Speaking of Inequality…

And speaking of inequality, Megan McArdle kicks off a series of articles and posts at Bloomberg on the subject:

If we want to have a public discussion about inequality, the first thing we have to do is define which sorts of inequality meet the definition of a “problem.” We then need to decide which of these problems should be solved. Not every problem qualifies.

The history of public policy is littered with “solutions” that turned out to be worse than the problem they were supposedly solving — the political equivalent of the proverbial fool who blows his own head off to cure his headache.

I can offer one suggestion that I’m sure won’t be heeded: policy should disaggregate the economic effects from the non-economic ones. Lumping them together tends to benefit the beneficiaries of the economic side effects of policies rather than the intended beneficiaries of the policies.

0 comments

Rich, Richer, Richest

newgildedage

While doing a little research relevant to a discussion going on in comments I stumbled across the eye-catching graphic above in this article by Peter Coy at Bloomberg. Note that the graphic illustrates wealth not income. What does your net worth need to be to qualify as rich (the 1%), richer (the .1%), or richest (the .01%)?

The threshold for being in the top 0.1 percent of tax filers in 2012 was wealth of about $20 million. To be in the top 0.01 percent—that’s the 1 Percent club’s 1 Percent club—required net worth of $100 million. Of course, even $100 million is a pittance to Bill Gates, whose net worth, according to the Bloomberg Billionaires Index, is nearly 800 times that.

There are about 1.4 million rich households, 140,000 richer households, and 1,400 of the richest households and among them they hold just about 40% of U. S. wealth.

That’s an enormous concentration of wealth but even that doesn’t tell the whole story. If you only look at the 14 richest people in the United States, a list that includes such worthies as Bill Gates, Warren Buffett, Larry Ellison, Jeff Bezos, Mark Zuckerberg, and Sergey Brin, their combined net worth is around $250 billion which peels a little less than one of those percentage points away from that richest .01 percent in favor of the richest 1% of the richest.

So, here are a few facts about the rich.

  1. It is true that the richest 10% of the 1% hold more wealth than the balance of the 1%. Not by a lot, but it’s true.
  2. It is not true that the richest 1% of the 1% (the richest) hold more wealth than the merely rich (99%-99.9%).
  3. The merely rich hold nearly as much wealth as the richer and the richest household put together.
  4. Numerically, how the rich get their income is pretty different than how the richest do. Most of the rich get their income from wages (as opposed to interest, dividends, or royalties).
  5. At least a third of the rich have boosted their incomes via rent-seeking.

My off-hand guess is that most of the richer and richest tend to be in the tech and financial sectors. The top earning entertainers and sports figures tend to be in the “richer” category although I just happen to know that the highest-compensated actor has a net worth of around $150 million.

One more point: when I talk about excessive compensation, I’m talking about the compensation derived from rent-seeking.

3 comments

Something We Need Not Worry About

Here’s a snippet from Leonid Bershidsky’s Bloomberg article on automation and employment:

The people at the top of the income distribution aren’t all bankers or tech gurus. Seven percent of the top 1 percent of earners are lawyers, another 7 percent doctors, 3 percent work in insurance and real estate. According to a recent article by Jonathan Rothwell, a Brookings Institution fellow, “there are five times as many top 1 percent workers in dental services as in software services.” Technological disruption doesn’t explain the rise of the top 1 percent and the lack of median income growth.

There are some other factors that do, however. Those include occupational licensing and other regulations, subsidies, and mass immigration.

I’d also add upper level managers in big companies to my list of “people at the top of the income distribution”. I know how I’d curb that but I’m interested in your views. How would you curb excessive executive compensation? How would you define it?

5 comments

Among the Many Things

What’s wrong with this passage from Nicholas Kristof’s New York Times column?

We progressives believe in diversity, and we want women, blacks, Latinos, gays and Muslims at the table—er, so long as they’re not conservatives.

Universities are the bedrock of progressive values, but the one kind of diversity that universities disregard is ideological and religious.

I do not earn my living as a writer. I don’t receive a sou from this blog despite writing an average of a thousand words a day here. Nonetheless, I devote substantial effort to ensuring that I use good diction, formation, and proper spelling and punctuation. It may not show but I do.

Is it too much to ask that Mr. Kristof do the same? Or is it that his prejudices are showing?

