The Art of Controlling the News

There are many ways in which the news media groom the news. The most obvious strategy is by what they choose to report. If the AP, New York Times, and Washington Post run with the same story incessantly for days, it will assume importance regardless of its actual merit. It’s effective. It’s one of the reasons Donald Trump is on the brink of becoming the Republican nominee for president of the United States.

There’s another way in which the news is groomed or, as I suspect they would prefer to think of it, curated and that’s by what the major news outlets refuse to report or put into the back pages or their digital equivalents. That’s even more effective and not nearly as overt. It’s darned hard for a story that the major news outlets aren’t interested in to get any traction.

What was the most important story of yesterday? I think it was the murder by a DAESH-affiliated terrorist of a French police commander in Paris in broad daylight, which the editors of the Wall Street Journal have decided to remark on today:

Nearly lost amid the coverage of the weekend’s Orlando terror attack, Monday evening saw another Islamic State outrage in France. This time the victims were a senior police officer and his companion, stabbed to death in and around their home by a man who pledged support to Islamic State and uploaded a video of the murders on the internet. The victims are survived by their 3-year-old son, who witnessed the attack.

The alleged attacker identified by prosecutors, Larossi Abballa, was known to authorities. He spent several years in prison after a conviction for membership in a French group feeding recruits to al Qaeda in Pakistan and Afghanistan. He was under surveillance before Monday’s attack. After police killed him while storming the victims’ house they found a list of other potential targets. Islamic State claimed responsibility for the attack.

The human interest stories of the grief of the family and friends of the victims of the Orlando murders are bathos. They aren’t news. They should be left to their grief and we shouldn’t wallow in it or be forced to do so.

The French must be asking themselves if a police commander in France’s largest city isn’t safe, who is? France is teetering on the brink of a political upheaval. This story is another push towards that brink and its importance shouldn’t be ignored.

IMO this story was pretty darned important, too. Russian government hackers breached the Democratic National Committee’s servers. What did they go after? Their oppo research on Donald Trump. Why? I think they’re trying to figure him out. When, as I think is inevitable, they decide they’d rather deal with him than Hillary Clinton, expect a deluge of the material they hacked from Sec. Clinton’s private email server (or received from third parties) to become public. Sec. Clinton’s problems over what she acknowledges was her mistaken use of an insecure private email server are just beginning.

11 comments

Vote of No Confidence

As you might guess the State of Illinois has a formal process by which it solicits bids for the various goods and services the state purchases. First, the state issues a request for bid. Then there’s a hearing for prospective vendors. And so on.

The state is now entering its second year without a budget and there’s been an interesting development. As it works out I’m on the state’s RFP mailing list (it’s a long story) and over the last week or so all of the hearings have been cancelled because no vendors signed up to attend.

Maybe that’s just a fluke and next week it will be different. But if that continues it really sounds like a no confidence vote. Vendors need to be paid and many of them can’t wait two or three years after delivering the goods or performing the services before they are.

1 comment

Why Increase Federal Taxes?

I have to confess that I found Jared Bernstein’s article at The American Prospect baffling. Summarizing his proposals for increasing federal taxes is easy: reverse every tax cut of the last thirty-five years. He makes only the flimsiest of arguments for why we should do that.

His explanation stands on a number of planks. First, cutting taxes doesn’t promote economic growth:

Most of the Democrats on the committee rightly and soundly objected to the supply-side fairy dust, pointing out that no evidence exists to support that case. As nonpartisan tax economist Bill Gale and colleagues recently wrote, “At the federal level, there is virtually no evidence that broad-based tax cuts have had a positive effect on growth. … That has been amply demonstrated at the national level, where tax cuts have eroded revenue without discernable effect on economic activity.”

Second, there are a lot of things that could be done with more money (from the slug):

More tax dollars will be essential to improve our infrastructure, push back on global warming, fight poverty and inequality, and improve health and retirement security.

That there is no consensus and maybe not even a Congressional majority in favor of such things and that there is very little evidence that federal spending will accomplish any of those objectives do not seem to figure in his calculus.

Infrastructure spending is usually brought up in the context of Keynesian stimulus. If that’s his context, I don’t think that Mr. Bernstein is clear on the concept since it requires federal spending without increasing federal revenues to be effective. All other things being equal increasing federal taxes in order to increase federal spending will almost certainly reduce private sector economic growth through deadweight loss if nothing else.

