Up, Down, and Around and Around

The Economist is worried about a “Drawbridge Up” America:

A FEW years ago a wise pollster—pondering how labels like left-wing and right-wing have been scrambled by globalisation—came up with a different way to sort voters in Western democracies. Electorates, he suggested, broadly divide into two groups, one of which sees change and the outside world as a threat, and a second which takes a more optimistic view, looking for opportunities to harness global forces and turn them to good ends. The pollster, Stefan Shakespeare of YouGov, calls these two camps “Drawbridge Up” and “Drawbridge Down” people.

Just after lunch on June 12th President Barack Obama was mugged by the Drawbridge Up bit of America, or at least by its elected representatives. A large majority of Democrats in the House of Representatives, joined by hard-right Republicans, voted to stall (and potentially kill) his hopes of reaching a big new free-trade pact between America and 11 other Pacific Rim nations, the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP). The Senate has already passed a bill that would allow Mr Obama to press ahead with TPP, and the House may return to the question as early as Tuesday.

Apparently, the editors of The Economist are not ones for fine distinctions. Even as I type the EU ministers are debating the fates of the half million refugees waiting in Libya, yearning to reach Europe, and braving the Mediterranean in rickety boats to do it. It must be might cozy complaining about up and down from an island with a drawbridge raised by Nature itself.

The default position for Europeans seems to be chiding Americans for raising our drawbridge from time to time while keeping their own safely up.

4 comments

The Other Foot

The panic that has set in over the breach of cyber-security in the Office of Personnel Management reminds me of nothing so much as Harry Truman’s famous wisecrack to the effect that it’s a recession when your neighbor is out of work and a depression is when you’re out of work. There have been major security breaches in private company after private company (Wal-Mart, Home Depot, Target, Neiman Marcus, Apple, Sony) and several government agencies (IRS, DoD, Medicaid, State Department). Very little has been done. Don’t tell me about how much money has been spent—that’s just measuring inputs. Results are determined by measuring outputs not by measuring inputs.

The one ray of hope that might come from the exploit is that the federal government might actually start taking cybersecurity seriously. They might start by asking a few questions. Why were these records digitized in the first place? Why were they exposed to the public Internet?

0 comments

A Mere Procedural Snafu

The editors of the Wall Street Journal are apoplectic over the House’s denial of “fast track” trade negotations authority to President Obama which would allow him to proceed more quickly in his negotiations with the 12 nation Trans-Pacific Partnership:

Thus fast track isn’t dead yet, but no one should think Friday’s fiasco is a mere “procedural snafu,” as White House spokesman Josh Earnest put it with his typically oblivious aplomb. U.S. stocks sold off on the trade defeat, with the Dow dropping 141 points or 0.8%. Failure on fast track would probably doom the 12-nation Pacific trade talks, which would undermine the economic reforms of Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe and send a strategic gift basket to China’s Xi Jinping. It would also vandalize the U.S. businesses that are losing overseas markets to foreign competitors.

If House Democrats really want to take political responsibility for this damage to appease the labor lobby and progressive fringe, that is their right. But then spare us the hot takes about how “Washington is broken” and that ideological Republicans are to blame. The adults in the GOP managed to fend off the talk radio and online smear campaign that by the end was simply making up fake reasons to oppose “Obamatrade.” They had to rise above what has become a trade version of a Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact between the AFL-CIO’s Richard Trumka and Mike Huckabee.

As suggested in the quote above, some believe that lack of fast track authority dooms the three initiatives the Ohama Administration is negotiating with the TPP. Maybe, maybe not. Next week the president may get fast track authority and all of this week’s kerfuffle will have been forgotten.

To my mind it does raise a question. Let’s take a poll.

Who’s the head of the Democratic Party now?

  1. Nancy Pelosi
  2. Harry Reid
  3. Hillary Clinton
  4. It’s still Obama. This is just a speed bump.
  5. Richard Trumka
  6. Other
  7. No one
16 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Underwater

There’s an old joke about Chicago being a large city at the bottom of Lake Michigan. Chicago and the Chicagoland area are underwater in another way:

The percentage of Chicago-area home borrowers “underwater” on their mortgages fell in the first quarter but is among the highest in the country, according to Zillow.

