Yet Another Precinct Heard From

The editors of USA Today come out in favor of the Federal Reserve raising interest rates:

Supporters point out that the U.S. economy finally appears durable enough to withstand a bump in rates. It has added 13 million jobs since the depth of the Great Recession. The jobless rate dropped to 5.1% last month, a level considered close to full employment.

An even more persuasive argument for raising rates is that the U.S. economy has never had rates so low for so long, and no one really knows what the effects will be. The housing bubble that caused so much grief to the global economy was the result of greed, avarice and dishonesty — but also of low interest rates.

Institutional investors such as pension funds, hedge funds and sovereign wealth funds were seeking decent returns from the conservative portions of their portfolios. With bonds and money market accounts paying so little, Wall Street invented a story about how it could package high-risk mortgages in such a clever way that the overall bundle would be low-risk while providing attractive returns.

As I wrote yesterday although I’m of mixed mind (as usual) I don’t think that the merits of a rate increase at this time outweigh the risks. Inflation is low and I don’t see how an interest rate hike would improve employment. I don’t favor another round of quantitative easing. I just think we need to have a contingency plan.

2 comments

The Song Not the Singer

Well, we now know that Jeb Bush supports cutting taxes:

First, I want to lower taxes and make the tax code simple, fair and clear. It should be easy to understand and make it easy for people to fill out their own tax forms.

We will cut individual rates from seven brackets to three: 28%, 25% and 10%. At 28%, the highest tax bracket would return to where it was when President Ronald Reagan signed into law his monumental and successful 1986 tax reform.

With this reform in place, roughly 15 million Americans will no longer bear any income-tax liability. The plan nearly doubles the standard deduction now taken by roughly two-thirds of all filers. It eliminates the marriage penalty, expands the Earned Income Tax Credit, ends the death tax, retires the Alternative Minimum Tax and ends the employee’s share of the Social Security tax on earnings for workers older than 67.

Second, I want to eliminate the convoluted, lobbyist-created loopholes in the code. For years, wealthy individuals have deducted a much greater share of their income than everyone else. We will retain the deductibility of charitable contributions but cap the deductions used by the wealthy and Washington special interests, enabling tax-rate cuts across the board for everyone. And while we’re doing that, we will treat all noninvestment income the same, so unless you stake capital in an investment, you won’t be able to claim the capital-gains tax rate on your market gains.

Third, I believe that the tax code should no longer be an impediment to the nation’s competitiveness with China, Europe and the rest of the world. Liberals will tell you that we need walls and tariffs to protect U.S. businesses from international competitors. The liberals are wrong; we need tax reform. To stop American companies from moving out of the country, I will cut the corporate tax rate from 35%—the highest in the industrial world—to 20%, which is five percentage points below China’s.

We will end the practice of world-wide taxation on U.S. businesses, which fosters the insidious tactic called corporate “inversions.” This is when small overseas companies buy big U.S. companies so that both can enjoy the lowest tax rate possible, costing American jobs and revenue. And we will assess a one-time tax of 8.75%, payable over 10 years, on the more than $2 trillion in corporate profits sitting overseas.

which is hardly surprising. I’ve complained before that Republicans only know one song: cut taxes.

I wish there were more in that plan about how he plans to pay for that tax cut. Since, presumably, defense cuts are off the table it doesn’t leave much and I see only the most oblique references to eliminating tax expenditures in that op-ed.

Since people in the lower income quintiles no longer pay income taxes, any tax cut is definitionally a “tax cut for the rich” so I expect he’ll be excoriated for this plan but it’s hardly a surprise.

IMO it’s time that we stopped using the tax code as our only economic plan.

3 comments

The Concerning Job Statistics

Here’s a bit of statistical information that should, at the very least, be concerning. In August 2015 nearly 700,000 native-born Americans lost their jobs. That was offset somewhat by foreign-born Americans getting jobs:

The one chart that matters more than ever,has little to nothing to do with the Fed’s monetary policy, but everything to do with the November 2016 presidential elections in which the topic of immigration, both legal and illegal, is shaping up to be the most rancorous, contentious and divisive.

