What Should the U. S. Do About DAESH?

Recently, in the comments of one of Doug’s OTB posts, I was challenged, rather rudely, to come up with “a better anti-ISIS policy”. Here are my thoughts in bullet form:

  • DAESH is a problem for Iraq. It’s a problem for Syria. It’s a problem for Turkey (even if the Turks don’t realize it), the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, and the other Gulf states.
  • Because of overflow and policy decisions, DAESH has become a problem for Europe.
  • DAESH is not a problem for the United States.
  • Violent radical Islamists (hereafter referred to as “jihadis“), regardless of affiliation, are a problem for the United States.
  • Some of the risks posed by jihadis can be mitigated by screening visa applications from MENA more closely and monitoring visa-holders from those areas more closely while they’re here.
  • Some of the risks posed by jihadis can be mitigated by considering all imams who receive funding from the citizens of any majority Muslim country other than Muslim countries that are liberal democracies as unregistered foreign agents. Change the FARA accordingly.
  • Some of the risks posed by jihadis can be mitigated by reducing our footprint in the Middle East and North Africa.
  • The U. S.-born children of Muslim immigrants or Muslim immigrants who came here at a young age appear to present some risk of radicalization. Special steps, including home visits and counseling, should be taken to mitigate that risk.
  • We should support the internationally recognized government of Syria rather than its opponents. If we can’t bring ourselves to do that, we should maintain a low profile with respect to Syria.
  • Above all, we should stop supplying, financing, or training jihadis regardless of where they are.

The need to appear strong against DAESH is a political problem not a policy problem. I don’t care about political problems.

Those prescriptions are a work in progress. Feel free to contribute your own ideas in the comments. Keep in mind that any proposal involving permanent occupation of the Middle East in force is a waste of keystrokes. We’re not going to do that.

25 comments

I Live in the Hype

Mark Holden and Ronal Serpas take to the op-ed page of the Washington Post to throw cold water on the idea that the U. S. is experiencing a crime wave with an op-ed with the caption “Don’t buy the hype: The U.S. is not experiencing a terrible new crime wave”:

There has been a surge of assertions about rising crime recently. At the Republican convention in July, GOP nominee Donald Trump said, “Decades of progress made in bringing down crime are now being reversed by this administration’s rollback of criminal enforcement.” The Manhattan Institute’s Heather Mac Donald echoed these concerns, noting that homicides increased by nearly 17 percent in the 56 largest U.S. cities last year and citing sharp rises in Baltimore, Chicago and the District. In an op-ed in last Sunday’s Post, Sean Kennedy and Parker Abt made the same case.

As two strong conservatives, let us set the record straight. These statements on rising murders are highly misleading. The truth is that Americans are still experiencing hard-won historic lows in crime.

I live in the city of Chicago. Here the rising number of homicides is not “hype”. We call it “the weekend”. Another page of the Washington Post reports:

Chicago has experienced a surge in violence in the past year, much of it concentrated on the city’s South Side, where Lucas lived. A staggering 2,500 people have been shot in the city since the beginning of the year, more than in any year at this point since the 1990s. There have been at least 426 homicides in 2016, far more than in New York, which has three times Chicago’s population.

Turn to the website HeyJackass to see the scope of Chicago’s problem in lurid black, red, and baby blue. If the number of murders here continues at the present rate we’ll have had more than 700 homicides by the end of the year—something not seen since the 1990s.

These homicides are concentrated in just a few neighborhoods and are mostly of young, black men perpetrated by other young, black men.

Some things to keep in mind when thinking about these sad statistics:

  • Tough gun laws do not reduce the rate of gun homicide. If there’s any correlation at all, it’s a positive one (which I interpret as “people enact tough gun laws where there are lots of gun homicides”). Chicago has some of the toughest gun laws in the country.
  • More police officers per 100,000 population do not reduce the rate of gun homicide. Chicago has one of the highest number of police officers per 100,000 population of any city in the country, probably more than we can afford.
  • If the statistics tell us anything, it’s that if you pack enough young, black men into a small enough area without much in the way of available jobs or hope for the future but with plenty of drugs and alcohol, the number of murders will rise. Nearly half of the young, black men in Chicago are neither working nor going to school.
4 comments

Don’t Get Captured

At Bloomberg View Eli Lake says the rules of engagement for U. S. forces in Syria amount to “don’t get shot”:

U.S. special operations forces in Syria do many things in the war against the Islamic State. They gather intelligence, build relationships with local communities, help spot targets for air strikes and train and advise local forces on the ground. One thing they cannot do, though, is enter into range of the enemy’s fire.

