The Unshakeable (Updated)

I commend to your attention Mel Robbins’s remarks at CNN:

The FBI basically just called the story Clinton has been telling the public since 2015 a bunch of nonsense. Contrary to what Clinton has been saying, the server did in fact contain classified emails: 113 of them. Her actions did in fact expose the classified information to attacks by “hostile actors.”

As Comey said, “any reasonable person … should have known that an unclassified system was no place” for that sort of information. And Clinton and her team did delete emails that contained classified information. Those are facts, and they contradict what Clinton and her team have been saying.

The head of the FBI slammed Clinton and her team as “extremely careless.” I think it’s worse; I think she’s extremely clueless about the bigger picture.

In law school, we often talked about the letter of the law versus the spirit of the law. She may not have violated the letter of the law (although there’s debate there, too) but she sure as hell violated the spirit of it.

Read the whole thing.

Update

It ain’t over ’til it’s over. Read Charles Lipson’s analysis at RealClearPolitics on what we may expect about Hillary Clinton’s emails. They include political ads showing her lying, demands that the results of the FBI investigation be made public, sad stories of lower level people having been jailed for doing less than Hillary Clinton did, leaks from the FBI, and leaks of emails from Russia, China, etc.

6 comments

Splitting the Baby

Clearly, the FBI’s criminal investigation of Hillary Clinton’s private email server was a thankless job. FBI Director James Comey is getting it from both sides for his decision not to recommend that Hillary Clinton be indicted for her crimes while outlining those crimes in some detail. In the Washington Post former FBI Director of Public Affairs Matthew Miller complained about the latter:

When FBI Director James B. Comey stepped to the lectern to deliver his remarks about Hillary Clinton on Tuesday, he violated time-honored Justice Department practices for how such matters are to be handled, set a dangerous precedent for future investigations and committed a gross abuse of his own power.

while the editors of the Wall Street Journal complained about the former:

Mr. Comey spent nearly all of his media appearance laying out the multiple ways in which Mrs. Clinton’s use of a private email server for official State Department business had violated official policy and jeopardized America’s secrets. Yet at the end he declined to recommend prosecution because her behavior was merely “extremely careless” rather than “grossly negligent” as the law requires. This is a rhetorical distinction without a difference that deserves to be mocked.

Mr. Comey’s facts grossly—if we may use that word—belie his conclusion. Of the 30,000 work-related emails Mrs. Clinton turned over to State, 110 contained classified information at the time they were sent or received. Eight email chains contained information judged to be Top Secret. The FBI also found three emails containing classified information among emails that Mrs. Clinton had deleted (rather than turned over to State)—but which the FBI was able to find through forensic analysis.

What was Director Comey trying to accomplish through his decision and speech? Ann Althouse has suggested that he was trying to follow the least controversial path. If so, it was a futile exercise.

He may have genuinely believed both prongs of his argument with an Orwellian ability to hold two contradictory ideas simultaneously. He may have been directed not to recommend indictment in no uncertain terms, followed orders in the hope of holding onto his job, but engaged in a minor act of rebellion by also explaining why his decision was wrong.

May we reasonably infer what he was trying to accomplish what he actually accomplished? He provided his superiors a figleaf for not recommending prosecution. He ensured that Hillary Clinton would be the Democratic nominee for president. He may have tried but clearly failed at burnishing his own reputation as a straight shooter. This:

This is not to suggest that in similar circumstances, a person who engaged in this activity would face no consequences. To the contrary, those individuals are often subject to security or administrative sanctions.

demolished that particular case.

Mr. Comey’s agency’s function was investigative not prosecutorial and in any event he should not have made decisions as a prosecutor. There was enough evidence, merely in what has been made public, for the case to go to a grand jury. Had a grand jury decided that there was insufficient evidence to go to trial, the matter would have been truly and finally ended. As it is, it will hang in the air forever.

I don’t know the specifics of what the FBI was asked to investigate but IMO the single-minded focus on classified material was an error. As I’ve been saying all along, violations of the Espionage Act were not the only problems. Violations of the Records Act were obvious and deeply disturbing. And, as Mr. Comey should surely know, intent may be inferred from a pattern of action and he made the case for the pattern in his remarks.

Well, the decision, along with Loretta Lynch’s announcement that she would not proceed, makes a pretty good case for the release of Sec. Clinton’s interview with the FBI and, predictably, there have already been calls for that release.

3 comments

An Interesting Insight

When I read this post of Tim Worstall’s at Forbes about how its new owners turned Hostess around, it occurred to me that it contained an interesting insight. The most important technological advancement in modern business may be organizational. Business processes rather than robots.

