October Unemployment Situation Report

The Bureau of Labor Statistics has released its unemployment situation report for the month of October 2015. A whopping 271,000 jobs are reported as having been added in October, far more than were expected:

Total nonfarm payroll employment increased by 271,000 in October, and the unemployment rate was essentially unchanged at 5.0 percent, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today. Job gains occurred in professional and business services, health care, retail trade, food services and drinking
places, and construction.

Household Survey Data

Both the unemployment rate (5.0 percent) and the number of unemployed persons (7.9 million) were essentially unchanged in October. Over the past 12 months, the unemployment rate and the number of unemployed persons were down by 0.7 percentage point and 1.1 million, respectively. (See table A-1.)

Among the major worker groups, the unemployment rates for adult men (4.7 percent), adult women (4.5 percent), teenagers (15.9 percent), whites (4.4 percent), blacks (9.2 percent), Asians (3.5 percent), and Hispanics (6.3 percent) showed little or no change in October. (See tables A-1, A-2, and A-3.)

The number of long-term unemployed (those jobless for 27 weeks or more) was essentially unchanged at 2.1 million in October and has shown little change since June. These individuals accounted for 26.8 percent of the unemployed in October. (See table A-12.)

The civilian labor force participation rate was unchanged at 62.4 percent in October, following a decline of 0.2 percentage point in September. The employment-population ratio, at 59.3 percent, changed little in October and has shown little movement over the past year. (See table A-1.)

Well, good. Another couple of years of months like that and we’ll be showing some headway.

Several things of which note should be taken. First, that number is 50% higher than expectations. 50% is a lot. Either the last couple of months’ worth of unemployment situation reports have been off or this one is. Or maybe it’s just an anomaly.

Second, the labor force participation rate remains at its 38 year low. That’s not good.

Third, to my untutored eye the biggest gainer seems to be in temp jobs (not a particularly good sign) while manufacturing, wholesale, and warehousing, the real bread-and-butter sectors, are still in the doldrums. Healthcare is a major gainer, too, but I’ve expressed my opinion of that often enough in the past.

Finally, August’s figures were adjusted up slightly while September’s figures were adjusted down. The August-October average was right about 187,000 or, said another way, just about the rate of natural increase—another way of saying that we’ll need a lot more months of major increases to start putting the long-term unemployed back to work.

20 comments

What to Look for in the TPP Agreement

I didn’t want to let this go by without remarking on it. The details of the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement have finally been revealed:

The long-awaited text of a landmark U.S.-backed Pacific trade deal was released on Thursday, revealing the details of a pact aimed at freeing up commerce in 40 percent of the world’s economy.

If ratified, the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP) will be a legacy-defining achievement for U.S. President Barack Obama and his administration’s pivot to Asia, aimed at countering China’s rising economic and political influence.

China has responded with its own Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP), a proposed 16-nation free-trade area including India that would be the world’s biggest such bloc, encompassing 3.4 billion people.

The TPP, which will set common standards on issues ranging from workers’ rights to intellectual property protection in 12 Pacific nations, was kept largely from public scrutiny during negotiations, angering transparency advocates concerned over its broad implications.

The text is here, courtesy of the government of New Zealand.

I haven’t read it yet and I don’t know that I’m stalwart enough to do so. Like most other people I may end up relying on other people’s reports and analyses. I would, however, like to propose a few guidelines for considering the agreement:

  1. The provisions of the agreement.
  2. The provisions that are enforceable.
  3. The provisions that are actually deliverable.
  4. Who wins and who loses.
  5. Provisions that are poisoned pills for one Congressional caucus or another.

And for goodness sake don’t call it a “free trade agreement”. It’s a trade agreement. Free trade has little to do with it.

3 comments

Are These Really the Results?

Is it really true, as claimed by Jonathan Tobin at Commentary, that only 260,000 of those who’ve gained healthcare insurance since the provisions of the PPACA became operative two years ago have enrolled in the insurance exchanges rather than the expanded Medicaid program?
That’s not a very robust showing, particularly in light of the billions that have been spent.

It also would seem to throw the claim that the PPACA was creating the perception of a right to healthcare insurance and would pave the way to some better, more enlightened program into a cocked hat.

Note that I’m not making or supporting the claim, merely pointing out that they make it and looking for contradictory evidence (other than ad hominem arguments).