The chart is the following, showing the cumulative addition of foreign-born and native-born workers added to US payrolls according to the BLS since December 2007, i.e., since the start of the recession/Second Great Depression. [ed.: see chart in linked post]

The chart is especially important because what it shows for just the month of August will be enough to provide the Trump – and every other – campaign with enough soundbites and pivot points to last it for weeks on end: namely, that in August a whopping 698,000 native-born Americans lost their job. This drop was offset by 204,000 foreign-born Americans, who got a job in the month of August.

But the punchline: since December 2007, according to the Household Survey, only 790,000 native born American jobs have been added. Contrast that with the 2.1 million foreign-born Americans who have found a job over the same time period…

And people wonder why populist opinion, whether that of populist Republicans supporting Donald Trump or that of populist Democrats supporting Bernie Sanders, is in increasingly nativist.

It’s not as simple as Americans being replaced by foreigners (although in some cases it is). It’s also that some jobs are disappearing and other jobs are being created and a lot of the jobs being created are going to the foreign-born.

Clearly, we’re doing something wrong. I don’t know whether that something is educational or social or that we have lousy immigration policy or what. But we’re doing something wrong.

3 comments

The Fed Should Do Its Job

and only its job.

Before the Federal Reserve actually renders its decision about whether to raise interest rates or not, I think I’ll give my opinion. I see little evidence of inflation. If anything deflation is beginning to take hold in earnest. Commodities are falling price. Most goods are falling in price. Gold has fallen in price. Oil has fallen in price.

Some services are continuing to rise in price, specifically healthcare and education, but in my view that’s due to government mismanagement. Indeed, in the cases of healthcare and education that’s practically definitional. However, I believe that the solution to government mismanagement is better government management rather than no government management. But that’s not the Fed’s job.

By law the Federal Reserve has two mandates. First, it has the mandate of maintaining stable prices. Second, it’s supposed to maximize employment. Here’s the actual statutory language from the Federal Reserve Act as revised in 1977:

The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System and the Federal Open Market Committee shall maintain long run growth of the monetary and credit aggregates commensurate with the economy’s long run potential to increase production, so as to promote effectively the goals of maximum employment, stable prices and moderate long-term interest rates.

I do not believe, however, that it’s the Fed’s job to “run the economy” as it’s sometimes put. It’s also not the Fed’s job to ensure that the stock market always rises. And it’s definitely not the Fed’s job to ensure that the Chinese stock market always rises.

I completely recognize the havoc that persistent low interest rates are playing in the economy. You can hardly open the newspaper without reading about public pension crises, direct consequences of persistent low interest rates. And, as I’ve noted before, there are two ways of making money in the insurance business: the insurance business and shrewd money management. There are strict limits on how fast and how high companies can raise premiums which makes it much harder to make money in the insurance business these days than it used to be. As insurance comes to be seen as a right (which means it’s not insurance any more), it will become that much harder. And with limits on what companies can do with the premiums they must hold in reserve to pay off claims. Persistent low interest rates makes it hard to make money that way, too. Those are some of the reasons the insurance companies are squawking.

Given that context I see little cause for the Fed to raise interest rates to fulfill its mandates but lots of reasons for the Congress to start mitigating the risks that persistent low interest rates have produced. Interest rates have been, essentially, zero or less than zero at least since February of 2009 and arguably since February of 2008 which makes the latter a matter of some urgency.

Time’s a wastin’.

0 comments

Coping With a Mad Tea Party

In Lewis Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland after the March Hare, the Mad Hatter, and the Dormouse had used the china and soiled the linen during their Mad Tea Party, they moved down to the table to clean cups and linen. The Mad Tea Party has now reached Europe’s doors.

After castigating the Obama Administration for “chosing to do almost nothing” in Syria:

The refugees are fleeing horror shows across North Africa and the Middle East, but especially the Syrian civil war that is now into its fifth year. Committed to withdrawing from the region, President Obama chose to do almost nothing. Europe, which has a longer Middle Eastern history than America and is closer, chose not to fill the U.S. vacuum.

the editors of the Wall Street Journal turn their fire on Europeans:

Europeans who dislike an America they think is overbearing should note what happens when the world’s policeman decides to take a vacation and let the neighbors fend for themselves. In the modern world of instant communications and easy transportation, the world’s problems will wash up on the wealthy West’s shores one way or another. If Europe isn’t prepared to handle nearby crises, militarily if necessary, be prepared to accept the refugees.