In the Chicago area, 23.7 percent of homeowners with a mortgage were underwater during the quarter, according to data Zillow released today. While that was down from 28.1 percent in first-quarter 2014, it was the second-highest proportion of underwater homes among the 35 largest U.S. housing markets. Las Vegas was highest at 25 percent.

Chicago does have the nation’s biggest number of underwater loans—413,690—with New York a distant second at 307,573.

Chicago never experience the rapid run-up in house prices that Las Vegas and New York did but prices did fall. six years after the start of the recovery we’re still suffering from it. No wonder the state legislature thinks this is a good time to raise property taxes.

I guess I should look at the bright side. If the number of home mortgages that are underwater were lower, the net outmigration from the state would probably have been even higher.

0 comments

Conflicting Objectives

There’s an interesting interview at the French language Lebanese daily L’Orient Le Jour with the French Air Force Chief General Denis Mercier:

En Libye, on est allé chercher les centres de gravité de Kadhafi (centres de commandement, points de regroupement…). C’est en attaquant ces centres qu’on a fait basculer Kadhafi, pas en allant tirer 150 pick-up par jour. Là, on y serait encore”, a-t-il dit lors d’une rencontre avec la presse. “C’est exactement le même problème en Irak aujourd’hui. On tire beaucoup sur la ligne de front mais derrière il faudrait qu’on se concentre plus sur les centres de gravité. Le problème c’est qu’ils ne sont pas forcément en Irak” mais en Syrie, a-t-il ajouté. En Syrie, où la France n’intervient pas, la coalition internationale emmenée par les Etats-Unis fait face à une situation délicate, les opérations contre l’EI risquant de renforcer le régime de Bachar al-Assad. En Irak, les autorités de Bagdad ont en outre demandé qu’on ne frappe pas ces centres de gravité, a-t-il concédé.

For non-French speakers the gist of his remark is that the U. S. has conflicting objectives in its campaign against DAESH. We can’t go after DAESH’s command and control centers because they’re in Syria and we don’t want to strengthen Assad’s position. We can’t go after their centers in Iraq because the Iraqi government is afraid of reprisals in Baghdad or in the Shi’ite south. So we’re stuck making bombing runs against pick-up trucks.

It’s what an old friend of mine used to call “having too many oars in the water” or the paradox of Buridan’s ass, which starves to death between two bales of hay, unable to decide between them.

Hat tip: Sic Semper Tyrannis.

5 comments

Watch Out, Indeed

The Economist warns that the developed economies have not recovered much during the recovery:

THE struggle has been long and arduous. But gazing across the battered economies of the rich world it is time to declare that the fight against financial chaos and deflation is won. In 2015, the IMF says, for the first time since 2007 every advanced economy will expand. Rich-world growth should exceed 2% for the first time since 2010 and America’s central bank is likely to raise its rock-bottom interest rates.

However, the global economy still faces all manner of hazards, from the Greek debt saga to China’s shaky markets. Few economies have ever gone as long as a decade without tipping into recession—America’s started growing in 2009. Sod’s law decrees that, sooner or later, policymakers will face another downturn. The danger is that, having used up their arsenal, governments and central banks will not have the ammunition to fight the next recession. Paradoxically, reducing that risk requires a willingness to keep policy looser for longer today.

I think they’re far too sanguine about the U. S. economy and to understand what’s happened you need to descend below the 50,000 feet view and look at things on a county by county basis. Some counties have not only recovered but prospered. Others have recovered. A lot of counties are still waiting for an economic recovery.

6 comments

Cooking the Books—CPS Edition

What is with the Clintonistas? Is getting caught really the only sin? If so, they’ve committed it:

Chicago school officials are taking steps to make sure dropouts aren’t being mislabeled to make the city’s graduation rates look better.

The action comes after WBEZ and the Better Government Association reported widespread problems in how student were being classified when they left high school. Thousands were labeled as leaving the city, but then supposedly enrolled in GED programs. State law and policy dictate that students who leave districts to go to GED programs are dropouts.

