The Role of Genetics in Autism

I read a provocative article at the BBC on a twins study that provides some evidence for something that I’ve been wondering about for some time:

Autism is caused by genetic make-up in 74-98% of cases, a Medical Research Council study of 516 twins indicates.

The King’s College London team said 181 of the teenagers had autism, but the rate was far higher in the identical twins, who share the same DNA.

The researchers told JAMA Psychiatry tens if not hundreds of genes were involved, and they do not rule out environmental factors entirely.

Both twins in each pair had been raised by their parents in the same household.

which is the role that genetics plays in autism. Over the years lots of candidates for the “cause” of autism have been put foreward. From the 1950s through the 1970s (at least) childrearing practices were blamed, the “refrigerator mother” (look it up) hypothesis. That was succeeded by the suggestion of possible environmental factors. Everything from preconception parental behaviors to vaccines have been blamed at one time or another.

In my view the cause of autism is probably multi-factorial but it’s going to become increasingly difficult to deny that genetics plays some role. The follow-up question is why has there been an up-tick in the diagnosis of autism? The article’s explanation is that’s an artifact of physicians making more diagnoses rather than more frequent occurrence but I have my doubts. I can’t help but wonder if, unwittingly, we’ve been breeding selectively for autism.

That is the way evolution works, after all. Traits that were favorable in the parents are reproduced. If those traits are amplified in the offspring, that can result in the amplified version of the traits being unfavorable in them.

3 comments

Where You Sit Is Where You Stand

The usual suspects are lining up in the usual way on the subject of how the justices of the Supreme Court will decide King v. Burwell, the latest case against the Affordable Care Act. The editors of the New York Times think the case is frivolous and can’t see how the justices could fail to decide in favor of the PPACA:

The case, King v. Burwell, will determine the fate of legislation that has transformed the American health care system. But the argument provided few solid clues to how the justices will rule.

The chief justice remained virtually silent for the entire argument, while most of the others took predictable positions in questioning the government or the challengers. The surprise this time came from Justice Anthony Kennedy, who had voted with the dissenters from the 2012 decision that upheld the Affordable Care Act and appeared to have no interest in protecting the law.

Nevertheless, Justice Kennedy flagged a “serious constitutional problem” with the current challenge, which focuses on a single phrase — “established by the State” — embedded deep in a subsection of the act.

Michael Carvin, the plaintiffs’ lawyer, had been arguing — against all evidence and logic — that when Congress passed the act in 2010, it simultaneously undermined the law’s central goal of affordable health care for all Americans by supposedly denying tax-credit subsidies to all residents in the 34 states where the federal government runs the health care exchange.

while the editors of the Wall Street Journal argue that the plaintiff’s case is a strong one:

King v. Burwell turns on the statute’s plain text limiting health subsidies to those insurance exchanges established by the states, rather than the 36 run by the federal government as fallbacks. This condition for federal dollars was meant as an incentive for Governors to participate in ObamaCare, which is the normal framework whenever Washington wants to enlist the states to act on its behalf under cooperative federalism, from Medicaid to highway funding to clean-air laws.

But Justices Anthony Kennedy, Elena Kagan and others wondered if this arrangement crosses over from Congress merely attempting to influence state decisions into using spending and regulation to compel these sovereigns to join ObamaCare. “From the standpoint of the dynamics of federalism . . . there’s a serious constitutional problem if we adopt your argument,” Justice Kennedy told plaintiffs counsel Michael Carvin.

I have no idea how the justices will find. I do find the prevailing wisdom in the blogosphere, that the justices will simply vote their political affiliations, appalling. I think that’s a drastic oversimplification. In my view the justices’ theories of jurisprudence and judicial review, their ideologies, and their political affiliations are interwoven in complicated ways and all will play roles in how the case is ultimately decided.

Keep in mind that the same people who’ve been arguing all along that the case was completely frivolous and couldn’t possibly make it as far as the Supreme Court are now arguing that it’s completely frivolous and the Supreme Court will reject the plaintiff’s case. And that the Obama Administration’s record on cases brought before the Supreme Court has been, frankly, lousy. They’ve been defeated by unanimous votes of the justices too many times for an administration that’s supposed to have so many smart lawyers.