It also raises a question I’ve long wondered about. Why don’t unions purchase bankrupt companies to keep the jobs rather than letting themselves be reorganized out of existence as happened in the case of Hostess? Are there legal barriers? Psychological barriers? Political opposition?

10 comments

Remain

When President Obama leaves office 8,400 U. S. soldiers will remain in Afghanistan, CNN reports:

(CNN)President Barack Obama said Wednesday that he will leave behind more troops in Afghanistan than originally planned.

Speaking from the White House, Obama said he would draw down troops to 8,400 by the end of his administration, from the initial target of 5,500. The current level of troops in Afghanistan is 9,800.

Their mission will continue to be to train and support the Afghan military and participate in counter-terrorism activities.

So, a force inadequate to accomplish its ill-defined and probably impossible mission will remain in Afghanistan indefinitely. Charming.

3 comments

The Limit

While I agree that scientific breakthroughs could enable people to live 20% longer than the old “threescore and ten”, i.e. 90 or maybe a bit beyond, as this article at Seeker suggests:

Austad and others are currently looking for 70 candidates for the first five-year trial. Metformin effects three metabolic pathways in the body responsible for aging. Diabetic patients who took the drug lived longer than healthy patients who did not, according to Austad. Because its already been approved for use by federal officials, Austad and his team won’t have to go through lengthy pre-clinical tests for safety.

At the same time, other researchers are working on several other strategies to combat aging. Another drug is rapamycin, which inhibits cellular processes during cell metabolism.

“When you give it to a variety of animals, they all live longer and healthier,” said Nir Barzilai, professor of medicine and genetics at the Albert Einstein College of Medicine.

“If we give mice a combination of rapamycin and metformin, their lifespan is increased 25 percent,” Barzilai said. “For humans it’s a lifespan of 100 years instead of 75 years. This is the most promising approach.”

However, I’m skeptical that extending the human lifespan beyond around 115 will ever prove practical. Of the 7 billion some-odd human beings wreaking havoc on the world today, only a handful have reached 115 or beyond and those who’ve lived that long aren’t wreaking a great deal of havoc any more.

You’d think that if it were even possible for a human to live to, say, there would be at least one. That there isn’t suggests to me there’s actually a limit to the length of human life that science will not be able to extend.

1 comment

Forum Question: Fourth of July

The subject of this week’s Watcher’s Council forum was the Fourth of July. Council members share their reflections here.

This was my contribution:

I was going to subject you to a lecture on the meaning of the Fourth of July. Perhaps another time.

Instead I’ll share some of my fondest memories of Fourths of Julys past.

I remember watching fireworks shot over the Meramec River from Aunt Margaret and Uncle George’s house on stilts down on the river. I remember fireworks displays in the Valley Park village square.

I remember enduring 90% humidity and 105 degree temperature with a million (not an exaggeration) other people under the St. Louis Arch 40 years ago on the Bicentennial Fourth of July.

I remember watching the fireworks going off at eye level from our friends’ 16th floor condo in Marina Towers on the marina.

Perhaps my fondest Fourth of July memory is of sharing a Fourth of July in a small town in rural Illinois. Veterans parading. Fireworks in the town square. Speeches by local politicians. A perfect Fourth of July of classic Americana. It was like taking a time machine and experiencing a shared understanding we’re in danger of losing.

0 comments

Clinton’s Heedless Incompetence

There are any number of bons mots in Walter Shapiro’s Roll Call column in reaction to FBI Director James Comey’s statement of yesterday. For my money the best was this:

Fortunately for Hillary — but not the Democrats — heedless incompetence is not a federal crime. Comey’s cascade of carelessness is an indictment of a woman who is partly running for president on her ability to handle a 3 a.m. emergency phone call on a secure line. –

My opposition to Hillary Clinton predates all of her many scandals, real or imagined, by years. The woman is a serial bungler. Her every instinct is wrong and that’s intolerable in the president of the United States even when her opponent is a dangerous blowhard. I won’t vote for either one of them.

1 comment

The Unindicted

By now you’ve all undoubtedly heard about FBI Director James Comey’s remarkable statement of his decision not to seek an indictment of Hillary Clinton on charges related to the private email server on which she used for all of her work-related email during her tenure as Secretary of State. The editors of the Wall Street Journal did a pretty fair job of expressing my views:

By a reasonable person’s standards, Mrs. Clinton’s decision to use a private server, to give her aides access to it, to email classified information on it, to fail to secure it, and to use it in hostile territory was grossly negligent. We can’t wait for the next minion prosecuted for mishandling secrets to invoke the “extremely careless” defense.

