There’s an interesting, slightly counter-intuitive claim in this post at The National Interest from John Allen Gay:
Because jihadism is unpopular with the majority of Muslims, the only way that the West could experience waves of Islamist violence is by the admission of large numbers of people from places with these cultural tendencies—by a system of mass immigration with no fundamental restrictions on where that mass immigration comes from. And all this comes as mass immigration is on track to get more massive; at current rates, within ten years the foreign-born share of the U.S. population will be larger than any other time in our history. It’s a similar story in Europe. If current trends continue, the West will only see more violence.
I’ll need to ruminate on that for a while but it made me start thinking. What’s our greatest concern?
The perpetrator in the Orlando murders wasn’t an immigrant. He was the American-born child of immigrants. Similarly, Nidal Hasan, the murderer at Fort Hood was the American-born child of immigrants.
Syed Rizwan Farook, the murderer in the San Bernardino terrorist killings, was also the American-born child of immigrants. His wife was herself an immigrant.
The perpetrators of the Boston Marathon bombings were immigrants and IIRC naturalized American citizens. One of the Tsarnaev brothers came here as a young teenager; the other at eight or nine.
The perpetrators of 9/11 were visitors or on overstayed student or tourist visas.
Now let’s look for commonalities. They were all Muslim. Most were young. Most were men. There’s some evidence that they grew up in homes filled with resentment. The perpetrators of the spree killings were, by and large, native-born albeit reared in immigrant homes. The perpetrators of the mass killings of 9/11, the only incidents that were definitely suicide attacks, were not native-born.
Roughly 70 people were killed in the terrorist spree killings with some scores of injured. Thousands were killed in the 9/11 attacks and thousands more were injured. The number of perpetrators in the terrorist sprees is under a dozen. The number of perpetrators of the 9/11 attacks was 19.
I don’t see a great deal of evidence to support the idea that terrorist attacks can be eliminated or their number reduced simply by not accepting large numbers of Muslim immigrants. The terrorist sprees were mostly perpetrated by native-born Americans and the number of perpetrators is quite small.
If you have discovered a way to prevent resentment in young people, please publicize it. You’re the first.
I think the evidence is actually pretty clear. Whether you’re concerned about terrorist spree killings or mass terrorist attacks (like the 9/11 attacks), there are no non-draconian solutions. The problem of terrorist attacks is not amenable to simple solutions, at least not simple solutions that are palatable to a substantial proportion of Americans.