Ways and Means

Nicholas Kristof cites, apparently with approval, the following strategies to reduce income inequality:

  • Government should be more concerned with monopolies and competition policy.
  • Trade unions should be bolstered to represent workers’ interests.
  • Government should provide public-sector jobs at minimum wage to those who want them, in areas such as meals-on-wheels, elderly care, child care and so on.
  • In addition to a minimum wage, there should be a framework to restrain pay at the highest levels. Atkinson cites companies that have voluntarily decreed that executive pay should be capped at 65 or 75 times the average pay in the firm.
  • Personal income taxes should be made more progressive, with a maximum rate of 65 percent.
  • Every child should get a “child benefit” payment, to help keep kids out of poverty.

Just for the record I support his first proposal, think the second is fighting the last war (which has already been lost), cautiously support the third, agree with the fourth but think it’s beyond the power of the federal government to effect without disastrous consequences, and have grave reservations about the sixth. Have we learned nothing from our experience with AFDC? Watch the movie Precious some time for a primer.

It’s the fifth I’m curious about. I have no objection to it in principle but am skeptical that it will accomplish anything. Consider the history of the effective rate of taxation. I’ll save you the trouble of clicking over. It’s been tremendously stable over a very great period of time, resistant to changes in marginal tax rates. The only exception has been during a period of national emergency (World War II).

What measures does Mr. Kristof think should be implemented to increase the effective rate of taxation of the highest income earners?

#3 could be quite expensive. Unless you think that the federal government can extend credit to itself indefinitely without a collapse in the dollar, that means that additional revenue will be needed. Additional revenue means more than increasing the marginal rate of taxation. It means increasing the effective rate.

What concerns me about the plan is that even if all of the above were implemented it still wouldn’t do much about income inequality. To do that you’ve got to train your guns on the top 3% of income earners rather than just the top .1%, curtail immigration, and stop currency manipulators.

1 comment

Dreaming

There must a word for it. Every once in a while I run across an argument that if we implement some extreme form of some program or other that all sorts of benefits would flow from it. That’s frequently the argument that anarcho-capitalists make. If we just get rid of all laws and government other than what’s necessary to enforce contracts, think how great it would be!

Most recently I’ve heard the same sort of claims made about drug legalization. We need to end the “War on Drugs” (by which they mean the legalization of all Schedule 1 drugs). Think of all the resources that won’t be squandered on police and prisons and all of the people who won’t be encarcerated!

The problem with all of these utopian plans is that only when the most extreme version is implemented will the benefits accrue. Take the case of ending the “War on Drugs”. There is no prospect whatever that all Schedule 1 drugs will be legalized and with anything less than that there will still be a war on drugs. Drug dealers will continue to be sentenced to prison terms and police will still be needed to enforce the laws.

As a matter of social policy I think we should legalize the possession and personal use of marijuana to bring the law into line with what’s actually happening in the country. Resign ourselves to reality. However, it should be recognized that even in states where marijuana has been legalized it continues to be illegal to give or sell it to minors (widely considered the bulk of the market).

Ironically, that would just be bringing the laws on marijuana into line with the laws on alcohol during Prohibition. Personal use and possession of alcohol was never illegal and individuals were allowed to make beer and wine for their and their family’s use.

6 comments

The Problem

I shop and run errands on Saturdays. On a typical Saturday I’ll hit the bank, grocery store, the hardware store, Costco, the drugstore, and the vet’s. While I’m doing so I typically listen to NPR. If it’s after 1:00pm I listen to oldtime radio, broadcast every Saturday afternoon on one of our public radio stations.

Yesterday on my appointed rounds on This American Life I heard the extremely bizarre story of how the late North Korean dictator Kim Jong-Il had South Korea’s most famous actress and her equally famous director ex-husband kidnapped. Think Elizabeth Taylor in her 50s and, say, Steven Spielberg to get some idea of the importance of the figures we’re talking about.

You can listen to the whole story at the link. I wish I had a transcript but, unfortunately, none is available yet.

The aspect of the story that struck me most strongly was an audio tape of remarks by Kim Jong-Il that the couple brought back with them when they at long last escaped their captors. In the course of his remarks in identifying the reasons that North Korean films were so lousy he gave as succinct a critique of socialism as heard. Essentially what he said was if his filmmakers make a good film, they get their rations. If they make a bad film, they get the same rations.

The problem is that true socialism runs afoul of human nature.

Here in the United States very few people want true socialism. They don’t trust government enough and for good reason. We don’t have the kind of consensus here that some European countries, particularly the Scandinavian countries, do. Government here is viewed more as a tool for personal gain rather than as one for public gain. And socialism for private gain is no better than oligarchy or corporatism for private gain.

