Dave Schuler
November 3, 2015
Last night on my way home from work I heard an interview with David Holbrooke, the son of now deceased Richard Holbrooke, the Special Envoy to Afghanistan and Pakistan for the Obama Administration. Mr. Holbrooke recounted how his father had become increasingly disturbed by how out of step his views were with those of the administration he served. He saw the Obama Administration as being poorly informed on the situation in Afghanistan and Pakistan, convinced that they were knowledgeable and informed, and insistent on pursuing strategies that were doomed to failure.
I wonder when if ever the supporters of the administration will come to the realization that’s an accurate characterization of this administration not merely on its policies with respect to Afghanistan and Pakistan but with respect to its foreign and domestic policies more generally.
Maybe never. Dreams die hard.
Dave Schuler
November 2, 2015
To Mike Nelson’s post at RealClearDefense I will only add that if the ways do not effect the ends or if you do not will the means you cannot will the ends.
Dave Schuler
November 2, 2015
As I was driving in to work this morning, I heard an NPR interview in which were made what struck me as the most delusional comments I’ve heard from an American politician or military figure in some time. They were from Gen. Philip Breedlove, NATO’s Supreme Allied Commander Europe.
The first statement that I questioned was his assertion that Russian President Putin has stepped up Russia’s activities in Syria for the express purpose of distracting Western attention from what’s going on in Ukraine. I’m not making this up. That’s what he said.
Here’s why I question it. Russia’s relationship with Syria goes much farther back than Russia’s annexing the Crimean peninsula or backing anti-government rebels in Ukraine. Russia has interests in Syria—following the ouster of Moammar Qaddaffi in Libya, Syria was Russia’s sole remaining client in MENA.
His second remark that astonished me was his assertion that for twenty years the U. S. has been trying to cultivate Russia as a partner. How do
- Recruiting Warsaw Pact countries into NATO
- Recruiting former Soviet republics into NATO
- Encouraging countries that were historically part of Russia (Ukraine) into NATO
- The European Interceptor Shield that was planned to be installed in Poland
- Aiding Libyan rebels in overthrowing Russian client Moammar Qaddaffi
- Supporting rebels who oppose the Syrian government
figure in that cultivation? I find the Russian view on this much more credible: for the last twenty years we’ve been going out of our way to snub, antagonize, and counter Russia.
I realize that Gen Breedlove is privy to many more intelligence sources than I am but really.
Dave Schuler
November 2, 2015
Maybe its something in the water. Right along with the popularity of fantasy football, as Robert Samuelson points out in his most recent Washington Post column, we have fantasy tax policies from both political parties. I can’t say that the fantasies are equal and opposed but they’re certainly different. Here’s the Republicans’ fantasy:
Many Republican candidates have already issued detailed plans that lower personal and corporate income tax rates. For instance, Jeb Bush would replace today’s seven individual rates with three — 10 percent, 25 percent and 28 percent — and cut the top corporate rate to 20 percent from today’s 35 percent. Some of these cuts are offset by eliminating personal and business tax breaks. But not all.
The nonpartisan Tax Foundation evaluated seven Republican tax plans and concluded that all lose gobs of tax revenue. Some estimated shortfalls are gigantic. Over a decade, Donald Trump’s plan results in a $12 trillion revenue loss. The other losses include $6.1 trillion for the plan from Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) and $3.7 trillion for Bush’s.
and here’s the Democrats’
The same can be said of Democrats’ faith in soaking the rich. Their political narrative seems powerful. The rich have gotten richer and don’t pay their “fair share†in taxes. Raising their taxes will temper inequality and finance good causes. Redistribution becomes an engine of social justice. The trouble is that the math doesn’t match the rhetoric, as a new Brookings Institution study shows.
In it, economists William Gale, Melissa Kearney and Peter Orszag asked this question: What would happen if the top income tax rate were increased from 39.6 percent to 50 percent? The answer — less than you think.
For starters, it would raise about $100 billion in tax revenues. That seems like a lot (and is), but it’s actually slightly less than a quarter of the $439 billion budget deficit for fiscal 2015. Never mind paying for new programs. Even if the $100 billion were directly distributed to the poorest fifth of Americans (an average $2,650 per household), the effect on overall inequality would be “exceedingly modest,†the authors say.
From these contrasting fantasies Mr. Samuelson concludes that tax increases that extend well into the middle income quintiles is in our future. I think it’s more likely that there won’t be any tax reform at all.
There are three good, practical ways to reduce income inequality: increase the number of jobs, increase the pay of the jobs on offer (without reducing their number), and reduce the subsidies we’re paying to the top decile of income earners. None of those makes a particularly good soundbite.
Dave Schuler
November 2, 2015
Yesterday evening my wife and I watched the 1951 movie Storm Warning starring Ginger Rogers, Doris Day, and Ronald Reagan. Prior to watching that picture if you’d said “movie starring Ginger Rogers, Doris Day, and Ronald Reagan” to me, I’d’ve thought “light comedy”. Far from it.
The movie has a Ku Klux Klan theme treated as a fairly conventional Warner Brothers crime drama with strong performances by Ronald Reagan and Ginger Rogers. The cinematography, particularly in the early part of the picture, is actually more reminiscent of late 30s or early 40s cinematography.
Amazingly, there’s nothing about race relations in the picture which got it slammed by critics at the time. The KKK is treated as a criminal gang.
Prior to Ginger Rogers taking the part, Lauren Bacall had rejected it which got her suspended by Warner Brothers. Then they offered it to Joan Crawford who turned it down, laughing, on the grounds that no one would believe that Doris Day was her sister.
