Reminder: the Fat Lady Has Not Sung


source: tradingeconomics.com

To throw a bit of cold water on the glowing descriptions of the U. S. employment situation, there are some things that need to be kept in mind.

  1. As the graph above shows, the U. S. labor participation rate is lower than it’s been since the 1970s. That can’t be attributed entirely to retirements or kids in college.
  2. The long-term unemployment rate remains too high.
  3. Wage growth has been flat or slow (ibid.)
  4. The jobs that have replaced the jobs lost during the Great Recession don’t pay as much as the old jobs and frequently don’t carry benefits.

There’s a lot of heavy-lifting left to do. Not that I see any. We shouldn’t be hanging out that “Mission Accomplished” banner just yet.

One more sobering thought. It is all but certain we will have an economic downturn before the end of the present presidential term or some time in the next regardless of who is elected. We’ve already experienced the third longest expansion in the post-war period and, if it were to continue through the entirety of the next presidential term, it would be the longest. We will have almost no tools left for fighting the next economic downturn. Feel lucky, punk?

9 comments

Contagion

Has anyone else noted an up-tick in the number of attempted infections by malware? I certainly have. Nowadays you don’t need to go to a porn site to pick up something. Many media sites are serving up phishing and other malware in their ads. I honestly don’t know what ordinary unwary computer users do. Get infected I suppose.

1 comment

The Wedding March (1928)

Last night I watched the 1928 Erich Von Stroheim picture The Wedding March, part of the selection of Fay Wray movies TCM was showing yesterday (it was followed by King Kong). You can get the plot synopsis elsewhere. Austrian prince falls in love with commoner girl (Fay Wray), marries heiress (ZaSu Pitts). I recommend it. Even in the imperfect print we saw the cinematography and art decoration were impressive. Written, directed, and produced by von Stroheim who also starred and participated in the art direction, editing, set decoration, costume design, etc.

My dad would have loved the picture with all its Germanic pomp and circumstance.

Today my wife showed me the relevant passages in Fay Wray’s autobiography, On the Other Hand (get it?), about The Wedding March. Ms. Wray had nothing but glowing things to say about von Stroheim and her experience making the movie more generally. She also provided a summary of what the movie was supposed to have been like.

You see, as released the movie was just under two hours. As envisioned by von Stroheim it weighed in at more than six hours and consisted not only of The Wedding March, roughly the first third of the movie, but of its sequel The Honeymoon, released only in Europe and now lost, and the unfilmed last third. Ms. Wray’s remarks were very interesting and informative.

Now you might ask how we just happened to have Fay Wray’s autobiography sitting on our shelves. I’ve mentioned before that we have a lot of books.

1 comment

The Knowns of the Rio Olympics

At RealClearLife Sean Cunningham ponders the known factors present at the Rio Olympics which could lead to a disaster:

At some point, most Olympics feel like a catastrophe in the making. (Who can forget the reports in 2014 of Sochi having to round up and poison stray dogs ahead of the Winter Olympics?)
Yet ultimately the Olympics happen, tend to go pretty smoothly, and leave the host nation with a lot of utterly useless buildings.
Brazil may be the rare Olympics that feels like it’s going to fail and actually does.

He lists twelve reasons:

  • The World Cup Hangover
  • Many Brazilians Want Nothing to Do With the Olympics
  • There’s a President Problem
  • The Criminals in Congress
  • The Water
  • The Super Bacteria
  • The Russians Are Remarkably Doped Up
  • The Zika
  • The “Return” of Olympic Golf
  • Much of the Olympic Village is “Unlivable.”
  • The Crime
  • Their Murdering Their Own Mascot

and those are just the known factors.

0 comments

Willing Suspension of Disbelief

The editors of the New York times have weighed in on Chicago’s police scandal which became national news when the video of Laquan McDonald being executed by a Chicago policeman came to light after having been mysteriously withheld until the elections were safely over:

This spring, a task force appointed by Mayor Rahm Emanuel found that the department was plagued by systemic racism and still operated with contempt for the lives of black citizens. The task force made many recommendations and proposed scrapping the current police oversight system in favor of a new investigative agency that would be under civilian control.

Mr. Emanuel created the task force shortly after the city was forced to release a police video of a white police officer, Jason Van Dyke, firing away at a black teenager named Laquan McDonald on a busy Chicago street. The city added to the African-American community’s already deep sense of grievance by withholding the video from the public for 13 months — while the police circulated a false account of the episode. Only after the court ordered the video released did the state’s attorney, Anita Alvarez, charge Officer Van Dyke with murder.

We are, of course, expected to believe that Sergeant Schultz Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel knew nothing about the murder, the lies, the cover-up, or the racism.

