A Difference of Opinion

On May 16 Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner vetoed Illinois House Bill 580, known to its supporters as “the fair arbitration bill”. The governor’s veto message, AFSCME’s response, and the governor’s open letter to the people of Illinois are all reproduced at Capitol Fax.com. That link may not be permanent. You can also find Gov. Rauner’s open letter at the Springfield State Journal-Register and the AFSCME response on the local’s web site.

Here’s a snippet from the governor’s veto message:

Today I veto House Bill 580. Nearly one year ago, the General Assembly passed an almost identical bill, Senate Bill 1229. I vetoed that bill because it was a dangerous, unprecedented attack on our taxpayers. HB 580 recycles the same dangerous proposal that I vetoed last fall.

Prior to the veto override vote on SB 1229 and within the last few days, newspaper editorial boards from all corners of the state – north to south, urban and rural, heavily Democrat and Republican districts, and those with large union and non-union readerships – wrote about the dangers of stripping taxpayers of their voice at the collective bargaining table.

The editors at The Southern wrote, “[n]othing like SB 1229 exists anywhere in the country. Nor should it. It’s an open assault on transparent representative government.” The Pantagraph in Bloomington wrote, “This is a terrible piece of legislation that should have never received much attention.” Just yesterday, the Dispatch-Argus rightly called HB 580 “worse than the original.” And The News-Gazette described HB 580 as “wrong on so many levels that it represents Exhibit A for the sloppy, irresponsible manner in which our failed state has been and continues to be run.”

HB 580 goes even further than SB 1229 did, sneaking in additional costly language under the guise of technical changes. For the reasons I explain in this message, our taxpayers rightly insist that HB 580 not become law.

From AFSCME’s response:

Public service workers in state government keep us safe, protect kids, respond to emergencies and much more. They want to stay on the job to serve their communities, not be forced out on strike, and they deserve fair pay and health care they can afford. This bill seeks compromise and avoids a strike by allowing an independent, neutral third party to settle the differences between workers and management. It is the process already used for tens of thousands of fire fighters, police officers, correctional workers and others throughout Illinois.

Beneath Governor Rauner’s false claims and wild exaggerations about the bill is this reality: The governor walked away from negotiations with our union in January and is seeking total power to unilaterally impose his demands, including forcing state and university employees to pay double their current costs for health care. Given that power, the governor could impose his demands and leave state employees no choice but to strike. That’s exactly what Rauner as a candidate vowed to do.

Governor Rauner doesn’t like HB 580 because it would require him to be moderate and seek compromise. He wants his way or no way at all. Public service workers in state government want better for the millions of citizens we serve. That’s why new polls show voters support the fair arbitration bill by 3-1 margins even in Republican districts, and why we will urge all lawmakers of both parties to protect public services, ensure fairness and override the governor’s veto of HB 580.

And from the governor’s open letter:

For too many years, Illinoisans have been misled. Employees in state government have been misled. Taxpayers who fund government have been misled. Recipients of public services, including our most vulnerable residents, have also been misled. The consequences are before us, and they are dire.

I ran for office to right these wrongs. I believe that solving our state’s crisis requires a simple first step — for someone to tell the truth. So here it is.

The truth is that Illinois is broke. Our taxpayers, who pay the highest property taxes in the nation, are maxed out and local governments continue to raise property taxes.

Illinoisans also pay the highest sales tax in the nation and Chicago plans to raise its sales tax even higher. Illinois’s relatively low income tax is the only thing that maintains Illinois’s status as a medium-tax state. Instituting a graduated state income tax would require an amendment to the state’s constitution.

Who’s right? I think they both are. Gov. Rauner is arguing his case as well as he can and so is AFSCME.

The question that needs to be asked is whether Illinois’s problems can be solved by raising taxes and I think it’s obvious that they can’t. Illinois has gone for nearly a year without a budget. The way forward is through compromise. Illinois’s legislature needs to give Gov. Rauner at least some of what he wants, as bitter a pill as that is to swallow, and Gov. Rauner needs to allow the legislature to raise taxes, even though the clearest interpretation of his election to the governorship is that it was a rebellion against the previous increase in the state’s income tax. That temporary increase was sold as a way to solve Illinois’s fiscal problems. Instead of doing what they had promised Illinois’s legislators used the extra tax revenue to boost spending without solving the underlying problems.

