There Are No Rules

In assessing President Obama’s “drone war” the editors of the New York Times declaim:

The Obama administration in 2013 adopted stricter guidelines for the drone campaign, which is run by the Central Intelligence Agency and the Pentagon. They instruct intelligence and military personnel to determine with “near certainty” that their target is present at the location of an intended strike, that noncombatants will not be hurt or killed, that capture is not a feasible option and that the local government is not equipped to address the threat.

But it is impossible to assess whether these rules are being followed without more detailed information, including the identity of targets, dates, locations and assessments of collateral damage by strikes. This data could be released without compromising national security. This is also true of the secret legal memos that justify the drone campaign. Harold Koh, who served as the legal adviser at the State Department from 2009 to 2013, said the lack of transparency has unnecessarily damaged perceptions of the drone program.

Let me help the editors: there are no rules. On the one hand there are actions and on the other there are public relations statements.

That’s completely characteristic of the Obama Administration in which laws and regulations are mere instruments of ego gratification—addressing the concerns of the moment. Rules that flexible are no rules at all. We can look forward to four or eight years of the same since Hillary Clinton operates by the same playbook.

2 comments

Labor Force Participation, Again

Presumably the chart above, gleaned from this post at Bloomberg is intended to convince us that all young Americans should pursue college educations. IMO the chart would be more helpful if its granulation were a bit finer. If it disaggregated bachelors only from bachelors or more, we might be able to distinguish whether people with college degrees were participating in the labor force at a higher rate or whether those with post-graduate and, especially, professional degrees were participating at a very high rate indeed.

Additionally, it would be interesting if the graph distinguished between native and non-native individuals. Since more than 50% of immigrants have high school educations or less the rapidly falling labor force participation rate for those with high school educations or less might just mean that the demand for such workers is falling while the supply is increasing, bolstered by 25 million immigrants. We just can’t tell from the graph.

Note, too, that the long-term trend is down regardless of the level of educational attainment and that’s been true for a very long time.

The text of the post itself contributes this:

Unfortunately, some public policies have made things worse. Thanks to background checks, for example, the burgeoning ranks of men with criminal records — some for transgressions as minor as marijuana possession — are effectively locked out of the labor market.

Occupational licensing has also created barriers, requiring people to invest in a time-consuming and expensive process before entering fields ranging from haircuts and interior design to law and medicine. Too many licenses have evolved as a way to protect incumbent workers at the expense of new entrants. Since licensing laws vary by state, they also make it harder for workers to move to where the jobs are.

When you add the deadweight loss created by massive healthcare subsidies, patents and royalties, regulations, and other government intervention in the economy, it’s clear that government at all levels is a substantial part of the problem.

I’m not an anarcho-capitalist or a minarchist. I believe that government is necessary for human well-being including the effective functioning of the economy. But we really need to do better at the business of governing. I attribute the problem to ideology. How about giving evidence-based government a try?

6 comments

Italy’s Banking Crisis

Italy is in the throes of a banking crisis. Since no American troops are involved and there’s no obvious way to turn it to domestic political advantage, we don’t hear much about it here in the States. Here George Friedman presents a briefing and some observations on it:

This crisis has absolutely nothing to do with Brexit, although opponents of Brexit will claim it does. Even if Britain had unanimously voted to stay in the EU, the Italian crisis would still have been gathering speed.

The extraordinarily high level of non-performing loans (NPLs) has been a problem since before Brexit, and it is clear that there is nothing in the Italian economy that will allow it to be reduced. A non-performing loan is simply a loan that isn’t being repaid according to terms, and the reason this happens is normally the inability to repay it. Only a dramatic improvement in the economy would make it possible to repay these loans, and Europe’s economy cannot improve drastically enough to help. We have been in crisis for quite a while.

The crisis was hidden, in a way, because banks were simply carrying loans as non-performing that were actually in default and discounting the NPLs rather than writing them off. But that simply hid the obvious. As much as 17 percent of Italy’s loans will not be repaid. As a result, the balance sheets of Italian banks will be crushed. And this will not only be in Italy. Italian loans are packaged and resold as others, and Italian banks take loans from other European banks. These banks in turn have borrowed against Italian debt. Since Italy is the fourth largest economy in Europe, this is the mother of all systemic threats.

I honestly don’t know how one could conclude that Europe’s financial problems aren’t due to Italy, Greece, Portugal, Spain, France, or the United Kingdom but due to Germany. Maintaining a nationalist mercantilist trade policy in the context of common currency leads inexorably to such problems. We’d have the same problems if California or New York maintained a mercantilist trade policy with respect to the other states.

