The Scope of the Volkswagen Problem

CNN puts it into perspective:

Here are seven key facts that show what’s at stake:
1. The Volkswagen group accounts for roughly one in 10 vehicles sold globally*.
2. The auto industry is the largest industrial sector in Germany, contributing about 2.7% to gross domestic product.
3. Some 20% of Germany’s exports are made up of vehicles and parts.
4. Domestic auto sales and exports were worth 368 billion euros ($411 billion) in 2014.
5. Most German auto sales came from the Volkswagen group, which reported just over 202 billion euros in revenue in 2014.
6. Roughly 70% of Volkswagen vehicles are sold outside German borders.
7. Volkswagen employs nearly 600,000 people around the world, and more than a third of the 775,000 people who work in the auto industry in Germany.

The CEO of Volkswagen US just admitted that the company “screwed up”. If it were only ein Fehler—a mistake—it would be bad enough. It’s ein Verbrechen—a crime. He’s acting as though somebody inadvertently didn’t tighten a lug nut enough.

20 comments

Will VW Survive?

There have been multiple developments in the VW story I mentioned yesterday. The number of vehicles involved may be as many as 11 million worldwide:

Volkswagen’s emissions scandal ballooned Tuesday as the automaker said it affects 11 million vehicles worldwide and will require the company to set aside 6.5 billion euro ($7.3 billion).

The startling admission instantly makes the crisis one of the most expensive automotive scandals in recent memory.

The crisis also threatens to upend the company on its rapid path to becoming the world’s largest automaker. Volkswagen had seized the title from Toyota for the first six months of 2015.

“This could damage the Volkswagen brand globally for years to come,” said former automotive marketing executive Peter De Lorenzo, blogger at Autoextremist.com, in an interview. “Trust and belief in the brand has been broken.”

It looks as though VW’s CEO is on his way out:

Volkswagen will dismiss Chief Executive Martin Winterkorn, a German newspaper said on Tuesday, after the carmaker admitted to cheating U.S. vehicles emissions tests and said 11 million of its cars could be affected worldwide.

The Tagesspiegel newspaper, citing unidentified sources on Volkswagen’s supervisory board, said Winterkorn would be replaced by Matthias Mueller, the head of the carmaker’s Porsche sports car business.

A Volkswagen spokesman denied the report. A spokesman for Porsche said Mueller was attending a Volkswagen board meeting at its headquarters in Wolfsburg.

Never believe any rumor until it has been officially denied. South Korea is opening its own investigation into the VW fraud:

The scandal engulfing Volkswagen AG (VOWG_p.DE), which has admitted cheating diesel vehicle emissions tests in the United States, spread east on Tuesday as South Korea said it would investigate three of the maker’s diesel models.

Volkswagen shares plunged by 19 percent on Monday after the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) said on

Friday that the world’s biggest carmaker by sales used software that deceived regulators measuring toxic emissions and could face penalties of up to $18 billion.

Media reports say the U.S. Department of Justice has started a criminal probe into the allegations, which cover several VW and Audi-branded diesel models including the Audi A3, VW Jetta, Beetle, Golf and Passat.

The South Korean probe will involve 4,000 to 5,000 Jetta, Golf and Audi A3 vehicles produced in 2014 and 2015, Park Pan-kyu, a deputy director at South Korea’s environment ministry, told Reuters.

The ministry will consider recalling those vehicles after conducting the investigation, he said.

“If South Korean authorities find problems in the VW diesel cars, the probe could be expanded to all German diesel cars,” he said.

Expect damage control from the German government sooner rather than later. The French finance minister is calling for a Europe-wide investigation:

French Finance Minister Michel Sapin has called for a Europe-wide inquiry after revelations that Volkswagen placed secret software in cars to dodge US pollution tests. The German carmaker’s shares fell four per cent at opening in Frankfurt on Tuesday morning, following a 17 per cent fall on Monday.

“We are in a European market, with European rules that need to be respected and that have been broken in the US,” Sapin told Europe 1 radio.

“Even if it’s just to reassure each other, it seems necessary to carry them out also on French carmakers,” he said, although he said he had no “particular reason” to suspect them of wrongdoing.

According to US authorities, Volkswagen has admitted equipping about 482,000 diesel cars with software that turns off pollution controls, except when they are undergoing emission tests.

“This is not a minor subject, it’s not about speed or the quality of leather,” Sapin said. “What we are dealing with is making sure people avoid being poisoned by pollution.”

The irony, of course, is that these vehicles were marketed as one way of reducing pollution. As with so many of Europe’s strategies, the unforeseen effects are coming around to bite them in the hind quarters. Anti-pollution measures have apparently incentivized VW to look for clever ways of evading detection.

The question now is whether VW can weather this storm. Before this morning’s news I would have predicted that VW would circle the wagons and seek protection from the EU. Does the company have enough U. S. assets to cover its fines here?

