Just Like Grandma Used to Open

Megan McArdle seeks to debunk the idea that grandma was making traditional peasant food:

Nor does this “good country cooking” really come from the country. As Laudan says: “The dishes we call ethnic and assume to be of peasant origin were invented for the urban, or at least urbane, aristocrats who collected the surplus. This is as true of the lasagne of northern Italy as it is of the chicken konna of Mughal Delhi, the mooshu pork of imperial China, the pilafs, stuffed vegetables, and baklava of the great Ottoman palace in Istanbul, or the mee krob of nineteenth-century Bangkok. Cities have always enjoyed the best food and have invariably been the focal points of culinary innovation.”

Most of our ancestors were not wealthy urbanites; they were peasant farmers. Why are these things, then, so associated in our minds with the tired, the poor, the huddled masses yearning to breathe free, the wretched refuse of the teeming shores from which our grandparents emigrated?

I think Megan is either confused or over-generalizing. I would submit that very few of today’s Americans have or had rural peasant immigrant grandmothers. Great-grandmothers or great-great-grandmothers, maybe. Let’s start with my own experience (probably not very typical).

All four of my grandparents were born in the 19th century. One of my grandmothers was born in 1891, the other in 1898. One of my grandfathers was born previous to the fourth quarter of the 19th century. All were born in the United States. None was rural.

One of my grandmothers ran a restaurant but didn’t cook. The other was the daughter of a butcher and a cook and she was an excellent cook. I know and prepare some of her recipes. They weren’t remotely traditional rural peasant food.

I would suggest that most of our grandmothers’ recipes were the same mixes and processed ingredients that people are using now or at least their predecessors. Most were clipped out of newspapers, printed on the backs of commercial packaging, or taken from The Joy of Cooking or The Better Homes and Gardens Cookbook. You open a can of Campbell’s Cream of Mushroom Soup and dump it over cut up chicken pieces. You bake a beef roast sprinkled with a package of Lipton’s Onion Soup.

I would also suggest that our most recent wave of immigrants are mostly urban rather than rural. Their grandmothers’ recipes are “traditional” rather than being traditional.

In closing, I haven’t had a decent knish in 30 years. I know why. The grandmothers who made them have been dead for a half century and their daughters and granddaughters are doctors, lawyers, and marketing consultants who don’t have the time or inclination to learn their great-grandmothers’ recipes.

5 comments

Not Just a Franchise

As I was reminded recently, I’ve been blogging here for more than a decade. For several years before that I had been leaving long, link-filled comments on other people’s blogs. As early as the end of 2001 I was emphasizing the point that, contrary to the assertions of some who thought it was just a relatively small group of guys, Al Qaeda was more like a modern franchise operation like McDonalds or Dunkin Donuts, complete with headquarters resources and quality assurance.

After more than a decade times have changed. Today Al Qaeda is more like a brand. How much does “headquarters” really monitor and provide resources for the “franchises”? There’s a new terrorist organization on the block. DAESH. (I prefer that to ISIS or ISIL for propaganda reasons.) Younger, hipper. Disaffected people who thought that Al Qaeda was just too secular and too passive. Think of it as Five Guys to Al Qaeda’s McDonalds.

There are several contrasting, even complementary views of DAESH. One is that it’s an unlikely partnership between the group I mentioned above (guys who thought Al Qaeda was too secular and not violent enough) and some of Saddam’s generals and intelligence apparat. That’s how they explain, for example, the tactical sophistication I mentioned earlier today and the infiltration of cities prior to actual invasion that has been characteristic DAESH’s operations. They’re just activating old sleepers.

What I think we might want to consider is that DAESH is much more a network organization than Al Qaeda ever was. More like Anonymous than Burger King. Much more media-savvy. Skilled with using social media. And, like Anonymous, it may no more be possible to defeat DAESH using military force than it would be to “degrade and destroy” Anonymous that way.

0 comments

Transcendent Experience

When I was driving around on my various errands this morning I heard a very strange story on the radio. It was the story of an Englishman who ran a pub in the English countryside who, following the death of his newborn son, Ben, had a dream of angelic music. After the dream he was driven to get the music recorded. That lead him to leave his wife and children, live homeless on the streets of London for years, until:

One day while sleeping rough outside the BBC’s Television Centre he met jazz musician Anthony Wade, who offered him a place to stay and helped transcribe the music.

Wade told him that to realize his dream he’d need a million pounds. So he went out and made a million pounds. Then he got his “symphony” transcribed. Then he got it played and recorded by the London Philharmonia.

