Over at Bloomberg Megan McArdle gives her reaction to the Swiss rejection of a universal basic income that I wrote about yesterday:
Oh, we weren’t going to get rid of Medicare? Nor Medicaid or Obamacare? And of course we’ll keep providing public schooling, and assistance for disabled children, and…. By the time you’ve started saving programs that obviously can’t be cut without immiserating large chunks of the population who currently rely on the government, what you have is a $2.7 trillion program to substitute for Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (welfare), unemployment insurance, Social Security and food stamps — four programs upon which the federal government currently spends about $1.2 trillion.
Moreover, since the grant would be, in many cases, less generous than what a lot of people are currently collecting, we will probably have to either top up for those groups, or increase the size of the benefit, until we have a $3 trillion or $4 trillion program to replace $1.2 trillion worth of welfare spending. Even if we tax back the whole benefit from higher earners (which would reintroduce many of the marginal tax problems we were trying to avoid with the UBI in the first place), the dead-weight loss of the additional taxation needed to pay for this program will probably harm economic growth, making the program more expensive still. I’m not a supply-side hawk who thinks that any tax increases will plunge us all back into the dark ages, but running an additional $2 trillion to $3 trillion through government coffers every year might give even some ardent big-government Democrats pause.
These numbers are, of course, specific to the U.S., but the problem is the same in any developed country. Handing out a universal benefit of any size at all will be fantastically expensive. You can make it smaller, of course, but then you don’t get any of the vaunted benefits: It doesn’t prevent the benefit cliffs, doesn’t encourage entrepreneurship, doesn’t lessen the distortions of all the in-kind benefits you’ve left in place.
One of the key points is that the advocates of a UBI are trying to address a problem that we don’t actually have, may never have, and for which there are politically simpler solutions: displacement of workers by automation.
Whatever degree technological unemployment is presently a problem is overwhelmed by any number of other laws, regulations, and other policies we’ve introduced over the years. There are good reasons for some of them, e.g. some environmental regulations. The reasons are less good for others, e.g. occupational licensing requirements for jobs that don’t require much in the way of skills.
Something that’s generally ignored is there’s no law of nature that the proceeds that result from the market distortions that are created by such laws, regulations, and policies need to remain in the hands of those who benefit from them. IMO that should be the first line of recourse: either getting rid of unnecessary regulations or getting rid of the deadweight loss from necessary regulations.
That won’t solve the problems of poverty and unemployment in one, grand master stroke but good stewardship frequently requires boring, detailed work rather than grand master strokes.