I do agree with the conclusion of his article: that the PPACA won’t survive. As I’ve said before I think it will be seen as a well-intentioned misstep on the path to healthcare reform and that what replaces it probably won’t resemble the pseudo-market libertarian dreams that most of the PPACA’s opponents support.

11 comments

Fear Not!

This dog’s butt is in a sling. In more ways than one. I’m surprised at how composed he is, actually. My dogs would be a lot more worried than that.

0 comments

War Game in Progress

Pat Lang has started war-gaming the Syria conflict. I don’t plan to participate myself other than via commentary here.

I think that those who’ve suggested a major troop commitment by the Russians by the end of the year are mistaken. The Russians are doing just fine with airstrikes. I think that ground troops will continue to be provided by the Syrian government and the Iranians. The Russians are almost undoubtedly receiving better ground intelligence than we are and that, coupled with the very much higher number of sorties they’re flying, means that their air campaign is significantly more effective than ours has been. They’re also not hampered by the struggle to distinguish good rebels from bad rebels.

I wouldn’t be surprised if Chinese observers showed up and by that I mean actual observers.

I also think that the continued mayhem in Syria, Afghanistan, Somalia, Yemen, and Libya will push ever more migrants into Europe. At least two European governments will have major shakeups as a result. Pressure from some German states, e.g. Saxony and Thuringia, will lead the Merkel government to refocus attention. My off-hand guess is that they’ll renew their call for other EU countries to take their fair share of the migrants. I also expect more violent incidents against Middle Eastern, North African, and West Asian migrants in Germany, Sweden, and possibly elsewhere before the end of the year.

4 comments

Will Tunisia’s Experiment Fail?

I’d like to throw a question on the floor. A year from now will Tunisia’s experiment in democracy still be under way or will it have failed and why?

I think it will have failed because, as in many if not all countries with Arab Muslim populations many of the people are Islamists and in nascent democracies the most radical few percent hold veto power.

However, I’m willing to be persuaded otherwise and would like to hear the arguments for both sides of the question.

5 comments

Harder Than They Think

I think that the editors at Bloomberg are wrong. They think it would be relatively easy to extend various public benefits to all of those eligible:

Taken together, those three small changes — repetition, simplification and disclosure of potential benefits — persuaded 31 percent more eligible tax filers to claim the earned income tax credit. If the same changes were made nationwide, they could provide tax credits for millions more needy families.

It stands to reason that smarter messaging could also increase sign-ups for other social programs — even Obamacare, which has struggled to persuade most of those who qualify for subsidized insurance to buy it.

The world is not linear. The experience in every developed country has been that bringing each additional cohort within any plan has been more difficult than the one before. At some point the return on investment is just too low.

For example, 30 to 40% of the chronically homeless are mentally ill. It doesn’t seem likely that repetition, simplification, or disclosure will be enough to reach them with the benefits for which they are eligible.

0 comments

Putting the Cart Before the Horse

It doesn’t appear to have been Einstein who first said that the sign of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results. If this Wall Street Journal editorial is to be believed, the IMF is embarking down a path that hasn’t lived up to expectations in the past, hoping that this time it will be different:

The International Monetary Fund is expected this month to include the Chinese yuan in the basket of currencies that make up its notional reserve asset, known as special drawing rights (SDRs). That move won’t immediately affect global holdings of the yuan. But by certifying that the currency meets its standards, including being “freely usable,” the IMF will give the yuan an important imprimatur. The quest for this gong is one part of Beijing’s effort since 2009 to make the yuan an international reserve currency.

Some will hype wider acceptance of the yuan as a challenge to the U.S. dollar. That may be, but a bid for greater prestige is also a renewed Chinese commitment to reform and opening. Americans should welcome it.

The key is making the yuan convertible. Much of the economic friction between China and the West is due to controls on the movement of capital in and out of the country. This made it easier for Beijing to keep the value of its currency stable, which fostered growth. But the accumulation of foreign-exchange reserves led to accusations by Western protectionists that currency manipulation underpinned the country’s trade surplus.

I’m in favor of a fully convertible yuan. But I’m also in favor of a less mercantilist and predatory China, one that lives up to the commitments it made when it was admitted to the WTO and still hasn’t lived up to, in some cases a decade after the scheduled implementation date.

A better course of action for the IMF would be to include the yuan in their “basket of currencies” when and not until the yuan is fully convertible. To do otherwise removes an incentive for the Chinese authorities to change and places the IMF at the mercy of an oligarchy that first and foremost looks out for their individual personal interests.