Arguing that tax cuts thirty-five years ago do not produce economic growth now does not imply that tax increases today will not reduce private sector growth today is specious.

Finally, he refers obliquely to “demographic pressures” as a justification. I presume that by that he means the increasing number of Americans over the age of 65. I don’t find the idea of increasing the inter-generational income transfer that he’s implicitly proposing particularly appealing but I’d like to see him make the argument. He could start with the phrase “We should tax young black and brown Americans to pay more to older, wealthier, mostly white Americans because…” My suspicion is that he will find his ideas politically unpalatable.

If he means something else by “demographic pressures”, I think he should specify what he’s talking about a bit.

Social Security is not threatened by an aging America. It’s threatened because too little income is subject to the tax. That’s relatively easy to remedy, either by increasing FICA max. And Medicare’s problem isn’t that too many people are being covered under the program. It’s that healthcare in the United States is too expensive, something that can’t be cured by spending more money as should be apparent by now.

I see very little case that the federal tax code is an effective tool for reducing income inequality. Quite to the contrary I think there’s a much better case that it’s a good tool for increasing income inequality.

1 comment

How Do You Defend What You Don’t Believe In?

Brendan O’Neill remarks on the response to the murders in Orlando:

Consider how extraordinary this is: in less than 48 hours, the Western response to a horrific massacre of our fellow Westerners, of our fellow democratic citizens, became bound up in divisive discussions over terms and jealous efforts to ‘own’ the massacre. Where once we might have responded to such an act with human empathy, and with a determination to come together to insist on the right of all people to live as they please, now we fight over who has the greatest moral claims on the massacre; we police emotional reactions.

which I find very reminiscent of what I predicted when I first heard about the horrific incident. And while his closing exhortation:

Our response to Orlando should be a human one, a renewed determination to defend humanist ideals against murderers and misanthropes who seek to slay them. Let us now fight harder than ever for the value of human solidarity, and for the greatest humanist ideal of all, the one most under threat from both Islamists and identitarians in the 21st-century West: that people should be free to think, say and live as they please, regardless of who it offends.

is appealing I think it misses the point. Just here in the United States there is disagreement. Not all of us believe that people “should be free to think, say and live as they please”.

That’s a critical division. It’s what prevents us from responding with anything other than a cacophony.

10 comments

Concentrating the Mind

Amazingly, Illinois voters have actually been paying attention. From the Illinois Mirror:

Governor Bruce Rauner and House Speaker Michael Madigan have spent the better part of the last several weeks blaming each other for the state’s historic budget impasse. Capitol Fax’s Rich Miller conducted a poll that revealed who voters blame, and the results are unequivocal.
On Tuesday, June 7, Miller sent an email to Capitol Fax subscribers detailing the results of “a recent Capitol Fax/We Ask America poll” that were “particularly negative for anyone who can be credibly connected to House Speaker Michael Madigan.”
The poll showed that voters overwhelmingly blame Speaker Madigan for the contentious budget impasse that has been plaguing the state for nearly a year.

The poll was of 1,231 registered Illinois voters and was taken June 5-6.

It remains to be seen whether that will have any consequences in November. And, of course, the only poll that really concerns Speaker Madigan is the one that takes place in his district and voters there show few signs of abandoning him.

If you’re wondering about the title to this post it’s a hat tip to Dr. Johnson who remarked that having been sentenced to death in a fortnight tends to concentrate the mind.

8 comments

Do We Need More Doctors?

There’s an interesting post at Stateline about how states are trying to cope with the impending shortage of physicians. The estimated shortfall is nearly 100,000.

There are multiple bottlenecks but the most significant is in residencies:

Residencies often are the bottleneck in the physician supply chain.

The AAMC says that the U.S. has a shortage of several hundred residency slots as a result of a cap on Medicare spending on graduate-level medical education.

To translate that for you, the Medicare program pays about $85,000 per year to hospitals per medical resident. No subsidy—no new residents. The average medical resident earns $40,000 to $50,000.

The article mentions telemedicine and expanding the role of nurse practitioners and physician assistants as strategies but there are some things that go unmentioned.

The first and most obvious is automation. There is no sector of the economy so much in need of increased automation as healthcare.

I also wonder how much there’s a shortage of physicians and how much a shortage of internal medicine specialists.

