The Judge

Last night on the plane back from California I watched the 2014 movie, The Judge. It might be the movie with the best ensemble cast that I’ve seen in 30 years. Maybe ever. The cast includes some of the screen’s most consistently interesting actors of today: Robert Downey, Jr., Robert Duvall, Vincent D’Onofrio, Billy Bob Thornton, Vera Farmiga. Even the smaller character parts are played by actors of astonishingly high caliber: Ken Howard, Denis O’Hare, David Krumholtz. What a privilege for young performers like Dax Shephard or Leighton Meester to work with such performers!

Indeed, it might be the best picture I’ve seen in 30 years. Highly recommended.

0 comments

How the Federal Government Infantilizes the States

I found this post by Jason Sorens at RealClearPolicy quietly reassuring, footnoting as it does the intuitions I’ve frequently expressed here about the effect of federal money on the states:

Americans have long debated the proper role of the central government, and for good reason: Today, state and local governments receive between a fifth and a third of all their revenue from the federal government. As I argue in a new paper, the evidence suggests that intergovernmental transfers like these can adversely affect the total level of government spending, government debt, the tax burden, government efficiency, public knowledge about government, and economic growth.

[…]

Yet the bigger problem with grants may be that they empower state governments and loosen their accountability to their own voters. Windfalls of federal money arrive even if state residents don’t think the programs funded this way are a good investment, and such grants are an attractive target for voracious interest groups. By contrast, when states have to get revenue from their own taxpayers, they have to pay attention when workers and businesses leave because of shoddy public services or excessive tax burdens. Fiscal competition makes governments more efficient.

The long term effect of federal grants is to increase state and local tax burdens:

Economists Russell Sobel and George Crowley find that federal transfers “ratchet up” state tax burdens in the long run, because states decide to keep funding programs even after federal grants decline. If they’re right, states that expanded Medicaid will eventually face higher tax burdens when federal funding declines.

The grants are not spent effectively enough:

University of Pennsylvania economist Robert Inman (working from numbers developed by Brown University’s Brian Knight) estimated that 40 cents out of every dollar spent in federal highway grants is deadweight loss, or waste.

There may be a causal effect between the nationalization of programs and a detached, poorly informed electorate:

A study of Spain looked at regions that had taken different approaches to decentralization; in areas where governments had to fund their own programs from their own revenues, voters became more informed about the division of program responsibilities between governments.”

The country most like us, Canada, has been moving in the opposite direction:

Our neighbor to the north, Canada, provides an example of partially successful reform. There, the federal government has allowed provinces to reclaim “tax points” by reducing federal income taxes — in other words, federal taxes decrease by a certain percentage, and provincial taxes increase by an equivalent amount — so that provinces may fund health and social programs as they desire.

You don’t need to hate government to think that centralizing decision-making and power is a bad idea.

6 comments

Remembering

For the last few days I’ve been out in California attending the memorial service for my mother-in-law. Some of those in attendance I hadn’t seen in 30 years.

The occasion was one of mixed feelings. On the one hand we missed her but on the other she was 93 years old and has been suffering from dementia for a number of years. The woman we had known has not been really present for some time. As her son put it, she’s been released.

I don’t know how to adequately describe her to you. She had children who treasured her. Even during the many years in which she was in a skilled nursing facility she was visited on a daily or near-daily basis. She had a husband who was mad about her. They had eloped at 18 and were like newlyweds right until the time of his death twenty years ago.

She maintained an immaculate home while working outside the home.

She came from a family of craftsmen and was always working on something. To paraphrase my wife’s eulogy of her, she could see the potential in a piece of dirt or scrap of cloth or block of wood. Or in a person.

From each she would coax the best to create something beautiful. A beautiful garden. A dress. A carving. A better person.

She is missed.

4 comments

The Desert Shall Rejoice

Via Mashable Death Valley is experiencing a rare “superbloom” this year:

Thanks to record-breaking rainfall last October, Death Valley — which is one of the driest and hottest places on Earth — currently looks like sea of yellow.

