The Adventure That Is Illinois

It’s a never-ending adventure here in Illinois. The latest example is that the janitorial service for the Thompson Center, the big state office building in downtown Chicago, has quit, reasonably enough, because they weren’t being paid. An emergency RFQ has gone out to try and find a replacement.

Meanwhile, the state employees in the Thompson Center have been asked to start packing their own trash out of the building for the duration. Like backpacking—you pack it in, then you pack it out.

1 comment

Did the Nuclear Family Really Prevail in Traditional America?

Speaking of Mike Lotus’s America 3.0 speculation, in it he places a lot of weight on the importance of family structures in American development, citing the “absolute nuclear family” of western England and northern Europe as highly influential. He may be right but I’m not convinced. Although I grew up within such a family, my father did not. Quite to the contrary he grew up in what is called a famille patriarcale in a very extreme form and one that prevailed well into the 20th century.

The Schulers’ style of family organization is one that I have been given to understand is one that prevailed in traditional Switzerland, particularly in Canton Schwyz. In this style all of the family’s sons including married sons and their wives and children lived near to one another and the sons all worked for their father who held title to all of the family’s real possessions.

So, for example, my grandfather and his two brothers all worked for my great-grandfather Schuler. They owned nothing. They did not receive a salary for their labors. Grandpa Schuler paid the bills and saw to it that they had spending money. That situation continued right up until Grandpa Schuler’s death.

7 comments

The Revolution Has Been Cancelled

In remarking on James Piereson’s book, Shattered Consensus, Michael Goodwin touches on themes I’ve sounded here from time to time. I believe the dissatisfaction in the United States now is higher than at any time I can recall including during the 1960s. Indeed, I think the dissatisfaction is as great as it’s been other than during a very few periods including the lead-up to the American Civil War.

However, unlike Mssrs. Piereson or Goodwin or my blog-friend Mike Lotus with his America 3.0 hypothesis (look it up), I don’t think that America has a revolution in store or even, in what might be better diction, a paradigm shift. Revolutions, real or figurative, aren’t started by the poor. They’re fomented and led by the middle class, the intelligentsia to use the Russian phrase, and our middle class are so thoroughly dependent on Things As They Are I suspect they’ll defend them to collapse and beyond.

What I expect is the Detroitification of the United States, an ongoing slow motion decay in which things just aren’t quite as good for this generation as they were for the last and things just aren’t quite as good for the next generation as they were for this, accompanied by a general lack of optimism. Look to Chicago and Illinois as Ground Zero.

If, within a generation, Chicago introduces either a) a major decentralization of power and a reversal of the high tax, corrupt, government-centric style that has prevailed here for the last sixty or seventy years or b) has a socialist revolution, I’ll be proven wrong. If, on the other hand, Chicago’s political leadership continues to pursue the same old policies regardless of their efficacy and the people of Chicago keep right on voting for them, it will strongly suggest I am right.

11 comments

I Wonder What He Means?

On one thing I think we should all be able to agree. The diplomatic order created following the Yom Kippur War in 1973 and which persisted, for most of its tenure on life support, until 2003, has collapsed. It’s fallen and it can’t get up. As he was one of the primary architects of that order, I’m prepared to listen to Henry Kissinger’s advice on what should replace it and he offers that in his Wall Street Journal op-ed. Unfortunately, I don’t think that it comports with the reality that’s on the ground there.

Like any good epic, Dr. Kissinger’s account begins in medias res:

The debate about whether the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action with Iran regarding its nuclear program stabilized the Middle East’s strategic framework had barely begun when the region’s geopolitical framework collapsed. Russia’s unilateral military action in Syria is the latest symptom of the disintegration of the American role in stabilizing the Middle East order that emerged from the Arab-Israeli war of 1973.

In the aftermath of that conflict, Egypt abandoned its military ties with the Soviet Union and joined an American-backed negotiating process that produced peace treaties between Israel and Egypt, and Israel and Jordan, a United Nations-supervised disengagement agreement between Israel and Syria, which has been observed for over four decades (even by the parties of the Syrian civil war), and international support of Lebanon’s sovereign territorial integrity. Later, Saddam Hussein’s war to incorporate Kuwait into Iraq was defeated by an international coalition under U.S. leadership. American forces led the war against terror in Iraq and Afghanistan. Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia and the other Gulf States were our allies in all these efforts. The Russian military presence disappeared from the region.

which explains some of the background for the policy. Filling in a little of the earlier history, the first direct contact between a U. S. president and a Saudi head of state took place in 1945. Generally, our attitude towards the Middle East had been one of disinterest.

Truman immediately recognized the state of Israel. Eisenhower connived at the overthrow of Mossadegh in Iran and supported the Shah after the putsch that overthrew him but was predisposed to be wary of Middle Eastern involvements. We did not join Britain and France in the Suez Crisis and the situation between the United States in Israel during this period was, well, tense. Kennedy was a full-throated supporter of Israel as was Johnson.

U. S. policy in the Middle East during Kissinger’s tenure as Secretary of State had at its foundation a balancing of tensions among the Iraqis, Saudis, the Iranians, and the Israelis. That equilibrium collapsed when the Iranian revolution removed the Shah, replacing him with the present theocracy. Our policy has never recovered from that.

