Slouching Towards Armageddon

For your good news of the morning check out this post at Sic Semper Tyrannis on the U. S.’s prodding of Russia into a full-fledged war with Ukraine. At this point it’s just a rumor and I consider it somewhere between discounting it completely and being skeptical of it. But it’s disquieting nonetheless.

6 comments

What To Do To Safeguard Privacy?

I’m inclined to agree with the editors of the Wall Street Journal that something should be done about the data breach of the Office of Professional Management announced last week other than issuing a stern demarche:

U.S. government incompetence seems to grow by the month, and now we know it’s becoming a threat to national, and even individual American, security. The Obama Administration announced last week that Chinese hackers made off this year with personnel files that may have included those of all 2.1 million federal employees, plus former employees going back to the 1980s.

This is no routine hack. The Office of Personnel Management (OPM) lost background-check data to the Chinese nine months before this breach and still hadn’t locked the cyber front door. OPM’s inspector general issued a damning report last November that parts of its network should be shut down because they were riddled with weaknesses that “could potentially have national security implications.” You can’t ring the alarm much louder than that, but the failure to take basic precautions continued.

As to the form that retaliation should take, I’m of mixed minds. There are all sorts of possibilities. As I said a couple of days ago whether the Chinese government ordered and supervised the data breach or not the Chinese have not been good Internet citizens. There is no doubt in my mind that the Internet as a whole would be better off if China were cut off from the rest of the world network. And it wouldn’t be particularly hard to do.

I’ll throw the question on the floor. What should be done?

When the barn door is open the very least should should do is close the barn door even if the horses have fled. It’s a good habit to get into, you might have more horses some day, and you’re signalling a willingness to keep the door closed. A good place to start would be considering the OECD’s guidelines for data privacy, promulgated 35 years ago. They are

  1. Notice—data subjects should be given notice when their data is being collected;
  2. Purpose—data should only be used for the purpose stated and not for any other purposes;
  3. Consent—data should not be disclosed without the data subject’s consent;
  4. Security—collected data should be kept secure from any potential abuses;
  5. Disclosure—data subjects should be informed as to who is collecting their data;
  6. Access—data subjects should be allowed to access their data and make corrections to any inaccurate data; and
  7. Accountability—data subjects should have a method available to them to hold data collectors accountable for not following the above principles.

and it pertains to private institutions as well as governments. If Target can’t protect my credit card information from hackers, I see no reason they can be trusted with any other personally identifiable information and that includes my email address, my phone number, or my Social Security number.

Due to the way our legal and political systems work I couched my proposal in terms of property rights. The phone company, your credit card company, and the Social Security Administration shouldn’t be thought of as owning the information about you that they hold. You should. And they should be required to retain and use it within strict restrictions.

1 comment

The Ordinary President

I think that Dan Mitchell is asking the wrong questions in his musings over President Obama’s economic legacy:

I’m not a big fan of Obamanomics. We’re going through the weakest recovery since the Great Depression. Income and wages have been stagnant, particularly when compared to previous expansions. And while the unemployment rate has finally come down, that’s in part a consequence of people dropping out of the labor force.

The net result is that our nation’s output is far lower than it would be if economic performance had simply matched the average for previous business cycles. And that translates into foregone income for American households.

You don’t judge a president by the events that occur on his watch but by what he or someday, possibly, she does. I don’t give President Obama as much credit as he or his supporters do for saving the economy for several reasons. First, it’s not entirely clear to me that the economy has been saved and, secondly, he’s largely continued his predecessor’s policies. I won’t give Bush credit for saving the economy and consequently I can’t give Obama credit for doing the same things Bush was doing. After all TARP, Keynesian pump-priming, and saving GM were all Bush policies, too. Like it or not Keynesian pump-priming is the prevailing wisdom in Washington. Under Bush (or McCain) it would undoubtedly have taken a slightly different form but it would have been essentially the same policy. What part of economy policy belongs uniquely to Obama? “Cash for Clunkers” which I think we should all agree was an error.