0 comments

Freedom to Screw Up

I agree with just about every word of Matthew Hennessey’s post in City Journal on the murder of five police officers in Dallas on Thursday night:

Ordinary, law-abiding people should be allowed to foul up, most of us agree. This is a free country, not a totalitarian police state. No one “deserves to die” while riding in a car with a legal gun, just as no one deserves to die for selling CDs in a parking lot or peddling loose cigarettes. But on Staten Island, where Eric Garner died during a confrontation with the NYPD in July 2014, what turned the encounter from a routine arrest into a tragedy was Garner’s failure to heed police commands. He was ordered to comply and he refused. He told the cops, “This ends today.” That was a mistake.

Did the NYPD cops who dealt with Garner mess up? You bet. One of them put Garner in a chokehold, banned by department regulations, and Garner died. But no cop shows up to work looking to kill someone, and the day would have ended differently had Garner followed the instructions he was given. Sad but true.

We should hold cops to a higher standard of accountability than the average citizen because they are given great power—including the legal use of deadly force. Yet, we can’t forget that the police are people, too. They don’t have unlimited patience or a sixth sense about when their job will turn violent. Recognizing bad guys takes experience—and a critical aspect of experience is learning from mistakes.
This creates an obvious problem. The collective experience of all cops is supposed to be distilled into police training programs, but each individual cop must learn some hard lessons on his own. All the training in the world won’t put an end to police mistakes. The only way to have no police mistakes is to have no police.

When every party does everything perfectly correctly, as in the case related in the Facebook post I passed along yesterday, there’s a happy ending. When mistakes are made, tragedies may occur instead. The more heavily armed you are, the more dire the consequences of your screwing up.

There’s an aspect of the phenomena he describes that deserves more emphasis: rich people can screw up without serious consequences more readily than poor people can; white than black. That’s unjust but I don’t know if it’s remediable. The latter case maybe, over time. In the case of the former the cure would probably be worse than the disease.

One more point, brought to mind by murders in Dallas and the other instance of race-based homicidal violence perpetrated by a black man against whites. Whatever the injustices suffered by blacks in this country, the very last thing black folk should want is race war. In such a war too many of the casualties would be black. That’s something of which the civil rights leaders in the 1960s were painfully aware but I’m afraid that recognition has been lost today.

20 comments

Making America Truly Great

—one mutually respectful encounter at a time. Young black man stopped by Tucson police. Is armed with handgun. Here’s what happened:

So, I’m driving to my office to turn in my weekly paperwork. A headlight is out. I see a Tucson Police Department squad vehicle turn around and follow me. I’m already preparing for the stop.

The lights go on and I pull over. The officer asks me how I’m doing, and then asks if I have any weapons.

“Yes, sir. I’m a concealed carry permit holder and my weapon is located on my right hip. My wallet is in my back-right pocket.”

The officer explains for his safety and mine, he needs to disarm me for the stop. I understand, and I unlock the vehicle. I explain that I’m running a 7TS ALS holster but from the angle, the second officer can’t unholster it. Lead officer asks me to step out, and I do so slowly. Officer relieves me of my Glock and compliments the X300U I’m running on it. He also sees my military ID and I tell him I’m with the National Guard.

Lead officer points out my registration card is out of date but he knows my registration is up to date. He goes back to run my license. I know he’s got me on at least two infractions. I’m thinking of how to pay them.

Officers return with my Glock in an evidence back, locked and cleared. “Because you were cool with us and didn’t give us grief, I’m just going to leave it at a verbal warning. Get that headlight fixed as soon as possible.”

I smile. “Thank you, sir.”

I’m a black man wearing a hoodie and strapped. According to certain social movements, I shouldn’t be alive right now because the police are allegedly out to kill minorities.

Read his Facebook post.

I thought we could use some good news for a change.

4 comments

Revenge in Dallas

You have undoubtedly already heard about the terrible news from Dallas overnight. Eleven police officers have been shot, five are dead, and one innocent woman has been killed by snipers as a peaceful demonstration protesting the killings by police officers in Minneapolis and Baton Rouge ended. NBC Fort Worth reports:

Five officers are dead — four Dallas police officers and one DART transit officer — after two snipers ambushed and opened fire on police at the end of a peaceful protest against nationwide officer-involved shootings Thursday night, officials say.
One suspect is dead, a Dallas police detective tells NBC 5 early Friday morning, and three other suspects were in custody in connection with the shooting.

President Barack Obama, who was in Warsaw, Poland, for a NATO meeting, condemned the “vicious, callous and despicable attack.”
“I believe I speak for every single American when I say that we are horrified over these events and that we stand united with the people and the police department in Dallas,” the president said.

