Chicago won some relief from its pension burden as Illinois’s legislature cut required payments into police and fire retirement systems. Yet lawmakers failed to agree on a budget, deepening a crisis that threatens the state and city alike.
The Senate voted 38 to 20 Sunday for a bill that would reduce Chicago’s payments over the next five years in a move meant to relieve immediate pressure, though it doesn’t address the city’s risk of insolvency from $20 billion in unfunded liabilities.
Note that the move isn’t a permanent solution, doesn’t put Chicago’s public pensions on a sounder footing, or mean that Chicago won’t also need to hike property taxes. It just kicks the can down the road a bit. Whether it will do anything to remove the Damoclean sword in the form of payments to banks due to the city’s low credit rating remains to be seen.
Also unknown is whether Gov. Rauner will sign the bill into law. He might prefer to use it as leverage to get something of what he wants out of the state legislature (read: Mike Madigan). He actually doesn’t have a lot of leverage. Democrats have a veto-proof majority in the legislature and Mssrs. Madigan and Cullerton can get pretty much anything they care to passed.
I’m disappointed. I had hoped that at the very least Illinois could serve as an object lesson. Apparently not:
The Census Bureau says Connecticut was one of six states that lost population in fiscal 2013-2014, and a Gallup poll in the second half of 2013 found that about half of Nutmeg Staters would migrate if they could. Now the Democrats who run the state want to drive the other half out too.
That’s the best way to explain the frenzy by Governor Dannel Malloy and the legislature to raise taxes again and blow through a state constitutional spending cap. They’ve been negotiating behind closed-doors over the details of a two-year $40 billion budget that could be revealed this weekend, but it’s already clear that Connecticut residents will pay big time.
Mr. Malloy promised last year during his re-election campaign that he wouldn’t raise taxes, but that’s what he also said in 2010. In 2011 he signed a $2.6 billion tax hike promising that it would eliminate a budget deficit. Having won re-election he’s now back seeking another $650 million in tax hikes.
But that’s not enough for the legislature, which has floated $1.5 billion in tax increases. Add a state-wide municipal sales tax that some lawmakers want, and the total could hit $2.1 billion over two years.
One reason Mr. Malloy needs cash is because the state economy isn’t growing. According to the federal Bureau of Economic Analysis, the state grew a scant 0.9% in 2013, the last year state data are available. That was tied for tenth worst in the U.S. The state’s average compounded annual growth for the last four years is 0.42%.
Slow growth means less tax revenue but spending never slows down. Some “40% of the state budget goes to government employee compensation and benefits, including payroll, state pensions, teacher pensions and current and retiree health care,†says Carol Platt Liebau, president of the Hartford-based Yankee Institute. “These items are growing at a rate that exceeds the growth of the economy.â€
As H. L. Mencken observed nearly a century ago there is always a well-known solution to every human problem — neat, plausible, and wrong. Increasing taxes to solve the problems of a government whose wants have exceeded its means when its revenues are slowing because of inadequate growth is one of them. If fostering economic growth were easy and painless, everybody would do it.
And because China is so vast, its successes can be attributed to whatever your pet cause is. Do you oppose free markets and privatization, like John Ross, former economic policy adviser for the city of London? Then China’s success is because of the role of the state. Do you favor free markets, like the libertarian Cato Institute? Then China’s success is because of its opening up. Are you an environmentalist? China is working on huge green-energy projects. Are you an energy lobbyist? China’s building gigantic pipeline projects. Are you an enthusiast for the Protestant work ethic, like historian Niall Ferguson, who describes it as one of his “killer apps†for civilizations? Then credit China’s manufacturing boom to its 40 million Protestants — even though they’re less than 5 percent of its 1.3 billion people.
With a massively changing country, correlation and causation are easily confused. China’s boom years in the 2000s, for instance, correspond nicely with an explosion in the number of pet dogs; perhaps some canine enthusiast is even now explaining how this is evidence that Bo, not Barack, should be making policy.
There are fields, such as education, where China’s supposed achievements are almost pure illusion. Program for International Student Assessment (PISA) statistics, which show China topping the lists in reading, math and science, are often cited by Common Core advocates in the United States and by proponents of traditional teaching methods in Britain, such as former education minister Michael Gove. Yet these PISA statistics cover just an elite group of Shanghai schools, where entry depends on bribery and string-pulling. In the rest of the country, classes average 50 students, only a third of rural children make it to high school, and I’ve found innumeracy to be just as common as in the United States.
China grew rapidly, prodded by the authoritarian Chinese Communist Party, but it grew from a base of practically nothing. Now it has a much larger base, the low-hanging fruit has been plucked, and the CCP’s tyranny and corruption are holding it back.
