I’ve been thinking for some time about Stephen Taylor’s brief post at Outside the Beltway on the utility of the phrase “radical Islam”. The post consists largely of a quote from a Vox.com post that in turns quotes Emile Nakhleh, formerly the director of the CIA’s Political Islam Strategic Analysis Program. The gist of Dr. Nakhleh’s view is that the term “radical Islam” is counter-productive because it raise Muslims’ hackles. Stephen concludes with a backhanded swipe at those who criticize President Obama for his avoidance of the term:
Because it ends up that governing is complicated and simplistic declarations are not helpful. (And the silly bickering over this term underscores a profound lack of understanding of the world and how it has to be navigated).
I’m not highly invested as some are in the centrality of the president’s saying “radical Islam” and I think a better phraseology would be “radical Islamism” (“Islamism” defined as political Islam) than “radical Islam”. It’s a subtle but important distinction. However, I think this topic provides an opportunity for digging into some issues I find interesting.
First, is appealing to Dr. Nakhleh a useful or fallacious appeal to authority? Second, can we gain more support in Muslim communities by eschewing the phrase “radical Islam”? Third, what’s the right policy?
Let me give my answers first and then explore them in a little more detail.
- We can’t tell.
- No.
- Use the phrase “radical Islamists” to describe radical Islamists, e.g. DAESH, Al Qaeda, and, probably, the Saudi government.
In researching Dr. Nakhleh I discovered that he worked for the CIA, that he’s a venerable scholar on Middle Eastern politics, and that he’s been pushing the goal of increased “engagement” of the United States with Muslims in the Middle East for decades. Merely having worked for the CIA not only is not a credential it may be an anti-credential. The CIA is capable of being wrong. It was wrong over a period of 40 years on the Soviet Union, consistently overestimating its strength and mistaking its motives. Most relevantly it has utterly bungled its findings on the Middle East for decades, viz. Iran, Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Al Qaeda. Was this bungling going on during Dr. Nakhleh’s tenure at CIA? It seems likely.
Dr. Nakleh’s doctorate is in political science and modern scholars are specialists. His doctorate does not make him an all-purpose expert on the Middle East. He has some narrow area of expertise in which I would acknowledge him as an expert. But I am reluctant to grant him the status of expertise on all things Muslim or all things Middle Eastern.
As a human being Dr. Nakhleh has preferences and an agenda. What’s his agenda? It’s relevant to judging his authority. His personal agenda may be overwhelming his judgment. There’s no way for us to tell.
It’s possible that Dr. Nakhleh’s pronouncements on this subject are authoritative; it’s possible that they aren’t. We simply can’t tell.
I think that asserting that we can cultivate a healthier relationship or even gain the support either of Muslims in the Middle East or in the United States by eschewing the phrase “radical Islam” is as ill-conceived as a claim that using the term will solve all of our strategic problems in dealing with violence perpetrated by radical Islamists. Both claims are naive and simplistic. Use of the term is not dispositive. It’s not enough to sway a reasonable person one way or the other and the notion that we can sway unreasonable people by changing our diction is absurd.
Furthermore, we can’t control the message. There will always be some American somewhere who uses the phrase “radical Islam” and, since we can’t control the message, that American will become the type of all Americans on the part of those who are predisposed to see Americans in that light. There’s nothing we can do about it.
I also wonder if avoiding the phrase “radical Islam” does not have the opposite effect to the one that is presumably intended. I think that Muslims, like most other people, generally just want to be left alone to live their lives. If they are led to believe that the fight has nothing to do with Islam, they’ll be inclined to stand to one side under the mistaken idea that it doesn’t involve them.
The truth is almost the diametric opposite—the war is going on within Islam and non-Muslims are merely caught in the crossfire. We are not the intended recipients of the messages that are being sent by terrorist attacks. Other Muslims are the audience.
Organizations like DAESH and Al Qaeda express what motivates them very clearly: it’s their radical interpretation of Islam. Saying so is merely a statement of fact. Clear and accurate speech facilitates clear thought and clear thought facilitates clear and effective policy. Can you imagine having tried to fight World War II without mentioning the Japanese or Nazis? It boggles the mind.
Yes, governing is complicated. It’s made more complicated by fuzzy thinking, imprecise modes of expression, and relying on experts of indeterminate authority.