3 comments

House Poor

In her article in Atlantic sympathizing with Neal Gabler’s bellyaching (which I wrote about before) and blaming it all on the system, Rebecca Rosen finally gets around to some prescriptions:

In a sense, the people who say rising wages would help are on to something, but the key is not getting households more money—it’s about building a different system, one in which the upside to getting ahead isn’t so high, and the downside to falling behind isn’t so low. Better wages are a symptom of such a system, but they don’t themselves bring one about. That would require systemic changes—changes to the tax code, changes to corporate-governance practices, changes to anti-trust law, changes to how schools are funded, to name a few.

from which I gather that when she was a little girl Ms. Rosen always colored within the lines. If there is evidence that the problems to which she attributes the national propensity to spend beyond our means can be remedied by changes in the tax code, vague “changes to corporate-governance practices” or “changes to anti-trust law”, or changes to the ways schools are funded, I have yet to see it. Show your work, Ms. Rosen. Quite to the contrary, I think the problems will persist as long as the financial and healthcare sectors are as bloated, out-sized, and over-compensated as they are regardless of other reforms.

How would you go about identifying the source of the problem? Among the strategies I can think of, you could, for the last thirty of forty years:

  • Identify the sectors in which wages (total wages) have risen or fallen.
  • Determine whether total real taxes paid have risen or fallen.
  • Look at the relationship between tax rates and educational outcomes (hint: there is no clear relationship).
  • Determine how much real spending on education has risen (hint: it’s three times as high as it was in 1992).
  • Look at the relationship between spending per student and outcomes in education (hint: there is no clear relationship).
  • Determine when executive salaries exploded (hint: in 1993 when the rules on executive compensation changed).

That would be a start. I don’t think the facts fit her prescriptions.

An enormous transformation has taken place in the United States. We’ve gone from a country in which it was believed that hard work and determination were the keys to success and there was at least some truth to it to a country full of people trying to win the lottery. Both the strategies and the objectives have changed.

18 comments

But the Game Isn’t Played That Way

I recommend that you read Michael Lewis’s commentary in Bloomberg on former Bank of England Governor Mervyn King’s book, The End of Alchemy. Mr. Lewis is the author of Moneyball among others and the commentary is chatty, anecdotal, and hard to summarize. Here’s the kernel:

King’s starting point is that the 2008 crisis wasn’t an anomaly but the natural consequence of bad incentives that are still baked into money and banking — and so quite likely to create another, possibly even greater, crisis. “The strange thing,” he writes, “is that after arguably the biggest financial crisis in history nothing much has really changed in terms either of the fundamental structure of banking or the reliance on central banks to restore macroeconomic prosperity.”

with this

The financial system, King reveals, is still wired so that a handful of well-connected people capture the benefits from risk-taking while the entire society bears the cost. Complexity was once used to disguise the risk in the financial system. Now it’s being used to disguise how little has actually been done to fix that system.

and this

The first thing that King thinks must be done is to separate the boring bits of banking (providing a safe place to deposit money, facilitating payments) from the exciting ones (trading). There is no need, he thinks, to break up the existing institutions. Deposits and short-term loans to banks simply need to be separated from other bank assets. Against all of these boring assets, banks would be required to hold government bonds or reserves at the central bank in cash. That is, there should be zero risk that there won’t be sufficient cash on hand to repay people wanting to flee any bank at a moment’s notice — and thus no reason for those people to flee.

I can’t remark on banking in the United Kingdom but in the United States the evils he’s trying to remedy are the purpose of the system. Let me put it another way.

If you reduce the risks of the system, the rewards will be reduced as well. If you reduce the rewards, there won’t be any cushy jobs in finance for former Fed governors or other alleged public servants. The whole object of the game is to offload risk on to the greater society while continuing to capture the outsized rewards. Those aren’t bugs, they’re features.

There’s no earthly way short of revolution (and I don’t mean figurative revolution) that his proposed reforms would ever be adopted, at least not in the United States.

4 comments

The Beatings Will Continue Until Morale Improves

The Wall Street Journal has reported that the Chinese government as part of its plan to promote China’s economic growth is, shall we say, encouraging economists and journalists to provide more up-beat reports:

BEIJING—Chinese authorities are training their sights on a new set of targets: economists, analysts and business reporters with gloomy views on the country’s economy.

Securities regulators, media censors and other government officials have issued verbal warnings to commentators whose public remarks on the economy are out of step with the government’s upbeat statements, according to government officials and commentators with knowledge of the matter.

The stepped-up censorship, many inside and outside the ruling Communist Party say, represents an effort by China’s leadership to quell growing concerns about the country’s economic prospects as it experiences a prolonged slowdown in growth. As more citizens try to take money out of the country, officials say, regulators and censors are trying to foster an environment of what party officials have dubbed “zhengnengliang,” or “positive energy.”

I’m sure that will work. I know that Keynes considered “animal spirits” important in promoting a country’s economic growth but somehow I doubt this is what he had in mind.

If you were an animal spirit, what kind of animal spirit would you be?

