The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Should We Tax Remittances?

“Remittance” is the term used to describe money sent from a country in which a guest worker or resident alien is working to his or her home country. More than $100 billion, that’s billion with a “b”, is sent from the United States to other countries annually with India, China, Philippines, and Mexico being the biggest destinations for funds.

Should we tax remittances?

8 comments

The Odds Against

After my post on the econometric prediction that the odds are against the Democratic candidate prevailing in November, I thought you might be interested in another prediction, this time from a political scientist who studies election behavior. From The Daily Caller:

A political science professor who claims his statistical model has correctly predicted the results of every election except for one in the last 104 years has forecast that the odds of Donald Trump becoming America’s next president currently range from 97 percent to 99 percent.

The professor is Helmut Norpoth of Stony Brook University, reports The Statesman, the campus newspaper at the public bastion on New York’s Long Island.

Specifically, Norpoth predicts that Trump has a 97 percent chance of beating Hillary Clinton and a 99 percent chance of beating Bernie Sanders.

His model has successfully called the winner in every election since 1912 with the exception of the 1960 election. Here’s the point that’s too many are ignoring:

Norpoth’s general election formula measures candidates’ performances in primaries and caucuses to gauge party unity and voter excitement. It also focuses on certain patterns in electoral cycles. One major assumption is that the party which has just held the presidency for two consecutive terms is less likely to win a third term.

The emphasis is mine.

Don’t construe this or the previous post as my rooting for the Republicans. Far from it. What I think is that:

  • the dynamics of American presidential elections favors a change of parties
  • the present approval rate of the incumbent favors a change of parties
  • Hillary Clinton is a weak candidate

That the Democratic Party can’t drum up any candidates who are less than 65 years old is a scandal and an outrage.

8 comments

The Fair Model Looks at 2016

Amidst all of the hooplah, incomprehensible media coverage, and exaggerated reactions to the present absurdity by which American voters choose from among the unpalatable candidates seeking the presidency, there is something that I think is being lost and that is that the American political history and experience suggests that the fundamentals favor the Republicans, regardless of which candidate each party eventually nominates. In this post I’ll submit a little evidence for that.

For the last 20 years Yale economist Ray Fair has been using an econometric model to predict the popular vote results for the presidential and Congressional elections and over the years the accuracy of his model has continued to improve. If you think it’s relevant, Dr. Fair is a progressive Democrat.

The table below illustrates his model’s predictions for the last three presidential elections along with the actual popular vote results. Red denotes results for a Republican, blue for a Democrat.

Year Prediction Actual
2004 57.7 50.7
2008 51.9 52.9
2012 49.0 51.1
2016 45.7  

There are a number of different possible reactions to this:

  1. Dr. Fair’s model is correct and the economic fundamentals favor the Republicans this cycle.
  2. Dr. Fair’s model is wrong. His 2008 and 2012 predictions were a coincidence.
  3. Never tell me the odds!
  4. This time is different.

I think that Dr. Fair’s model is correct, at least in terms of the directionality of his results and that it ignores the Democrats’ ground game which, for example, gave John Kerry better results than he predicted in 2004. I also think that this time is different. I think that both the ordinary members of both parties are rebelling against their respective party’s nomenklatura.

You can tinker with Dr. Fair’s model at the link above. Basically, it predicts that we’ll need third quarter growth that is, frankly, unimaginably high for the Democratic candidate not to be swimming against the tide.

36 comments

Reforming the Corporate Income Tax

There’s an interesting post at RealClearPolicy on reforming the corporate income tax. The claim in the post is that there’s a consensus among Congressional Republicans and Democrats about the direction of the reforms that are necessary but I have my doubts. I think there are a lot of Senate Democrats who believe that the corporate income tax needs to be a lot higher and, especially, don’t want to run for re-election after having lowered the corporate income tax.

I’m not as concerned about the complication of reforming the taxes on S-corps and partnerships as the author despite their representing such a large proportion of total corporate income (55%). Many of those S-corps and partnerships are financial concerns and professional firms and the amount of income they represent is an artifact of the tax system we want to reform. You can’t reform an entire economy just by changing the corporate tax code.

I’d be happy if we just brought our tax system more in line with that of other OECD countries. That will require giving ground not just on rates but on the territorial issue and, frankly, it’s hard for me to see the present Senate Democrats doing that.