The ordinary president does what his predecessor or opponent would have done under the same circumstances. The extraordinary president does something different. Something, well, extraordinary. I gave Franklin Roosevelt credit for his actions during the Great Depression of the 1930s because he worked tirelessly, ceaselessly, and ineluctably trying different strategies. That’s what the American people saw at the time and that’s why they elected him to the presidency four times. He was extraordinary.

Excluding that he has been the U. S.’s first mixed race president, the most extraordinary thing about him has been just how ordinary he his. Despite the fulminations of his political opponents a big reason that Mitt Romney was unable to prevail against him was that they were largely espousing the same policies. They were both pretty ordinary as far as mainstream American politicians go and all other things being equal Americans tend to re-elect their presidents.

I agree with Michael Moore to this extent. I think that, barring some catastrophe over the next year and a half, 100 years hence Barack Obama will be remembered as the first mixed race president, a harbinger of things to come in a country that is largely mixed race.

2 comments

When Did the Workplace Become So Grim?

For the last year I’ve been working a regular 9 to 5 schedule (or, depending on how you look at it, a 7:30 to 7:30 schedule), going to an office every day, and the whole rat race. That’s something I haven’t done for nearly 30 years. One of the things that has jumped out at me is how grim the workplace has become. It’s not just that it’s Dilbertland although that’s part of it. Nobody smiles or laughs or appears to enjoy what they’re doing.

When I’m in a workplace on a regular basis it’s different. I crack wise. I tell jokes and stories. At first people react with a sort of guilty horror, secretly enjoying my lack of discretion and decorum. I wouldn’t go so far as to say that I spread joy wherever I go but I do lighten the mood.

When did the workplace become so grim? It wasn’t like that when I started my working life (gasp!) a half century ago. And it wasn’t like that 30 years ago when I at least put in an appearance in conventional offices on a regular basis.

5 comments

Is Education Really the Solution to Income Inequality?

While I’m predisposed to agree with Jared Bernstein and Ben Spielberg that income inequality is a real problem that deserves serious attention, I’m quite disappointed in their prescriptions, most of which focus on education. Is education really the solution to income inequality? To my ear that sounds like a “Field of Dreams” strategy. It simply isn’t true that more people getting college degrees automatically creates more jobs for which college degrees are needed. What it does mean is that people with college degrees will crowd out people who don’t when competing for jobs that don’t require college degrees. The beneficiaries of such a system aren’t workers generally but educators.

Meanwhile, we’re already spending twice as much in real terms on education as we did 20 years ago even as during the same period income inequality increased substantially.

That raises several questions. How much do we need to spend on education and where will the money come from? And how do they reconcile their prescription with the tremendous increase in education spending contemporaneous with an increase in income inequality?

14 comments

Giving Up on Manufacturing?

I stumbled across an op-ed at IndustryWeek by Scott Paul, president, Alliance for American Manufacturing. In the op-ed Mr. Paul points to some hints that the Obama Administration and, by extension, the Democratic Party are giving up on manufacturing as a force for growth in the U. S. economy:

My morning paper this week contained an unpleasant surprise. This passage, from a larger Washington Post article on the politics of the proposed Trans-Pacific Partnership trade agreement, caught my attention:

For decades, Democrats have pitched a manufacturing revival as the key to lifting millions more workers into the middle class. In recent months, though, some of the party’s leading economic thinkers have conceded that may not be true, because manufacturing employment is receding around the world as factories become more automated.

[…]

Does his [ed. President Obama’s] administration believe that the best days for “Made in America” are already behind us, or was it all just a cynical political ploy?

Meanwhile, what is to be made of the automation argument laid out in the Post article? Is it an inevitable force that will swamp factory jobs as we know them?

It’s an interesting op-ed and something to think about.

Just to add a little fuel to the fire, consider this chart from the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Private sector union membership, at 6% of the total workforce now roughly half of unionized workers, is holding its own only in financial activities, business and professional services, education and health services, and hospitality and it isn’t exactly booming in those areas.

In other words, manufacturing just isn’t that important politically to the Democratic Party any more.

9 comments

Yes, We Have No…

I learned exactly one useful thing from Michael Lynch’s post at Forbes on the EPA’s report on fracking which gave the practice a tentative go-ahead. It’s an acronym to put on the shelf next to NIMBY: BANANA. Build Absolutely Nothing Anywhere Near Anything.

