I agree wholeheartedly with Steve Verdon’s full-throated defense of free trade and specialization in his post at Outside the Beltway:
I do not get Donald Trump’s (or anyone else’s like Bernie Sanders) argument for protectionism/mercantilism. I do not understand why trade between nations is viewed a fundamentally different than trade between states in the U.S. or even between individuals and firms. To quote Don Boudreaux, I have been running a trade deficit with my grocery store ever since I started shopping for groceries. I always buy from them, but they in turn never buy anything from me. Clearly using the “logic†of these neo-mercantilists I must clearly be worse off with this arrangement. In fact, I would be so much better off if I would stop going to the grocery store and instead produce all the stuff I buy at the grocery store myself. Let me see, I’ll need some cows, some pigs. I’ll have to grow wheat and corn, I’ll need quite a bit more land too….oh yes, this will make me so much more better off. And I can spend all of my time doing this, so I’d better quit my job too.
Some might say, but it is different when it is another country. I’m still waiting for a good explanation of that one. How is it different? They aren’t Americans? So? Why should that matter? That Americans might lose their job? Okay. So what you are saying is that we should keep these people employed at a job that could be done with less cost. How is that different than welfare? It is no less a transfer of some of my income to those workers than if it were a literal cash transfer. Is that it? Are Trump and the neo-mercantilists espousing nothing more than workfare? Keeping people employed at a job that is actually more costly? That is a recipe for economic prosperity? I don’t think so.
However, as Yogi Berra put it in theory there’s no difference between theory and practice; in practice there is.
We don’t have free trade between the United States and any other country. NAFTA and the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement are mammoth managed trade agreements, not free trade. You can write a free trade agreement on the back of an envelope. The length alone of these agreements should tell you that they’re not instruments of free trade but carefully constructed to pick winners and losers which is not free trade. They remind me of Adam Smith’s famous remark:
People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices.
We don’t even have free trade between the states. Every one of the hundreds of thousands of pages of laws and regulations each state has enacted and which vary from state to state is a barrier to free trade.
In an environment of free trade there would be no restrictions on immigration, no occupational licensing, no subsidies or special tax break paid to businesses, no patents, no copyrights, no tariffs, no statements of country of manufacture, no certificates of need, and no quotas. There would either be a uniform system of laws and regulations or none at all.
Clearly, that’s not the world we live in and I think there are good arguments why we shouldn’t want to live in such a world. But each of those barriers alters the structure of supply and demand, incentivizes investments in some industries while discouraging investment in others, and generally distorts the market.
In David Ricardo’s work on trade there were natural limits to how much one nation could buy from another. In today’s world there are no such limits.
One more point: the United States will not be able to specialize in consumption while other countries specialize in production. It just doesn’t work that way.
As a result of all of the foregoing you can’t justify, for example, the TPP on the basis of free trade. You’ve got to make a reasoned value judgment based upon its net results. Is it of great enough benefit to enough people to justify? Or is it just of substantial benefit to a relative handful of people while hurting a lot more?