0 comments

The Golden Thread

This morning I’ve listened to a lot of news reports on the indictments of the six police officers in Baltimore. In every single instance so far whenever a legal authority commented he or she expressed skepticism over the ability of prosecutors to secure convictions for the most serious of the charges. Some, like Alan Dershowitz, did so in very harsh terms:

“This is a very sad day for justice . . . Today had nothing to do with justice. Today was crowd control. Everything was motivated by a threat of riots and a desire to prevent riots,” Dershowitz said on “The Steve Malzberg Show.”

“The mayor outrageously said we’re going to get justice for the victim, the family and people of Baltimore, never mentioning the defendants. Under our Constitution, the only people who are entitled to justice are the defendants.

“They are presumed innocent, they need due process of law, and the mayor and the state attorney have made it virtually impossible for these defendants to get a fair trial. They have been presumed guilty.”

The skepticism is very much in line with what I’ve been saying. Those who are convinced that justice for Freddie Gray lies in putting police officers behind bars for second degree murder should prepare themselves to be disappointed.

I don’t know what the truth of this case is. I’m reserving judgment, as I think all of us should. However, I do know that the presumption of innocence is the golden thread that runs through the web of the criminal law. The very large number of would-be Madame Defarges who are crying for blood today does not lead to a good place.

11 comments

The Limits of Air Power

One of the lessons of warfare that I would have hoped we might have learned but apparently have not is that however effective it might be air power has distinct limitations. Significant among those is that air power gives you no ability to control the situation on the ground. If you misunderstand or are indifferent to the situation on the ground, the use of air power alone can have deadly consequences that persist for years:

Nearly 3,700 migrants were rescued from boats near the coast of Libya on Saturday and early on Sunday, the Italian coastguard said.

A spokesman said rescue operations were likely to continue throughout Sunday. All of those pulled from boats were being taken to Italy.

Italian authorities said the migrants were rescued by Italian and French navy vessels in 17 separate operations.

At least 1,750 people have died this year trying to cross the Mediterranean.

The number is a 20-fold increase on the same period in 2014, when 96 people died. Many more migrants are expected to make the crossing as smugglers take advantage of calmer weather.

Here’s what I think. If it’s not worth putting “boots on the ground” to try to control the outcome, we should have a lot more reluctance to use air power to achieve our objectives than we presently do.

2 comments

Old Age

Yesterday my wife and I received the distressing news that an elderly friend of our had entered what is likely to be a final decline. One of the many aspects of old age I don’t think people appreciate sufficiently is that however independent you’ve been throughout life inevitably there comes a point at which you will lose that independence and others will start making decisions for you.

That was true of my mother, one of the most staunchly independent individuals let alone women I have ever known. After having lived nearly a half century following my dad’s death as sole guide of her own life and fate at the end my siblings and I were making decisions for her. For some, like my mom, those making the decisions are spouses or children and these individuals may have different levels of ability, inclination, or even good will. For others it is strangers.

I won’t burden you wish the details of our friend’s situation. Suffice it to say it’s not a good one and there’s nothing any of us can do about it.

As Bette Davis put it, old age is no place for sissies.

0 comments

A Feature Not a Bug

More on that Disney thing that I commented on the other day:

A healthy U.S. immigration policy, as opposed to what we currently have, would encourage responsible levels of legal immigration, ideally adjustable to prevailing economic conditions, and have a high priority for skilled workers. It would also keep illegal immigration as low as is possible.
In addition, what a healthy immigration policy must not do—at either the low- or high-skilled level—is displace American jobs purely for corporate profit while at the same time creating an entire class of workers who do not enjoy the full rights of citizenship. The H-1B program as currently constituted, unfortunately, seems to do both those things. High-skilled Americans either lose their jobs or have their wages depressed, and America doesn’t get many of the usual benefits of allowing talented immigrants into our country through traditional means: the innovation, entrepreneurship, and drive that it adds to our culture and economy.

I want to hear from both parties how their preferred approach to immigration reform would prevent this.

0 comments

TV Comic Book Adaptations

When I was a kid I read a lot of comic books. I was an eclectic reader and comic books had their place along with Dickens, Isaac Asimov, Hawthorne, Mark Twain, Jules Verne, Robert Heinlein, H. Rider Haggard, Dumas, and boys’ (and girls’!) series books. That was a long time ago. I lost interest in comic books more than a half century ago.

Now comic books rule the world and everywhere you turn there’s a comic book adaptation, whether on the big screen or the small one (aside: the “small screen” isn’t so small any more). I thought I’d tell you my impressions of the comic book adaptations currently on TV.

Agent Carter

Agent Carter gave Peggy Carter from the first Captain America movie a vehicle of her own. I loved it and hope it returns. The acting is decent and I attribute a lot of the show’s charm to the attitude that its star, Hayley Atwell, gives the character. I find the cartoonish way it portrays the post-war period a bit trying at times but, heck, it’s a comic book.