2 comments

Where a Dollar Is a Dollar

The Tax Foundation has an interesting post discussing what a dollar buys in each state using data from the National Bureau of Economic Analysis. There’s quite a bit of variation from Mississippi where $100 of income buys $115.34 worth of goods and services to the District of Columbia where that same $100 is the equivalent of $84.67.

State-levvel differentials in income, prices, and their relative have some interesting consequences. For example:

For example, Nebraskans and Californians earn approximately the same amount in dollars per capita, but after adjusting for regional price parity, Nebraskan incomes can buy more.

In other words the purchasing power parity of income in Nebraska is about 20% higher than in California for just about the same average income. When you add the difference in Gini coefficient (California is much less equal than Nebraska), it points to very different social and economic conditions between the two states. The obvious retort, I presume, is would you rather live in California or Nebraska? The answer is the one I always give when asked that question (and I frequently have been). California is a very good state to live in if you’re rich.

But can you guess in which state of all of the states plus the District of Columbia, $100 of income buys the closest to $100 of goods and services? That would be Illinois ($99.30).

13 comments

Catastrophic Care

From her perch at Bloomberg View, Megan McArdle speculates on the direction in which the healthcare insurance exchanges established under the PPACA are moving. Her scenarios vary from the fairly benign:

Rates will settle down because insurers are just finding their footing. For the first few years, supporters of the law had a mantra: “Look how great Obamacare is; rates are lower than expected.” They had to stop chanting that in 2015, when insurers started asking for — and getting — great big price hikes. The new mantra became: “It’s a new market and insurers needed time to figure out how to price, but rates will settle down.”

to the disastrous:

Insurers will just give up on a bunch of markets, leading to a crisis in which a number of exchanges have no policies at all offered. I assume that the government does something at that point. Not sure what. Maybe we get the public option. Maybe Democrats are hounded from office by angry voters and Republicans get to actually try having a health-care plan. Maybe the sweet meteor of death arrives while we’re still arguing about it.

Back in 2009 my judgment was that over time the PPACA would tend to become “Medicaid for all” and I see nothing to contradict that judgment.

I think the more interesting question is what the legislative fate of the Affordable Care Act will be. Assuming that Hillary Clinton is elected president, I think there will be a perceived need to preserve President Obama’s legacy of which the PPACA is the greatest part. To whatever extent that means leaving the PPACA as originally constructed, eschewing even commonsense reforms, it will create ever more serious problems with the passage of time. Politics always has a way of overruling policy.

9 comments

Nostalgia Economics

I disagree with Phil Gramm and Michael Solon’s Wall Street Journal op-ed on slow U. S. economic growth following the Great Recession but I’m having some difficulty in coming up with a formulation as to exactly why I disagree with them. I have little doubt that millions of pages will end up being written about the Great Recession and its aftermath. When the partisan rancor has died down (if ever), I hope it is recognized that only two hypotheses about the Great Recession itself are tenable.

Since the recession had ended by June of 2009 and none of the spending of the ARRA (“stimulus package”) had been released let alone disbursed, the recovery, such as it was, can only be attributed either to ordinary business cycle reasons, i.e. government action had nothing to do with it, or it was ended by the steps taken during the last years of the George W. Bush presidency which included fiscal stimulus. I’m not prepared to disaggregate the effects of all of the things that were done.

I am not now and never have been a fan of George W. Bush but the timing admits of no other explanation.

What, then, did the ARRA do? I think the answer is “not much”. As President Obama himself admitted after the fact, there are no “shovel-ready projects” and a lot of the spending went to projects that had already been approved by state and local governments. In other words they provided little stimulus that would not have been provided anyway. The state and local governments moved money from one pocket to another, using the money freed up to increase the pay of public employees which aggravated the pension problems they’re facing now.

I think the problem I have is with their prescription:

The dominant lesson of the Great Depression and the Great Recession is that when government overspends, overtaxes and over-regulates, economic freedom is suppressed and economic growth vanishes. When growth fades, it takes the American dream with it. Give America back its economic system of freedom and opportunity, and the ensuing growth will bring back the American dream.

Most government spending is devoted to just three categories: the military, Social Security, and healthcare spending. Add interest on the debt and it accounts for nearly 90% of federal spending. What spending do they want to cut?

In the past I’ve advocated cutting military spending. Slowing the growth of healthcare spending won’t do much to reduce federal spending as long as non-healthcare sector growth is as phlegmatic as it has been. You’ve got to actually cut spending and to the best of my knowledge no one has proposed anything that will accomplish that.

In the final analysis I think that conditions have changed since the 1920s, the last time the federal government had the very small footprint that Mssrs. Gramm and Solon long for. We have economic competitors both at home and abroad. If lower taxes and government spending result in greater economic growth, it will be greater economic growth in Germany and China not here. As long as the top 1% of income earners capture 52% of all additional personal income, it’s hard to see where all of the new economic growth will come from.