Equally obviously, the main stumbling block to compromise is Illinois House Speaker Mike Madigan. He’s held that office for most of the last 40 years so his fingerprints are all over Illinois’s economic and fiscal messes.

1 comment

Job for the Modern Day: Generational Consultant

If you find yourself out of a job, here’s a new career you might consider: generational consultant. As reported by the Wall Street Journal:

Millennial expert Lindsey Pollak says she can teach companies a thing or two about young workers. First, they expect work to be meaningful. Second, they crave frequent feedback. Third, they despise voice mail.

People born in the 1980s and 1990s now make up the largest single generational group in the workforce, and managing them has become a source of agita for big businesses such as Oracle Corp., Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and Coca-Cola Co.
Millennial issues also have become a source of income for a host of self-anointed experts who say they can interpret young workers’ whims and aspirations—sometimes for as much as $20,000 an hour. Oracle, Red Robin Gourmet Burgers Inc. and Time Warner Inc.’s HBO have retained millennial advisers to stem turnover, market to young people and ensure their happiness at work.

I think that’s probably something I could do for $20,000 an hour. I mean, that’s not Hillary Clinton money but it’s good pay nonetheless.

I do think that there are some particular ways in which you must treat millennials different than you would, say, Baby Boomers but not many. Most of the examples given in the article are just good management, whether your employees are Baby Boomers, Generation X, or millennials.

As suggested by one of the practitioners of the art quoted in the article, it’s obviously a racket.

5 comments

Slave Labor

I suspect that this exposé by Louis Hansen in the San Jose Mercury-News will surprise practically no one:

When Gregor Lesnik left his pregnant girlfriend in Slovenia for a job in America, his visa application described specialized skills and said he was a supervisor headed to a South Carolina auto plant.

Turns out, that wasn’t true.

The unemployed electrician had no qualifications to oversee American workers and spoke only a sentence or two of English. He never set foot in South Carolina. The companies that arranged his questionable visa instead sent Lesnik to a menial job in Silicon Valley. He earned the equivalent of $5 an hour to expand the plant for one of the world’s most sophisticated companies, Tesla Motors.

Lesnik’s three-month tenure ended a year ago in a serious injury and a lawsuit that has exposed a troubling practice in the auto industry. Overseas contractors are shipping workers from impoverished countries to American factories, where they work long hours for low wages, in apparent violation of visa and labor laws.

Let’s be very clear about this: the “specialized skill” that Mr. Lesnik possessed was the willingness to work for slave wages under what may have been unsafe working conditions. My suggestion? They should take Elon Musk out, break both of his legs and some of his ribs, tear the ligaments in his knee, and give him a concussion, which are the injuries that Mr. Lesnik suffered.

In a more serious vein, the enforcement of the bans on such hiring practices is too lax and the penalties are far too light.

Unanswered in the article: what was Tesla paying the middleman for this worker and why didn’t it figure out what was going on?

Is it any wonder that Donald Trump is making hay with the immigration issue? Multiply this story hundreds of thousands of times over and you begin to see the problem’s scope.

33 comments

Now That’s What I’m Talking About

When I talk about geoengineering solutions to solve environmental problems (including global warming), I don’t mean things like huge airborne umbrellas to block out the sun or injecting sulfur dioxide into the upper atmosphere (I’ve seen proposals for both). I mean solutions like this from enGadget:

Air pollution is a huge problem in cities around the globe. The widespread burning of fossil fuels combined with the destruction of air-cleaning forests results in dense concentrations of smog in large urban centers. What’s more, the World Health Organization estimates that air pollution contributes to 7 million premature deaths each year. To address this enormous public health problem, engineers from around the world have developed some cool (and crazy) gadgets to help clean up the air. In Italy, the world’s first vertical forest have inspired designers around the world, but smaller projects are actively fighting pollution too. From a sidewalk that eats smog to an air-cleaning vacuum that turns pollution into jewelry, you’ll be amazed by the ways people are working to improve air quality.

Check out their gallery. Some very cool ideas.

1 comment

Okay, I’ll Bite. What Skills?