Mr. Comey justified what he called his “unusual statement” in the name of political “transparency.” But by declaring that no prosecutor should indict Mrs. Clinton, he also hurt the cause of political accountability. The decision to indict or not rests with prosecutors, not the FBI, as Mr. Comey noted. But now prosecutors can merely point to Mr. Comey’s public statement to justify taking no action. He could have passed on his evidence quietly, but instead he acted like a prosecutor while denying that he is one.

It is true that prosecutors must consider the context when deciding whether to press charges. But we wonder if Mr. Comey and the FBI would have shown the same forbearance had the target of their probe been someone less prominent or loved by the Washington establishment. Mr. Comey’s bosom friend, Patrick Fitzgerald, the special prosecutor he named to pursue Scooter Libby, showed no such restraint.

Most distressing is what this episode augurs for another Clinton Administration. Mrs. Clinton deliberately sought to evade the Federal Records Act, recklessly flouted laws on handling classified information, spent a year lying about it, and will now have escaped accountability. This will confirm the Clinton family habit, learned so painfully in the 1990s, that they can get away with anything if they deny it long enough and are protected by a friendly media and political class.

The rule of law requires its neutral application. We almost wish Mr. Comey had avoided his self-justifying, have-it-both-ways statement and said bluntly that he couldn’t indict Mrs. Clinton because the country must be spared a Donald Trump Presidency. It would have been more honest and less corrosive to democracy than his Clinton Standard.

Rather than ruminating over what the decision means, I’ll list some things that it doesn’t mean.

  1. It did not exonerate Hillary Clinton.
  2. The opinion of the editors of the New York Times notwithstanding, it did not provide “legal clarity” to the matter. That could only be done through a court of law. In the absence of an indictment and adjudication, charges could be brought at any time, at least until whatever applicable statutes of limitations run out.
  3. It did not place Hillary Clinton’s guilt or innocence beyond reasonable doubt, as Dana Milbank seems to think. Quite to the contrary, Director Comey ably outlined why a reasonable person would think that Sec. Clinton had done something illegal, as poll after poll has suggested a majority of Americans do.
  4. Director Comey did not make an impartial judgment based on the facts, as his own statement clearly shows. He made a political judgment, electing to appear impartial and not take sides rather than sticking with the facts wherever they led.
  5. It did not close the matter of Hillary Clinton’s email server. There will be leaks of information, some from the FBI, some from hackers, some from foreign governments. Quite to the contrary, his statement insured that there will continue to be eruptions on the matter straight through to the November elections and, possibly, beyond.

What Director Comey’s statement did is ensure that Hillary Clinton will be the Democratic Party’s nominee for the presidency.

3 comments

The Purposes of NATO

I find that Stephen Kinzer’s op-ed in the Boston Globe captures my views of NATO pretty succinctly:

The North Atlantic Treaty Organization was founded in 1949 as a way for American troops to protect a war-shattered Europe from Stalin’s Soviet Union. Today Europe is quite capable of shaping and paying for its own security, but NATO’s structure remains unchanged. The United States still pays nearly three-quarters of its budget. That no longer makes sense. The United States should remain politically close to European countries but stop telling them how to defend themselves. Left to their own devices, they might pull back from the snarling confrontation with Russia into which NATO is leading them.

Russia threatens none of America’s vital interests. On the contrary, it shares our eagerness to fight global terror, control nuclear threats, and confront other urgent challenges to global security. Depending on one’s perspective, Russia may be seen as a destabilizing force in Europe or as simply defending its border regions. Either way, it is a challenge for Europeans, not for us.

Furthermore, managing whatever challenge Russia poses to the Europeans is completely within their capabilities.

As it stands NATO performs three functions:

  1. It provides a method for European countries to spend less than 2% of GDP on their own defense, transferring the burden to the U. S.
  2. It provides a venue other than the United Nations Security Council in which the United States can seek approval for making aggressive war.
  3. It provides jobs for a relative handful of bureaucrats, generals, and scholars.

I don’t think that any of those functions advances our national interests.

4 comments

Retrocession

Colbert King’s most recent Washington Post column has convinced me. It’s time for the Congress to draw a line around the various federal buildings and monuments, administer them directly, prohibit residence within that area by anyone other than the president (and maybe vice president), and cede the balance of the District back to Maryland. That process is called “retrocession”.

I suspect that wasn’t his objective in the column but IMO that’s the case he makes.

6 comments