Martin Feldstein’s Vie en rose

The world in which Martin Feldstein lives must be very pleasant indeed:

The Fed’s strategy worked, causing household net worth to increase by $10 trillion in 2013. Households responded by spending more, leading to an accelerated rise in gross domestic product and a decline in unemployment.

The increase in network was highly concentrated; debt has been rising, much of it student debt; the labor force participation rate has plummeted to what it was 40 years ago. As Bernie Sanders points out in his stump speeches, if the LFPR was what it was in 2007, unemployment would be 10%.

Market participants know that the economy is now essentially at full employment, that the consumer-price index is close to 2% and that there is little risk of deflation. They know therefore that interest rates must rise, and that a return to normal levels will reverse the mispricing of assets. The Fed cannot hide that realization by postponing rate hikes for a few months. And so the Fed should get on with the task of normalizing rates, particularly so that investors and lenders are no longer tempted to sink deeper into mispriced assets.

I’m not sure the market participants know any such thing. The CPI is closer to 0% than it is to 2% and MIT’s Billion Price Project, an actual empirical measurement of prices across the economy and, consequently, inflation already shows deflation.

I agree with Dr. Feldstein that the Fed shouldn’t gauge their reactions by stock prices but that’s what they’ve been doing for the last eight years. Even less should they gauge those results by stock prices in China but there are those urging just that.

1 comment

Policies Have Implications

The editors of the Wall Street Journal, observing the fall of China’s stock markets and the attendant decline in stocks elsewhere in Asia, in Europe, and, yesterday, in the United States, recognize that China has a problem:

hose advantages have also created new vulnerabilities, however. Since capital controls kept domestic savings from seeking better returns abroad, the government was able to harness savings to keep interest rates artificially low. That created higher levels of investment, about 50% of GDP, and faster growth than the world has seen in a major economy.

This growth and a highly motivated workforce also attracted global capital. In order to keep these inflows from forcing up the value of the yuan and creating inflation, the People’s Bank of China bought foreign currency with yuan, and then removed those yuan from circulation. It did so by issuing bonds or raising the level of reserves banks are required to keep, a process known as sterilization.

The result was a Goldilocks economy that for much of the 2000s grew quickly without overheating. The sterilized inflows drove the deepening of the financial system and expansion of the money supply. That underpinned loans for investment as well as speculation, especially in real estate. And the pressure on the yuan to appreciate created a virtuous cycle of more capital inflows.

This investment boom on steroids started to unravel during the 2008 crisis, after which Beijing extended it with financial stimulus and then a stock market bubble. But as confidence in rapid growth has ebbed, capital flows have reversed and begun moving out, turning a virtuous cycle into a vicious one.

but I doubt they have apprehended the scope of the problems. Too much of China’s “internal demand” has been directed towards building airports in which no planes land, roads to nowhere, cities without populations, and idle factories whose capacity not only exceeds China’s needs but the world’s needs. IMO what China’s economic slowdown and its stock market crash reveal is that China has reached the end of the road on the approach they have taken towards growth over the period of the last 35 years or, said another way, they know no other way.

The end of that road will have implications not only for the Brazils and Australias of the world that have supplied the raw materials for China’s capital malinvestment but for Germany which has supplied its factories and industrial tools. Look for Germany’s economy, powered too long by China’s industrial build-up, to decline as well.

4 comments

Another Precinct Heard From

Lars Christensen, in a very good post, makes four distinct observation. First, China and the U. S. are in a de facto currency union. That is something that policy makers here have completely failed to take into account, one of the many reasons why policy here has been so flawed.

Second, it is not a good policy union. I wish he had fleshed this out more in the post. I suspect that it’s suboptimal for several reasons including drastically different fundamentals in the two economies and policies that are pulling in opposite directions.

Third, China should de-peg. I think this has been obvious for a decade but the Chinese authorities have clearly seen it as being in their favor to leave the two currencies semi-pegged, so why the heck not?

Fourth, the Fed should not increase interest rates. His argument is, essentially, that the Chinese economy may well circle the drain if the Fed doesn’t postpone its rate increase. I can only speculate he’s making a “stay with the devil you know” argument, i.e. a stability-based argument. We haven’t been doing stability lately.

5 comments

Duke Kahanamoku, 1890-1968

Today is the 125th anniversary of the birth of Duke Kahanamoku and today’s Google doodle honors him. He was a champion swimmer, in his heyday said to be without equal in the water. He won three Olympic gold medals, one in 1912 and two in 1920. In 1924 he took a silver medal to Johnny Weissmuller’s gold. He was 34 at the time.

He did more than anyone else to popularize the sport of surfing. He used a traditional olo board: 16 feet long, 114 lb. Not a board for weaklings.

