Plus ça change, plus c’est la même chose

Every year the Wall Street Journal reprints the same editorial, now 54 years old. This snippet particularly struck me this year:

And a traveler cannot but be struck on his journey by the thought that this country, one day, can be even greater. America, though many know it not, is one of the great underdeveloped countries of the world; what it reaches for exceeds by far what it has grasped.

So the visitor returns thankful for much of what he has seen, and, in spite of everything, an optimist about what his country might be. Yet the visitor, if he is to make an honest report, must also note the air of unease that hangs everywhere.

For the traveler, as travelers have been always, is as much questioned as questioning. And for all the abundance he sees, he finds the questions put to him ask where men may repair for succor from the troubles that beset them.

His countrymen cannot forget the savage face of war. Too often they have been asked to fight in strange and distant places, for no clear purpose they could see and for no accomplishment they can measure. Their spirits are not quieted by the thought that the good and pleasant bounty that surrounds them can be destroyed in an instant by a single bomb. Yet they find no escape, for their survival and comfort now depend on unpredictable strangers in far-off corners of the globe.

How can they turn from melancholy when at home they see young arrayed against old, black against white, neighbor against neighbor, so that they stand in peril of social discord. Or not despair when they see that the cities and countryside are in need of repair, yet find themselves threatened by scarcities of the resources that sustain their way of life. Or when, in the face of these challenges, they turn for leadership to men in high places—only to find those men as frail as any others.

Other than the writing style, a bit florid for today’s tastes, it could have been written yesterday. More’s the pity.

0 comments

Captives

The editors of the Chicago Tribune remark on the video of Laquan McDonald being executed by a Chicago police officer:

We share the protesters’ anger. We understand their urge to hold public servants accountable. We expect them to make their voices heard. But it will take more than protests, more than the criminal prosecution of a single cop to repair the often fractious relationship between Chicago’s police and its people.

This isn’t about a stunning, isolated event. Zoom out, and it’s part of a broader nationwide clamor over the use of lethal force by white cops against black suspects. Zoom in, and it’s about Chicago’s long-standing failure to deal effectively with rogue police officers.

Think back to the decades of systematic torture of suspects at the hands of Cmdr. Jon Burge and his crew, as prosecutors and police supervisors looked the other way. That stain will be with us for a long, long time.

But the city also has a poor record for dealing with everyday allegations of police misconduct, from unprofessional behavior to unnecessary force.

A Tribune review of four years’ worth of complaints against police officers found that just over 4 percent were sustained, and in nearly half of those cases, the officer was given a reprimand or a “violation noted.” That’s it.

People are asking questions, among them why did it take a year for the video to be made public? The answer given is that an investigation was in progress and that’s true as far as it goes. If you know anything about Chicago, you know that it might have been because of an investigation but it wasn’t solely because of an investigation. If the video had been made public immediately, it would have become public in the middle of Rahm Emanuel’s campaign for re-election as Chicago mayor. Bad feelings between the mayor and the CPD would have threatened that.

But, wait! There’s more. Chicago is on the hook for billions in unpaid back payments into its employee pension funds. There is no ready way for the city to make those payments. Borrowing is very expensive since the city’s bonds are already rated as junk. That 5 million bucks the city paid in preemptive damages to McDonald’s family? Borrowed money. Which means that the people of Chicago will be paying interest at those exorbitant rates forever. There’s no practical other than moving out of town for the people of Chicago to get off the treadmill. There will be tax increases and service reductions as far as the eye can see.

The bottom line here is that we in Chicago are captives of the city’s public employees’ unions, among which are the Fraternal Order of Police.

The motto of the Chicago Police Department, like many of the country’s other police departments, is “To Protect and to Serve”. Who was being protected or served when Laquan McDonald was executed? I note that none of the other police officers on the scene moved to stop Van Dyke until he paused to reload. Who were they protecting? Who is being protected now? Perhaps the motto should be changed “To Protect and to Serve Ourselves”.

11 comments

Mother of Mercy…

…is this the end of NATO?

Here’s the scenario I’m thinking about right now. Imagine that the Turks shot down the Russian plan over Syrian airspace as actually seems somewhat likely given that the Russian pilots apparently ejected over Syrian territory. Even if the Russians did engage in a technical violation is certainly seems like a gross overreaction by the Turks.

Now imagine that the Russians start shooting every time they see a Turkish aircraft, not that unreasonable a course of action under the circumstances. Or start attacking Turkish artillery batteries. Turkey invokes Article 5.

Note that in my scenario Turkey is the aggressor. I don’t think the NATO charter was set up with the understanding the member countries would be the aggressors.

19 comments

Slouching Towards Armageddon


CNN is reporting that a Russian warplane has been shot down by Turkey:

One of the world’s most volatile regions was roiled further Tuesday when a Russian warplane went down near the Turkish-Syria border. Turkey said it “responded” to a plane after the aircraft repeatedly violated its airspace and ignored several warnings.