Don’t rely on importing more foreign-trained physicians to solve the shortfall. The competition for internationally trained professionals from other OECD countries, e.g. Canada, UK, France, Germany, is steep. That’s one of the reasons that the wages for GPs are nearly the same in all major OECD countries. Other specialties aren’t nearly as portable and competition will do that, in this case high U. S. wages push up the wages of physicians everywhere.

Hat tip: RealClearHealth

5 comments

He’s Dreaming

The foreign policy advocated by Jerry Hendrix at National Interest, which eschews both isolationism “imposing our traditions on the world” and which he characterizes as a “truly conservative foreign policy, is something I think a lot of Americans would sign on to:

Maybe it’s time to try a classically conservative approach to the world beyond our borders. What would that look like, many might ask? Do you mean isolationism? Do you mean a withdrawal from the world? Of course not. Classic conservatives recognize that the world does exist and that it will and must impact each nation and each must react to those impacts according to established principles and traditions. Certainly the United States, the most powerful nation in the world, in fact the most influential nation that has ever existed, must be prepared to play a leading role, a role that a conservative foreign policy must seek to, well, conserve. How should we go about that?

Too bad there aren’t any true conservatives any more. We’re just offered a choice between neo-conservatism and liberal interventionism.

1 comment

We Won

Among the commentary on the terrible events last night and this morning, I’ve heard several people on the “talking heads” programs lament that with all of the advertising and marketing talent in the West and in the United States in particular we haven’t been able to come up with a counter-narrative with the power to convince those who hate us to change their minds and to deter people from rallying to the banner of the haters.

IMO that reflects an almost complete misunderstanding of what’s happening in the world which can be summed up in two words: we won.

There’s no need to come up with a counter-narrative. The gospel that we’ve been preaching at least for the last 70 years has swept everything before it. Monarchies are teetering on their last legs. Communism has collapsed under the weight of its own inconsistencies—what the Chinese are practicing now isn’t communism, it’s fascism, state capitalism with a nationalistic and racist slant.

What we’re seeing is a last, desperate gasp from traditionalists trying to hold on to a romanticized past. There will always be a few.

My recommendation is enough with the death wish. We have no need of embracing those who want to kill us. Let them kill each other. But don’t abandon a victorious strategy to pacify our enemies.

2 comments

Pushing All of the Buttons


CNN is reporting that there has been a mass shooting in a gay nightclub in Orlando:

Orlando, Florida (CNN)Fifty people were killed inside Pulse, a gay nightclub, Orlando Police Chief John Mina and other officials said Sunday morning, just hours after a shooter opened fire in the deadliest mass shooting in U.S. history.

At least 53 more people were injured, Mina said. Police have shot and killed the gunman, he told reporters.
“It’s appears he was organized and well-prepared,” the chief said, adding that the shooter had an assault-type weapon, a handgun and “some type of (other) device on him.”

Officials warned that a lengthy investigation was ahead, given the number of victims and the scope of the violence.

[…]

The shooter is not from the Orlando area, Mina said. He has been identified as Omar Saddiqui Mateen, 29, of Fort Pierce, about 120 miles southeast of Orlando, two law enforcement officials tell CNN.
Orlando authorities said they consider the violence an act of domestic terror. The FBI is involved. While investigators are exploring all angles, they “have suggestions the individual has leanings towards (Islamic terrorism), but right now we can’t say definitely,” said Ron Hopper, assistant special agent in charge of the FBI’s Orlando bureau.

It’s being characterized as the worst act of terrorism in the United States since 9/11.

First and foremost my heart goes out to the victims, their friends, and their families. But second I weep for my country. This story pushes all of the buttons. Some will inevitably see this story through the prism of gun control. If only, they will say, we prohibited firearms capable of such destruction.

With equal inevitability some will view this story primarily as Islamist terrorism.

Still others will see it an anti-gay hate crime, as proof positive that immigration in the United States is out of control, as a law enforcement problem, as evidence for concealed carry of firearms, or with any of a thousand other preconceived notions. The Blind Men and the Elephant.

And they’ll all be screaming at each other.

Let’s inhale, mourn the dead, and wait until we know more before drawing any conclusions. And let’s not exploit this situation on behalf of our pet causes.

12 comments

The Council Has Spoken!

The Watcher’s Council has announced its winners for last week.

Council Winners

Non-Council Winners

0 comments