Rejecting a Universal Basic Income

The BBC reports that with characteristic prudence three-quarters of Swiss voters have rejected a universal basic income for Switzerland:

Swiss voters have overwhelmingly rejected a proposal to introduce a guaranteed basic income for all.
Final results from Sunday’s referendum showed that nearly 77% opposed the plan, with only 23% backing it.
The proposal had called for adults to be paid an unconditional monthly income, whether they worked or not.
The supporters camp had suggested a monthly income of 2,500 Swiss francs (£1,755; $2,555) for adults and also SFr625 for each child.

The reasons given by the Swiss for rejecting the proposal reflected a concern that millions of people would flock into Switzerland, drawn by the subsidy. In the context of a million refugees streaming from the miserable countries of West Asia, the Middle East, and North Africa into Europe in 2015 with 2016 on target to exceed that number and the manifest willingness of the migrants to venue shop for the best package of subsidies, the Swiss’s concerns are well-founded. Add to that a desire to remain Swiss, something that even the Dalai Lama has proclaimed justifiable.

Closer to home when I read Charles Murray’s Wall Street Journal op-ed proposing a universal basic income for the United States, I didn’t know whether to file it under “Business and Economics”, “Politics”, or “Humor”, presumably after the fashion of Jonathan Swift’s A Modest Proposal. This is a plan he’s been pushing for a decade. The gist of the plan is that the U. S. would pay a $13,000 basic income to every American, $3,000 of which would earmarked for healthcare insurance and the plan would be paid for by abolishing the Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid programs:

First, my big caveat: A UBI will do the good things I claim only if it replaces all other transfer payments and the bureaucracies that oversee them. If the guaranteed income is an add-on to the existing system, it will be as destructive as its critics fear.

Second, the system has to be designed with certain key features. In my version, every American citizen age 21 and older would get a $13,000 annual grant deposited electronically into a bank account in monthly installments. Three thousand dollars must be used for health insurance (a complicated provision I won’t try to explain here), leaving every adult with $10,000 in disposable annual income for the rest of their lives.

It’s hard to know where to start in critiquing such a plan. I’ll start by pointing out that health insurance for a single person costs about $8,000 per year exclusive of subsidies and his plan presupposes no subsidies. The median apartment rental in the cheapest of the 25 largest metropolitan areas (where about half of Americans live) is $1,300 per month.

It isn’t often that you run into a proposal that makes an assumption and its opposite within the same argument but that seems to be the case for Dr. Murray’s plan. His argument is based on the idea that jobs will become increasingly hard to come by but the only way that many people who are presently unemployed will be able to survive under Dr. Murray’s plan is by getting a job.

Roughly a third of those over the age of 65 live almost entirely on Social Security. Without Social Security, Medicare, or Medicaid or any other form of “safety net” program how the heck does he expect them to survive other than by taking a non-existent job that they wouldn’t be hired for anyway? Or does he expect them to hurry up and die so it will decrease the surplus population?

4 comments

Don’t Do Violence

I’m trying to understand the behavioral model that Ms. McGowan is advocating:

As 20th Century Fox’s X-Men: Apocalypse stormed theaters over the long weekend, critics took aim at billboards featuring Oscar Isaac’s Apocalypse choking Jennifer Lawrence’s Mystique.

Among them was Rose McGowan, who elaborated on a May 25 Facebook post to THR: “There is a major problem when the men and women at 20th Century Fox think casual violence against women is the way to market a film. There is no context in the ad, just a woman getting strangled. The fact that no one flagged this is offensive and frankly, stupid. The geniuses behind this, and I use that term lightly, need to to take a long hard look at the mirror and see how they are contributing to society. Imagine if it were a black man being strangled by a white man, or a gay male being strangled by a hetero? The outcry would be enormous. So let’s right this wrong. 20th Century Fox, since you can’t manage to put any women directors on your slate for the next two years, how about you at least replace your ad?”