Four U.S. military officials told me that the 300 or so U.S. special operators in Syria are under very strict rules of engagement. Because such rules are highly classified, these sources have requested anonymity.

But the rules in place, known as “last cover and concealment,” are highly restrictive compared to special operations missions in the war on terror before 2014. Those rules of engagement allowed for U.S. special operators to fight alongside the local forces they trained. The rules of engagement for Syria, according to one military officer, amount to: “don’t get shot.”

In my opinion those are the wrong rules. Their first rule should be “don’t get captured”. A single captured U. S. special forces member could result in our invading Syria in force which, given the participation of Russia in the conflict, could escalate to nuclear war.

Is ousting Assad really worth destroying the world?

5 comments

What’s Wrong With Sub-Saharan Africa?

Novelist Chigozie Obioma’s op-ed at Foreign Policy is a grab-bag of truths, half-truths, and balderdash. In the “truth” category is this:

Nigeria, the most populous black nation on Earth, is on the brink of collapse. The machineries that make a nation exist, let alone succeed, have all eroded. One might argue that the nation’s creation by self-seeking white imperialists engendered its failure from the beginning, as I did in my recent novel. But this is only a part of the cause. A culture of incompetence, endemic corruption, dignified ineptitude, and, chief among all, destructive selfishness and greed has played a major role in its unravelling. The same, sadly, can be said for most other African nations. States like Zimbabwe, Cameroon, and Equatorial Guinea are farcical democracies ruled by men who exclusively cater to their interests and those of their clipped circles.

and that’s barely scratching the surface. The Central African Republic, Democratic Republic of the Congo, and the Republic of the Congo are in very rough shape.

I wonder what he thinks of Botswana which seems to be a success story would seem to be the exception that proves the rule. My assessment is that in the final analysis whether you’re talking about Nigeria or Russia or Ukraine or Botswana or the United States institutions matter.

I would place the blame he casts on non-blacks for the problems of sub-Saharan African countries in the category of half-truths, see this:

The Arabs enslaved tribes and nations and then colonized and evangelized them. Then came the Europeans, who, persuaded the Africans were of an inferior race, divided up the continent over lunch in Berlin in 1884. They carted off a large population of its people — sometimes leaving entire villages almost empty — and brought those who remained on the continent under their rule. So complete was the transformation that no black nation retained its ancestral nationhood, national language, or national identity. And today we often hear of how China or India or some other nation is “taking over” Africa economically.

and this

One might argue that the nation’s creation by self-seeking white imperialists engendered its failure from the beginning, as I did in my recent novel.

They are half-truths for any number of reasons. The Arabs and the Europeans certainly didn’t help and I agree that they wrought enormous harm. But he fails to recognize that slavery existed in sub-Saharan Africa before Europeans began transporting slaves and probably before Arab contact there as well and the slavery was a consequence of disunity and war. It was disunity and war that created the openings for Arab and European invaders—they didn’t arise ex nihilo and they’re still dragging sub-Saharan Africa down.

But in my opinion this is balderdash:

Black elites should allow for self-criticism and soul-searching and for the restoration of the Pan-Africanist movement with an eye toward building sustainable black nations. We must come to realize that to a great extent the fate of the black man in America is inextricably linked to that of his brother in Africa. Although largely unacknowledged in American political discourse, Jim Crow ended in part because of the African Independent movements.

relying on post hoc propter hoc reasoning. The abolition of slavery, then Jim Crow, and then the slow process of creating a single society rather than two, a process still incomplete, was the work of American whites and American blacks almost completely without contact with sub-Saharan Africans.

In what category should the following assertion be placed?

Black elites and activists across the world have adopted a culture of verbal tyranny in which they shut down any effort to reason or criticize us or black-majority nations by labeling such attempts as “racism” or “hate speech.” Thus, one can be certain that any suggestions that our race may indeed need to do something to remedy our situation will not be aired — not by the terrified people of other races. And anyone within our race who makes such a suggestion will be deemed weak and pandering or a sellout, as U.S. President Barack Obama has been repeatedly called.

6 comments

Is That His Biggest Mistake?

Do you agree with Nicholas Kristof’s point, made in the New York Times, that President Obama’s biggest mistake was not intervening forcefully in Syria?

I admire Obama for expanding health care and averting a nuclear crisis with Iran, but allowing Syria’s civil war and suffering to drag on unchallenged has been his worst mistake, casting a shadow over his legacy. It is also a stain on all of us, analogous to the indifference toward Jewish refugees in the 1930s, to the eyes averted from Bosnia and Rwanda in the 1990s, to Darfur in the 2000s.