At some point positive energy becomes obvious delusion. Has China reached that point yet or did it reach it long ago? Trying to enforce positive energy suggests the latter.

2 comments

The Only Way to Win Is Not to Play

If this article from CBS News is to be believed, medical error is the third leading cause of death in the United States:

Medical errors, including wrong diagnoses, botched surgeries and medication mistakes, are the third leading cause of death in the United States, a new study suggests.

Scientists from Johns Hopkins found that more than 250,000 Americans die due to medical mishaps every year, greater than the toll from any major medical condition except heart disease or cancer.

The findings, published in The BMJ, come from an analysis of death rate records spanning eight years.

I have considerable sympathy for the medical professionals on this score. When you intervene, some of the patients will die. That’s just the way it is. And sometimes you make mistakes. To err is human.

There are any number of ways to reduce the rate of medical error. The most obvious is to curb the predisposition to intervene.

Another is something that the medical profession has been fighting a vain, inevitably losing battle against for decades: automation. Computers don’t tire, don’t rush so they can make it to their daughters’ dance recitals, and don’t need vacations. Increasingly, computers are looking over physicians’ shoulders and that’s something that will only increase. And that will reduce the rate of medical error.

10 comments

Looking For Mr. Goodbar

Now that Ted Cruz has dropped out of the race for the Republican nomination for the presidency it would seem to have put to bed the notion that if only a conservative enough candidate could be found he would be a shoe-in for election. If you can’t win the Republican nomination running as the true conservative, it would seem obvious that you can’t win the general election. Who would have been more conservative (whatever that means now) than Ted Cruz? Unfortunately, no candidate is so perfect that the “No True Scotsman” fallacy can’t be applied.

But there’s a pretty simple explanation for it: most Americans aren’t ideological.

I think there’s a kind of Maimonides Ladder of politics. At the lowest level of actualization are those who are completely disengaged from politics. Being motivated by party affiliation or ideology are somewhere in the middle.

Now the prevailing wisdom seems to be that a) Donald Trump will be the Republican nominee; b) the Republican Party is broken; and c) he will go down to ignominious defeat in November. See Howard Fineman’s post at Huffington Post for why (c) might not be true.

I think something entirely different is going on. Non-ideological, inconsistent, and even incoherent Americans are frustrated with the candidates that have emerged from the conventional party structures. What that might portend for November I have absolutely no idea.

Something that might be going on is that we’re witnessing a complete shuffling of both of the present political parties. As I’ve said before I’m completely baffled by what’s been going on in American politics for the last eight or nine months (maybe longer).

Expect Bernie Sanders to be absolutely deluged with demands that he “suspend his campaign”. What in Sen. Sanders’s life to date would lead anyone to believe he would do that? I think that he’s banking on the many known unknowns and maybe even some unknown unknowns that continue to dog Hillary Clinton’s candidacy. Who knows? He could be the last man left standing.

49 comments

Math Is Required

There’s a very good post from Derek Thompson at Atlantic which explains why the recovery looks so good to some people, e.g. President Obama, but not so good to a lot of people. And it has nothing to do with racism or ideology but with the structure of the American economy today:

The U.S. economy’s power-law features, in which averages disguise massive inequalities in outcomes, go a long way in explaining how Obama can tell a story about the economy vastly different from the ones that are propelling some presidential candidates. A prime example is the pattern of income growth. Between 2009 and 2013, most measures of real personal income showed slow but steady improvement. Average hourly earnings for private sector workers grew about 7 percent. But what about the distribution? The top 1 percent saw its disposable income grow by 11 percent. Everybody else got close to nothing. For the bottom 99 percent, income actually declined through the first five years of the recovery. “So far all of the gains of the recovery have gone to the top 1 percent,” the economist Justin Wolfers wrote.

which if you will recall is what I’ve been saying for some time.

Left unaddressed is what to do about it. We could produce a lot more growth. Enough so that it would trickle down to a higher proportion of the people. Unfortunately, nobody knows how to do that. Everybody has an idea and many of the ideas are mutually exclusive.

We could raise taxes on the beneficiaries of the growth of the last few years and transfer the proceeds to those who haven’t benefited. That has two problems. First, getting the taxed to sit still long enough to pay is harder than it sounds. And second when the proposals get filtered through the Congress somehow rather than going to people in the bottom 90% of the economy the transfers always end up going to people in the top income percentiles. On behalf of the bottom 90%, natch.

My proposal—stop subsidizing the rich—never seems to get any traction. To do that you’ll need to let banks fail, make the ownership of assets (as opposed to work or the production of goods) less profitable, and kill a sacred cow or two, e.g. the home mortgage interest deduction, an astonishing proportion of the benefits of which go to the highest income earners. Funny, that.

4 comments