There Are Other Democrats

The editors of the New York Times and USA Today have both come out today with editorials critical of Hillary Clinton, with different levels of severity.

NYT:

So far, no security breaches have been reported; a separate F.B.I. investigation is looking into that. But above and beyond security questions, the inspector general’s report is certain to fuel doubts about Mrs. Clinton’s trustworthiness, lately measured as a significant problem for her in public polls.

Across the years of the Clintons’ ascendancy, the public has seen that Mrs. Clinton can be fiercely protective of her role and prerogatives — at times grudging in admitting error and, during Bill Clinton’s presidency, blaming a “vast right-wing conspiracy” for allegations against her and her husband that began early in his tenure and continued on through the impeachment scandal. (The right wing was definitely on his case, but hardly alone in its doubts about Mr. Clinton’s personal conduct.)

This defensive posture seems at play in the email controversy, as well as her refusal, for that matter, to release the lucrative speeches she made to Wall Street audiences. The reflex she is revealing again now — to hunker down when challenged — is likely to make her seem less personable to many voters, and it will surely inflame critics’ charges of an underlying arrogance.

USAT:

If Clinton wants to become the president of the United States, she needs to explain how she could make such a reckless decision. She had a chance to answer questions when the Obama administration-appointed inspector general contacted her about the investigation that was released last week. Among five recent secretaries of State, only Clinton refused.

While Clinton is under potential criminal investigation by the FBI for the mishandling of classified material sent through her email, remaining silent might be in her best interests and it is certainly her right. But to be president, she is going to have to convince voters that she can put the national security of the United States above her own short-term self-interest.

From both of these it’s pretty clear that editors don’t speak federal bureaucratese. Let me translate from the State Department Inspector General’s report:

  1. He thinks it’s likely that she committed several crimes.
  2. Sec. Clinton and her campaign have lied.

There have been rumors floating around (and not just from partisan Republicans) that the FBI is preparing to ask a grand jury to consider whether criminal charges should be filed. Expect these to multiply unless and until the FBI actually releases its report.

While the Clintons, the Clinton campaign, and various loyalists and apparatchiks continue to circle the wagons, it seems timely to point out that there are other Democrats. And quite a number of them would have been running for president if Hillary Clinton hadn’t been sucking all of the air out of the room.

How about thinking about some? Preferably some who aren’t liars, serial bunglers, and 70 years old.

18 comments

Damned If You Do

You don’t expect significant news to come out over the long Memorial Day weekend but that’s just what has happened in Illinois. The Illinois legislature has voted to override Gov. Rauner’s veto of a bill allowing Chicago to defer payments into and, indeed, borrow from a fund used to pay the pensions of Chicago police officers and firefighters. The Sun-Times reports:

SPRINGFIELD — Just days after Mayor Rahm Emanuel said Gov. Bruce Rauner told Chicago taxpayers to “take a hike,” Democrats delivered the same message to the governor.

In a stunning move, the Illinois House on Monday voted 72-43 to override Rauner’s veto of the Chicago police and fire pension bill that had sparked a war of words between the Republican governor and Emanuel. The action came just hours after the Illinois Senate voted 39-19 to override the bill. It will now become law.

The votes mark a significant defeat for Rauner and a big win for Emanuel, whose own top aides had acknowledged last week that overriding the veto in the House was going to be a tough battle. When it first passed, the pension bill received 66 votes in the House, five short needed for an override.

Rauner blasted the bill, which defers city payments to the pension funds, as financially irresponsible by merely kicking the can down the road. Emanuel said Rauner’s veto, if sustained, would have meant a $300 million property tax hike for city property owners, which Emanuel quickly dubbed the “Rauner Tax.”

I’m of decidedly mixed minds on this action by the Illinois legislature. I think it was necessary but not sufficient.

Gov. Rauner is right. It is just kicking the can down the road. And in Illinois with its stagnant or shrinking tax base that alone is not a good strategy.

On the other hand burning the village (or in this case the City of Chicago) in order to save it isn’t much of a strategy, either. Chicago does need a reprieve but it needs a solution, too, and this ain’t it.

1 comment

Reflections on Propaganda

Over the weekend I thought about what new hook I could use for posting about Memorial Day. I’ve explained its history multiple times and related my own almost entirely non-military family history. Except for my mom’s Uncle Ed who was one of the happy few who participated in World War II, the Korean War, and the Vietnam War.

I’ve written posts about war movies and multiple posts about movies specifically appropriate for Memorial Day (here and then here).