This is a crisis that cries out for American leadership, and Obama hasn’t shown enough.

That’s the kind of thinking that makes me wonder if a good strategy on any given issue wouldn’t be to find out what Nicholas Kristof is recommending and do the opposite.

Here are some questions that I think that Mr. Kristof should consider. What was the U. S. role in fomenting the rebellion against Assad? Would it have existed at all without external support? Have our actions in training and supporting the rebels actually prolonged and aggravated the carnage rather than bringing about the removal of Assad?

As to President Obama’s biggest mistake I think it’s a broad field so it’s difficult to choose. Keynesians would probably say that not pushing a larger stimulus package was his biggest error. Foes of the Affordable Care Act would say that signing that into law was his biggest mistake.

I’m sure there are diehards out there who don’t think that the president has made any mistakes. If I were pressed to the wall, I’m torn between the Afghan Surge and not following through on the promise of his first election campaign and starting out with a national unity government.

26 comments

The Next Four Years

Respected election analyst Charlie Cook makes some interesting observations about the election in National Journal to the effect that

  1. Hillary Clinton will probably win the election.

…it is hard to look closely at the oth­er data and say that her lead is not mean­ing­ful; clearly some of it is very real and prob­ably dif­fi­cult to chip away. Us­ing the Real­Clear­Polit­ics.com av­er­ages as a yard­stick, Clin­ton is ahead by 7 points in the two-way tri­al heat, 6.6 points in the three-way with Liber­tari­an Gary John­son in­cluded, and 6.5 points in the four-way, with both John­son and Green Party can­did­ate Jill Stein thrown in­to the mix, pulling 8 and 4 per­cent, re­spect­ively. Clin­ton is at 43.2 per­cent and Trump at 36.7 per­cent.

Just for the sake of sim­pli­city, let’s just say that half of Clin­ton’s cur­rent mar­gin is real and half is froth (ad­mit­tedly this is a very ar­bit­rary po­s­i­tion, and I sus­pect a very small “c” con­ser­vat­ive one). That puts Clin­ton’s lead roughly com­par­able to Pres­id­ent Obama’s 2012 3.9 per­cent vic­tory mar­gin over Mitt Rom­ney. Look­ing at state-level polling, Trump does not cur­rently lead in a single state that Obama car­ried last time.

  1. She won’t have much in the way of coattails.

While I think that Clin­ton’s neg­at­ives are too high for her to win by a big, let alone land­slide mar­gin, oth­ers are talk­ing up that chance and cal­cu­lat­ing the im­plic­a­tions. People are of­ten quick to re­mem­ber the big Re­pub­lic­an gains that ac­com­pan­ied Ron­ald Re­agan’s 10-point, 51-41 point win in 1980, when he car­ried 44 states over Pres­id­ent Carter, res­ult­ing in a 34-seat House gain and 12-seat Sen­ate gain for Re­pub­lic­ans. They tend to for­get what happened in the oth­er three big land­slide pres­id­en­tial years.

In 1964, Pres­id­ent John­son beat Barry Gold­wa­ter by 22 points, 61 to 39 per­cent, car­ry­ing 44 states, ac­cord­ing to Vi­tal Stat­ist­ics on Con­gress, but while Demo­crats did pick up 37 seats in the House, their gain in the Sen­ate was a single seat. In 1972, when Pres­id­ent Nix­on was pound­ing George McGov­ern by 23 points, 61 to 38 per­cent, and car­ry­ing 49 states, Re­pub­lic­ans gained only 12 House seats and ac­tu­ally had a net loss of two seats in the Sen­ate.

  1. That’s likely to be the case even if she wins by a very large proportion of the popular vote.

Two factors make me sus­pect that even if Clin­ton wins by a much lar­ger mar­gin than, say, Obama’s win over Rom­ney four years ago, I don’t think the down-bal­lot im­plic­a­tions would be that huge. In the House, there are few­er com­pet­it­ive dis­tricts than at any point in our life­times; between nat­ur­al pop­u­la­tion sort­ing and ger­ry­man­der­ing, there just isn’t much elasti­city in the House these days. In the Sen­ate, the GOP ma­jor­ity is ab­so­lutely on the line; my guess it will end up 50-50, give or take a seat or two, but giv­en voters’ doubts about Clin­ton, the “don’t give Hil­lary Clin­ton a blank check” ar­gu­ment may well be a polit­ic­ally po­tent one, and a lot of hold-their-noses Hil­lary voters may well look for a check and bal­ance down-bal­lot.