She continued: “I’ll close with a text my friend sent, a conversation with his daughter. It follows: ‘My daughter and I were just having a deep discussion on the brutality of that hideous X-Men poster yesterday. Her words: ‘Dad, why is that monster man committing violence against a woman?’ This from a 9-year-old. If she can see it, why can’t Fox?”

The article includes a picture of the billboard in question.

Here’s my question. Would Ms. McGowan accept a depiction of a man being throttled by Apocalypse? Would she accept a depiction of a woman throttling a man? The content of a billboard advert is clear: it’s the movie. X-Men movies appeal to the fans. They expect violence.

I’m probably the only person in this audience who’s actually fought women in martial arts competitions. I have occasionally inflicted serious injury on women against whom I’ve competed. Not deliberately. They’re just too fragile.

I think that depictions of men and women inflicting violence on each other should be avoided even in fantasy movies because it’s just too dangerous a norm but if you accept that you must accept the possibility of men inflicting violent injury on women needs to be accepted as well. When depicted it should be done so realistically and brutally which means that women may be injured. Anything else is delusional and, consequently, dangerous.

10 comments

Lies, Damned Lies, and Statistics

Here’s the peroration of the editors of the Wall Street Journal’s remarks on the Bureau of Labor Statistics Employment Situation for May 2016:

Which brings us back to Mr. Obama’s magical economic recovery tour. He kicked it off this week with a return to Elkhart, Indiana, where he touted the area’s 4% jobless rate as the recreational-vehicle industry has recovered. He knows his legacy is on the line in November, and he can read the polls that show that Donald Trump is leading Hillary Clinton on who would do better for the economy.

Thus his economic pep talk and attempt to rebut what he called “myths” spread by Republicans and the “conservative” media about slow growth and mediocre incomes. But he doesn’t need to blame us. His bigger beef is with Mrs. Clinton and Bernie Sanders, who have spent the last year deploring the economic condition of America’s middle class. And as of Friday with his own Labor Department, which reported facts that are hard even for this President to spin away.

But who ya gonna believe? The president or your own lyin’ eyes? which highlights the predicament in which Hillary Clinton finds herself. Willy nilly she’s running for President Obama’s third term and on her husband’s coat tails. Indeed, she has no campaign without them. But she’s also basing her campaign on running against Obama’s record and her husband’s policies. It’s an impossible balancing act. No wonder she’s counting on a tribal election.

1 comment

The Sum of All Fears

In his analysis of Hillary Clinton’s critique of Donald Trump’s foreign policy positions at the Washington Post, Dan Drezner provides what I think may be the best pocket summary of the incipient election to date:

Look, if you want to intellectualize the foreign policy portion of this campaign, let me suggest relying on Walter Russell Mead’s typologies. On foreign policy, this election is about Clinton uniting the Hamiltonians and Wilsonians, the Jacksonians finding their savior in Trump, and the Jeffersonians pulling their hair out in despair. But I’m not even sure that’s completely accurate.

I’ve described those typologies here. I’m a Jeffersonian (with a dash of Jacksonian).

Dan, no Trump supporter, has the same problem Hillary Clinton does. Most of the electorate are not intellectuals. And “Dangerous Donald” is a bad nickname for her to latch onto Trump. For much of the electorate dangerous is good. Particularly when the status quo is intolerable.

10 comments

The Impasse

Author Amy Hassinger’s cri de cÅ“ur over the consequences of Illinois’s budget impasse on higher education in the state is the lead op-ed this morning on the New York Times opinion page:

Urbana, Ill. — THIS spring my friend’s daughter received exciting news: She had been accepted to the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. It’s our hometown campus, but also the state’s flagship public university and one of the best research institutions in the country.

My friend is a single mom with a few part-time jobs; finances are tight in her house. But the university offered them a decent financial aid package, one that would have made it possible for her daughter to attend. If, that is, it was an offer they could count on. But they couldn’t. The financial aid letter clearly stated that their award was “contingent upon continued funding” from the state, and might need to be “reduced or rescinded,” depending on what happened in Springfield, the state capital.