It’s a pretty fair movie and it’s certainly an artifact which is what moved us to watch it in the first place. We got it on DVD from Netflix.
Dave Schuler
November 1, 2015
There’s an interesting article at Fortune on the goings-on at Hewlett-Packard. If you hadn’t been aware of it the company is splitting into two components.
What I think the staunch HP-istas are missing is that if HP had remained an engineering-dominated company after Dave Packard retired, it would have fared worse than it did. Its sales would have dwindled and it would have been acquired by Digital Equipment or Compaq rather than the other way around.
The reason it transformed itself into a marketing dominated company is that it had to to survive.
I doubt that the new Hewlett Enterprise will be successful in establishing a solid presence in the cloud computing market. I think that market’s already mature. If you hadn’t noticed Jeff Bezos just became the wealthiest man in America, largely on the basis of Amazon Web Services not Internet retailing.
Dave Schuler
November 1, 2015
Nouriel Roubini sees a pattern emerging in Europe:
TOKYO – The recent victory of the conservative Law and Justice (PiS) party in Poland confirms a recent trend in Europe: the rise of illiberal state capitalism, led by populist right-wing authoritarians. Call it Putinomics in Russia, Órbanomics in Hungary, Erdoğanomics in Turkey, or a decade of Berlusconomics from which Italy is still recovering. Soon we will no doubt be seeing Kaczyńskinomics in Poland.
All are variations on the same discordant theme: a nationalist leader comes to power when economic malaise gives way to chronic and secular stagnation. This elected authoritarian then starts to reduce political freedoms through tight-fisted control of the media, especially television. Then, he (so far, it has always been a man, though France’s Marine Le Pen would fit the pattern should she ever come to power) pursues an agenda opposing the European Union (when the country is a member) or other institutions of supra-national governance.
He will also oppose free trade, globalization, immigration, and foreign direct investment, while favoring domestic workers and firms, particularly state-owned enterprises and private business and financial groups with ties to those in power. In some cases, outright nativist, racist parties support such government or provide an even deeper authoritarian and anti-democratic streak.
Some would see the increasing influence of Tea Party conservatives in the Republican Party as evidence of the same thing here. They may be right about some Tea Party conservatives. Those I know personally are all libertarians rather than nativist social conservatives.
Some would, presumably, see that in me although I don’t see how they could if they’d read what I’ve actually posted over the years rather than just extracting a few phrases they find problematic. I simply think that both the United States and Mexico would be better off if Mexico’s leaders didn’t regard sending workers to the United States who would send remittances back to Mexico as a pillar of the country’s economic policy. I also think that the preference that some U. S. employers have for illegal workers is because they’re illegal just as the preference that some employers have for H1-B visa workers is because they’ll work for lower wages. I don’t see pushing the wages of U. S. workers down as a benign strategy for U. S. economic or social policy.
Dave Schuler
November 1, 2015
You know, as I read this post about scary stock value declines, I began to wonder. Are energy sector stock declines positively or negatively correlated with more general declines in economic activity?
One of those research questions that I’ll probably never tackle.
Dave Schuler
November 1, 2015
For some ungodly reason there are people who refuse to admit that central planning is always catastrophic. It may be as has been said that those people always envision themselves as running a totalitarian regime rather than living under one. It was catastrophic in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe where it may take decades or even centuries to undo the harm done by Communist Party mismanagement. And, as noted by the editors of the Washington Post, it has been a catastrophe in China where the full horror of the catastrophe is yet to be fully realized:
DRAMATIC HUMAN catastrophes, engineered by the Communist Party, punctuated the 30 years following the establishment of the People’s Republic of China in 1949: A bloody intervention in the Korean War; manmade famine during the “Great Leap Forwardâ€; the Cultural Revolution. After the rise of more pragmatic Communist leaders in 1979, China settled down (with the notable exception of Tiananmen Square in 1989) and got on with the business of economic growth. Abuse of state power hardly ended, though; it simply took less spectacular form. The “one child†policy, which created havoc one family at a time, epitomized this period.
Read the whole thing. In my view the only people who can laud the CCP’s actions are those who hate the Chinese people or, possibly, human life in general.
Dave Schuler
November 1, 2015
Life is all too frequently the art of choosing among available alternatives, none of which is particularly appealing. In Syria the alternatives are the present secular Alawite government, Al Qaeda, and DAESH. Among these unpalatable alternatives the present government is the least bad alternative as outlined in this Boston Globe op-ed:
In this war, the United States has only enemies. We oppose every major force involved on the battlefield: Assad’s government, ISIS, the Nusra Front, Shi’ite militias, Iran and Russia. Although we cry for peace, we have no plan to achieve it. That is because winning in Syria means aligning ourselves with one vicious gang or another. Facing this reality is difficult but necessary. Today we have no strategic goal in Syria — and countries that have no strategic goals can never achieve them.
Any military action by us in Syria is illegal, immoral, and antithetical to U. S. interests. Why is the president deepening our involvement there?
The president could start alleviating some of these shortcomings. He could seek Security Council authorization for the use of force in Syria, something he’s unlikely to receive because of Russia’s involvement in the conflict on behalf of the Assad government, a legal act of the Russian’s part because they are operating at the invitation of the internationally recognized government of Syria. He could seek a declaration of war from Congress, something he’s unlikely to receive from the Republican majorities in both houses of Congress let alone from his own caucus.
Neither of those actions would alleviate the most basic problem with greater involvement in Syria: it’s not in our interest. U. S. involvement there is an instance of Talleyrand’s wisecrack: it’s worse than a crime, it’s a mistake.