The U.S. economy continues to stumble. It’s creating jobs at a goodly clip, but other aspects of growth are less impressive. Business investment has been lackluster. The housing recovery is improving but remains short of where many economists thought it would be. Consumer spending, representing slightly more than two-thirds of total spending, has been soft. The economy has a tentative quality that repeatedly disappoints forecasts of stronger growth.
My main explanation for this — as I’ve argued before — is the hangover from the 2008-2009 financial crisis and the Great Recession. These events changed economic psychology, precisely because they were unanticipated and horrific.
How, then, does he explain the continued low business investment—other than in housing construction—since the end of the dot-com bubble? The recession of the early Aughts was largely due to a lack of business investment rather than a lack of consumer spending. That was misdiagnosed by the Bush Administration which applied its one-size-fits-all remedy—subsidizing consumer spending—to the problem with weak, short-lived results.
Let me provide an alternative explanation. There’s been plenty of business investment. Just not here. The investment has been in China, Malaysia, Thailand, Viet Nam, and dozens of other countries.
Clearly, they’re going where the grass (and the greenbacks) are greener. For business investment to return to the U. S. of A. something will need to change. What?
Here in the United States, in fact, it’s hard to identify any looming or imminent external threats, and certainly none as dire as the dangers that other societies face or as serious as the challenges the United States has overcome in the past. As I’ve noted before, the United States still has the world’s largest and most diverse economy, the world’s most powerful conventional forces, and a robust nuclear deterrent. It has no powerful enemies nearby, close allies in every corner of the world, and it is insulated from most foreign dangers by two enormous oceans. Despite the hype about the shrinking of geopolitical space and the emergence of a tightly connected “global village,†distance and the “stopping power of water†still provide considerable security, if not quite 100 percent protection.
[ ]
In fact, if you look at the past 25 years or so, it is abundantly clear that external enemies have done far less damage to the United States than we have done to ourselves. Saddam Hussein was a very bad man, but he wasn’t threatening or harming Americans after we kicked his ass in 1991. Ditto Slobodan Milosevic, Muammar al-Qaddafi, and the whole wretched Assad family. They were all problems, to be sure, but they weren’t threatening many Americans and U.S. leaders did business with each of them at one time or another.
What are the real threats? As Pogo said, we have met the enemy and he is us. Political corruption, bad policies, and misplaced fear are the real threats. We can mitigate any external threats we face at much lower cost than by using military force.
As Ben Franklin said
Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.
which seems appropriate as the Senate meets in a rare Sunday session, debating renewal of the Patriot Act, a law for which the government has not cited a single terrorist act that has been prevented through using the data collection provisions of the law (they assure there have been some; they just can’t tell us about them) and for which the Department of Homeland Security itself has identified scores of abuses. And those are just the ones they admit to.
I just watched a clip of the young actress Natalie Portman addressing a college graduating class. In the clip she related an anecdote about a famous concert violinist she met who said that he couldn’t be a composer because he knew too many great musical works and every time he wrote a note he was overwhelmed by thoughts of another great work with that note and couldn’t continue. From that she inferred that ignorance and inexperience is the key to creativity and, consequently, the young people graduating, unencumbered with knowledge or experience, were in a position to create great things.
There are two problems with her remarks. The first is that she is undermining the college education that she would presumably be saluting with her remarks. The other more serious problem is that her view of creativity is an illusion of youth. In most walks of life the key to creativity is the skill and knowledge that are the products of years or decades of experience.
There are exceptions, of course. Music and mathematics happen to be two of them in which prodigies are the rule rather the exception. The gloomy news for the young people Ms. Portman was addressing is that if, at the age of 20, they haven’t already composed great music they probably never will.
And if they wish to be great writers, painters, architects, engineers, doctors, lawyers, or even salesmen they have years of learning and toiling ahead of them before they will be able to do something great.
For an economic story in somewhat better spirits, consider the chart above illustrating the growth in exports of distilled beverages from Kentucky. They are prospering:
Kentucky exported a record $397.9 million in spirits in 2014 — the vast majority of the whiskey variety — putting the state second for spirits exports in the United States, behind only Tennessee. It marks a 72.6 percent increase since 2010.
The data was compiled by the Kentucky Cabinet for Economic Development, which includes bourbons as part of the whiskies category. In 2014, Kentucky exported $301.1 million worth of whiskey — its second-best tally ever. The record for whiskey exports came in 2012, at $314.6 million.
Still, from 2010-2014, Kentucky’s whiskey exports rose 56.7 percent.
The Commonwealth was the second-largest exporter of whiskies in the U.S. behind Tennessee, which exported $712 million in 2014. Total U.S. whiskey exports were $1.3 billion in 2014, also a record.
“Non-whiskey spirits” denotes cordials and liquers, a category in which Kentucky leads the nation. It would take a lot of whiskey to offset the U. S.’s loss of leadership in the exports of automobiles or computers but it’s a start.