This statement of Dr. Kissinger’s puzzles me:

That geopolitical pattern is now in shambles. Four states in the region have ceased to function as sovereign. Libya, Yemen, Syria and Iraq have become targets for nonstate movements seeking to impose their rule.

because of a curious lacuna. We have intervened in all four of those countries. They didn’t simply cease “to function as sovereign”. We ignored their sovereignty. We’ve knocked them down or helped to knock them down.

ISIS’ claim has given the millennium-old split between the Shiite and Sunni sects of Islam an apocalyptic dimension. The remaining Sunni states feel threatened by both the religious fervor of ISIS as well as by Shiite Iran, potentially the most powerful state in the region.

DEASH didn’t simply grow. Its growth was a direct consequence of U. S. policy, in particular the combination of removing Saddam Hussein and de-Ba’athification. Does anyone really doubt that one of the factors behind DAESH’s successes was remnants of Saddam’s military for whom there was no place in the new Iraq?

On one level, Iran acts as a legitimate Westphalian state conducting traditional diplomacy, even invoking the safeguards of the international system. At the same time, it organizes and guides nonstate actors seeking regional hegemony based on jihadist principles: Hezbollah in Lebanon and Syria; Hamas in Gaza; the Houthis in Yemen.

Nonsense. That’s like being a little bit pregnant. The mullahs are willing to hide behind the skirts of the rights of Westphalian sovereignty but unwilling to limit themselves to the restrictions and responsibilities of a Westphalian state. Dr. Kissinger is cloaking opportunism and hypocrisy in the garments of a legitimate policy.

Dr. Kissinger continues by outlining the present situation in the Middle East. I don’t think he gives appropriate weight to Russia’s interests in this passage:

On the surface, Russia’s intervention serves Iran’s policy of sustaining the Shiite element in Syria. In a deeper sense, Russia’s purposes do not require the indefinite continuation of Mr. Assad’s rule. It is a classic balance-of-power maneuver to divert the Sunni Muslim terrorist threat from Russia’s southern border region. It is a geopolitical, not an ideological, challenge and should be dealt with on that level. Whatever the motivation, Russian forces in the region—and their participation in combat operations—produce a challenge that American Middle East policy has not encountered in at least four decades.

The support that wealthy Gulf Arabs have provided to violent radical Islamists within Russia is a threat to Russia unmatched by any interest we have in the region. The same wealthy Saudis, Bahrainis, etc. are supporting DAESH and Al Qaeda in Syria. Meanwhile, the U. S. participated in the destruction of Russia’s other ally in the Middle East and North Africa, Libya. That Russia would respond to these threats is hardly surprising we’d’ve done the same thing. The Russians aren’t just responding to a U. S.-fomented power vacuum as Dr. Kissinger would have it. They’re responding to threats to them we’ve abetted, frequently against our own interests.

Dr. Kissinger’s proposed path forward has six components.

  1. Prioritize the destruction of DAESH above the removal of Bashar al-Assad. I agree with this. Given Russia’s involvement little action is required on our part. Refraining from supporting Al Qaeda or DAESH would be beneficial.
  2. Accept Russia’s role in the effort but try to limit its involvement to the destruction of DAESH. This is a knee-slapper:

    In a choice among strategies, it is preferable for ISIS-held territory to be reconquered either by moderate Sunni forces or outside powers than by Iranian jihadist or imperial forces.

    Unfortunately, there is no such choice. There is no “moderate Sunni” force in Syria capable of opposing either the Al Qaeda-supporting or DAESH-aligned radicals. Searching for one is a fool’s errand the Obama Administration has belatedly discovered that.

  3. Descend into fantasy:

    The reconquered territories should be restored to the local Sunni rule that existed there before the disintegration of both Iraqi and Syrian sovereignty.

    Local Sunni rule in those territories lasted for about 45 minutes. Previous to that they were ruled in Syria by the Alawite Assad regime and in Iraq by the Shi’ite-led Iraqi government. Our experience of the last several years is that “local Sunni rule” is unstable.

  4. A federal structure could then be built between the Alawite and Sunni portions.

    The Alawites certainly don’t see it that way. They appear to be fighting for their lives. They were treated like dirt for centuries until the French put them in charge of the new Syrian state. Isn’t “Syrian sovereignty” actually synonymous with minority rule? Indeed, isn’t the persecution of ethnic and religious minorities a standard feature of Middle Eastern states that aren’t dominated by autocrats? And some that are?

  5. The U.S. role in such a Middle East would be to implement the military assurances in the traditional Sunni states that the administration promised during the debate on the Iranian nuclear agreement, and which its critics have demanded.

    Nostalgia ain’t what it used to be. That “tradition” goes back less than a century. Indeed, that’s what’s collapsing right now.

  6. In this context, Iran’s role can be critical. The U.S. should be prepared for a dialogue with an Iran returning to its role as a Westphalian state within its established borders.