Michael Bloomberg (former mayor of New York and owner of the Bloomberg news empire) and Jamie Dimon (CEO of JPMorgan Chase) take to Bloomberg View to argue for the teaching of “skills schools aren’t teaching”:

We will not solve the critical challenges of poverty, underemployment, wage stagnation and bulging prisons unless we get serious about investing in effective programs that prepare kids who are not immediately college-bound for middle-class jobs. Other countries — such as Germany and Switzerland — have figured this out. We must, too.

About 70 percent of young Americans, and 83 percent of blacks and Hispanics, do not earn a bachelor’s degree by age 29. Most who attend community college don’t graduate. And without having gained career-focused skills in high schools, many are getting left behind.

It used to be that a high-school diploma was enough to qualify for a job at the local factory that paid wages high enough to buy a home and raise a family. Those days are long gone. There are still more than 12 million manufacturing jobs in the U.S., down from a high of nearly 20 million in 1979. But most require far more skill than they once did. A high-school diploma no longer cuts it.

Okay, I’ll bite. What skills? They don’t say. Let me present a few facts

  1. Half of big city students don’t graduate from high school on time and a third don’t graduate in five years.
  2. Nearly 20% of high school graduates can’t read and nobody knows how many more are functionally illiterate. That hasn’t changed in more than a decade.
  3. Wages haven’t been growing for STEM workers for more than 15 years. Mssrs. Bloomberg and Dimon might want to google “market clearing price”.
  4. Technical skills, by and large, have a short shelf life. Nowadays by the time you’ve learned one it’s already obsolete. That’s a big problem for anybody who gets involved with a large, multi-year project. When the project is done, so is their career.
  5. Since the Great Recession, the areas of the economy that have hired the most new workers are retail, hospitality, and healthcare (and in healthcare the jobs that have grown the most are those that need the fewest skills).
  6. Among high school students, about 10% don’t speak English at all and in many big cities a quarter or more don’t speak English at home.

So, here’s my proposal for the skills the schools should teach: readin’, writin’, ‘rithmetic, English.

Now, I’d like to ask Mr. Dimon a question. When was the last time he hired someone who hadn’t graduated from one of the top 10 colleges in the country? (You know, Harvard, Yale, Princeton, MIT, Stanford, University of Chicago, etc.)

I’m all for increasing the amount of vocational training. I think it’s a necessity. Here’s another necessity. We need to create a lot more jobs that are worth getting training for.

15 comments

Whose Prejudices Are Being Catered To?

I stumbled across this post by Gillian B. White at Atlantic. In the post Ms. White remarks on a study of the lack of diversity in the casts of Hollywood movies:

Venkat Kuppuswamy and Peter Younkin, business-school professors at the University of North Carolina and McGill University, respectively, took a look at data on the film industry in order to measure how diverse casts went over at box offices.

For their study, Kuppuswamy and Younkin took a look at 723 mainstream English-language movies released in major theaters between 2011 and 2015, and determined the number of black actors in lead roles in each film. In nearly two-thirds of the films, there were no black actors cast in any lead roles. In 23 percent of the films, there was one. Only in 11 percent were there two or more black principals.

What was found was that U. S. box office isn’t much affected by cast diversity, “diversity” being defined as “the number of black actors in lead roles in each film”. While I agree with her conclusion that we shouldn’t blame Hollywood’s choices on U. S. audiences, I don’t think that tells the whole story.

Based on the abstract of the study (which is paywalled), they’ve limited it to U. S. box office receipts. The business school profs are perhaps not aware that Hollywood movies are shown to a global audience and that many movies, particularly the blockbusters where a lot of the profits are made, make 2/3s of those profits in the overseas market. The issue may not be that black principal casts reduce domestic box office but that they reduce overseas audiences. My suggestion: ask the studios.

And this observation of Ms. White’s:

One additional factor that Kuppuswamy and Younkin’s investigate is the gatekeeper theory, which says that part of the reason there are so few black actors in lead roles is because there isn’t enough diversity among directors, who help make hiring decisions.

is just the tip of the iceberg. Don’t just look at principal casts and directors. How many producers are anything other than white? Indeed, look at the entire motion picture industry, most of which is in back of the camera rather than in front of it. That’s where the real action is.