1 comment

Move to Lovely Cape Breton!

Via ABC Chicago there’s an alternative for Americans who can’t face the prospect of Donald Trump being elected president: move to lovely Cape Breton in Canada:

A Canadian website is encouraging Americans to move to the island of Cape Breton if Donald Trump is elected President of the United States.

The island is located on the east coast of Canada and is “about the same size as the Hawaiian Big Island.”

“But the truth is, we welcome all, no matter who you support, be it Democrat, Republican or Donald Trump,” the website says.

The website lists information on diversity, weather, beaches and claims to have the most affordable housing market in North America.

“In Cape Breton, the average house price is about double the average annual household income. In Vancouver, it is 8 times as much. In Hong Kong, it is 17 times as much!” it says.

It started as a gag site but the poor guy was overwhelmed by responses.

1 comment

What’s In a Name?

The graph above illustrates a poll taken by the Kaiser Family Foundation of the opinions of Democrats on the effect of different labels applied to the same healthcare reform proposal which I sampled from this post at the Wall Street Journal.

As you can see Bernie Sanders is doing a pretty darned good job of selling his proposals just by the way he labels them.

I have contended all along that the PPACA reflected exactly what Senate Democrats wanted in 2009 and the graph gives you a hint on why that might have been the case. They were worried about their re-election chances if they enacted a single-payer system. What they did was the risk-averse solution.

2 comments

What Greece and Hungary Did Wrong

As I read about the bickering back and forth among the members of the EU, I can only think that if I had been in the shoes of the Greeks or Hungarians I would have responded differently. Take this, as reported by the Wall Street Journal, for example:

BRUSSELS—European officials clashed Thursday over how to reduce the migrant influx into the continent, as Greece recalled its ambassador to Austria and threatened to veto European Union policies if its territory became a huge refugee camp.

Greece’s surprise diplomatic move—a rarity among EU governments—came two days after Greece angrily protested being left out of a meeting of Balkan states in Vienna on how to better control the flow of migrants. It also indicated Athens’s growing frustration with moves by Austria and Balkan states to limit the number of migrants, which have caused thousands to become stranded in Greece.

You see what’s going on? The EU states (other than Greece) are meeting to determine how the Greeks are going to deal with the migrant crisis that Germany created.

I’d’ve created a corridor and moved the migrants to Germany as quickly as I could.

To re-purpose H. L. Mencken’s wisecrack, technocracy is the theory that experts know what it is good and deserve to get it good and hard.

3 comments

The Pack, February 2016

From our left to right that’s Kara, Ziva, and Nola. Smidge, the Australian Shepherd, does not take part in such festivities.

0 comments

The Looking Glass Russia

I think that Mathieu von Rohr, writing at Der Spiegel, has it almost completely backwards:

So what is it that Russia wants? It wants to expand its influence in the Middle East and Eastern Europe and it wants to once again be on equal footing with the United States on the international stage. As recent events have shown, President Vladimir Putin is willing to use almost all means necessary in the pursuit of this aim. Russia doesn’t even shy away from conducting airstrikes on residential areas in Syria, bombing hospitals in the process. It is likewise forcing the Sunni population to take flight, thereby increasing the flow of refugees and destabilizing Europe and Turkey. It has become obvious that Russia is not a partner to the West, not even, as some had hoped, in fighting the Islamic State.

On the contrary, Russia has become a destructive actor.

I don’t know if that’s the German view or what it is but it looks to me cartoonish, with Russia cast as a mustache-twirling Snidely Whiplash. Here’s a simpler, more benign explanation: Russia doesn’t want to be surrounded by enemies. It can stand adversaries but it can’t tolerate antagonists, eager to chip away at the territory it considers its own. It doesn’t see an Islamist Turkey or Syria or a neo-fascist Ukraine as benign. Continuing in a slightly less rosy vein, there are plenty of Russians who are nostalgic for the old Soviet Union and wouldn’t mind restoring those borders.

The U. S. contrariwise is not just weak; it has been acting perversely for decades, encouraging its enemies, discouraging its friends, pursuing objectives that don’t help it and failing to recognize its real enemies. It’s really hard not to see the U. S. as insane.

The real question we should be asking ourselves is why have we defined Russian defeat as American victory?

8 comments