Arrow

CW’s adaptation of the Green Arrow for television follows the CW formula. It has a very attractive young cast, short skirts, low-cut blouses, lots of beefcake, a very dark attitude, and terrible acting. It is a veritable festival of mugging, voguing, and reciting lines in extremely…portentous…tones. I found the first season interesting because of the concept and the angst-ridden central character. I’m starting to find it wearing.

Is the Arrow what has become of the Green Arrow in the comics these days? Green Arrow used to be funny. Played for laughs and armed with an enormous inventory of bizarre “arrows”. The very grim Arrow is nothing like that.

Daredevil

I’ve already expressed my views on this NetFlix series. I think it’s great.

The Flash

Same CW formula, this time applied to the Flash. Not nearly as dark as Arrow, initially I found the series evocative of the Golden Age Flash—a comic character. Over time that has faded, sadly from my point of view. As it becomes increasingly dark and angst-ridden, I’m starting to lose interest.

iZombie

Another CW series. Interesting concept: a young woman can prevent her deterioration into “full zombie mode” all the time by eating brains. When she does she gets some of the memories and abilities of the individuals whose brains she’s consuming. Uses that to solve crimes. Obtains her sustenance more or less benignly in the course of working as an assistant at the morgue. So far so good. I’ll give it a few more episodes.

Marvel’s Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.

I watched this for most of the first season but I just lost interest. Better acting and not quite as grim as either of the preceding CW series. I just didn’t care about any of the characters. I find most female martial arts masters require too much of suspension of disbelief. Interesting sidelight: did you know that Ming Na was over 50? Looks pretty good for her age.

The Walking Dead

Although it’s the grimmest of the grim, I think this is one of the best series of any genre on TV now. Short summary: surviving the zombie apocalypse. Acting is decent, the Georgia location shooting is interesting. The best thing about this series is its ability to use its McGuffin (zombies) to explore serious topics. Child-rearing. Society. Relationships under trying conditions.

Have I missed anything?

10 comments

The Fault, Dear Brutus, Is Not in the Stars But in Our Genes

There’s an article at The Economist that takes note of a study that has suggested that the placebo effects varies from individual to individual and may be governed by our genes:

One thing that is known about the placebo effect is that it involves several brain systems, each under the control of a particular type of messenger molecule, called a neurotransmitter. These systems, like everything else in the body, are regulated by genes. This has led some researchers to ask whether different versions of the genes in question might modulate a person’s susceptibility to placebos.

A review of these researchers’ studies, published recently in Trends in Molecular Medicine by one of them, Kathryn Hall of Harvard Medical School, and her colleagues, suggests genes do indeed seem to matter. Dr Hall looked for links between the placebo effect’s strength and certain mutations, known as single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), in which a single DNA “letter” in a gene is changed. Altogether she found 11 genes, in four neurotransmitter systems, where SNPs made a difference. Five were in the system mediated by dopamine, which includes the brain’s reward centres. Four were in the system mediated by serotonin, which regulates mood. And the opioid and endocannabinoid systems had one each.

As their names suggest, these two systems are affected respectively by opium and its derivatives, and by cannabis and its. The other two are affected by cocaine, which blocks the retrieval of dopamine into nerve cells, thus increasing its power as a messenger; and Prozac, which has the same effect on serotonin, and is used as an antidepressant. It is not hard to imagine a similarity between the workings of these drugs and what happens in the brain when the placebo effect is operating.

The genes for which most placebo-related SNP evidence exists encode enzymes called catechol-O-methyltransferase and monoamine oxidase. Both of these are parts of the dopamine system, and both are responsible for metabolising dopamine, and thus regulating the amount of it around. (Indeed, monoamine oxidase is the target of a second type of antidepressant, which has a different mechanism from Prozac.) People with different versions of either of these genes experience the placebo effect to different degrees. These various versions, moreover, are all commonplace, suggesting differences in placebo perception may be widespread.

That’s not a surprise to me. I have observed in myself that I don’t tend to exhibit much placebo effect. I’m a skeptic. Add to that my family’s common experience of unusual or even perverse reactions to drugs and it’s easy to understand why we might be wary of them. It’s pretty discouraging when the post-surgical painkiller prescribed by your physician induces excruciating pain.

4 comments

Segregation Correlated With Diversity

There’s an interesting post at 538 that points out that the most diverse cities are also the most segregated. Their examples are Chicago and Lincoln, Nebraska. As a city Chicago is very diverse. On a by neighborhood basis it’s very segregated. Lincoln, Nebraska is the opposite.

I consider my neighborhood pretty diverse. In this block alone there are two black families, two South Asian families, a Cambodian family, and two Hispanic families. One of the “white” families is a family of Polish immigrants. Another of Irish immigrants. In the house across the street from me the husband is Chicago Irish and the wife is Puerto Rican and Salvadoran.

0 comments