But eleven million is a lot of vehicles and VW’s net revenues are only about $10 billion annually. If the problem is as difficult to remediate as I suspect it is, between fines, recalls, and the inevitable lawsuits (at least here in the States) not to mention the increasingly likely criminal charges and declines in sales due to lost reputation, I think that VW’s future is in serious doubt.

6 comments

Shutting the Barn Door

If there’s any sure sign that the Chinese authorities have achieved their objectives in the aggressive cyber-attacks they’ve promoted against the United States and U. S. companies this will tell us:

WASHINGTON — After what figures to be a pleasant meeting with Pope Francis this week, President Obama faces more contentious conversations with a powerful global rival: President Xi Jinping of China.

Hacking, cybersecurity, military ambitions in Asia, and Chinese economic troubles are among the tense topics on the agenda as Obama and Xi meet at the White House on Thursday night and Friday.

If the Chinese have obtained about as much intelligence as they think they’re likely to get, they’ll indicate their interest in a verifiable accord governing the use of cyberwarfare. IMO the Obama Administration erred in their response to the hacking of the Office of Personnel Records. If they had reliable evidence of Chinese involvement, they should have responded decisively and visibly. That’s why deterrence requires.

0 comments

The Volkswagen Test

There’s quite a bit of turmoil attendant to the revelations about Volkswagen’s having faked its emissions tests. Its stock has plummeted by 20%. Think about it this way. The affair will end up costing the company something in the vicinity of $30 billion (yes, that’s billion with a “b”) or three times its annual profits.

$18 billion will come right off the top in fines. It will be the largest auto industry fine by an order of magnitude. Then there’s the cost of the recall. It’s not a trivial fix. There may be no way for the company to make the customers who bought the vehicles in question whole other than by refunding the purchase price of the half million vehicles in question. They can’t leave things the way they are—it doesn’t meet emissions standards. If they adjust the emissions, the vehicles will lose power which means the customers won’t have the vehicles they paid for. VW doesn’t really have a solution for the problem. They’ll probably try to cut some soft of deal with their customers.

And then there’s the lost business. What did the Edsel flap cost Ford in lost sales? Maybe nothing or they may have reduced sales for a decade. Companies have exited the U. S. market over less.

And then there are the potential criminal charges. As I see it Volkswagen makes such a great target it will be a test for the Obama Administration’s willingness to enforce the law, particularly Sarbanes-Oxley.

  • It’s not a U. S. company.
  • IIRC its two U. S. plants are not unionized so they won’t have pushback over that.
  • Its plants are in purple Pennsylvania and deep red Tennessee.

If not VW, then who?

13 comments

An Idea Whose Time Has Come

Random drug-testing of the members of Congress:

WASHINGTON — While most Americans like the idea of drug testing for welfare recipients, they LOVE the idea of drug testing for members of Congress.

According to a new HuffPost/YouGov poll, 64 percent of Americans favor requiring welfare recipients to submit to random drug testing — a measure pushed by Republican lawmakers in recent years — while 18 percent oppose it. But an even stronger majority said they’re in favor of random drug testing for members of Congress, by a 78 percent to 7 percent margin. Sixty-two percent said they “strongly” favor drug testing for congressional lawmakers, compared to only 51 percent who said the same of welfare recipients.

Heck, I’d settle for sanity checks.

2 comments

Unknown Script Found in Georgia

Writing of a heretofore unknown style has been found in the Caucasus:

GRAKLIANI, Georgia—Sophia Paatashvili, a third-year graduate student in archaeology at Ivane Javakashvili Tbilisi State University, was excavating an ancient temple at an Iron Age site called Grakliani last month when she noticed something strange: a series of marks carved into a stone slab just below the temple’s collapsed altar.

Unlike inscriptions found in other temples at Grakliani, these didn’t show animals or people, nor were they random decorative elements.

Instead, says Vakhtang Licheli, who heads the university’s archaeology institute and has led excavations at Grakliani during the past eight years, they may be the oldest example of a native alphabet in the Caucasus—fully a thousand years older than any indigenous writing previously found in the region.

When I was a kid I was fascinated with the stories of how the great writing systems of antiquity—Egyption hieroglyphics and Sumerian cuneiform leading the pack. I read everything I could get my hands on on the subject. I was amazed when within my own lifetime the writing system of the Maya was decoded.

There are still undeciphered scripts waiting to reveal their secrets, the most notable being the writing system of the Indus Valley Civilization. I still have hopes that it will be deciphered.

There are still other writing systems that have eluded understanding. Linear A (the other Cretan writing system). Rongorongo (the writing system found on Rapa Nui). Proto-Elamite (another Middle Eastern writing system, different from cuneiform). In the case of many of the undeciphered inscriptions that have been found they don’t even know what language they’re written in.