The national park, which occupies parts of California and Nevada, has more than 20 different types of wildflowers blooming there now, in what people have taken to calling a “superbloom.”

Read the whole thing. Lots of beautiful pictures

The wilderness and the solitary place shall be glad for them; and the desert shall rejoice, and blossom as the rose.

Isaiah 35:1

1 comment

Can Illinois Block CPS Bond Sales?

Here’s an interesting new wrinkle in the ongoing and depressing argument between the Chicago Public Schools and the State of Illinois. The Sun-Times is reporting that Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner has said that the state could block CPS’s bond sales:

Gov. Bruce Rauner said Monday the Illinois State Board of Education has the ability to block Chicago Public Schools from entering into bad bond deals.

And less than an hour later, CPS CEO Forrest Claypool had a simple response: No, they don’t.

Rauner made the statement just three weeks after CPS borrowed $725 million by selling bonds carrying an extraordinarily high interest rate of 8.25 percent — and days after his handpicked education leaders announced they’re investigating the finances of the state’s largest district.

I don’t know the details of the statute in question but I do know that as a general matter the city of Chicago, the Chicago Public Schools, and all other government entities subordinate to the State of Illinois have no power other than that which the state gives them. They are creatures of the state and operate entirely at its pleasure.

If the statute cited by Mr. Claypool does what he says it does:

Speaking at Curie Metropolitan High School on the Southwest Side, Claypool denied that state authority to block CPS borrowing exists.

“The governor has come up with a number of novel legal theories, but I would just refer him back to the statute,” Claypool told reporters. “The statute is very clear that the authority he seeks to exercise does not apply to the Chicago Public Schools.

rather than what the governor said it does:

The latest tussle between the governor and Chicago’s schools system centers on a phrase in the school code both leaders are leaning on: whether or not CPS is “subject to” a section of school code establishing a School Finance Authority for districts in cities with more than 500,000 inhabitants.

Naturally, Claypool believes the district is still ruled by that article, which would allow the state board merely to notify Chicago’s mayor of any financial difficulty an investigation turns up.

But Rauner contends that as of 2010, it isn’t anymore.

“That applied only when the reform board existed, which it no longer does,” Rauner spokeswoman Catherine Kelly said.

blocking the CPS’s bond deals would require an act of the Illinois legislature. The legislature hasn’t shown any particular fondness lately either for the governor of the CPS so I have no idea whether they would do that. But they could so in that sense at least the governor is right.

4 comments

A Long Telegram to Saudi Arabia?

At the Washington Post Dan Drezner commemorates the 70th anniversary of George Kennan’s “Long Telegram” by calling for a similar missive with respect to the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia:

No, if there’s a place I want to see a Long Telegram from, it’s Saudi Arabia. Last week in the Atlantic, Sarah Chayes and (my Fletcher School colleague) Alex DeWaal offered up quite the warning about the protector of Mecca and Medina…

As you may recall George Kennan’s “Long Telegram” set the agenda for our Cold War policy with the Soviet Union. IMO there’s more than one country for which we could use a change in strategy and, despite all of the mau-mauing in the op-ed pages of the NYT, WP, and WSJ, Russia and China are far down on the list. The KSA is a good pick. How about Israel?

16 comments

Is It Time for a Universal Basic Income?

Over at RealClearMarkets Richard Reeves argues for a universal basic income:

The labor market continues to work pretty well as an economic institution, matching labor to capital, for production. But it is no longer working so well as a social institution for distribution. Structural changes in the economy, in particular skills-based technological change, mean that the wages of less-productive workers are dropping. At the same time, the share of national income going to labor rather than capital is dropping.

This decoupling of the economic and social functions of the labor market poses a stark policy challenge. Well-intentioned attempts to improve the social performance of the labor market – through higher minimum wages, profit-sharing schemes, training and education – may not be enough; a series of sticking leaky band-aids over a growing gaping wound.

pointing to a project in the UK.