Ah, Springfield.

Our lawmakers have spent the last year locked in a staggering budget impasse, with no end in sight. The state is deep in debt, with mountains of unpaid bills, while the Democratic-led Legislature and the Republican governor fight a war of attrition. Another deadline just blew by this week: May 31 was the last official day of the legislative session. Still no budget. Any proposal now needs a three-fifths majority to pass, an even higher bar. Meanwhile, the collateral damage is swirling like sand in a windstorm.

She continues with a litany of the woes that colleges and universities face in the absence of their stipends from the state and concludes:

Illinoisans are fed up. Yes, the problem is gnarly and complicated. Yes, the political divisions are deep and wide, just as they are nationally. But our governor and legislators must find a way to cross them soon and to pass a functional budget, before the damage they’ve already done to public higher education becomes irreversible. Until they do, our best students will head elsewhere for college — or, even worse, nowhere at all.

We’re in this situation because Illinois politicians have been behaving irresponsibly for, literally, generations, spending more than revenues would allow and borrowing the rest. Borrowing in order to consume more is a reasonable strategy in periods of high inflation or robust growth when it becomes easier to make each successive payment. It’s dangerously irrational when inflation is low (or, worse, there’s deflation) and when growth is slow or nonexistent and a declining population suggests that will be the case for the foreseeable future.

Illinois already has the highest real estate and sales taxes in the country. Its state income tax is among the lowest so, obviously, that’s a tempting target. Illinois cannot impose a graduated income tax without amending the state’s constitution.

Illinois’s governor has refused to sign budgets delivered to him by the legislature that are out of balance in violation of constitutional requirements, particularly in the absence of action on his “turnaround agenda”, a laundry list of reforms including a property tax freeze, spending cuts, limitations on public employee unions, and reforms to workman’s comp. He won’t relinquish the only bargaining chip he has in a state in which both houses have Democratic supermajorities and, given the will, can override any veto he may impose.

The state legislature for its part finds item on the “turnaround agenda” anathema and won’t take responsibility for the fecklessness of its actions. House Speaker Mike Madigan, who’s held his job for most of the last 40 years and whose fingerprints are all over Illinois’s problems, would apparently rather have the election issue than a resolution.

And here we stand. Both sides seem to think they’re winning. We’re entering our second consecutive year without a budget. Illinoisans aren’t winning.

2 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

The announcement post at the Watcher’s site is here.

0 comments

We Have Our Own Facts

I weep when I think of Pat Moynihan. Contra his famous quip, nowadays everybody does have their own facts. There’s a sort of blog war going on right now which I find amusing in a gallows humor sort of way. First, Zero Hedge produced some charts right off a Bloomberg terminal. Then Donald Trump tweeted the charts. Then Philip Bump fact-checked the charts at the Washington Post.

Now Zero Hedge has come back to explicate its charts, laced with a sizable dollop of mockery:

As author Philip Bump, who apparently has never encountered a Bloomberg terminal before, says, “there are nine little graphs embedded in there, with hard-to-read axes and unclear provenance for the numbers, all of which are meant to bolster one argument: Barack Obama’s presidency has been bad.”

Well, Philip, you can interpret the “bolstering” in any way you want, what you can’t however interpret are the facts – which is what those charts show. Of course, everyone can make up their own conclusion about what the ongoing economic deterioration means: one can even say that almost 8 years later, it is still “Bush’s fault.”

Alas, we were naive to assume that the WaPo can’t “fact-check” charts based on facts. Because that is precisely what they did. And in doing so it provided much amusement.

The entire exchange is an exercise in futility. Everybody has their own facts. For each fact there is a contradictory fact. If you point out the low rate of job growth (and the number of people who are so frustrated they’ve given up looking), someone else will point out the low rate of unemployment. If you point out the shallowness of the recovery, someone else will point out its duration. If you point out the number of jobs that have been created over the last seven years, someone else will contrast the jobs lost with the jobs created.