1 comment

Mass Incarceration

I have a feeling we’re going to be hearing a lot on this subject so let’s think a bit about it. Rather than link to any single article I’ll just start by listing some views. I’m pretty certain that I can find prominent voices saying each of them.

  • Blacks and Hispanics are being imprisoned in large numbers due to white racism.
  • People are being imprisoned who shouldn’t be because there are too many acts that have been designated as crimes that shouldn’t be.
  • Blacks and Hispanics are committing crimes in numbers disproportionate to their total numbers because of a lack of economic opportunity for them.
  • Blacks and Hispanics are being imprisoned in disproportionate numbers because they commit a disproportionate number of the crimes.
  • Blacks and Hispanics are being imprisoned in disproportionate numbers because they’re being targeted by the police.
  • Blacks and Hispanics are being imprisoned in disproportionate numbers because they can’t afford adequate representation.
  • Blacks and Hispanics are committing crimes in numbers disproportionate to their total numbers because of social dysfunction within their communities.
  • A lot of people are going to prison here because the United States is a good place to be a career criminal. Our wealth and our system attract criminals.
  • There are very few innocents in prison. The reason that there appears to be a large population in prison for non-violent crimes is an artifact of our legal system.
  • The incarceration rate in the United States is only drastically out of line if you think we’re a European country. Incarceration rates tend to be higher in large, diverse countries than they are in small, homogeneous ones with lots of social cohesion.

Have I left anything important out?

My take: nearly all of the above. I think that we should decriminalize simple possession of small amounts of drugs and beef up the treatment options available. However, I also think that won’t have as great an effect as many advocates believe. I think that prosecutors should have less discretion in pleading violent felonies down to misdemeanors and in particular pleading them down to simple possession. I think that the numbers don’t support the idea that there are a large number of first-time offenders doing prison time for simple possession. I also think that the common practice of releasing serial offenders again and again after they’re arrested without punishment until they finally do something more serious and then convicting them on a lesser charge and sentencing them to prison has serious implications. Among them being that it brings the justice system into disrepute.

6 comments

The Migrants

I agree with Francis that we have an obligation to aid the needy. Do we have a similar obligation to the wanty? Do the needy generally appear in populations overwhelmingly consisting of young men?

3 comments

Hearing What You Want to Hear

…and disregarding the rest. The Wall Street Journal‘s editors are willing to give President Obama the benefit of the doubt:

In July two Defense Intelligence Agency analysts lodged a complaint with the Pentagon’s Inspector General alleging that Centcom—the military command that oversees the effort against ISIS—was altering its intelligence assessments to bring them into line with the Administration’s positive spin. The allegation has since been corroborated by more than 50 other analysts, according to the Daily Beast.

We won’t join the clucking brigades claiming that President Obama or his inner circle are “manipulating intelligence”—the dishonest and discredited claim endlessly made about the Bush Administration’s mistaken intel on Iraq. If you need a refresher on this score, read the conclusions of the July 2004 bipartisan report from the Senate Select Intelligence Committee, or the equally definitive Robb-Silberman report from March 2005.

What we know of the Centcom story so far reminds us that intelligence is a complex business involving partial information, unverifiable sources, conflicting analysis and bureaucratic turf wars—all of it aimed at a moving target. Even in an age of cybersleuths and surveillance drones, it’s more often a wonder when intelligence agencies get things right.

The more pertinent question now is what are the correct policies with respect to Iraq, Syria, and the Middle East, generally? There’s an idea called “path dependency”, the notion that today’s decisions are limited by yesterday’s, more succinctly expressed a “you can’t unring a bell” or, maybe, “don’t cry over spilt milk”. We should never have invaded Iraq but we did and that decision limits the future decisions we can make about what we do.

President Obama seems remarkably unable to learn from experience, whether the experience of others or his own. Maybe that’s what it takes to become president these days. Why are we supporting violent radical Sunni Islamists in Syria and opposing them in Iraq? What does he think will happen if Assad is out of the picture? What alternatives does he think Assad has? What alternatives does he think the Alawites have? Is there an objective to be attained in Syria that warrants risking major power confrontation?

1 comment

Their Worst Qualities

I was aware of my parents’ many fine qualities from a very early age. Maybe all kids are—at least the lucky ones are. People generally are eager to portray themselves in the best possible light and I guess that pertains to the side of themselves that parents show to their kids. My parents were intelligent, accomplished, hard-working, loyal to a fault, fun, thoughtful, and loving. I never had a second when I doubted they loved me.

It wasn’t until much later that I began to become aware of their flaws. In my dad’s case it was until many, many years after his death at all too young an age.

Somewhat to my surprise I have learned that I inherited all of my parents’ worst qualities.

3 comments