All this to say that I won’t be surprised whether the justices support or reject the plaintiff’s case and I don’t think anybody else should be, either.

3 comments

Wings Available on NetFlix

If you’ve got a NetFlix subscription (and most of you probably do), there’s something you might want to check out. The 1927 film Wings is now available for streaming at NetFlix. It’s an important picture for three reasons. First, (unless you consider The Actor a silent movie) it remains the only silent film to have won the Academy Award for Best Picture. It was the first Best Picture winner. Second, it’s the picture that made Gary Cooper a star.

Finally and most importantly its aerial combat scenes remain some of the greatest ever put on film. Keep in mind that this movie was made more than a half century before even primitive computer graphics-driven special effects were possible. We’ll never see anything like those scenes again.

4 comments

Foreign Policy Blogging at OTB

I’ve just published a foreign policy-related post at Outside the Beltway:

Joint Iraqi-Iranian Operations in Tikrit

There is a joint operation presently going on to retake the city of Tikrit from DAESH which includes the participation of the Iraqi army, elements of the Iranian military, and Shi’ite militiamen. We didn’t know anything about it (or at least claim not to have known anything about it) until it was already under way.

1 comment

The Race So Far

With a family history in the theater and years spent in the theater, I have a quirk. Actually, I have many but the one I’m talking about here I describe as always seeing the personality of the actor coming across the footlights to me. The upshot of this, as you might expect, is that there are certain very troubled performers that I find quite painful to watch. That’s my reaction to the recent set of close-in pleas to the camera being made by Rahm Emanuel in his bid for re-election.

Here’s how Alex Isenstadt at Politico sees things:

Recent polling shows the race between Emanuel and his unknown and underfunded rival, Jesus “Chuy” Garcia, has closed to within single digits. With local and national progressive groups lining up behind Garcia and promising to pour cash into the effort to deny Emanuel a second term, the mayor is suddenly scratching and clawing for his political existence.

“In Chicago, politics is a contact sport, and it looks like we’re going to have one of those full-contact battles,” said Bill Daley, a former White House chief of staff whose father and brother each served as Chicago mayor for more than 20 years.
Emanuel — once thought to be a shoo-in in the April 7 runoff — plans to launch an ad campaign in the coming days intended to discredit Garcia and cast him as a do-nothing pol who’s accomplished little during his two decades in public service, according to sources close to the mayor. The commercials will also present the mayor, who’s come under fire for closing underperforming schools in hardscrabble neighborhoods and for hiking taxes to close the city’s budget deficit, as someone who is willing to make tough decisions even if they aren’t popular.

I have no doubt that the mayor will come across as sincere in these ads. There’s a certain shall we say personality type that always comes across as sincere. Will smearing his opponent be an effective strategy? Or will it depress the turnout of both his supporters as well as his opponents below the 25% I would think will turn out for the run-off? Is running on his record an effective strategy for the mayor? Or will it remind people of why they don’t like him?

0 comments

What About the Rest?

I agree with two of the assertions made by John B. Taylor in his recent Wall Street Journal op-ed. First, that the Obama Administration has been satisfied with far too litte:

For years I and many others have argued that a return to the principles of economic freedom would convert this not-so-great recovery into a great one. But Washington has not seriously considered pro-growth policy—no tax reform to lower tax rates and spur hiring, no regulatory reform to scale back costly regulations, no new free-trade agreements, no entitlement reform to stop the debt explosion, and at best only a hint at monetary normalization to reduce uncertainty.

One reason: There is growing skepticism that these tried and true policies will boost growth rates. It is too late now, pessimists say. The economy missed the 6% or 7% 1980s-style growth at the start of the recovery, and it is impossible to make it up. Or even more pessimistically, an incurable “secular stagnation” plagues the economy with permanently diminished rates of return on investment and ever-increasing income inequality. Why bother with difficult reforms if they won’t make much difference? At least we’re doing better than Europe.

Not once in six years has the Obama Administration even put forward a plan to return to full employment. Blaming it on the Republicans is a lot easier than working for change but that’s the difference between running for office and doing the job.

