Eugene Robinson applauds the incipient carbon emissions agreement between China and the United States:
This week’s stunning announcement of a long-range agreement between the Obama administration and the Chinese government over carbon emissions is the best environmental news in years. Not to sound grandiose, it means the world still has a chance to save itself from unmitigated disaster.
The significance of the accord, which was doggedly pursued by Secretary of State John Kerry, is not just that the world’s two biggest emitters of greenhouse gases have agreed to take action. China’s ambitious target of generating 20 percent of its energy from sources other than fossil fuels by 2030 promises massive investment and innovation — a huge boost for clean-energy technologies, with impact worldwide.
I think I must be confused. My understanding was that the planet was threatened by the amount of carbon being spewed into the atmosphere, not by the rate of increase of the spewing. Can someone produce some evidence that’s the case?
If, on the other hand, my understanding is correct, the standard by which the agreement should be judged is by whether it reduces the amount of carbon emissions. If it does, I’d like to see the numbers. So far the entire discussion has been very short on numbers. Let’s do a little back-of-the-envelope calculation. If China’s emissions increase by just 1% a year, we’d need to reduce our emissions by 15% a year to compensate for it. Can anybody see any realistic prospect of that happening? Over the period of 15 years?
To my mind Tom Maguire sums the agreement up pretty accurately:
This seems like a good opportunity to introduce my new diet plan. YOU will cut out sugar, sweets, treats, carbs, and beer and limit your alcohol to one drink per day or less. I won’t change a thing. But together, and on average, I believe we will lose a lot of weight – let’s go!
I also think that, contrary to the administration’s predictions and those of its rooting section, the agreement sets a very bad precedent. India, Brazil, Russia, and other major emitters will need to do nothing for the foreseeable future because China, the largest emitter, didn’t.

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.