This is the story I listened to:

Here’s a short clip from the “Angeli Symphony”:

I don’t know whether Stuart Sharp is insane or a genius or a huckster or maybe a little of all three but let’s take his story at face value. If everything happened as he said it did, his story sounds familiar. He had a genuinely transcendent experience. Like Moses, Paul of Tarsus, and Mohammed. He had the experience, it overwhelmed him, and, despite a lack of any training or professional experience, he felt compelled to put that experience into a form in which it could be shared with others.

I don’t know whether he was touched by the hand of God or not but I’m not sure we have a better way to describe it.

3 comments

The Evolution of Warfare

Consider this account of one of DAESH’s tactics used in capturing Ramadi:

The State Department is sharing new details about the deadly fighting in Ramadi, Iraq, last Sunday, saying the city fell into ISIS hands after the militant group set off 30 suicide car bombs in the city center, 10 of which each were comparable in power to the Oklahoma City truck bomb of 1995.

The explosions took out “entire city blocks,” said a senior State Department official who spoke to reporters at the State Department Wednesday on condition that he not be named. The vehicle-borne improvised explosive devices, or VBIEDs, were able to gain access to the city center after an armored bulldozer plowed through T-wall barricades lining the city’s critical government buildings, the official said, adding that the same bulldozer was later used as a power VBIED, itself.

Soon after the bombs went off, the Iraqis deployed a reinforcing column into the city center, but they were forced to retreat after coming under heavy enemy fire, the official said. That retreat led to a larger exodus of Iraqi security forces and the civilian populations, leaving the streets looking “barren,” according to this official.

Let’s consider what they were doing there. Their use of “suicide car bombs” replicates our own use of laser-guided bombs and missiles, except that they’re much cheaper (as long as you don’t count the cost of your suicide bombers in the cost). No wonder DAESH is advertising for suicide bombers.

And in an urban setting it’s tremendously more effective. Their “martyrs” are able to mingle and move freely among a city’s population in a way in which our special forces never will.

5 comments

Advantage: DAESH

I stumbled across a post at Bloomberg, cataloguing the results of U. S. bombing in our conflict with DAESH prior to the Islamic State’s capture of Ramadi, that caught my eye:

In the month before the city of Ramadi in western Iraq fell, U.S. air strikes destroyed an armored personnel carrier, three humvees, three tanks, four mortars, four gun-mounted pick up trucks and two vehicle bombs belonging to the Islamic State outside the city. On Friday, Lieutenant Colonel Brian Fickel, a spokesman for U.S. Central Command, shared this data with me, adding that the U.S. also hit 25 “fighting positions” and 14 pieces of “miscellaneous equipment.”

Fickel told me Centcom disputed aspects of my column on Thursday, which disclosed how U.S. intelligence agencies were able to observe the Islamic State’s buildup of forces and equipment prior to the decisive battle, but the Pentagon “did not order airstrikes against the convoys before the battle started.” (I spoke with Centcom before publishing that column, but was not given the information Fickel has since provided.)

which forms an interesting juxtaposition with an article at Military.com from earlier in the week on the materiel captured by DAESH when they took Ramadi:

The ISIS fleet of captured U.S. military vehicles, including M1A1 tanks, grew by more than 100 when Iraqi Security Forces (ISF) fled the provincial capital of Ramadi 60 miles west of Baghdad and abandoned their equipment , Pentagon officials said Tuesday.
In addition, “there were some artillery pieces left behind,” said Army Col. Steve Warren, a Pentagon spokesman, but he could not say how many.
About 100 wheeled vehicles and “in the neighborhood of dozens of tracked vehicles” were lost to ISIS when the last remaining Iraqi defenders abandoned the city of about 500,000, Warren said.
The tracked vehicles were mostly armored personnel carriers but “maybe half a dozen tanks” were in the mix, Warren said. He did not say what type of tanks they were. Photos posted by ISIS on social media purported to show about 10 M1A1 Abrams tanks in their possession and large amounts of captured ammunition.

The Middle East is awash in weapons, ammunition, and military equipment, much of it furnished by us. It seems to me that there must be a cheaper, easier, and less risky way for us to reduce DAESH’s capacity for waging war. We’re destroying the equipment in retail while they capture it in wholesale.

They’re using a classic Fourth Generation Warfare technique. They don’t need to develop their own production facilities as long as we’re willing to supply their arms and ammo for them. We have an overwhelming tactical advantage over them that we’re unable to exploit because of our own strategic weakness.