I thought about organizing movies according to the wars that they portray. Have you ever noticed how few decent movies there are about the American Revolutionary War? Recently, there’s The Patriot but that’s about it. I can think of more movies about the French-Indian War than about the War of the American Revolution.

I can’t think of any good movies about the War of 1812 which I guess is understandable since we lost it. Movies have been made about it, certainly, but they’re mostly 1950s or early 1960s Hollywood fluff. They aren’t even good drama let alone good history.

Appropriately enough, there are a number of good movies about the American Civil War. Particularly notable are The Red Badge of Courage, Glory, Friendly Persuasion, and Shenandoah.

The only pictures I can think of about the Spanish American War or the Mexican American War are pretty awful.

There are a number of good movies about World War I: The Big Parade, Wings, Hell’s Angels, The Fighting 69th, and The Story of Sergeant York, just off the top of my head.

It was when I began thinking about the movies made about more recent wars that I noticed something interesting. Just as an aside, it occurred to me that World War II is now almost as remote in time as the American Civil War was when I was a kid. Times passes.

But what I began thinking about when I thought about more recent movies was propaganda movies. American propaganda movies seem to fall into several different categories.

First, there are advocacy movies. Just to name two of my favorite directors, Alfred Hitchcock and Michael Powell, Hitchcock’s Foreign Correspondent closes with a stirring call to arms encouraging American entry into the war while Michael Powell’s A Canterbury Tale is clearly intended to highlight the ties between the United States and the United Kingdom with the point that England is worth fighting for.

The second type of American propaganda movie is exemplified by The Northern Star and Days of Glory (Gregory Peck’s first starring role). Both of these movies dramatize how wonderful and heroic our Soviet allies were.

The third type of American propaganda movie is the hate movie. Hitchcock’s Lifeboat is arguably an anti-German hate movie as is Michael Powell’s 49th Parallel. The real vitriol was directed against the Japanese with The Purple Heart being the standout. It’s the archetype of the anti-Japanese hate film.

The fourth type of propaganda film is the anti-war picture. The best Vietnam War pictures fit into this classification, e.g. The Deer Hunter, Apocalypse Now, Platoon, etc.

7 comments

Atomic Weapons Can’t Be Undone

I commend President Obama for taking the path that I suggested was my preference during his visit to Hiroshima and keeping his eyes fixed on the horizon rather than looking back.

Unfortunately, it is no more possible to abolish nuclear weapons than it would be projectile weapons. They’ve been invented and that can’t be undone.

6 comments

Nostalgia Ain’t What It Used to Be

Writing at Time Rana Foroohar says that Paul Krugman’s and Hillary Clinton’s recollections of the 1990s are wrong:

In his column, Krugman advocates thinking about the policies of the 1990s as a model for how to create another bout of prosperity. But what were those policies, exactly?

Bob Rubin, then Treasury secretary, balanced the budget and focused on market-led growth, rather than the massive public investment plan advocated by the other Bob, former labor secretary Robert Reich. Reich’s strategy of real, sustained investment in infrastructure and education (which Bill Clinton actually campaigned on) was deep sixed in favor of a more market-oriented, quick hit growth plan.

“I pushed hard for a major public investment strategy, but it got ground up in demands from Republicans and some Democrats to cut the budget deficit,” says Reich, now a professor at Berkeley. “In some ways, it was an early exercise in austerity economics.”

Would the Rubin strategy work today? Absolutely not. If we tried to balance the budget right now, we’d get European-style austerity. And while we still rely on the sugar high of super low interest rates, their effectiveness for boosting Main Street has decreased. Low rates have led to record stock prices, but Main Street growth is still sluggish, and wages are still relatively flat (as is productivity).

I think they’re wrong for another reason: the boom of the 1990s was a consequence of about 15 years of technology investment, something that has not continued and might not produce the same outcomes even if it were.

2 comments

The Little Recovery That Wasn’t There

I generally find Jeffrey Snider’s posts at RealClearMarkets dense and prolix but I generally learn something, if only how certain kinds of investors think. I found his most recent offering quite interesting. The gist of it is that all of the blithe reassurances we’ve been receiving from the BLS for the last seven years or so have been bogus and there really hasn’t been much of any recovery at all:

A recession is a temporary deviation from trend, which is why the Census Bureau spent a lot of time and effort in determining trend-cycle components as the largest potential source of variation. The trend is supposed to remain dominant even for each given cycle. What we see here after the Great Recession is nothing like a cycle. Instead of a temporary drop below trend, even if that “temporary” was somewhat longer than usual, we increasingly find that the overall trend itself has been suppressed. Given that the trough of the Great Recession occurred in the middle of 2009, seven years is more than enough time to make such a momentous declaration: the economy didn’t fall into a recession great or otherwise, it shrunk.