And the Administration should pay more attention to the labor force participation rate:

As a matter of arithmetic, the growth of the economy equals employment growth plus productivity growth. Simply reversing the decline in the labor-force participation rate—it fell every year of the so-called recovery, to 62.9% in 2014 from 66% in 2008—would cause a 5% increase in employment, or 1% growth for five years. Adding about 1% for population growth from Census projections equals employment growth of 2% a year. The percentage of the working-age population that is working would thereby finally exceed 2009 levels, and the U.S. would begin seeing promising changes.

I wish Dr. Taylor had provided more suggestions for turning that around.

For the last two decades education policy has been the substitute for economic policy. At best that provides a solution for half of young Americans. What is to become of the rest? Are they to become permanent wards of the state?

For all of human history work has been more than just a paycheck. It’s been a source of purpose, meaning, and pride. What will replace that? Drugs? Facebook?

4 comments

Netanyahu’s Speech

I disapprove of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s addressing Congress on constitutional grounds. The Congress’s role in foreign policyh is delineated clearly there and inviting foreign heads of government to address them exceeds that. However, I agree with the editors of the Washington Post that the president should respond to Mr. Netanyahu’s claims with something other than pique and sniping:

Nevertheless, Mr. Netanyahu’s arguments deserve a serious response from the Obama administration — one it has yet to provide. The White House has sought to dismiss the Israeli leader as a politician seeking reelection; has said that he was wrong in his support for the Iraq war and in his opposition to an interim agreement with Iran; and has claimed that he offers no alternative to President Obama’s policy. Such rhetoric will not satisfy those in and out of Congress who share Mr. Netanyahu’s legitimate questions.

Being wrong on the invasion of Iraq isn’t much of a criticism. It also characterizes our last two Secretaries of State, both of whom were appointed by President Obama. Obviously, the president doesn’t consider that a disqualification. That the prime minister is a politician isn’t much of a criticism, either. BTW, I agree with the assessment that the prime minister’s visit is a political move whose target audience is Israelis. The Congress shouldn’t be so foolish as to allow themselves to become props in foreign elections.

However, the way to respond to arguments is with counter-arguments not ad hominems and the president should provide more of them.

Update

The editors of the Wall Street Journal are much more favorably disposed to PM Netanyahu:

For all the White House’s fretting beforehand about the speech’s potential damage to U.S.-Israel relations, Mr. Netanyahu was both bipartisan and gracious to Mr. Obama for all he “has done for Israel,” citing examples previously not publicly known. But the power of the speech—the reason the Israeli leader was willing to risk breaking diplomatic china to give it—was its systematic case against the looming nuclear deal.

Point by point, he dismantled the emerging details and assumptions of what he called a “very bad deal.” The heart of his critique concerned the nature of the Iranian regime as a terror sponsor of long-standing that has threatened to “annihilate” Israel and is bent on regional domination.

The Administration argues that a nuclear accord will help move the revolutionary regime toward moderation. But Mr. Netanyahu spent some 15 minutes laying out the regime’s historical record. Since Hasan Rouhani became president in 2013, Iran’s internal repression has become worse than in the days of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad . Iran has doubled down on its military support for Bashar Assad in Syria, gained control of north Yemen through its Houthi militia proxies, and continued to arm Hezbollah in Lebanon, Hamas in Gaza and Shiite militias in Iraq.

Those are interesting claims. Is there any actual evidence that the Houthi are Iranian proxies? Or is it merely assumed that all Shi’ites are in cahoots? And like Assad or not the present Syrian government is the internationally recognized government of Syria with a seat in the UN General Assembly. The US, in a bizarre turn of events, has been supporting Al Qaeda and DAESH against it.

I’m skeptical of the White House’s apparent belief that we can have a productive relationship with the mullahs who rule Iran. That’s a reversal of more than thirty years of US policy and it deserves more than a few comebacks.

11 comments

The Devil You Know

Tom Bevan calls for the re-election of Rahm Emanuel:

So Rahm got his comeuppance. He also became a historical footnote: He’s the first (and only) mayor in Chicago to be forced into a re-election runoff since the city shifted to the “non-partisan” election system in 1995.

It’s not hard to see why many were rooting for Rahm’s humiliation. His foul-mouthed, tough-guy shtick has worn thin over the past four years. His record of accomplishment is even thinner.