    Will that dialogue take place between rallies decrying the Great Satan? If there is evidence that the Iran of the mullahs has any interest in being a Westphalian state, I have yet to see it. Regime change is a precondition for Dr. Kissinger’s preferred outcome.

15 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Explicating the Russian Strategy

BTW, if you haven’t been following the many posts explaining the Russian strategy in Syria over at Pat Lang’s place, you’re missing out. At the very least they provide a benchmark for testing his and his other contributors’ predictions.

6 comments

Out With the Old, In With the New

Old narrative: Russia doesn’t have enough ability to project power to have a significant effect in Syria
New narrative: Russia doesn’t have the staying power to maintain its present level of activity

If the Russians’ claims are to be believed, they’ve flown as many sorties in the last couple of weeks as the U. S. has since it began its campaign a year ago:

Moscow (AFP) – Russia has hit more than 380 “Islamic State targets” since launching its bombing campaign in Syria on September 30, a senior military official said on Friday.

“Since the start of the operation we conducted more than 600 sorties and bombed more than 380 IS targets,” Colonel General Andrei Kartapolov, a senior Russian General Staff official, told Russian tabloid Komsomolskaya Pravda.

Russia launched a bombing campaign in Syria late last month in support of forces loyal to its longstanding ally President Bashar al-Assad.

Moscow’s military has almost uniformly claimed its strikes have hit “Islamic State” targets despite the fact that many of the sites struck seem to fall outside territory held by the group.

The US and other members of a rival coalition targeting IS say Moscow has focused the bulk of its firepower on other rebel groups battling Assad.

Kartapolov slammed the US-led coalition, saying the US had not responded to Russia’s invitation to cooperate in the fight against IS.

The Russians have a much clearer mission in Syria. Their view is that the only good Syrian rebel is a dead one. We’re still trying to identify and support the moderate rebels. That reminds me of Reagan’s manure pile story.

Earlier this morning I noted the reported involvement of Cuban troops in Syria. That move and the recent Iranian missile test cast real doubt on the administration’s policy of rapprochement:

Iran’s test of a ballistic missile earlier this week was a clear violation of a U.N. Security Council resolution and sends “a worrying message”, French Foreign Ministry spokesman Romain Nadal said on Thursday.

Iran tested a new precision-guided ballistic missile on Sunday in defiance of a United Nations ban, signaling an apparent advance in Iranian attempts to improve the accuracy of its missile arsenal.

“The Oct. 11 launch constitutes a clear violation of this resolution (1929). It is a worrying message from Iran to the international community,” Nadal told reporters in a daily briefing.

Ballistic missile tests by Iran are banned under Security Council resolution 1929, which dates from 2010 and remains valid until a nuclear deal dating from July 14 this year goes into effect.

11 comments

Why the Start-Up Stall?

This isn’t good news. The number of businesses that opened in 2013, the most recent year for which we have information, is lower than the number of start-ups in 2012:

The level of new U.S. businesses being created has been stalled since the end of the recession, according to an analysis of recently released Census data by Arnobio Morelix, a senior research analyst at the Kauffman Foundation. Given the long-term decline in entrepreneurship activity, “what we may be looking at is a new normal for the U.S.,” he says.

From the standpoint of financing there probably hasn’t been a better time to start a new company in American history. Is the reason for the sluggishness not enough demand? It would be interesting to see the number of new businesses formed per dollar GDP over time. I may try to dredge that out.

I think it’s a combination of demand, the ability of big companies to beat down competitors, regulation (related to the former), and generational shift.

I don’t think that Gen-Xers are starting businesses at the rate that Boomers did. Elon Musk, Sergei Brin, and Larry Page are all Gen-Xers but that’s just three. Elon Musk is a South African and Sergei Brin is a Russian. If anything that supports the notion that the U. S. is a great place to start a business.

Lots of great graphics in the linked post.

14 comments

More on Subjective Reality

Which of the two views expressed in Andy Pudzer’s Wall Street Journal op-ed is closer to reality?

In his remarks at a White House event last week called the Summit on Worker Voice, President Obama said that people who work hard “should be able to get ahead” but went on to acknowledge that workers are “seeing their wages and their incomes flatlining.”

The reason, according to Mr. Obama, is dwindling union membership. “Union membership today is as low as it’s been in about 80 years, since the ’30s,” he said. “And I believe that when folks attack unions, they’re attacking the middle class.” Thus he recommends “making it easier, not harder, for folks join a union.”

Here’s the reality: Wages and incomes for workers are stagnant because there aren’t enough jobs. It’s a matter of supply and demand. When jobs are scarce and people are unemployed, wages and benefits decline. When the job market is strong and businesses must compete for employees, wages and benefits improve. The solution, then, is more jobs.

I would say not just “more jobs” but more jobs that aren’t minimum wage jobs.

The policy for the last several decades has been to increase the number of minimum wage jobs, importing a work force to fill them. I don’t think that’s a winning formula but it may well be a winning political formula.

7 comments

My Question on the Democratic “Debate”

I did not watch the Democratic candidates’ “debate”. I won’t watch it and you can’t make me. However, based on John Cassidy’s remarks I have a question. Did Hillary Clinton convince anyone not already predisposed to vote for her to do so?

7 comments