He was an extremely handsome man of typically native Hawaiian type and appeared in bit parts in several movies. You can catch a glimpse of Duke in the latest of them Wake of the Red Witch in 1948 and Mr. Roberts in 1955.

0 comments

The Toxic Politics

The editors of the Washington Post urge action on the federal budget:

The big picture here is that, at a time when financial markets are already showing serious signs of stress caused by events in China, Europe and emerging economies, U.S. politics loom as yet another source of uncertainty rather than stability. The increasingly populist, decreasingly sensible election season discourse in this country is veering far away from practical issues — such as how best to raise and spend money for public purposes at the federal level — that ultimately determine the economic well-being of Americans and, indeed, the world. Instead, the ostensibly most powerful nation on earth has a federal budget patched together out of temporary law and borrowed private savings — and all of the people who aspire to lead that nation are talking about other things.

all of which underscores the basic problem with a political strategy that does not build coalitions but rather makes each succeeding accomplishment that much more difficult.

Should Democrats and Republicans collaborate in solving the country’s problems? Sure. Start building bridges rather than setting bonfires.

2 comments

If Not Now, When?

Following the path that Japan forged we are poised on the brink of ending a full decade of economic growth inadequate to bring the people who lost their jobs in the late recession back to work. Defenders of Keynesian responses continue to mourn the inadequacy of the federal government’s response in 2009. Other voices point to the recession as an example of a “balance sheet recession”, brought on by excessive debt.

This morning Lawrence Summers, by nearly every account the principle architect of the inadequate response who, to the best of my ability to determine, has advocated exclusively Keynesian responses to the recession as though it were an ordinary cyclic recession, takes to the Washington Post op-ed page to urge the members of the Federal Reserve Board to leave interest rates just where they are:

There can be no question that tightening policy will adversely affect levels of employment as higher interest rates make holding onto cash more attractive relative to investing. Higher interest rates also will increase the value of the dollar, making U.S. producers less competitive and pressuring the economies of our trading partners. This is especially troubling at a time of rising inequality. Studies of periods of tight labor markets such as the 1960s and the late 1990s make clear that the best social program for disadvantaged workers is an economy where employers are struggling to fill vacancies.

There may well have been a financial-stability case for raising rates 6 months or 9 months ago, as low interest rates were encouraging investors to take on risk and businesses to borrow money and engage in financial engineering. Even at that time, I believed that the economic costs of a rate increase exceeded the financial-stability benefits, but there were grounds for concern about the medium-term impact of low rates on financial stability.

Is there some point at which Dr. Summers will encourage structural changes or deleveraging policies or, like a good courtier, will he persist in encouraging the policies favored by his patrons? Keynes’s advocacy for monetary sovereigns to use short term deficit spending as a means for making up for a shortfall in aggregate demand was explicitly a short term solution. If the shortfall were allowed to persist, it would result in declines in aggregate product, calling for structural changes.

Meanwhile, total indebtedness grows, labor force utilization languishes, and pension funds seek ever-greater risks to realize the levels of return needed for them to remain solvent. The clock is ticking on the business cycle, which still hasn’t been repealed, and the Fed has very little in the way of tools to counter it.

His patrons will never call for structural change. Will he?

2 comments

Recapping Views on the Iranian Deal

Over the course of the last several weeks we’ve been discussing the deal on Iran’s nuclear development program in a series of posts, here, here, here, here, and here. A number of contrasting views have been articulated.

I think (see the first post linked above) that the Iranians are not developing nuclear weapons and have not done so for the last decade which means they are as good as their word on the subject. I think they are unlikely to resume nuclear weapons development. From that I draw the inference, counter-intuitive to some, that the deal that has been negotiated gives us precious little and we could have and should have arrived at a deal that was better for us than the one that the president and his team have negotiated. I also think that a better deal will no longer be forthcoming but that preserving sanctions for as long as we can is probably better than relieving them. I neither support nor condemn the president’s deal. I just think it’s weak tea. I do not think we have a cause of war against Iran and do not think we should go to war against Iran.

Andy has articulated the view, which I consider reasonable, that the information we gather through the deal is worth whatever is relinquished through the deal. He has also correctly discerned my view that we should want regime change in Iran.

Rob has enunciated the view that Iran has continued its nuclear weapons development program, that Iran will use sanctions relief to promote mischief throughout their region, and that war with Iran is probably inevitable. We disagree on the issue of preventive war.

steve believes that the president’s deal is a tremendous achievement and that if a Republican is elected president we’ll have war with Iran.

Are those fair statements and have I left any other views out? I don’t consider disagreeing with other people an articulated view.

30 comments

The 100 Greatest English Language Novels

While I agree with many of the selections in Robert McCrum’s list of the 100 greatest novels written in the English novels, I do have some disagreements. My first disagreement is with the name of the list. I think it should be “the 100 greatest writers who wrote in English” because if you were to create an actual list of the 100 greatest novels three would be written by Defoe and three by Dickens, crowding out a lot of other great novels and writers.