3 comments

The Swiss Do It Again

I don’t know that I’ve ever been prouder of the people of the country of my ancestors. Swiss researchers have discovered why holes form in Swiss cheese:

(CNN)For more than a century, the holes in Swiss cheeses such as Emmental have been attributed to carbon dioxide given off by bacteria.

But that’s not the whole story, and now the Swiss have determined exactly why the holes form the way they do.

The culprit? Hay.

In recent years, the holes in Swiss cheese — known as eyes — have gotten smaller because processing centers have gotten cleaner, according to the Agroscope Institute for Food Sciences, a Swiss research center. The old-fashioned barns and buckets of previous years allowed more and larger hay particulates into the process, leading to bigger eyes.

Clearly cleanliness is next to diablerie. It takes up a year and a half of women’s lives. It makes you sick. And now the capper: it reduces the number of holes in Swiss cheese.

First, the cuckoo clock. Then milk chocolate. Now the holes in Swiss cheese. What will they tackle next? Self-melting fondue?

I should tell the story of fondue sometime. It’s a Da Vinci Code-like adventure. Sinister organizations. Intrigue. Only in Switzerland.

20 comments

Explanation Wanted

Can someone please explain for me the consolidation that’s apparently going on in the chip industry? Unless I’m greatly mistaken it’s been 30 years since we’ve seen a cluster of mergers and acquisitions like this in that industry.

1 comment

Think, Men, Think

The Illinois legislature is apparently applying Meredith Wilson’s “Think System” to the state’s budget:

Democrats who control the Illinois House and Senate spent the last two weeks publicly shredding Republican Gov. Bruce Rauner’s “Illinois Turnaround” agenda.

House Speaker Michael Madigan on Memorial Day held a press conference to announce his plan to pass a budget that he acknowledged was $3 billion out of balance. The next day, all but a handful of Democrats approved nine bills that Republicans say spends $4 billion more than the state will take in during the budget year that starts July 1.

The Senate did the same a day later. It also held committee hearings that rejected key parts of Rauner’s agenda.

Think revenue, men. Think.

2 comments

Whistle a Happy Tune, GDP Edition

I suppose I ought to say something about the BEA’s most recent revision of 1st Quarter 2015 GDP information. The Wall Street Journal analysis pretty much says it all:

Trade was the biggest drag on top-line GDP figures in the opening months of the year. U.S. exports of goods fell by the most since the first quarter of 2009–the midst of the recession–while overall imports climbed. The widening deficit subtracted 1.9 percentage points from economic growth. A stronger dollar has tamped down overseas demand for U.S.-made goods while making foreign products cheaper to import. Meanwhile, congestion at West Coast ports constrained trade earlier in the year.

That was my hipshot reaction, too, even before I saw the WSJ’s take. We import too much of what we consume. It’s even worse when you take into account that we import a third as much oil as we did in 2007 at about the same price.

If you pay attention to that sort of thing the Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow forecasting model has been saying (my interpretation not theirs) that we’ve been in recession for the last quarter. Don’t be surprised if come September the NBER tells us just that.

The economy has been in recovery (such as it is) for sixty months now. That’s pretty typical for post-war business cycles. What concerns me is that even a mild recession could be disastrous given the phlegmatic recovery. And, yes, the downturn in the first quarter of 2015 could be due to bad weather in New England and the West Coast dockers strike. That wouldn’t explain a second quarter 2015 downturn, though.

9 comments

The Corruption in Illinois Continues

Speaking of corruption in Illinois former Republican Speaker of the House and Illinois Congressman Denny Hastert has been indicted by a federal grand jury:

YORKVILLE, Ill. — J. Dennis Hastert, the longest-serving Republican speaker in the history of the U.S. House, was indicted Thursday by a federal grand jury on charges that he violated banking laws in a bid to pay $3.5 million to an unnamed person to cover up “past misconduct.”

Hastert, who has been a high-paid lobbyist in Washington since his 2007 retirement from Congress, schemed to mask more than $950,000 in withdrawals from various ac­counts in violation of federal banking laws that require the disclosure of large cash transactions, according to a seven-page indictment delivered by a grand jury in Chicago.

The indictment did not spell out the exact nature of the “prior misconduct” by Hastert, but it noted that before entering state and federal politics in 1981, Has­tert served for more than a decade as a teacher and wrestling coach at Yorkville High School in Illinois.

I never had much use for Mr. Hastert as Speaker but it looks like Illinois is plumbing new depths. It’s getting so a self-respecting state won’t be seen with us.

7 comments