Turkey’s semi-official Anadolu news agency quoted Turkish presidential sources in reporting that the Russian Su-24 was “hit within the framework of engagement rules” in Syria’s Bayirbucak area, near the border with Turkey.

But Russia’s state-run Sputnik news agency said that, “According to preliminary reports, the plane was gunned down from the ground.”

Russian officials denied that the plane had violated Turkish airspace. Both pilots ejected from the plane, but their fate is unknown, Sputnik said.

The photo above was taken from Turkish television. The situation could hardly be more serious and what actually transpired remains unclear. It might be that it’s exactly as the Turks have reported it and a Russian warplane was shot down after entering Turkish airspace and repeated warnings to turn back. It might be that trigger-happy Turks shot down a Russian warplane in Syrian airspace they thought might enter Syrian airspace.

It might be, as some accounts have reported, that the body of a dead Russian pilot was recovered by Syrian Turkmen. Or it might have been recovered by Turkish special forces. I’ve been reading accounts of Turkish special forces masquerading as Syrian Turkmen for weeks.

1 comment

We’re #1!

What is the worst traffic bottleneck in the country? Yep, it’s the one that marks the route of my commute to work every morning and evening:

CHICAGO — A new study released Monday by the American Highway Users Alliance identifies America’s 50 worst bottlenecks and finds that the very worst bottleneck, as measured by hours of delay, is in Chicago.

The top-ranked Chicago chokepoint is located on the Kennedy Expressway (I-90) between the Circle Interchange (I-290) and Edens junction (I-94). The bottleneck was found to extend 12 miles, costing motorists 16.9 million hours’ worth of time, equivalent to $418 million in 2014. More than 6.3 million gallons of fuel is wasted on I-90 while cars idle or crawl in traffic.

By just fixing America’s worst bottleneck, an annual reduction of 133 million pounds of carbon dioxide emissions would also be likely, the study found.

In fairness to California, the next six worst traffic bottlenecks are in the Golden State.

My commute time is completely unpredictable. Some days it’s twenty minutes. Others it’s two hours. There is no rhyme or reason. Depart any time between 6:00am and 9:00am and it’s the same story—something between twenty minutes and two hours.

And I live in the city. In it. Eight miles from the Loop. I shudder to think of the commutes of people who drive in every morning from the western ‘burbs.

Actually, there’s no secret as to the source of the problem. Chicago’s traffic plan has fallen and it can’t get up. It was formulated a half century ago when the late Mayor Daley decided that everybody commuted into the city in the morning and commuted out of the city into the surrounding suburbs in the evening.

Nowadays there’s as much outbound traffic as inbound traffic at any given time. There aren’t as many people commuting by train, El, or bus as the mayor envisioned, either.

A good start at correcting the problem, at least within the Loop, would be to enforce existing law. On any given morning I see at least two dozen trucks, buses, and taxis speeding on the city streets, running red lights, parked or standing illegally, or driving the wrong way down the street.

3 comments

Out of Place, Out of Time

Under the circumstances, it seems to me that Amazon’s release of a dramatization of The Man in the High Castle, is pretty timely.

1 comment

Stranger in a Strange Land

According to an IPSOS/Reuters poll a majority of Americans feel out of place in America as it is today:

More than half (58%) of Americans don’t identify with what America has become. Almost as many (53%) feel like a “stranger in their own country”. This sense of loss is particularly pronounced when we look at party identification: while 45% of Democrats don’t identify with what America has become, a whopping 72% of Republicans don’t. Trump’s populism speaks to this real and emotional sense of economic and cultural displacement.

You’re more likely to feel that way if you’re old and white. Guilty on all counts.

I suspect that the reasons for my dissatisfaction may be different from those of many who feel that way. I’m unhappy with an America that’s always at war. I’m unhappy with an America in which the top 10% of income earners earn such large amount of the total income and possess such a large amount of the wealth. I’m unhappy with an America in which ordinary people see their lives as always being on the brink of disaster.

I’m uncomfortable in an America in which the nuclear family consisting of a man, a woman, and children is viewed as anything other than the norm. I’m uncomfortable in an America in which college students, rather than demonstrating for free speech, are demonstrating for restrictions on the speech of others.

26 comments

What Should We Do About DAESH and Why?