However, I have a question. While I suspect there are some people who actually believe that (after all, for any given blame-fool idea there’s somebody somewhere who believes it), how many are there and how influential are they?

3 comments

Bad Assumptions on Iraq

I agree with Michael Knights’s assertion that the administration is making bad assumptions about Iraq. And I agree that the administration is likely to “double down” on its existing strategy with respect to Iraq. That is, after all, what this administration does. I’m not so sure I agree with him on the precise assumptions the administration is making and, especially, I disagree with him on what we should do.

Here are the assumptions he says they’re making:

  • The more we do, the less they do.
  • The Islamic State is a terrorist group, not an army.
  • We cannot want the stability of Iraq more than Iraqis want it themselves.

I think the administration is assuming that Americans will tolerate anything as long as we don’t put “boots on the ground”. That makes them highly predisposed to overestimate what can be accomplished with air power alone.

Here’s his prescription:

If America is only in Iraq to kill Islamic State fighters, it is eventually going to face the reality of an unfixable collapsed state that will demand an open-ended counterterrorism campaign. The alternative is that the United States help Iraqis preserve the fabric of their nation to whatever extent is still possible. To do so will require a different outlook and greater decisiveness. Deliberation is understandable, but U.S. policy in Iraq has been verging on paralysis.

This is not rocket science: The U.S. options are clear. If the Obama administration wants to fully commit to the hard work of rebuilding Iraq, it should commit 3,000 to 5,000 U.S. Special Forces and support elements as combat advisers, so that Iraqi ground forces and coalition airpower can become far more effective. Secondly, it should use this intensified U.S. military commitment as leverage with Baghdad to win more sustained federal Iraqi government engagement of the Sunnis and the Kurds. Finally, it should accelerate the training of Iraqi forces to leave the next president with a better chance of responsibly downscaling the U.S. commitment in Iraq.

Without these steps, we should not expect to expel the Islamic State from Iraq. In the absence of undeniable U.S. commitment, our Iraqi allies may define victory down into something that looks more like defeat. And that is a risk that neither Iraq, nor the United States, can afford.

I’d like to see the administration clearly delineate our objectives in Iraq (isn’t it already clear it has abandoned its initial objectives to “degrade and destroy” DAESH?), quantify their value to us, and do a cost-benefit analysis.

What I think the administration is actually doing is attempting to minimize downside political risk at an ever-increasing cost.

9 comments

Privacy’s 10,000 Mile Journey

Now that the USA Freedom Act has been enacted and signed into law and the republic is, at least for the time being, safe, why stop there? Particularly in the wake of the hacking of Sony and the multiple credit card exploits over the last year or so, we should turn our attention to the ways in which private companies save and retain data.

Here’s a radical idea. The personally identifiable information that’s being gathered and retained by businesses from your phone company to Google or Amazon doesn’t belong to them. It’s the property of the persons who are identified by it. That includes names, email addresses, phone numbers, IP addresses, and geolocation information. There should be restrictions placed on the information they retain, how long they retain it, and the manner in which it may be retained. Just as an example, these companies have no excuse for retaining your information indefinitely in unencrypted form.

How’s that for a single step?

3 comments

Nowhere?

Megan McArdle’s post at Bloomberg on Hillary Clinton’s favorability rating has the provocative title “Clinton Support Has Nowhere to Go But Down”. I think that’s nonsense and to back up my belief I would happily bet a shiny new dime that at some point between now and November 2016 Hillary Clinton’s favorability rating as measured by the Washington Post/ABC News poll will be above the 45% that has everybody in such a twitter.

Quite the opposite of the “nowhere to go” view, I think that Sec. Clinton’s favorability and unfavorability ratings have both floors and ceilings. I would also happily bet a shiny new dime that at no time between now and November 2016 will Hillary Clinton’s favorability rating go over 60% or under 35%. If you gave me odds, I might be willing to tighten those margins a bit (but just a bit).

I assume that the title for that post was dreamed up by some unthinking editor because it really doesn’t match the post very well so I probably don’t have anybody to bet with. Nonetheless I wanted to put my marker down.

10 comments