IMO the policy problem with a universal basic income resembles that of reparations: who pays the income to whom and why? If the money needed were to be raised by increasing taxes, the policy might result in a small increase in growth and a decrease in poverty. It’s equally likely to create a positive feedback loop in which the guaranteed basic income chases goods and services that rise in price to meet it, increasing the concentration of wealth and having little effect on poverty.

If the program is paid for simply by extending credit to ourselves it might have greater growth effects but it’s also risky. It will work fine as long as confidence in the dollar is maintained but once confidence is lost it could prove disastrous. Feel lucky, punk?

I’m also skeptical that any plan, however effective on an island with relatively high degree of social cohesion, can be effective in a country that shares a 2,000 mile land border with a country where the per capita income is 10% what it is here and notoriously low social cohesion. As has been the case with most social programs in the United States (Medicare, SSDI, AFDC) costs will outstrip projections by orders of magnitude, the number of people claiming the benefit will be truly astounding, and the funds expended due to welfare fraud will be alarming.

There are other policies I’d much rather see tried before a universal basic income, e.g. taking a devaluation-export strategy, workplace enforcement of immigration laws, abolishing the payroll tax, or a system of wage subsidies.

15 comments

Another Recession Indicator Heard From

Per Wall Street 24/7 TrimTabs is reporting that withholding income declined last month:

TrimTabs is generally known for releasing data about employment payrolls each month. Now the research firm has a warning that U.S. Treasury tax receipts show the U.S. economy is stalling. TrimTabs’ real-time tax data indicates that the income tax withholdings was down by 0.2% year over year in real terms over the four weeks ended Thursday, February 18. This decline compares with growth of 2.0% year over year in December and 3.0% year-over-year in January.

What may really hurt is that TrimTabs noted that the year-over-year comparisons of these tax collection flows indicate that the U.S. economy has been decelerating since last fall. It further said that the flows turned flat-to-down in the past four weeks and could be headed for a recession if this trend continues.

It seems to me that if you’re reporting increasing incomes while withholding decreases, as the Bureau of Labor Statistics has been doing lately, you’re actually saying that income inequality is is becoming greater and, possibly, nothing whatever about wage income. I’m not sure how you reconcile the ideas of a continuing recovery with decreasing withholding.

2 comments

Are Primaries Predictors for General Elections?

As I read Michael Barone’s analysis of the primary elections and caucuses so far in RealClearPolitics, one question occurred to me. How reliable a predictor for general elections are primaries and caucuses, anyway? Here’s the relevant snippet from the post:

The upshot is the same: another long, hard slog to the nomination, but with a Clinton victory. And this time mirthless: Democratic turnout was down from 2008 in Iowa and New Hampshire, and Nevada super-analyst Jon Ralston says it sagged from 120,000 to 80,000 there. All this is assuming the FBI doesn’t weigh in.

Republican turnout was up 22 percent from 2012 in South Carolina; likewise, it was up in Iowa (54 percent) and New Hampshire (14 percent). Donald Trump has established that there is a high floor on his support — one-quarter in Iowa and one-third in New Hampshire and South Carolina. That’s enough to give him victories in many-candidate contests.

We don’t elect presidents at large. We elect them state by state. President Obama carried Florida and Ohio by less than 1% of the votes in those states and 2% of the vote in Colorado, Iowa, New Hampshire, and Virginia. Those states account for 79 electoral votes, easily more than the margin of victory.

A sharp decline in Democratic turnout and a sharp increase in Republican turnout is enough to swing the election in those states. It wouldn’t change the outcome in California or New York but it doesn’t need to.

That’s why I’ve been saying all along that the 2016 election will hinge on turnout.

10 comments

What’s Wrong With This Picture?

or “How to Lie With Statistics”.

I was looking for something else when I stumbled across this pie chart at a post on the website of the Kaiser Family Foundation:

Why is this graph a lie or, if not a lie, at least grossly misleading?

10 comments