The facts are being sprayed out as octopi spray out ink.

As I’ve said before, my approach is to count the teeth. If it doesn’t feel like a robust recovery, it isn’t one. Maybe I’m just prejudiced by living in Chicago.

4 comments

Remember Syria?

It was in all the papers. The fight against DAESH in Syria continues, as reported by ABC News:

U.S.-backed fighters pushed ahead in their offensive in northern Syria Friday, getting closer to a stronghold of the Islamic State group, opposition activists said.

The predominantly Kurdish Syria Democratic Forces took at least four more villages on the way to the IS-held city of Manbij, according to two activist groups, the Britain-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights and the Local Coordination Committee.

On Wednesday SDF fighters, aided by U.S.-led airstrikes, launched their offensive on Manbij, which is on a key supply route linking the Turkish border to the city of Raqqa, the extremist group’s de facto capital.

If the pictures from the combat area are any gauge, the offense against DAESH in Syria is getting increasing support from US “boots on the ground”, too.

Meanwhile, is anyone interested in starting a pool on when the Iraqi Army is going to begin its offensive to retake Mosul? That seems to be proceeding in Friedman Units.

1 comment

Wages Here and Wages There

WagesMap2000-2015

A topic that I’ve returned to repeatedly here is that averages don’t really tell you the story of today’s economy. The map above, from this report at Pew Research really caught my eye:

Workers in America’s oil and gas patches have enjoyed some of the country’s biggest gains in the buying power of their paychecks over the past decade and a half, while workers in several small and mid-sized manufacturing-oriented cities have watched their buying power shrink over the same time period.

A Pew Research Center analysis of federal wage data found that since 2000, most of the biggest inflation-adjusted gains in average weekly wages have occurred in metropolitan areas that have directly benefited from the boom in U.S. energy production – places like Midland and Odessa, Texas; Bismarck, North Dakota; Casper, Wyoming; and Houma and Lake Charles, Louisiana.

With the end of the oil boom a lot of those gains have now been given up.

Note a couple of things about that map. First, it’s very spotty—wage gains aren’t spread evenly across the country. Second, the increases in wages from oil-producing areas pointed out in the report.

Third, real wages over the 15 year period have really been pretty flat. But fourth, the areas surrounding state capitols with only a few rare exceptions are doing better than other areas in their states.

That tells an important story that hasn’t been emphasized enough. I think it also highlights why the primary election cycle proceeded as it did.

Hat tip: Zero Hedge

4 comments

Kwitcherbellyakin

At Bloomberg Justin Fox echoes the point I made yesterday:

Now, I realize that $100,000 or $200,000 or even $423,090 doesn’t go nearly as far in New York City or San Francisco as it does in, say, McAllen, Texas. There are lots of people making that kind of money in big cities and fancy suburbs who don’t have much in the way of savings and are stretching to make their mortgage payments.

These are the folks my former Fortune magazine colleague Shawn Tully dubbed “HENRYs” (for high earners, not rich yet), and economists Greg Kaplan, Giovanni L. Violante and Justin Weidner called “the wealthy hand-to-mouth.” They work long hours, they make big investments in education for themselves and their kids, and they pay among the country’s highest tax rates (the federal tax system is progressive up to somewhere high in the One Percent, where capital gains income and tax shelters begin to bring rates down). They’re not spending their days lounging poolside or eating bon bons — although I can report from personal experience that some of them permit themselves a piece or two of dark chocolate before bed.

But are these people affluent? Heck yeah! The median household income in the U.S. in 2014 was $53,657. If you’re making twice that, or more, you are doing quite well from the perspective of your fellow citizens in what happens to be one of the richest nations on earth.

I continue to think we have a major problem of unrealistic expectations. Our wherewithal says “rent” while the society says “buy”. Our earnings say “Versa” while our aspirations say “Mercedes”. And there’s all of that lovely credit leading you to borrow more and more.

3 comments