At least one civilian was injured. She was identified by family as Shetamia Taylor, and she was shot while shielding her children from the gunfire, her sister told NBC 5. Taylor’s condition is not known.

In addition at least one “suspicious package” has been found and the attackers threatened that they had placed bombs in various locations around Dallas.

It’s hard to know what to say about such dreadful events. What in the world were they thinking? There is not one unitary police force in the United States but thousands. Killing police officers in Dallas in revenge for killings by police in other cities is more likely to produce perverse consequences than good ones. Police officers are human beings, too.

If there are widespread consequences to the “little war” in Dallas, they are likely to be human reactions rather than institutional ones. The human reactions I might envision on the part of police officers are either to withdraw from circumstances in which they might be at risk or to shoot first and ask questions later. Either of those responses will result in the deaths of more black men, not fewer.

12 comments

Comey Continues

Here’s a telling passage from an exchange between Rep. Trey Gowdy and FBI Director James Comey, reported by Politico:

“In interest of time, because I have a plane to catch tomorrow afternoon, I’m not going to go through anymore of the false statements but I am going to ask you put on your old hat. False exculpatory statements, they are used for what?” Gowdy inquired.

Comey responded, “Either for the substantive prosecution or for evidence of intent in a criminal prosecution.”
“Exactly. Intent and consciousness of guilt, right? Is that right?” Gowdy asked. “Consciousness of guilt and intent. In your old job you would prove intent as you just referenced by showing the jury evidence of a complex scheme that was designed for the very purpose of concealing the public record, and you would be arguing in addition to concealment the destruction that you and I just talked about, or certainly the failure to preserve. Would you argue all that under heading of content–intent. You would also be arguing the pervasiveness of the scheme, when it started, when it ended and number of emails, whether they were originally classified or up-classified, you would argue all of that under the heading of intent. You would also probably under common scheme or plan argue the burn bags of daily calendar entries or the missing daily calendar entries as a common scheme or plan to conceal. Two days ago, director, you said a reasonable person in her should have known a private email is no place to send and receive classified information. You’re right.”

The emphasis is mine. I continue to have problems explaining Director Comey’s decisions in the light of his own statements.

11 comments

Can President Obama Pardon Illegal Immigrants?

To date President Obama has used his pardon powers as president fairly sparingly. In an op-ed in the New York Times Peter Markowitz makes a suggestion that I think is rather shocking—the president should use his pardon powers to pardon millions of illegal immigrants:

It’s a common assumption that pardons can be used only for criminal offenses, and it’s true that they have not been used before for civil immigration violations. However, the Constitution extends the power to all “offenses against the United States,” which can be interpreted more broadly than just criminal offenses.

The enormous administrative undertaking that would be required to put into effect the deferred deportation program — which some in Congress had hoped to defund — would thus be wholly unnecessary. Indeed, Congress would be impotent to restrict the president’s pardon as the Supreme Court has made clear that “Congress cannot interfere in any way with the president’s power to pardon.” If immigration enforcement agencies or any future administration failed to respect the pardon, individual beneficiaries could use it as a shield in any deportation proceedings that followed.

President Obama has plenty of time left to issue such a pardon. There is solid historical and legal precedent for him to do so. And although it would probably bring about legal challenges, opponents could not use the legal system to simply run out the clock, as they have with his deferred deportation program. A deferred deportation program could be undone by a President Trump. Unconditional pardons, in contrast, are irrevocable.

The differences between Jimmy Carter’s pardoning of a half million Viet Nam war draft dodgers and pardoning illegal immigrants could not be starker. President Carter pardoned American citiznes; he pardoned people who had avoided what had become an unpopular war; since the draft had ended in 1973 there was no moral hazard involved; it was a popular action. Quite to the contrary I can think of little more likely to spark a rebellion than what Mr. Markowitz is proposing, an action that, presumably, would be taken after Hillary Clinton has been safely elected president.

8 comments

The Forever War in Afghanistan

Three quarters of U. S. casualties in Afghanistan have occurred since Barack Obama became president. Can someone please make the case for me that President Obama did the right thing in his “Afghan surge” and that he’s doing the right thin now by kicking the can down the road to his successor? I just don’t see it.

The link between U. S. casualty rates and operational tempo could not be clearer.

I’m convinced that his decisions been governed by purely domestic political considerations (and now his legacy) right down the road. Convince me otherwise.

5 comments

I Dread October

Come October we’re likely to see more of two things than we can possibly stand and I don’t mean premiers of the network TV fall lineup. We’ll see political ads and Humira ads. Humira’s patent expires in December.

4 comments