrine that deals with typos—the scrivener’s error doctrine,†observes Sean Trende of RealClearPolitics. “As far as I can tell, the government has not asserted the scrivener’s error doctrine in this case. It isn’t that someone mis-copied the bill upon publication. At best, it is that the bill was not carefully edited enough before being debated and voted upon.†(He means “carefully enough edited†or “edited carefully enough.â€)
Krugman asserts further that regardless of what the law actually says, it is “clear from everything else in the act that there was no intention to set such limits,†and, moreover, that “you can ask the people who drafted the law what they intended, and it wasn’t what the plaintiffs claim.â€
That is at best debatable. As we noted in July, one of the law’s architects, Jonathan Gruber, endorsed the plaintiffs’ claim in early 2012, although he now disavows it and falls back on the “typo†excuse.
Moreover, many lawmakers who voted for the act—along with the president—asserted at the time that it was their intention to ensure that “if you like your plan, you can keep your plan.†In that respect, the law trumped the intention. Does Krugman think the executive branch has the authority to nullify a law based on its preferred view of the “intention� We’ll believe that if he makes an analogous argument when a Republican is in the White House.
He does put more flesh on the bones of the argument than I did as befits a man who makes his living by stating opinions unlike me for whom it is merely a hobby.
I wish that those who want the Supreme Court to make up for the Congress’s miscalculation would produce a clear statement of how they would like the Court and, more generally, the government to function not just in this specific case but as a general rule. Is it their preferred approach to government that the president articulate some lofty goals, the Congress endorse that by dumping a boatload of hastily drafted thoughts onto pages, basically whatever they can get the votes to enact, and the Court, the least democratic of the three branches of government, remedy the deficiencies later?
What was it that the road to hell was said to have been paved with? The idea that intentions can be imputed from political affiliation makes me very uncomfortable.
Quite to the contrary I think that you can infer intentions from what people actually do.

Every week members of the Watcher’s Council weigh on a single question. 