In other words, there may be less to those reports of improved on-time high school graduations in Chicago than met the eye. They may just have been changing the numbers.

First, the homicide statistics. Now on-time high school graduations. You don’t make things better by changing the statistics. You just make them look better, easing your way to the next election.

In fairness it might be the case that the CPS has been cooking the books on graduations long before Rahm Emanuel was mayor. For decades even. It’s an amazing coincidence, though.

1 comment

First Do No Political Harm

Despite his confusion between strategy and objectives, the scales are falling from Eugene Robinson’s eyes. I think he’s beginning to come around to the view that President Obama has no objectives in Iraq other than domestic political ones:

It is understandable that the president might feel pressed to do something in response to the Islamic State’s recent battlefield gains — including the rout of disorganized Iraqi forces in Ramadi, the capital of Anbar province. But Obama imposed such tight restrictions on the activities of U.S. soldiers that only the sunniest optimist would believe this increase can make a military difference.

U.S. troops will not be allowed near the front lines, where their presence, according to Obama’s critics, could stiffen the resolve of an Iraqi army that often chooses to flee rather than fight. There will be no American forward air controllers, who could direct U.S. airstrikes with far greater precision. There will be no use of deadly Apache attack helicopters in support of Iraqi ground operations.

In essence, sending the 450 new troops is less a military move than a political gesture. After the fall of Ramadi, Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi desperately needed a signal of U.S. support. In that strictly limited sense, I suppose, mission accomplished. Sort of.

Now if he’d only recognize that pertains to domestic policy as well.

That’s my unified field theory of the Obama Administration. If you look for deeper thinking or meaning than domestic politics, you’ll be disappointed. If you find them, you’re imposing your own beliefs on actions that have no deeper thinking or meaning.

8 comments

The 800th Anniversary of Magna Carta

However cozy your childhood home may appear through the lens of time and distance, you really can’t go home again.

There’s quite a bit of hoopla both in the UK and here in the States, at least in some circles, about the 800th anniversary of Magna Carta. I’m open to argument but it seems to me that the document’s importance to us Yanks is very much exaggerated. To understand why you’ve got to look at a timeline.

A gang of armed barons and, presumably, their men-at-arms forced John Lackland to sign Magna Carta on the 15th of June, 1215. That’s according to the Julian calendar so, presumably, it would actually have been a few days later according to our calendar but what’s a few days among friends?

The first permanent English settlement in the New World was in 1607. Said another way, American history diverged from English history a little less than 400 years after the signing of Magna Carta and has remained that way. Oh, Americans were aware of Magna Carta and it had some vague foundational influence. However, at least by my reading, Magna Carta was mostly about powerful aristocrats asserting their independence and rights against a king who tried to establish a modern state ahead of its time. Nowadays in the 21stcentury we’ve been separated from Magna Carta for longer than our English forebears (those of us who, unlike me, have English forebears) were governed by it.

Meanwhile, after 1607 the Americans were largely left without adult supervision, trying to create a society largely without those powerful aristocrats, most of whom remained on their estates in Old Blighty. When Thomas Jefferson wrote the Declaration of Independence he thought about Magna Carta but, legal scholar that he was, the Declaration owed more to Jean Jacques Burlamaqui and Francis Hutcheson than it did to Magna Carta. Or John Locke for that matter.

What I’m saying is that our Englishness is much exaggerated. How then did the U. S. become so Anglophile?

I would suggest that’s a relatively recent phenomenon. Throughout the 19th century there was more immigration from Ireland or Germany (or what was to become Germany) than there was from England. Wealthy Americans of English descent sent their kids to be educated at Oxford or Cambridge occasionally. Americans attended the Sorbonne, the University of Vienna, and Edinburgh, too.

I think the big push for American Englishness began right around 1914, pushing us towards England and away from Germany, and reached its zenith in the late 1930s in the effort to encourage American entrance into the war on England’s side.

I’d be interested in dissenting views but I think it would healthier for us if we recognized just how different we are from our English and European cousins. We are not English. We are not Europeans. We are Americans.

9 comments