9 comments

Madeleine Lebeau, 1923-2016

Madeleine Lebeau, believed to have been the last surviving member of the cast of the iconic 1942 film Casablanca, considered by many (including me) to have been the best movie of all time, has died:

Madeleine Lebeau, the luminous French actress who played Yvonne, the jilted lover of Humphrey Bogart’s Rick Blaine who wells up during the patriotic singing of “La Marseillaise” in the immortal film Casablanca, has died. She was 92.

Lebeau, who later portrayed an actress named Madeleine in another classic, Federico Fellini’s 8 1/2 (1963), died May 1 in Estepona, Spain after breaking her thigh bone, her stepson, documentary filmmaker and environmentalist Carlo Alberto Pinelli, told The Hollywood Reporter.

Lebeau is widely believed to be the last surviving castmember from Casablanca. Not too long before making the film, she herself had escaped Nazi-occupied France with her then-husband, actor Marcel Dalio.

Vive la France!

One by one, year by year, we are losing the few who connect us with the films of Hollywood’s Golden Age. To the best of my knowledge the last living star of that day is Olivia de Havilland, who turns 100 in July.

1 comment

O Tempora O Mores

My wife told me about this appalling local story. As reported in the Sun-Times:

A man choked an 8-year-old girl until she passed out inside the bathroom of a South Loop store last weekend, according to Chicago Police.

She was with her mother at the business in the 1200 block of South Canal when the girl went to the bathroom alone about 1:15 p.m. on May 7, according to Chicago Police.

The woman then heard a scream from her daughter and went inside to find 33-year-old Reese M. Hartstirn carrying the unconscious girl into a stall, police said. He had choked her with his hands, police allege.

Other people in the store helped restrain the man until police arrived to arrest him. The girl was taken to Comer Children’s Hospital, but police did not have information on her condition.

My immediate reaction to the story, of course, was relief that the creep hadn’t been able to go farther than he had. My second reaction was to marvel at how mild we’ve become. A couple of generations ago onlookers wouldn’t’ve stopped with restraining, at least not people of my acquaintance. Nowadays we’re lucky when people restrain miscreants until the police arrive so that eventually he can be tortured and beaten to death which we think of as the rule of law.

3 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

Sykes-Picot, Nation-States, and the Darkness Outside

In recognition of the centenary of the Sykes-Picot Agreement, a number of articles have begun appearing, mostly lambasting the agreement. As you presumably are aware the Sykes-Picot agreement was an Anglo-French pact on the political organization of the Middle East following the collapse of the Ottoman Empire. Basically, England and France divvied up the Middle East into spheres of influence for themselves, tossing a few sops to other European countries. The agreement was arrived at without the consent or even the participation of the people whose lives would be affected by it.

In his post at RealClearWorld Robert Zaretsky in essence complains that the boundaries drawn by Sykes-Picot are just lines on a map:

The appalling churn of events in the Middle East has blasted to smithereens not just untold human lives, but also stories we had long told ourselves about the region. Chief among these fictions is the desirability — which we so often confuse with inevitability — of the nation-state. In other words, a political construct endowed with a recognized state, institutions, and borders. Like a desert mirage, Middle Eastern nation-states have been evaporating before our eyes, leaving us to confront a bloody and battered reality.

while Michael Collins Dunn, writing at Middle East Institute, tries to clear up some misconceptions about the pact, namely that it was never actually implemented as written:

Look at the map above. Does it look like today’s Middle East? In addition to the British and French (pink and blue) zones, Zones A and B are areas of their influence. France controls Mosul, Kirkuk, and northern Iraq. Britain gets the rest of Iraq, plus southern Palestine, while northern Palestine and Jerusalem are internationalized. Russia controls Constantinople and the Straits, and Armenia. Italy gets its own pound of flesh. But that is not the postwar map of the Middle East.

The reason is simple: “Sykes-Picot” has become a convenient shorthand for “the entire postwar settlement of the Ottoman territories,” not the original agreement.

I would argue that national boundaries are a lot more than lines on a page. Within them are rights, responsibility, and order. Outside them are only chaos and darkness. For the last seventy years we have increasingly obscured that reality with transnational organizations, largely based on the illusions of the Europeans. Much of the mayhem of the last several decades is a direct consequence of a failure to realize that.

11 comments