1 comment

The Followership Deficit

It recently came to my attention that Illinois and Pennsylvania were having mirror image experiences. Both states are operating without budgets, their legislatures and governors at odds. The Democratic governor of Pennsylvania has proposed a tax increase to balance Pennsylvania’s budget which Pennsylvania’s Republican majority legislature has refused to enact. The Democratic legislature of Illinois has enacted an unconstitutional unbalanced budget for Illinois that the state’s Republican governor has refused to sign, demanding that either the legislature make certain concessions he has proposed (a limitation of public employee collective bargaining rights and a tax freeze being the most notable) or increase taxes and enact a budget themselves (presumably over his veto). The parties are different. Only the impasse is the same.

To be sure there are some differences. Illinois has the worst credit rating of any state in the Union. Illinois has the lowest state contribution to schools of any state in the Union. Illinois has the highest rates of individual and corporate net outflow of any state in the Union.

Given the choices of lead, follow, or get the hell out of the way, the legislatures of both states have elected “None of the above”. Sounds like a distinct deficit of followership to me.

Following my policy of accepting that states other than my should be allowed to do any damned fool thing they care to, I can’t comment on Pennsylvania but here in Illinois I think that Gov. Rauner probably could do more to cultivate good relations with the state legislature and extend an olive branch to them. Realistically, I’m not sure what he could do short of total capitulation that would move things forward.

2 comments

What’s the Opposite of a Force Multiplier?

The editors of the Washington Post are skeptical of the Obama Administration’s latest efforts in Syria:

WHEN HE was asked why the Obama administration announced the dispatch of a contingent of Special Operations forces to Syria on the same day a multinational conference was discussing diplomatic solutions to the country’s civil war, Secretary of State John F. Kerry responded that it was a “coincidence.” The remark was more revealing than he intended. A flurry of U.S. actions on Syria in recent days not only failed to add up to a coherent strategy, but also did not even support one another.

Mr. Kerry was in Vienna trying to win agreement on a plan for a political transition in Syria that would include the creation of a transition government, the drafting of a constitution and U.N.-supervised free elections. That broad idea won support, but Mr. Kerry’s proposal for a timeline under which Syrian President Bashar al-Assad would be removed in four to six months and elections held in 18 months was flatly rejected by Russia and Iran, according to the Wall Street Journal. That means the cease-fire the diplomats called for is unlikely to happen, since rebels will not accept an end to the war that leaves the blood-drenched dictator in power.

as are the editors of the Wall Street Journal:

Secretary of State John Kerry’s right-hand man even used a Vietnam War-era word to describe Mr. Putin’s supposed predicament: “The quagmire will spread and deepen, drawing Russia further in.”

Somehow we doubt Mr. Putin feels so beleaguered. So far his intervention in Syria has stabilized Mr. Assad’s regime and let the Syrian go on offense principally against rebels who are fighting both him and Islamic State. Russia has done so at the relatively modest cost of some weapons transfers, bombing runs, and 2,000 or so military advisers.

Mr. Putin was also able to midwife Iran’s presence at the peace talks for the first time. Mr. Kerry acquiesced to Iran’s participation and strong-armed our Sunni Arab allies to go along. The Obama Administration’s diplomatic logic seems to be that Iran will also throw over its long-time satrap in Damascus now that it has a seat at the table and Mr. Assad is stronger. In victory, it will surrender.

Where’s Richard Holbrooke when you need him? The diplomat, who died in 2010, understood that durable settlements are possible only when the U.S. negotiates from a position of strength. He was able to negotiate peace in the Balkans in the mid-1990s after he convinced President Bill Clinton to secretly arm Croatia against marauding Serbia. Mr. Clinton also supported NATO bombing to stop Serbian predations in Bosnia.

Only after the balance of forces on the ground had evened out did the Serbs seriously negotiate a settlement. It’s a measure of this Administration’s detachment from Middle East reality that it won’t even learn from successful Democratic foreign intervention.

When the means are so dissociated from the stated means or goals, you can’t help but be tempted to believe that the objectives are something other than what the administration is saying.

Meanwhile, If you had to prioritize the following three objectives in what order would you prioritize them:

  1. Ousting Bashar al-Assad
  2. Defeating Al Qaeda
  3. Defeating DAESH

What would your preference be?

10 comments