What we need is what I’ve characterized in the past as “prudent stewardship”. We can’t afford to throw money at problems any more. We should only spend and regulate what is necessary and effective rather than what we’d like to.

10 comments

Fostering Economic Growth

At Atlantic former Fed Governor Narayana Kocherlakota states the problem:

During the last two U.S. presidencies, from the end of 2000 to the middle of 2016, the most important measure of prosperity — economic output per capita — has grown at the anemic pace of less than 1 percent a year. Over roughly the same period, median inflation-adjusted income has actually fallen for several major demographic groups (including by a shocking 10 percent for black males).

and then proposes his solutions. In reference to his statement of the problem I suspect that if you consider only black males who are not college-educated immigrants or the children of those immigrants, the number is much higher. Sadly, two of his three proposed solutions will do very little for that group.

His proposed strategies for fostering growth are:

  • Infrastructure spending
  • Suspending all or part of the payroll tax
  • Provide a small guaranteed annual income

In his remarks on infrastructure spending he relies on the ASCE report. As I’ve pointed out previously, the report is misleading because it only analyzes the condition of individual roads and bridges rather than whether they’re worth restoring. Consequently, the report tends to overstate the problem. There are thousands of rural roads and bridges that are in disrepair for a good reason: they’re unused.

For an infrastructure building program to provide stimulus, it needs to be a federal program funded by expanding the money supply, i.e. “deficit spending”, given as block grants to the states. For it to be prudent the projects funded need to be worthwhile.

Take the case of the “Hillside Strangler”—the interchanges at the intersection of I-88 and I-290 here in suburban Chicago. Billions have been spent rebuilding those interchanges to practically no effect because it’s not an infrastructure problem but a classic case of just plain too many cars. The most it accomplished was pushing congestion to the east.

I would also caution that infrastructure spending just isn’t doesn’t provide as effective a fiscal stimulus as it used to because we no longer build roads with large gangs of workers armed with shovels. More could probably be accomplished if Davis-Bacon wage rules were suspended but that’s political kryptonite.

Turning to the proposal to suspend the employer portion of FICA, I’ve advocated that for years. I think that one of the greatest errors of the Pelosi-Reid Congress was reinstating the payroll tax. Its suspension was the most effective stimulus applied during the Great Recession.

The final guaranteed annual income proposal would be most effective as fiscal stimulus if provided via deficit spending. If, as has been suggested, low growth is not due to inadequate personal consumption expenditures but due to too much debt (“balance sheet recession”), a more targeted approach would probably be more effective.

Stimulating personal spending isn’t as effective a fiscal stimulus as it used to be, either. We just don’t make enough of what we consume and because of the changes in distribution, inventory, and sales of the last twenty-five years, retailers don’t add capacity when sales go up. Manufacturers in Germany and China do.

3 comments

Fishtown’s Problems Will Remain

In his most recent op-ed at the Boston Globe Niall Ferguson reminds us of those two distilled and contrasting communities, Fishtown and Belmont:

On the one hand there is a “cognitive elite,” who are educated together at universities like Harvard and Yale, then marry each other, work together, and live together in the same exclusive neighborhoods.

Concentrated in “super zipcodes” such as Beverly Hills, Santa Monica, Malibu, Manhattan, and Boston, these people are politically more liberal than the national average, as well as much richer and more inclined to eat quinoa salads.

On the other side of this social chasm is a new lower class: white Americans with nothing more than a high school diploma, if that. They eat Chick-fil-A, not quinoa. In a masterstroke of exposition, Murray vividly localized his argument by imagining two emblematic communities: Belmont, where everyone has at least one university degree, and Fishtown, where no one has any.

By one reckoning Donald Trump is running for president as the tribune of Fishtown. I think that’s a phantasm.

However, whoever is elected president Fishtown’s problems will remain. These include:

Since 2005, according to a new report by McKinsey, more than four fifths of population (81 percent) have had flat or falling incomes. The white lower class is in the grip of an epidemic of ill health and premature death.

consequences of

Family breakdown, loss of employment, crime, declining “social capital”…

and these have been exacerbated by policy.

Welcoming the residents of Fishtown into Belmont isn’t a workable alternative but it’s been the beacon for three consecutive presidential administrations. Even if 100% of the people had university degrees (absurd on the face of it), that wouldn’t mean that maids, nannies, gardeners, grocery store cashiers, bank clerks, and the millions of other people who work in poorly compensated white or blue collar jobs will sudddenly become highly compensated knowledge workers. It means they’ll be maids, nannies, gardeners, etc. with college degrees, disappointed that the degree wasn’t accompanied with what they thought were the trappings of the degree.

4 comments