Megan McArdle seeks to debunk the idea that grandma was making traditional peasant food:
Nor does this “good country cooking” really come from the country. As Laudan says: “The dishes we call ethnic and assume to be of peasant origin were invented for the urban, or at least urbane, aristocrats who collected the surplus. This is as true of the lasagne of northern Italy as it is of the chicken konna of Mughal Delhi, the mooshu pork of imperial China, the pilafs, stuffed vegetables, and baklava of the great Ottoman palace in Istanbul, or the mee krob of nineteenth-century Bangkok. Cities have always enjoyed the best food and have invariably been the focal points of culinary innovation.”
Most of our ancestors were not wealthy urbanites; they were peasant farmers. Why are these things, then, so associated in our minds with the tired, the poor, the huddled masses yearning to breathe free, the wretched refuse of the teeming shores from which our grandparents emigrated?
I think Megan is either confused or over-generalizing. I would submit that very few of today’s Americans have or had rural peasant immigrant grandmothers. Great-grandmothers or great-great-grandmothers, maybe. Let’s start with my own experience (probably not very typical).
All four of my grandparents were born in the 19th century. One of my grandmothers was born in 1891, the other in 1898. One of my grandfathers was born previous to the fourth quarter of the 19th century. All were born in the United States. None was rural.
One of my grandmothers ran a restaurant but didn’t cook. The other was the daughter of a butcher and a cook and she was an excellent cook. I know and prepare some of her recipes. They weren’t remotely traditional rural peasant food.
I would suggest that most of our grandmothers’ recipes were the same mixes and processed ingredients that people are using now or at least their predecessors. Most were clipped out of newspapers, printed on the backs of commercial packaging, or taken from The Joy of Cooking or The Better Homes and Gardens Cookbook. You open a can of Campbell’s Cream of Mushroom Soup and dump it over cut up chicken pieces. You bake a beef roast sprinkled with a package of Lipton’s Onion Soup.
I would also suggest that our most recent wave of immigrants are mostly urban rather than rural. Their grandmothers’ recipes are “traditional” rather than being traditional.
In closing, I haven’t had a decent knish in 30 years. I know why. The grandmothers who made them have been dead for a half century and their daughters and granddaughters are doctors, lawyers, and marketing consultants who don’t have the time or inclination to learn their great-grandmothers’ recipes.