That’s quite consistent with Keynesian theory. If the shortfall in aggregate demand persists, it becomes structural, i.e. results in a permanent contraction in aggregate product.

All of this highlights my frustration with economists, generally, and government economists in particular. When you’re going to build a bridge across a river, you use ordinary surveying methods to measure the span. When your measurements tell you that the bridge needs to be 800 meters long, you can fudge that with centimeters here and there or even a couple of meters but you don’t try to fudge it so that your bridge is a third of the length your measurements suggest it is or three times what they’re telling you.

But that’s exactly what’s being done in employment. The fudge factors are so much larger than the measured changes they’re reporting there’s really got to be something wrong.

I honestly don’t see any way what we’ve seen in employment or industrial production fits with the explanations we’re being given.

6 comments

Predictions

I think it’s time for a prediction. What’s going to happen?

  1. The FBI releases its report on issues related to Hillary Clinton’s email server after Sec. Clinton has already clinched her party’s nomination for the presidency. It does not recommend that anything be sent to a grand jury. At the convention Sec. Clinton becomes the Democratic nominee and goes on to win the presidency in November.
  2. Same as A but Clinton loses in November.
  3. The FBI releases its report on issues related to Hillary Clinton’s email server before the California primary. It recommends that the issue be sent to a grand jury. Sec. Clinton is trounced in the remaining primaries and superdelegates desert her in droves. At the convention Bernie Sanders becomes the Democratic nominee and goes on to win the presidency in November.
  4. Same as C but Sanders loses in November.
  5. The FBI releases its report on issues related to Hillary Clinton’s email server before the California primary. It recommends that the issue be sent to a grand jury. Sec. Clinton is trounced in the remaining primaries and she withdraws from the campaign. Through some sort of convention machinations Joe Biden becomes the Democratic nominee and goes on to win the election in November.
  6. Same as E but Biden’s nomination fractures the Democratic Party and Biden loses in November.
  7. The FBI does not release its report until after the November election and Hillary Clinton has been elected president despite the email issue being a constant source of irritation. The FBI’s report does not recommend that the case be sent to a grand jury. This results in mass resignations at the FBI and a number of extremely embarrassing things that have emerged from the FBI’s investigation are leaked to the media.
  8. The FBI does not release its report until after the November election and Hillary Clinton has been elected president despite the email issue being a constant source of irritation. The FBI’s report recommends that the case be sent to a grand jury. The grand jury finds cause to send the case to trial. Hillary Clinton is impeached and her vice president (whoever that is) becomes president.
  9. Roll your own.

As of this writing I think the greatest likelihood is A followed by B but I’m interested in getting your opinion.

Winners and losers would make an interesting prediction, too. It’s possible that the FBI could be the biggest loser from an institutional standpoint.

9 comments

Systemic Failure

Leave aside Peggy Noonan’s comments in her most recent Wall Street Journal column on Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump. This summary of the IRS scandal:

A high official in the IRS named Lois Lerner targets those she finds politically hateful. IRS officials are in the White House a lot, which oddly enough finds the same people hateful. News of the IRS targeting is about to break because an inspector general is on the case, so Ms. Lerner plants a question at a conference, answers with a rehearsed lie, tries to pin the scandal on workers in a cubicle farm in Cincinnati, lies some more, gets called into Congress, takes the Fifth—and then retires with full pension and benefits, bonuses intact. Taxpayers will be footing the bill for years for the woman who in some cases targeted them, and blew up the reputation of the IRS.

Why wouldn’t Americans think the system is rigged?

is not only succinct, it neatly divides the country into two groups: those who think this reflects a systemic failure and those who don’t.

I think it does represent such a failure and that you don’t need to be a Republican to think so, indeed, it’s an outrage that some people believe that only Republicans think so.

6 comments

Where You Stand, Where You Sit, and Email

I was too overwhelmed with work to write about it yesterday but as you undoubtedly know the State Department’s Inspector General released a report on Sec. Clinton’s handling of email that was highly critical of Sec. Clinton among others. From Jonathan Allen’s report at Reuters:

Hillary Clinton broke government rules by using a private email server without approval for her work as U.S. secretary of state, an internal government watchdog said on Wednesday.