The reality is that “world policeman” is a job that nobody wants any more. Under a Westphalian order there is no need for such a function. It is only under the post-Westphalian order that so many in Europe and the United States have longed for (with most of the rest of the world rejecting the premises of a Westphalian system) that we’ve been urged to take on that mantle, one that we are peculiarly unsuited for. The world’s largest economy will never be considered an uninterested party and “world policeman” demands an uninterested party.

The United Nations can’t fill that role. World government requires world consensus and if there’s a single lesson that should have been learned over the last twenty or thirty years it should be just how far from world consensus we really are. They continue with advice for Europe:

Absorbing refugees also requires a robust economy that Europe hasn’t had in years. Most refugees want to go to Germany, but even Germany is growing at a mere 1.6% annual rate. Unemployment looks low (4.7%) but the labor force participation rate is very low, about 60%, according to World Bank figures. For the rest of Europe, the ability to absorb a refugee influx is even worse.

Without economic reform to produce a growth economy, migration on the current scale is going to strain Europe’s welfare state and further encourage the rise of extreme anti-immigration parties like the National Front in France, Golden Dawn in Greece, Jobbik in Hungary and the Pegida movement in Germany. It will also begin to threaten such pillars of the modern European Union as its Schengen policy that allows passport-free travel and migration. Schengen has been a crucial economic safety valve that allows young people in particular to move for economic opportunity when their native country is in recession.

Where in the world would they get the idea that Germany has any interesting “absorbing” refugees? They haven’t absorbed the Turks and in some cases they’ve been in Germany for generations. The Middle Eastern and North African people who inhabit France’s banlieu’s haven’t been absorbed despite, in many cases, having been born French citizens.

And with advice for us:

All of which underscores that the migration crisis is far more than a humanitarian issue. By all means Europe needs to do more to end the immediate human suffering. So does the U.S., which could in particular accept Syrian Christians who are targeted for extinction by Islamists.

Does the United States really want more Christians? I could have sworn it was the opposite.

22 comments

When You Do Nothing

Just to put a little more context on my previous post, my view of “doing nothing” is drastically different either from Fred Hiatt’s view or, apparently, the Obama Administration’s. I don’t consider supplying the Syrian rebels, training them, or providing air support for them, each of which inevitably means we’re supporting DAESH in Syria even as we oppose it in Iraq, a loonier policy than which could hardly be found, to be doing nothing.

0 comments

Weighing Competing Interests

As I read the large number of articles, posts, etc. on the large number of refugees (or migrants, depending on your point-of-view) fleeing the Middle East and North Africa and the hostilities in Syria, Iraq, Yemen, Somalia, Libya, and Afghanistan, there’s a question that occurs to me: how do you weigh the competing interests of life, liberty, and property involved?

If you believe that people in the countries of the Middle East and North Africa have both a right to self-determination and to flee their home countries for destinations of their own choice, then you necessarily challenge the rights to property and self-determination of the people in the receiving countries. Think it through and you’ll see that is so.

The question has all sorts of alternative phrasings. One I’ve been asked is do we have not just a right but an obligation to overthrow the government of, say, Syria and install one more to our liking? That’s an extreme formulation and it would clearly be a denial of the Syrians’ rights to self-determination and self-government. Another formulation I’ve seen comes in the form of nostalgia for colonialism. See also this lament from Fred Hiatt.

I don’t know the answer to this question but I imply my view in the title of this post: I don’t think there is an absolute answer. I think it comes down to weighing competing interests and that to some degree is a matter of preference for which there is no hard and fast answer. Chacun à son goût. One man’s meat, etc.

Nonetheless I want to put the question on the floor. How do you weigh the competing interests?

