At Bloomberg Noah Smith has posted the latest installment in the ongoing series on inequality. Many of the discussions of inequality have focused on inequality at a global or national scale. In this installment Dr. Smith considers the question at a much more local level:
One reason urban inequality is so important is that this is how most people experience the phenomenon on a daily basis — in cities, rich, middle-class and poor people are in constant contact. Experiments and other studies clearly show that people care about their status relative to reference groups, and one important reference group is the people who live nearby. That makes intuitive sense. If some rich person in Switzerland is buying a mansion, I only perceive it as a statistic on paper, but every time I see someone walk into a restaurant that I can’t afford, it reminds me of my lower economic status.
These effects are visible in aggregate data as well. Economist Ed Glaeser finds a negative correlation between city-level inequality and self-reported happiness.
I’m not an economist but I am a person who is noted for getting things done. I’ve got to confess that I just don’t look at things the way Dr. Smith does. I tend to look at equality in terms of the factors, particularly the institutions, that foster equality and those that discourage equality. Let’s consider a few.
Type
Fosters equality
Does not
Income
Free market
Subsidies paid to service providers.
Relatively small, local banks.
Branch banking
Aggressive anti-trust activities
Little or no anti-trust activity
No barriers to entry
Credentialling
Wealth
High inheritance taxes
Low inheritance taxes
Personal property taxes
No personal property taxes
High property taxes
Low property taxes
Social
Low immmigration
High immigration
Common language
Multiple languages
Universal military service
Volunteer military with low participation
Free K-12 education that accepts everyone and which most children attend.
Private schools
That list is not intended to be exhaustive, merely indicative.
My point here is that, if you want greater equality, you’ve got to change the critical success factors. If you try to preserve all of the factors, nothing you do will result in greater equality.
What other factors do you think are involved in increasing/decreasing income, wealth, or social equality? Distinguish between the factors themselves and whether changing them is desirable. I’ll suggest another factor: zoning.
Simply put, Zika infection is more dangerous, and Brazil’s outbreak more extensive, than scientists reckoned a short time ago. Which leads to a bitter truth: the 2016 Olympic and Paralympic Games must be postponed, moved, or both, as a precautionary concession. There are five reasons.
He goes on to list them. Read the whole thing.
There’s another factor that should be taken into consideration which Dr. Attaran is, perhaps, too discreet to mention: Brazil is going through what is its most serious political crisis in decades, possibly the most serious in nearly a century. Will the Games help Brazil deal with everything it has on its plate or will they encourage them to postpone dealing with things in the hope of sweeping them under the carpet until after the Games are over? The history of the Games suggests the latter. Serious economic recession, political corruption both connected to the Games and not, Zika, and political crisis are a lot for any country to handle.
It may come as a shock but people occasionally do not do the right thing. That extends to the international Olympic Committee, Brazil’s Olympic Committee, politicians of whatever country, and the World Health Organization. Since the time of the Lydians, money has been a powerful inducement. I suggest that the countries of the world, particularly the members of the OECD, offer Brazil a sizable financial incentive to postpone its hosting of the Olympic Games for several cycles at the least.
To be honest I found their conversation unsatisfying for any number of reasons. They despair of solutions. Megan in particular does not seem to appreciate the risks that may accompany increasing income and wealth inequality and is too dismissive of the potential risks.
Over the period of the last 70 years we have torn down many barriers to social equality and erected new ones. On the one hand the barriers to equality among the races and between the sexes were substantial. But on the other the barriers that have been erected since then are nearly as substantial and may just be proxies for barriers based on race or gender.
Here are some questions I would ask:
How do you mitigate the risk of income or wealth inequality being transmuted into political and social inequality?
Does increased credentialing actually produce benefits for companies and other institutions?
Is credentialing just racial or gender-based discrimination by another means?
How can you maintain social and/or political equality while tearing down the institutions that foster them?
Driving an electric car in China, where coal is by far the largest power plant fuel, is a catastrophe for climate change. And if the coal plant lacks pollution controls—or fails to turn them on—it can amplify the extent of smog, acid rain, lung-damaging microscopic soot and other ills that arise from burning fossil fuels. The same is true in other major coal-burning countries, such as Australia, India and South Africa.
The good news: the U.S. is making a tectonic shift from burning coal to produce the majority of its electricity to using cleaner natural gas. The changeover produces less CO2, making electric cars cleaner across the country, roughly equivalent to a hybrid. On the other hand, the primary constituent of natural gas—methane—is itself a potent greenhouse gas. If methane leaks from the wells where it is produced, the pipelines that transport it or the power plants that burn it, the climate doesn’t necessarily benefit.
In short, electric cars are only as good as the electricity that charges them.
I see that quite a number of Democrats are starting to realize the same things that I did some time ago: both Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump are awful candidates, Hillary Clinton is a terrible campaigner, and Trump could actually win.
I still have no idea what a Trump presidency would be like and I don’t think that anyone else does, either. Including Donald Trump.
There is one thing I can say with considerable confidence. A President Trump would have persistent problems with the federal bureaucracy, particularly the State Department and the Department of Defense. They simply don’t operate the way he does and, well, I don’t think there could ever be a meeting of the minds.
I continue to think that this will be an election campaign like no other of my lifetime and suspect that a major political realignment is in progress that will affect both the Democratic and Republican Parties.
I engage in one of these writing exercises every so often and it’s been a while.
I’m 5’8 and have blue eyes. My hair used to be chestnut brown but is now mostly grey and thinning a bit. I still have more hair than most men of my age.