My other objections are more in detail. Only by the standard of influence on modern culture is Dracula a great novel. It’s more a novel-length penny dreadful. It’s not the first vampire novel in English and it’s far from the best vampire story in English.

How could you name Kidnapped over Treasure Island? If it’s because Kidnapped is less of a boy’s book, how could you name Kim? While E. A. Poe was a great writer, I don’t think he wrote a great novel. If the only thing he had ever written was Arthur Pym, IMO he’d be languishing among the many 19th century writers ignored today.

If you’re going to use influence as your yardstick, it’s pretty hard to explain why Uncle Tom’s Cabin isn’t on the list. It’s pretty awful but it’s probably the most influential novel in the English language not in the sense of having had a strong influence on subsequent literature but in the sense of having had an influence on world events.

There are a number of novels I was glad to see on the list: Three Men in a Boat, Gentlemen Prefer Blondes, Cold Comfort Farm, Joy in the Morning. In particular I think that humor, probably the most difficult of genres, is too frequently ignored as great literature.

While I was gratified to see some mysteries on the list, both English and American, I think that the absence of any Westerns on the list is a significant omission. There are any number of truly great Western novels. If the yardstick is by writer and by influence, it’s an even more significant omission.

Finally, if you’ve never read The Wind in the Willows, you owe it to yourself to do so. It is a great novel.

13 comments

What Should the Federal Reserve Do?

in their editorial on the forces pushing and pulling on the members of the Federal Reserve Board over whether they should raise interest rates, as they have said they would, or leave them where they are, I think the Wall Street Journal editors are pointing to the right facts. Not only has the Federal Reserve systematically misestimated U. S. economic growth over the last half dozen years, all of its errors have pointed in the same direction: they thought it would grow faster. Not only did they systematically overestimate the growth of the U. S. economy over the last half dozen years, they frequently estimated it would grow twice as fast as it actually did.

There is clearly no such thing as malpractice in economics. If an engineer estimated the load-bearing capability of a bridge as twice its actual ability, it would be malpractice. Physicians who prescribe half the amount of medication required by the patient in contradiction of the standard of care would be similarly guilty. That’s one of the problems in economics: there is no standard of care. But that’s another subject.

The editors conclude by asking an implied question that should make the members of the Fed squirm in their chairs:

At the very least it’s time for the Fed to examine why its policies have failed to deliver the buoyant economic results it promised.

I think there are any number of other questions we should be asking the Fed. For example, are you recalibrating your models to come closer to reality? What is the nature of that recalibration? Do you believe that income inequality poses a social or political problem in the United States? If so, how can you coherently adopt a policy the intent of which is to foster income inequality?

When you injure another it is not enough to point to your good intentions. At the very least you are morally obligated to remediate the injury to the extent that you are able. How do the members of the Federal Reserve Board intend to remediate the harm they have done to American society over the last half dozen years?

3 comments

Loving Nature Is Harder When It Doesn’t Love You

I hate to think what would happen around here if animal control wasn’t allowed to trap raccoons:

SAN FRANCISCO — In San Francisco’s Richmond District, a couple was attacked they say by a pack of raccoons and if it weren’t for a neighbor who came to their rescue, they believe they might have been seriously injured.

Many neighbors in the area say they don’t like going out after 11 p.m., not because they worry about getting mugged, but because they worry about a confrontation with raccoons.

Patty Upsavs says she and her husband went out Monday night to let their dog get one last walk and that’s when a raccoon pounced.

“So I started swinging the dog around trying to get it off,” Upsavs said.

Then a pack of raccoons attacked.

“And then I got another one on my other leg. And so at this point, I’m in the middle of the street and I look up to see, ‘Where is my husband? How come he’s not helping?’ And I look and he’s throwing… raccoons are just jumping on him,” Upsavs said.

The struggle lasted a few seconds until their neighbor Brian Wong came to their rescue. He ran down the hill with his golf club screaming like crazy. Wong says he used his club to bang on the garbage cans that were left out for trash collection night.

Upsavs suffered several bite wounds and scratches. She and her husband are going through a series of anti-rabies treatments.

Melanie Piazza is an urban wildlife expert at Wild Care in San Rafael. She says people shouldn’t be worried about raccoons attacking them because this was very unusual.

“Typically, the only time they’re going to come into contact with a problem animal again is if somebody has been hand feeding them and their used to people or if it’s a mom defending young and she feels threatened,” Piazza explained.

San Francisco Animal Care and Control told ABC7 News trapping the raccoons isn’t an option because that is against California law.

I suspect that sort of confrontation will become increasingly common. We upset their habitat so they moved into ours. Urban populations of deer, raccoons, and coyotes are growing.

5 comments