The long-awaited report by the State Department inspector general was the first official audit of the controversial arrangement to be made public. It was highly critical of Clinton’s use of a server in her home, and immediately fueled Republican attacks on Clinton, the Democratic front-runner in an already acrimonious presidential race.

The report, which also found problems in department record-keeping practices before Clinton’s tenure, undermined Clinton’s earlier defenses of her emails, likely adding to Democratic anxieties about public perceptions of the candidate. A majority of voters say Clinton is dishonest, according to multiple polls.

The report concluded that Clinton would not have been allowed to use the server in her home had she asked the department officials in charge of information security. The report said that staff who later raised concerns were told to keep quiet. Several suspected hacking attempts in 2011 were never reported to department information security officials, in breach of department rules, it said.

The editors of the Washington Post declaimed:

HILLARY CLINTON’S use of a private email server while secretary of state from 2009 to 2013 has been justifiably criticized as an error of judgment. What the new report from the State Department inspector general makes clear is that it also was not a casual oversight. Ms. Clinton had plenty of warnings to use official government communications methods, so as to make sure that her records were properly preserved and to minimize cybersecurity risks. She ignored them.

and the editors of the Wall Street Journal add:

Hillary Clinton has said for more than a year that her use of a private email server as Secretary of State violated no federal rules and posed no security risk. Only the gullible believed that, and now everyone has proof of her deceptions in a scathing report from State Department Inspector General Steve Linick.

The report obtained by news outlets Wednesday is ostensibly an audit of the email practices of five secretaries of State. But the majority of the report, and the most withering criticism, focuses on Mrs. Clinton. The IG concludes that the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee broke federal record-keeping rules, never received permission for her off-grid server, ignored security concerns raised by other officials, and employed a staff that flouted the rules with the same disdain she did.

Whether the report is “scathing” or a “nothingburger” depends somewhat on where the author sits. Austin Bay remarks:

In a pre-release copy of a report on Hillary Cinton’s failure to obey federal record-keeping laws, which Politico obtained, the State Department’s Office of the Inspector General (OIG) delivers an 83-page doozy.

The State Department inspector general’s office concluded that the former Secretary of State violated legally-mandated record keeping requirements. Quote: “Secretary Clinton should have preserved any federal records she created and received on her personal account by printing and filing those records with the related files in the Office of the Secretary. At a minimum, Secretary Clinton should have surrendered all emails dealing with Department business before leaving government service and, because she did not do so, she did not comply with the department’s policies that were implemented in accordance with the Federal Records Act.” (That’s on document page 23, page 26 of the pdf. Check it out.)

Bureaucratese riddles that last sentence, but the message is clear: she broke the law. Hillary Clinton has indeed done something wrong—her claims of innocence to the contrary.

while Josh Marshall, always a reliable weathervane of the DNC position, wearily writes:

A brief note on the State Department IG Report on the Clinton email issue. The ledes of a lot of stories present this as a rough hit for Clinton, bad news blah blah blah. Let’s focus on the essential point: Despite the fact that there are some real questions about the impartiality of the IG, the report says the issues with the management of the Secretary of State’s emails are of longstanding and go back with the last five Secretaries of State. The report also singles out Colin Powell, who had a similar set up. The criticism is there. It definitely wasn’t a good arrangement. But to see this as a damaging report after the hyperbolic and frequently insane coverage of this issue is crazy. This was never more than some poor judgment overlayed by a big bureaucratic pissing match all slathered over by a thick layer of partisan game playing and media derp.

Like most Clinton scandals, if there there hadn’t been months, maybe more than a year of weird conspiracy theories, expected perp walks and general nonsense, one might read this and say, wow, that’s disappointing. But after all that, it’s just a big nothingburger. Like it almost always is.

The reactions from defenders of Hillary Clinton follow a well-trod path: it’s old news and everybody does it. Neither of those is exculpatory. And arguing that everybody does it is the basis of Donald Trump’s campaign. Indeed, it seems to me that if that’s your argument, you’re advocating a vote for Trump, the “Control-Alt-Delete candidate”.

The IG’s report increases the urgency of the FBI’s report on its investigation. If the FBI fails to indict, it will call the agency’s integrity into question and, based on the leaks from the FBI, I would expect some insurgency from within the organization.

I hope the report is forthcoming before the California primary. That would, at least, provide the Democratic Party with some options that may be foreclosed later on.

10 comments

The Rectification of Names

Assault and battery are not legitimate forms of protest. Neither are throwing rocks at police, smashing doors in, and breaking down barriers.

Let’s not dignify these actions by calling them “protests”. They’re thuggery. Or rioting.

24 comments