I wear a 48 jacket, a 38 waist, and a 29 inch inseam. I wear a 16 1/2 inch collar and 34 inch sleeves. I do not have a gut but am very broad-shouldered and deep chested. I’m quite “long-waisted” which is a nice way of saying that my legs are short for my height—I’m proportioned very differently from most people. When I sit at a table with tall people, our eyes are at a level although, obviously, I’m a lot shorter than they are.
I have a short mustache. I once had a full beard. My beard and mustache used to be red but my mustache is now white. I haven’t grown my beard out in nearly 50 years. I’ve got a good complexion and, although I have dark lines under my eyes, I don’t have many wrinkles.
I hate having my picture taken. I don’t think I’m very photogenic.
I speak quickly and energetically. The way I write is basically the way I speak—in full paragraphs as befits the son of a lawyer/law prof and a remedial reading teacher.
I used to be very strong and very agile. I could jump to the top of a normal table from a standing start. One summer I hauled 300 lb. boxes around by hand until I learned that I wasn’t supposed to be able to do that.
I walk between three and five miles a day every day 365 days a year. I wish I could do more but there just isn’t time.
I stumbled across this post by Rob Isbitts at Marketwatch a couple of days ago, found it interesting, and wanted to pass it along. The gist of the article is that the Dow-Jones Industrial Index and the Standard & Poors 500 have become very detached from the real economy:
When we sort the S&P 500 by market capitalization from largest to smallest, we find that only three stocks (Microsoft Corp. MSFT, +0.82% Apple Inc. AAPL, -0.49% and Google parent Alphabet Inc. GOOG, -0.20% GOOGL, -0.21% ) comprise 10% of the index’s total value. You’ve heard of “FANG†stocks? I’m going to call these MAG. And I’m also going to call them a sign of a dangerously narrow stock market. More on that later.
To get from the top 10% by market capitalization to the top 20%, you only need to add seven more stocks to the mix. They are Exxon Mobil Corp. XOM, -0.51% Berkshire Hathaway Inc. BRK.A, +0.01% BRK.B, -0.52% Facebook Inc. FB, +0.39% Johnson & Johnson JNJ, -0.14% Amazon.com Inc. AMZN, +0.83% General Electric Co. GE, +0.26% and Wells Fargo & Co. WFC, +0.00% Those seven plus MAG (10 stocks in all) comprise just over one-fifth of the S&P 500’s value.
Consider this table to see how detached that is from reality:
Company
Total Revenue
Employees
Amazon
$107 billion
222,400
Apple
$234 billion
115,000
Google
$74 billion
61,814
Microsoft
$94 billion
118,584
Exxon Mobil
$269 billion
75,300
Berkshire Hathaway
$211 billion
331,000
When you add net revenues to the equation it becomes even more grotesque. Amazon has less than $1 billion in net revenue. Apple, Exxon Mobil, and Berkshire Hathaway sell real stuff and have lots of net revenue. However, Apple’s market cap has become almost completely detached from its net revenues.
Is zealous advocacy for its preferred policies on the part of presidential administrations right or wrong? Should the president and his staff overstate the benefits, understate the risks?
My own view is that, while administrations may advocate for their own policies, they should never propagandize for them and there is an ethical obligation for administrations to present a balanced view. Administrations should never lie to Congress and lying to the public, although occasionally necessary, should be a rarity.
After noting a poll that found that most Chicagoans are disturbed by what’s happening in their city and distrustful of city government, the New York Times turns to readers for their opinions:
CHICAGO — After a new poll of Chicagoans showed that they are deeply dissatisfied with the direction of their city, distrustful of their police force and divided along racial lines, people here and around the country weighed in on social media.
Some expressed shock at some of the most painful findings in the survey from The New York Times and Kaiser Family Foundation: More than 80 percent of African-American residents said it was at least somewhat likely that the young people in their neighborhoods would end up victims of violent crimes, and about the same number said it was likely the young people would go to jail. Far fewer white residents had those expectations about young people in their neighborhoods.
Others spoke of similar entrenched racial and economic problems in their own cities, suggested ways to improve relations with the police, and opined on leadership in big cities.
Some pointed to longstanding allegations of corruption in Chicago, the nation’s third largest city.
Chicago’s 12 step program hasn’t even begun, presumably because the city hasn’t hit rock bottom yet. Will Chicago’s voters recognize that there’s a problem and its nature while there’s still a chance for the city to escape Detroit’s fate?
The familiar nostrums—higher taxes, more police officers on the street, etc.—won’t solve Chicago’s problems. We’re going to be paying for what’s either managerial incompetence or corruption (or both) for decades.
The Chicago Superintendent of Police and the CEO of the Chicago Public Schools both earn upwards of $250,000 per year. That would be worth it if they weren’t corrupt or incompetent. Given the recent track record, we’ve had both. Will paying more within the painfully inbred worlds of big city policing and education actually help? Or just make the agony more expensive?
The graphic above, which I found rather distressing, is from an article by Dan Kopf at Atlantic:
Perhaps no aspect of the annual migration in and out of San Francisco is as notable as the outflow of African Americans. San Francisco was 13.4 percent African American in 1970, but its population as of 2016 is less than 6 percent black. The population has steadily declined, and the trend seems likely to continue. From 2010 to 2014, there was annual net out-migration of around 2,000 African Americans from the city. That represents a 4.6 percent decline of the population every year.
The reason, of course, is skyrocketing housing costs. When you constrain the supply, you shouldn’t be surprised if costs rise. Making it impossible for black folk to remain in San Francisco is one way of coping with your problems, I suppose. I don’t think it will be as effective in Chicago as it has apparently been in San Francisco.