To my eye (and palate) we’re experiencing a renaissance in the distillation of fine spirits in the United States. I’ve sampled the products of two craft distilleries in just year, Koval Distillery, just a good stretch of the legs from here, and Black Button Distilling in New York. I have three bottles of Koval’s products on my shelf right now: their rye whiskey, “Four Grain” whiskey, and their spelt whiskey. Not long ago I had the opportunity to sample a few of Black Button’s products. I’m not much of a gin drinker but their Citrus Gin is delicious. I encourage my readers to seek out local craft distillers and report back here on their experiences. And pass the bottle over here, boys.
I can only attribute the growth in craft distillers to the relaxation of state and local laws. To the best of my knowledge the stringent federal regulations on distilling have not been relaxed. Those are what destroyed the small distillery business a century ago and what are the most important factors in constraining their growth today: federal, state, and local regulations. There’s no reason that Missouri or Texas couldn’t produce brandy as good as that produced in the Cognac region of France other than the barriers that prevent people making a business of doing it.
There’s a lot to be learned from the article to which I linked above. For example, the top markets for exports of Kentucky whiskey are Australia, Spain, Japan, Canada, and Germany. All of those have increased their imports sharply except Germany where imports have decreased which I suspect tells us something about the European economy. What in the heck is going on in Spain?
For your cheery reading of the day, check out this post at Zerohedge which includes an extensive quote of Paul Singer. As a palliative keep in mind that the folks at Zerohedge are gold bugs.
I think they’re asking the wrong question. If bonds do, in fact, crash, I doubt they’ll all crash at once. I think that Europe is at much greater risk than we are.
In one sense they’re right. Fiscal and monetary policy have been lousy for a long time and, as has been said, anything that can’t go on forever won’t.
The consensus on Los Angeles’s trade unions asking for exemptions from the city’s big increase in its minimum wage that I remarked on earlier appears to be that the unions are acting their own interests rather than workers’ and venally so. Here’s a representative article:
However, unions asking for an exemption from Los Angeles’ higher minimum wage is a clear admission by the unions that they understand the basic principles of economics. They know such an absurdly elevated minimum wage would cause many workers to lose their jobs as employers cannot afford to keep workers who simply are not worth that much.
To put $15 per hour into perspective, according to the National Center for Education Statistics, that is the median earnings for somebody with a high school degree but no college. That means half of high school graduates earn less than what Los Angeles is proposing for a minimum wage. How could such a wage floor not cost jobs?
Actually, there is one way to avoid the large scale job losses sure to result from such a minimum wage increase and the unions have the answer. Because union workers could be paid a sub-minimum wage, employers who wish to avoid the $15 per hour minimum wage can encourage their workers to unionize. Then they can pay a lower wage (assumedly something higher than what the employer was paying, but lower than the non-union minimum wage). Workers get a smaller raise, but still a raise, and they get to keep their jobs (or at least most of them do; since wages are still likely to rise somewhat, employment will still drop by a smaller amount).
The other advantage of this arrangement is that the unions collect dues from all these new members. This is not a trivial matter, and unions appear to following a widespread strategy of pushing for higher local minimum wages and then getting an exemption for union members. As Diana Furchtgott-Roth reported, cities including San Francisco, Chicago, Milwaukee, and San Jose along with both the Los Angeles and Seattle-Tacoma airports have minimum wage laws which explicitly exempt union members.
I think that the unions should definitely not get their exemptions for the very reasons their leaders articulated so ardently when arguing in favor of the increase. And we should all keep on eye on Los Angeles’s experiment.
If Los Angeles’s economy flourishes without reducing the number of people employed or the rate of job growth, they should consider increasing the minimum to $40 or even $50 an hour. I’ll certainly be watching closely.
Meanwhile, if I were asked what Los Angeles’s most important problem is, I doubt I’d say it was that it didn’t have enough minimum wage workers or the San Andreas fault or even the drought. I think I’d say that Los Angeles’s most important problem is that its prosperity depends on factors the city is not willing to promote. It’s dependent on cheap energy and enough water to supply a growing population. The city hasn’t financed a new water project in decades. And Southern California’s closing of nuclear power plants and coal-fired plants in favor of yet-to-be-built natural gas (or other) power plants is another grand experiment. It may work. It may not. Stay tuned.
Can someone explain to me why Martin Feldstein is flogging inflation now? He’s got two articles out, one at Time and the other at Project Syndicate, both of which warn of inflation.
Although I don’t dismiss inflation entirely, if I had to list my top ten economic worries, inflation wouldn’t be one of them. I’d list slow growth, slow rate of formation of new businesses, slow job growth, job growth in the wrong sectors, trade imbalance (particularly as a strategy and particularly on the part of China, Japan, and Germany), and the lack of remaining tools for reacting to an economic downturn, just to name a few. But not inflation. So why now?