If he’s right, the next four (or, heavens forfend, eight) years are likely to resemble the last seven years quite closely. If you think that’s a good thing, you will no doubt be delighted. Otherwise…

2 comments

Question of the Day

Will the ongoing outpouring of anti-Trump news stories, editorials, op-eds, etc. in the New York Times, Washington Post, CNN, MSNBC, et al.:

  1. Persuade voters of the folly of voting for Trump.
  2. Get tuned out.
  3. The news media doesn’t have any influence any more.
  4. The lack of balance will further discredit the news media.
  5. Persuade people that they should vote for Trump.
  6. What “outpouring”?
  7. What news media?
  8. Other
2 comments

Ghostbusters to Lose Money

The Hollywood Reporter says that based on its box office to date the Ghostbusters reboot will lose money:

Immediately upon the opening of Ghostbusters in mid-July, top Sony executives boldly declared a sequel to Paul Feig’s all-female reboot of Ivan Reitman’s 1984 classic was a given. “While nothing has been officially announced yet, there’s no doubt in my mind it will happen,” said Rory Bruer, president of worldwide distribution at Sony.

That was the studio’s last public mention of a sequel. As of Aug. 7, Ghostbusters had earned just under $180 million at the global box office, including $117 million domestic. The film still hasn’t opened in a few markets, including France, Japan and Mexico, but box-office experts say it will have trouble getting to $225 million despite a hefty net production budget of $144 million plus a big marketing spend. The studio has said break-even would be $300 million.

That’s consistent with what I’ve been predicting. However, IMO the politics of the reboot is largely a distraction. The reality is that there’s a ceiling for how much can be spent making an action comedy and $144 million is just too much. It could have been the Citizen Kane of action comedies and it would still have lost money. Maybe that’s not a good example: Citizen Kane didn’t do all that well at the box office, either. In today’s market you’ve got to take a movie’s prospects for international box office into account and comedies just don’t travel that well. The female leads may not have helped but they weren’t the only factor.

What implications will Ghostbusters failure have on the announced female Ocean’s 8? Not as much as you might think in my view. It’s not expected to be a comedy which will broaden the audience. I suspect it might face a different problem.

The Ocean’s 11 reboot did a box office of $450 million. Each of the successive sequels in what has become the “Ocean’s” franchise has earned less. Expect a ceiling of around $300 million for Ocean’s 8. Whether that’s consistent with the all-star cast they’ve announced for it remains to be seen.

1 comment

If You Feel Like It’s a Recession…

it probably is. Yesterday the Bureau of Labor Statistics revised its estimate of second quarter 2016 nonfarm business sector labor productivity to an annualized figure of -.5%:

Nonfarm business sector labor productivity decreased at a 0.5-percent annual rate during the second quarter of 2016, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today, as output increased 1.2 percent and hours worked increased
1.8 percent. (All quarterly percent changes in this release are seasonally adjusted annual rates.) From the second quarter of 2015 to the second quarter of 2016, productivity decreased 0.4 percent, the first four-quarter decline in the series since a 0.6-percent decrease in the second quarter of 2013.
(See table A.)

Labor productivity, or output per hour, is calculated by dividing an index of real output by an index of hours worked of all persons, including employees, proprietors, and unpaid family workers.

Given the fundamentals of this year’s presidential election, e.g. phlegmatic economy, unease about terrorism and the international situation more generally, the tendency of the American voter to vote for the party not holding the White House after two terms, etc., a more conventional Republican presidential candidate might well have sauntered to election in November. That this is manifestly not the case for Donald Trump shows just how weak a candidate he is.

With Hillary Clinton’s flaws as a candidate, a Rose Garden strategy would probably be more effective. That she is not doing that suggests that she recognizes that the fundamentals are not on her side.

0 comments

Their Anniversary

I’ve been rather glum today. Today would have been my parents’ wedding anniversary, more years now than I care to count.

Both of them are deceased and I guess the day is only important to me now. I can hardly forget. The date is engraved in the ring that I wear—my mother’s wedding ring, sized to fit me.

They were two people, neither of whom had much in the way of families or childhoods of their own, who joined forces, determined to be better parents than theirs had been.

They were tremendously successful at that. My siblings and I all had happy childhoods, all of us graduated from college (some of us with post-graduate degrees), we’ve all worked hard our entire lives, none of us have been divorced or convicted of any crimes, all but me are retired or nearly so, all of us are reasonably healthy for our ages.

You done good, Mama and Daddy.

5 comments