Since the three most prolific Outside the Beltway contributors have expressed their views on the war against DAESH over the last few days, I thought I might put my two cents in. James Joyner says that DAESH is winning because we’re overreacting:

A week after the ISIS attacks in Paris, Brussels is on high alert, essentially shutting down the city. The US embassy has advised all US citizens in Belgium to shelter in place and US government personnel are prohibited from traveling to Brussels or Paris. The US Congress has passed, on a bipartisan basis, prohibitive restrictions on taking in refugees fleeing the Syrian civil war and the EU is likely to adopt travel restrictions that would undermine the Schengen protocols that are its basis.
It’s entirely possible that these decisions are entirely prudent given intelligence to which our governments are privy and we are not. But they demonstrate, yet again, the lamentable degree to which one successful terrorist attack in a Western city can massively disrupt our lives and cause us to re-examine core principles.

and that President Obama’s course of action has been largely correct:

While I’ve been critical of Obama’s rhetorical excesses—notably his “Assad must go” stance, his “red line” over chemical weapons, and his declaration that a very limited, air-only intervention by the United States would “defeat and ultimately destroy” ISIS—I’ve quibbled with his general policy only at the margins. I’ve shared the assumptions that Kagan attributes to the president. Indeed, like Obama, I downplayed ISIS’ threat the day before the Paris attacks. Whereas he pronounced ISIS “contained,” I declared in a Twitter conversation with Jim Henley that it was “a rather marginal threat to the US,” adding that “Several flu strains have been more menacing.”
Even considering the Paris attacks an attack on the US by virtue of NATO’s Article 5, 168 deaths is hardly an existential threat.

Stephen Taylor remarks:

So while this does not mean we just sit back and take it, it does mean that reality is what is and there is no way to make the world terrorism free. More importantly: a lot of what we do in the face of terrorism (like the current freak-out over refugees, among other reactions) actually can have the effect of incentivizing more terrorism. For terrorism to truly work, there has to be a massive over-reaction.

In those posts and in their comments sections several different views on what should be done have emerged. Some think that President Obama’s course of action is the proper one because it’s his course of action. Some, like James, think the president’s course of action is the proper one if only because they’re concerned about overreacting. One notable commenter argues for a maximalist response to DAESH i.e. a “scorched earth” (literally) policy.

I’d like to propose some rules of thumb to use in identifying the proper course of action. First, we should act in a way consistent with our interests. Not Germany’s, France’s, Israel’s, Iraq’s, or Saudi Arabia’s but our own. If Germany’s interests and U. S. interests are identical, one or the other of the two countries is going about pursuing them in the wrong way. Second, we should not divide the world into friends and enemies so that opposing the actions of those in the enemies list is automatically reckoned to be in our interests regardless of the other merits. Consequently, even if Russia, Syria, and Iran are not our friends, reflexively opposing their actions is not necessarily in our interests.

Third, we should suit means to ends. If the strategic objective is to destroy DAESH, we must employ means capable of doing it. If it is not the strategic objective, we should not say that it is simply because we don’t care to employ the means that would be required. Which takes us to my fourth and last rule of thumb.

We are in desperate need of the president’s enlisting the support of the American people in whatever we do with respect to Syria. If we’re going to destroy DAESH, he needs to get the people behind that goal.

Those considerations drive me to the conclusion that we should be doing nothing in Syria. We shouldn’t supply the radical Islamists who oppose the Syrian government. We shouldn’t be conducting sorties without suitable targets.

Pat Lang thinks that we will inevitably be drawn into unavoidable war with DAESH:

Four of the Paris attack group had entered Europe in the last few months, two on Syrian passports as part of the migration and two on Turkish passports simply traveling within the Schengen area without much trouble. You never know what you don’t know and we don’t know how many others IS has sent toward targets in Europe and North America, especially before the Paris attacks.

PM Trudeau and his political colleagues are going to admit at least 25,000 “Syrian” migrants to Canada in the next few months. There is no possibility that the Canadian authorities will be able to adequately screen that number of people for identity or prior associations. It will anger Canadians here for me to say so but the US/Canada border is a joke. You can walk across it in thousands of places outside the ken of authorities on either side.

The pattern is clear, IS sends in fighters to reinforce local adherents.

IS has announced its intention to attack New York City and Washington, DC.

We should take this statement of intention very seriously.

It might surprise some but if we’re going to fight a war, I agree with the “notable commenter” mentioned above. Our strength is strength. Why fight the enemy’s war?

But I’m also drawn to my inevitable question. So, you’ve removed DAESH. What then?

37 comments

What Will Happen?

Given the coordinated terrorist attacks in Paris last week, the attempted stadium bombing in Germany, and the most recent goings-on, the “threat of imminent attack” in Belgium, what do you think is going to happen in Europe?

  1. Nothing. The Europeans will put up with the tension, addition expense, and occasional murders by terrorists indefinitely.
  2. The Europeans will eventually get tired of the above and take action on the ground in the Middle East.
  3. The Europeans will eventually get tired of the above and start expelling Muslims, largely on an ethnic basis.
  4. The Europeans will eventually get tired of the above and start expelling Muslims including Muslim citizens, largely on an ethnic basis.
  5. They won’t have to do anything. It will all eventually settle down and everything will go back to the way it was before.
2 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments