Terms of Surrender

I think the reality of the truce that has been negotiated in Syria is being widely misreported in the Western media. Here’s the story, as reported by the BBC:

The US and Russia have announced that a planned cessation of hostilities in Syria will come into effect at midnight on 27 February.

Their statement said the truce did not include so-called Islamic State (IS) and the al-Qaeda-linked Nusra Front.

World powers agreed on 12 February that a truce would come into effect within a week, but that deadline passed and scepticism remains over the new plan.

[…]

Separately, Syria’s government has called a parliamentary election for 13 April. The last was in 2012 and they are held every four years.

The White House said that President Barack Obama had phoned his Russian counterpart Vladimir Putin at Mr Putin’s request to discuss the efforts to establish the cessation of hostilities.

After their phone call, the joint Russian-US statement was released.

The truce applied to “those parties to the Syrian conflict that have indicated their commitment to and acceptance of its terms”, the statement said.

This excluded IS, Nusra and “other terrorist organisations designated by the UN”.

Air strikes by Syria, Russia and the US-led coalition against these groups would continue, the statement read.

It said that armed opposition groups taking part would have to confirm their participation by midday on 26 February.

Russian and Syrian planes would halt any attacks on the armed opposition groups.

My interpretation of this is that the terms of surrender of the “moderate opposition” in Syria have been negotiated. DAESH and the Al Nusra Front, the two largest and most powerful opposition groups, are explicitly excluded from the deal. Russian bombing of these groups will continue.

If the other opposition groups join the truce, it will enable Russia and the Syrian government to focus on the greater threats which should be welcome to everybody except, possibly, Turkey and the Gulf States who’ve been supporting DAESH all along. Whether the U. S.-supported Kurds will join the ceasefire is an open question but I would assume that they’re a major source of concern for the Turks.

You should take a look at the map depicting where airstrikes have been taking place. IMO it reveals the Russo-Syrian government strategy pretty clearly. Consolidate the populated areas of the country under government control. Cut off the Al Nusra Front and DAESH from Turkish supply lines. Create chokepoints. Encircle the chokepoints with ground troops to reduce the enemy.

2 comments

What’s the Point?

Some readers have been wondering what the point of my last post was. The point is simple: growth must come from somewhere. The components of economic growth are personal consumption, business investment, government spending, imports, and exports.

If you want government spending to level off or even decrease, fair enough. If you still want more growth, something else has to increase to produce that increased growth.

Personal consumption isn’t a likely candidate. Personal consumption expenditures are already over-extended and our economy is already more dependent on PCE than other major economies.

I also think we’ve got to honest with ourselves. Exports aren’t likely to make up the difference. Germany, China, and Japan are already trying to do that. China has an enormous amount of over-capacity.

That leaves two candidates. We can import less or businesses can spend more. Whichever you pick, the policies you like should promote those objectives.

Don’t just tell me what you don’t like. Tell me what policies will accomplish your objectives.

17 comments

Why We Have Slow Growth (and Not Enough Employment)

I wanted to comment on the graph above, sampled from this post at the blog of the Financial Times. The graph illustrates the trend in spending by state and local governments and a projection of their future spending based on trend. I’ll put my observations into the form of question and answer.

Why has spending by state and local governments slowed?

Unlike the federal government state and local governments need to balance their budgets. When revenues flatten or fall, so will spending. State and local governments derive their revenues from taxes and by and large tax revenues depend on three things: personal incomes, retail spending, and real estate values. If those things rise, so do state and local government revenues. If they don’t, they don’t.

When their revenues flatten or fall, so does their spending.

Isn’t that a good thing?

How you answer the ideological question implicit in that is up to you. It could be a good thing if the shortfall in spending were made up from somewhere else. What I care about is the reduced economic activity that has caused the decline in state and local government revenues and the future decline in economic activity that will result unless the difference is made up somewhere.

What if the difference isn’t made up?

If the difference isn’t made up, there will be less economic growth than there would be otherwise. Lower incomes, less retail spending, fewer jobs.

If the spending needed to produce economic growth doesn’t come from state and local governments, it must come from the federal government, from personal consumption, or from business investment. There isn’t anywhere else for it to come from.

There is little or no actual evidence that the painfully slow recovery in employment that followed the 2007-2008 Great Recession has been due to technological unemployment. If you think it has, fine. Produce your evidence. In the absence of actual, hard evidence of technological unemployment, your impressions or that it stands to reason aren’t enough. You’ve got to have actual evidence to convince me. Because there is actual evidence of other things producing unemployment. Among those things are our perversely importing workers from other countries and drastic distortions in our economy.

What kind of distortions?

I’ll just mention three: financialization of the economy, overinvestment in health care production, and overinvestment in education production.

What’s wrong with spending on the health care and education sectors?

Nothing. If those sectors were actually increasing production. We now spend more than twice as much in real terms per capita on health care than we did 35 years ago and three times as much in real terms per capita on education than we did 25 years ago with extremely meager evidence of actual increases in production in either sector.

When you pour money into things without increasing production, it results in deadweight loss.

IMO what’s actually happening is an enormous increase in deadweight loss resulting in lower economic growth than would be the case otherwise. And increases in income inequality.

What’s wrong with financialization of the economy?

Once upon a time when people invested, it meant that they built factories, started businesses, prospected for gold or did something that employed more people. Now it means that they invest in financial instruments which doesn’t result in much of an increase in employment.

It also results in an enormous concentration of wealth, particularly in the financial sector.

I’ve cited the statistics often enough in the past. There is an optimum size for a financial sector relative to the rest of an economy. We passed that optimum decades ago.

How did that happen?

Two ways. First, we’ve been buying stuff at a discount from China and they’ve been taking the dollars they receive in trade and investing them in financial instruments. That has increased the size of the financial sector all by itself. But that’s not all.

We’ve been subsidizing all three of those distorting sectors enormously. Over just the last nine years we’ve subsidized the financial sector to the tune of trillions of dollars. The subsidies to the health care and education sector are in the vicinity of a trillion dollars a year each. Note that I’m using the economic definition of “subsidy” here rather than some politicized definition. It means spending that would not otherwise have taken place.

What do we do about it?

It’s like that old burlesque comedy routine.

Patient: Doctor, it hurts when I do this (throwing himself into some sort of contortion).

Doctor: STOP DOING THAT!

12 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Men at Work

I found the graph above, gleaned from this post at Bloomberg, fairly eye-popping. It illustrates the employment rate for men aged 16 to 64 in Canada, Germany, Japan, the UK, and the United States. Because of its construction (just men 16 to 64) it excludes the demographic explanation for our low labor force participation rate. And it also calls into question one of the routine excuses brought forward—that everybody’s in school. A higher proportion of the Canadian population has college educations than here so it’s at least a reasonable inference that more Canadians are in school but somehow they manage to maintain a higher LFPR than we do. Here’s the author’s explanation:

Despite job gains over the past few years, then, the labor market in the U.S. seems to be malfunctioning in a way that labor markets in other rich countries aren’t.

Why is that? Maybe the U.S. system of unemployment insurance and job retraining and placement is busted. Maybe the perverse incentives built into the Social Security Disability Insurance program are keeping people who could work out of the labor force. Maybe the U.S. educational system is doing an especially poor job of preparing people for work. Maybe increasing geographic divergence in employment in the U.S. is leaving job seekers stranded far from jobs. Maybe poor child-care options are keeping American women at home. Maybe U.S. corporations, under pressure from capital markets, are spending so much money on share buybacks that they’re underinvesting in labor. Maybe the U.S. is on the cutting edge of technological job displacement, with the robots taking over here first.

Why not the obvious explanation? That the job increase statistics are mostly phony baloney and a lot of the new jobs are going to workers imported from somewhere else because the employers have those workers over a barrel. They don’t dare complain or ask for raises because their continued presence in the country is contingent on the continuing good will of their employers.

Whatever the explanation there is clearly something wrong here that is not wrong in other major economies. We need to change something other than making college cheaper.

33 comments

The Urge to Power

Over at City Journal Oren Cass does a masterful job of describing how our present federal government operates. It’s longish for a blog post but well worth reading. He then goes on to propose a reform that he calls “Flex Fund” which boils down to the federal government retaining the taxing power and redistributing the funds for social programs back to the states unencumbered by the myriad of mandates, requirements, etc. that exist under our present system.

Whatever sense such a system would make, it will never happen for one reason: the urge to power.

4 comments

Comparing Imaginary Systems With Real Ones

This post at RealClearPolicy on the problems inherent in a single-payer system stuck in my craw a bit. Here’s the meat of their argument:

Market prices inform producers about the value of their services, enabling them to best serve consumers. If lots of consumers want laser eye surgery, high demand will lead to higher prices, which encourages other entrepreneurs to enter the market. If consumers don’t care for colonoscopies, the lower demand drives prices down and encourages entrepreneurs to stop focusing on that service.

This feedback mechanism is absent when government sets prices. The result is misallocation and chaos, as we see in Medicare.

Medicare tries to centrally plan around 6 billion prices every year. The resulting prices are often arbitrary. Cataract removals, for example, are reimbursed at eight times the rate of a visit to a primary-care physician. This is despite the fact that cataract removal is a 50-year-old assembly-line procedure that can be done in 10-15 minutes. In contrast, primary-care physicians are required to draw on a wide range of medical experience in order to diagnose a range of problems.

This pricing structure distorts the health-care market. One result is a shortage of primary-care physicians that experts predict will only get worse.

Let’s get down to brass tacks. Imagine a system in which once a year or, maybe, once every couple of years the AMA tells the federal government’s experts the relative value of all of the procedures that docs perform. Then imagine that the experts take those values, add their own secret sauce, and decide on reimbursement rates. Finally, imagine that the system I’ve just described accounts for more than half of all healthcare spending.

Actually, you don’t need to imagine such a system. It’s a real one: it’s the Medicare system.

Armed with that information, imagine a different system that isn’t the Medicare system, in which the market decides the prices for medical services, and that provides a reasonable level of healthcare for senior citizens and other people on fixed incomes. Such a system will be purely imaginary because no such system has ever existed, at least not in the United States. We used to have a largely free market system but that didn’t provide a reasonable level of healthcare for seniors.

Under that system prices were never really determined by a free market because the supply of healthcare services was capped. Any system in which the supply is capped while the demand is allowed to rise will eventually price some people, maybe a lot of people, out of the market. That’s inherent.

But all of the foregoing also highlights why I’m more or less in despair over our healthcare system. We aren’t even speaking the same language. Anarcho-capitalists keep imagining fantasy systems while social democrats imagine perfectly functioning governments.

Instead, I think we should start with real systems: Medicare, Medicaid, the system of VA hospitals, for example. We know how they work. We know their shortcomings. We know that neither Medicare nor Medicaid has been able to control costs. Start from there.

4 comments

The Military Solution in Syria (Updated)

Der Spiegel is in despair over what appears to be an impending victory for the Assad regime over its opponents in the civil war in Syria:

Aleppo has been a horrific place for some time now and few thought that it could get much worse. But things can always get worse — that’s the lesson currently being learned by those who have stayed behind in an effort to outlast this brutal conflict. People who have become used to dead bodies in the streets, hunger and living a life that can end at any moment.

“For the last two weeks, we’ve been living a nightmare that is worse than everything that has come before,” says Hamza, a young doctor in an Aleppo hospital. At the beginning, in 2011, he was treating light wounds, stemming from tear gas or beatings from police batons. When the regime began dropping barrel bombs in 2012, the injuries got worse. But now, with the beginning of the Russian airstrikes, the doctors are facing an emergency. Every two or three hours, warplanes attack the city, aiming at everything that hasn’t yet been destroyed, including apartment buildings, schools and clinics. Often, they use cluster bombs, which have been banned internationally.

Somehow the article manages to ignore the many firsthand reports of life going on peacefully and as usual in Aleppo outside the areas held by the opposition and the multiple reports of large numbers of foreign fighters in the opposition, many from the Gulf states but also from Chechnya and even Uyghurs from China. It’s pretty darned hard to characterize an invading army as a popular revolt.

Also ignored is that Russia is operating within international law while Western support and training for the opposition is going on without Security Council approval or, indeed, any kind of approval other than the policies of the countries involved. It’s getting harder and harder to tell the good guys from the bad guys.

Update

Stephen Kinzer at the Boston Globe provides a little supporting testimony:

COVERAGE OF the Syrian war will be remembered as one of the most shameful episodes in the history of the American press. Reporting about carnage in the ancient city of Aleppo is the latest reason why.

For three years, violent militants have run Aleppo. Their rule began with a wave of repression. They posted notices warning residents: “Don’t send your children to school. If you do, we will get the backpack and you will get the coffin.” Then they destroyed factories, hoping that unemployed workers would have no recourse other than to become fighters. They trucked looted machinery to Turkey and sold it.

This month, people in Aleppo have finally seen glimmers of hope. The Syrian army and its allies have been pushing militants out of the city. Last week they reclaimed the main power plant. Regular electricity may soon be restored. The militants’ hold on the city could be ending.

We’ve been supporting Al Qaeda. Our allies in the field have been largely financed and supported by foreigners with relatively little domestic support. And Der Spiegel is calling what’s happening now a tragedy? The tragedy has been running rampant in Aleppo for three years.

6 comments

Something There Is That Doesn’t Love a Wall

or, in this case, someone. Presumably, by now you’ve heard of the exchange of words between Pope Francis and American presidential aspirant Donald Trump, reported here at CNN:

(CNN)Thrusting himself into the combative 2016 presidential campaign, Pope Francis said Thursday that GOP front-runner Donald Trump “is not Christian” if he calls for the deportation of undocumented immigrants and pledges to build a wall between the United States and Mexico.

The Pope, who was traveling back to Rome from Mexico, where he urged the United States to address the “humanitarian crisis” on its southern border, did not tell American Catholics not to vote for Trump.

Here’s what Francis actually said:

A person who thinks only about building walls, wherever they may be, and not of building bridges, is not Christian. This is not the gospel. As far as what you said about whether I would advise to vote or not to vote, I am not going to get involved in that. I say only that this is man is not Christian if he has said things like that. We must see if he said things in that way and I will give him the benefit of the doubt.

Daring to rush in where angels fear to tread, I think that on the plane of faith and morals Francis is right. As Christians we have an affirmative responsibility to reach out to the truly needy. However, and as rarely mentioned by pontiffs, civil authorities also have a moral responsibility to see that the laws are executed, to ensure that people who would do harm to people or property are prevented from entering the country, and to preserve order.

It may be that Francis and I disagree on one particular point. I don’t think our responsibility to the truly needy should be construed as a blanket guarantee for anybody who wants to to work in the United States.

I’d also be interested in Francis’s views on some questions. For example, if I have two dollars, do I have a moral obligation to give one of them to someone who only has one dollar? Also, do migrants have moral obligations, too? I think the answers to those questions are “No” and “Yes”, respectively.

As to the other half of the conversation, I don’t care whether Donald Trump is a Christian or not and I don’t care what Francis says about Donald Trump (or vice versa).

I also think that Francis is taking it a little easy on wealthy Mexicans. Income inequality there is worse than it is here (second worst in the OECD, according to this backgrounder). And what about the “humanitarian crisis” on Mexico’s southern border? And they’re supposed to be Catholics. Selective criticism makes it sound as though he has the typical European intellectual’s disdain for America and all things American.

30 comments

Himshikar

Shortly after Himshikar, a Nepali-Indian restaurant in my neighborhood, opened, I went there and was unimpressed. Recently, I checked its Yelp listings, decided that if they were any gauge they had cleaned up their act, and resolved to give them another try.

Last night I got carry-out from Himshikar. I got an order of samosas, some chicken momo, the tandoori mixed grill, and a pilaf and I was glad I did. It wasn’t the best Indian food or even the best Nepalese food I’ve ever had but it was pretty good and the price was right. The mixed grill included chicken, chunks of chicken breast, kabab, shrimp, and lamb. We could easily have fed three and possibly even four people.

For people living on the Northwest Side who don’t want to go all the way to Devon Avenue, Himshikar is a good bet. It’s a storefront—not fine dining but for carry-out or delivery it’s fine. And (at least for me) the five minute walk can’t be beat.

2 comments