Some of his supporters feel he hasn’t gone far enough in tackling the serious budget issues facing the city. (He still has tire marks on his back from getting run over by Chicago Teachers Union President Karen Lewis in his first term.) Despite some nibbling around the edges, the city still faces massive fiscal issues which Emanuel has yet to address in any meaningful way.

Meanwhile his enemies, including the aforementioned Lewis, feel he’s gone too far on the budget and accuse him of racism, among other things, for closing some 50 public schools in poor neighborhoods around the city. They also accuse Emanuel of catering too much to business — those evil one percenters, in particular — and claim he’s responsible for creating “two Chicagos”: one where the downtown thrives and the other in which the neighborhoods on the south and west sides are left behind.

Mr. Bevan’s basic point is that bad as Emanuel is Chuy Garcia would be worse.

I think he needs to look at the bigger picture. Chicago will need a full-time mayor and whether he’s re-elected or not Rahm Emanuel won’t be a full-time mayor. He’ll inevitably be drawn into the presidential election and Chicago will receive short shrift. The difference between Michael Bloomberg and Rahm Emanuel is that Michael Bloomberg knows something about business. Rahm Emanuel knows something about fundraising.

Mayor Emanuel had better hope that my neighbors aren’t typical of Chicagoans. His support is extremely thin here. Of the Chicagoans that bothered voting the majority voted for “Anybody But Emanuel” and that feeling hasn’t gone away yet.

0 comments

Business Model Failure

I’ve got some advice for Catherine Rampell:

McDonald’s has thus far tried to address its image crisis by giving away free food and airing sentimental ads. But a better, more effective solution might be to address the sources of its troubles head on, and try to become a better global corporate citizen.

A lot of the superannuated hipsters who are complaining about McDonalds being a bad corporate citizen wouldn’t be caught dead in a McDonalds and there’s nothing the franchiser can do to change that. Its franchisees can’t raise their prices enough to cover the additional costs that would be incurred without business falling off disastrously.

McDonalds problem is business model failure. The company grew up in a period when there were a lot of growing families and lots of young workers without responsibilities coming into the job market for the first time. Cheap grub and cost control was the basic model. Those days are gone and the golden arches have lost their luster.

4 comments

The Other Shoe

Three prominent House Republicans double down on the Senate proposal for amending the PPACA that I mentioned yesterday. Here’s the kernel:

Here’s how it would work:

First, make coverage more affordable. Any state that uses our off-ramp would be able to opt out of ObamaCare’s insurance mandates. These coverage requirements are driving up costs, so eliminating them would empower individuals and families to choose from a wider range of plans that fit their personal needs and budgets. Our proposal will also allow participating states to opt out of ObamaCare’s burdensome individual and employer mandates, allowing Americans to purchase the coverage they want.

We would also force insurers to compete for your business, rather than force Americans to buy a government-approved health plan under the threat of IRS fines. Let people buy insurance across state lines. Stop frivolous lawsuits by enacting medical-liability reform. Let small businesses band together so they get a fair deal from insurance companies. Our committees and nonpartisan analysts alike estimate that these proposals will cut costs and raise quality across the board.

At the same time, we would set up other safeguards for patients. We would allow parents to keep children on their plan until age 26. We would prohibit insurers from imposing lifetime limits on benefits. We would protect people with existing conditions. And we would guarantee renewability for people already enrolled in a plan.

Second, help people buy coverage. Right now, those who get insurance through their employer get a lot of help from the tax code, while some people who buy insurance on their own, including potentially the millions of Americans the IRS put at risk, get no help at all. So we would offer those in the affected states a tax credit to buy insurance.

The credit would be “advanceable”—that is, you would get it when you needed it; you wouldn’t have to wait for tax season. It also would be “refundable”—that is, you would get the full amount no matter the size of your tax bill. And would adjust the size of the credit for age; the elderly, who face higher coverage costs, would get more support.

That confirms what I said yesterday—they’re ending White House regulation of what’s acceptable or not acceptable in healthcare insurance. And it relies on something I think is fictive: that there is a market in healthcare. There is no functioning market when the cost of entry is as high as it is in healthcare. And healthcare consumers are not rational optimizers. They don’t distinguish well between economizing on necessary healthcare and economizing on unnecessary healthcare and by and large those decisions are made for them by their physicians anyway.

0 comments