Over at RealClearMarkets Richard Reeves argues for a universal basic income:
The labor market continues to work pretty well as an economic institution, matching labor to capital, for production. But it is no longer working so well as a social institution for distribution. Structural changes in the economy, in particular skills-based technological change, mean that the wages of less-productive workers are dropping. At the same time, the share of national income going to labor rather than capital is dropping.
This decoupling of the economic and social functions of the labor market poses a stark policy challenge. Well-intentioned attempts to improve the social performance of the labor market – through higher minimum wages, profit-sharing schemes, training and education – may not be enough; a series of sticking leaky band-aids over a growing gaping wound.
pointing to a project in the UK.
IMO the policy problem with a universal basic income resembles that of reparations: who pays the income to whom and why? If the money needed were to be raised by increasing taxes, the policy might result in a small increase in growth and a decrease in poverty. It’s equally likely to create a positive feedback loop in which the guaranteed basic income chases goods and services that rise in price to meet it, increasing the concentration of wealth and having little effect on poverty.
If the program is paid for simply by extending credit to ourselves it might have greater growth effects but it’s also risky. It will work fine as long as confidence in the dollar is maintained but once confidence is lost it could prove disastrous. Feel lucky, punk?
I’m also skeptical that any plan, however effective on an island with relatively high degree of social cohesion, can be effective in a country that shares a 2,000 mile land border with a country where the per capita income is 10% what it is here and notoriously low social cohesion. As has been the case with most social programs in the United States (Medicare, SSDI, AFDC) costs will outstrip projections by orders of magnitude, the number of people claiming the benefit will be truly astounding, and the funds expended due to welfare fraud will be alarming.
There are other policies I’d much rather see tried before a universal basic income, e.g. taking a devaluation-export strategy, workplace enforcement of immigration laws, abolishing the payroll tax, or a system of wage subsidies.