2 comments

Try To See It Under Lights

You know, as I read Robert Samuelson’s column musing over whether China’s economy will crash or have a “soft landing”:

It now turns out that the Chinese — like the Japanese — are not infallible. Indeed, after allowing for differences in historical circumstances, China and Japan seem to have committed similar mistakes. Japan had relied on exports and business investment until an appreciating exchange rate in the mid-1980s undermined the price competitiveness of its exports. It then adopted an easy monetary policy, which led to bubbles in real estate and stock prices. Similarly, China depended on export-led growth and, when the financial crisis dampened trade, switched to a massive expansion of credit to finance infrastructure projects and more investment in heavy industry.

it occurred to me that, more than anything else, it illustrates the inability of our math-phobic opinion makers in dealing with large numbers. So, for example, an increase in 7.2 million non-farm jobs over six months sounds pretty impressive. But China’s total labor force is estimated to be around 800 million people so as a percentage that’s about .9%. Relative to total employment the U. S. economy added that many non-farm jobs in the month of August.

China faces some great challenges in the years ahead. A decade ago I wrote optimistically about the country’s ability to deal with them effectively. China’s leaders have completely failed to do so. I’ll leave the whys to someone else but every one of China’s greatest challenges, e.g. demography, environmental problems, is worse than it was a decade ago. They’re not moving in the right direction.

1 comment

DAESH Opens a New Front

I suspect that this will prove to have been a mistake:

The Islamic State’s so-called “province” in the Caucasus region has claimed responsibility for its first official attack since its was established earlier this year.

In a statement released online (seen above), and translated by the SITE Intelligence Group, the group says “the soldiers of the Caliphate were able to mount an attack on barracks of the Russian army in southern Dagestan, in Magharamakint village.” The raid allegedly “led to the killing and wounding of a number of them.” Afterwards, “the soldiers of the Caliphate returned to their positions safely and with spoils, and unto Allah is all praise and gratitude,” SITE’s translation reads.

The Islamic State announced its Caucasus branch in June, but the jihadists had not claimed responsibility for any attacks since then.

The Russians are a sentimental people but not about their enemies. Given Russia’s growing participation in the Syrian civil war, I wouldn’t be surprised at seeing a vigorous response to this challenge.

You might find the Russians’ view of the United States’s role in the events in the Middle East interesting:

In this system of values, the West is 100% good and Russia is 100% bad. The West may cooperate with 60% bad Islamists to struggle against the 90% bad guys, such as Assad. Saddam Hussein used to be a 70% “good guy” for a long time, but then he became a 90% “bad guy,” because he stopped doing the things that the “good guys” – the 110% USA – wanted him to do, the publication ironically wrote.

Now all the “bad guys” are dead, and Assad must join them because he is “bad” too, says the author. This is the reason why the “fighters for freedom in Syria had been receiving financial assistance from the CIA until they founded the “Islamic State.” The “good guys” became the “bad guys” in an instant, the author of the article concluded.

If ISIS terrorists were targeting Putin’s Russia, the West would be referring to them as “freedom fighters” rather than terrorists. In this case, the fighters of the Islamic State would become “good” again.

“We are doing only good things, because we are good by definition. If people die, it does not have anything to do with us,” this is the logic that the United States follows.

7 comments

More On That Kentucky County Clerk

Eugene Volokh makes almost precisely the argument that I’ve been making, namely that the court erred in throwing into jail the Kentucky Clerk who refused to issue marriage licenses to homosexual couples with her name on them (as required by state law):

There’s a lot of appeal to the “you take the job, you follow the rules — if you have a religious objection to the rules, quit the job” approach may be. But it’s not the approach that modern American federal employment law has taken, or the approach that the state religious exemption law in Kentucky and many other states has taken.

Muslim truck drivers who don’t want to transport alcohol, Jehovah’s Witnesses who don’t want to raise flags, Sabbatarians (Jewish or Christian) who don’t want to work Saturdays, and philosophical vegetarians who don’t want to hand out hamburger coupons can take advantage of this law. Conservative Christian county clerks who don’t want to have their names listed on marriage certificates and licenses likely can, too.

Read the whole thing.

Employers, even government employers, are required to make reasonable accommodations for the religious beliefs of their employees and in Kentucky that applies to elected officials, too. There are any number of remedies the judge might have applied, several of which are outlined in the post.

18 comments