Casting Light on the Issue of Immigration

Harvard economist George Borjas, in an attempt at creating more light than heat on the issue of immigration in an op-ed at Politico, states the problems succinctly:

Wage trends over the past half-century suggest that a 10 percent increase in the number of workers with a particular set of skills probably lowers the wage of that group by at least 3 percent.

In other words, the increase in the number of around 20 million in the number of low-skill workers has decreased the wages of the other 60 million low-skill workers by roughly 10%. That means for someone earning $20,000 per year the effective wage implications of the significant number of low-skill immigrants that have entered the country is a loss of about $2,000—a serious loss for people in that income group.

Low-skill workers aren’t the only ones affected. About 25% of medical doctors in the U. S. are foreign-born, meaning that immigration has lowered native-born physicians’ incomes by about 10%. The same is true in information technology and other areas in which large number of foreign-born workers have been brought into the country.

There have been wealth effects, too:

The total wealth redistribution from the native losers to the native winners is enormous, roughly a half-trillion dollars a year.

That immigration is a major factor in the increase of income inequality in the U. S. over the last 40 years is obvious.

There are also cost effects:

Immigrants receive government assistance at higher rates than natives. The higher cost of all the services provided to immigrants and the lower taxes they pay (because they have lower earnings) inevitably implies that on a year-to-year basis immigration creates a fiscal hole of at least $50 billion—a burden that falls on the native population.

He’s probably understating that fiscal hole. Direct services to immigrants aren’t the only costs they impose; more people use more sewers, more roads, more emergency services, and so on and those costs aren’t reckoned in his calculation of the costs of immigration.

However, in my view the most significant contribution of Dr. Borjas’s op-ed is this observation:

But we’re worrying about the wrong things, with policy fights focused on how many and which immigrants to accept, and not enough on how to mitigate the harm they create along the way.

and he offers an example of how that might be accomplished:

Similarly, Bill Gates claims that Microsoft creates four new jobs for every H-1B visa granted; if true, firms like Microsoft should be willing to pay many thousands of dollars for each of those coveted visas. Those funds could be used to compensate and retrain the affected natives in the high-tech industry.

Sadly, I think he’s being overly optimistic. In IT for example there is no need for the additional workers. If there were you would expect wages to be rising in the sector which they are not. The income transfers from losers (American workers) to winners (him) are the purpose of Mr. Gates’s support for increased immigration of IT workers.

Stated another way do you think that the top .1% of income earners would cheerfully accept a tax increase of $500 billion per year? Which is what it would take to remediate just the wealth effects of immigration. Would they grudgingly accept it? Would they accept a tax increase of $400 billion a year? They’d still be $100 billion per year in the black. I think the answers to all of those questions are “no”.

0 comments

Cue the Attacks

I see that Chris Cillizza has now jumped into the basket of deplorables (alongside Matt Lauer) under the category of “conspiracy-mongering misogynist”. Writing at his Washingon Post column:

Hillary Clinton falling ill Sunday morning at a memorial service on the 15th anniversary of the Sept. 11 attacks will catapult questions about her health from the ranks of conservative conspiracy theory to perhaps the central debate in the presidential race over the coming days.

“Secretary Clinton attended the September 11th Commemoration Ceremony for just an hour and thirty minutes this morning to pay her respects and greet some of the families of the fallen,” spokesman Nick Merrill said. “During the ceremony, she felt overheated, so departed to go to her daughter’s apartment and is feeling much better.”

What that statement leaves out is that a) it came 90 minutes after Clinton left the ceremony b) reporters — or even a reporter — were not allowed to follow her and c) the temperature in New York City at the time of Clinton’s overheating was in the low 80s. (A heat wave over the eastern United States broke last night/this morning.)

and

Whereas Clinton and her campaign could laugh off questions about her health before today, the “overheating” episode makes it almost impossible for them to do so. Not only has it come at a time when there was growing chatter — with very little evidence — that her health was a problem but it also happened at a 9/11 memorial event — an incredibly high-profile moment with lots and lots of cameras and reporters around.

Her campaign may well try to dismiss this story as nothing more than an isolated incident, meaning nothing. (Democrats were already pushing the story of George W. Bush fainting in 2002 after choking on a pretzel, via Twitter.)

But the issue is that Clinton kept reporters totally in the dark for 90 minutes after her abrupt departure from the 9/11 memorial service for a health-related matter. No reporter was allowed to follow her. (Clinton has resisted a protective pool for coverage because Donald Trump refuses to participate in one.) This is, yet again, the Clinton campaign asking everyone to just trust it.

I’ve made no secret of my distaste for Hillary Clinton and I am repeatedly on the record as pledging that there are no circumstances under which I would vote for Donald Trump. This is a timely point at which to repeat something I’ve said before: they’re both too old to be president. I don’t care what their personal physicians say. They’re physicians not augurs. I also don’t care how long their parents lived. The presidency is a hard, wearing job. It takes a lot out of a younger person and with the ages of these candidates and the stresses of the modern presidency, their ages are a significant risk.

18 comments

How Soon They Forget

At Newsweek, Niall Ferguson plays a game of “what if?”. In this case, presumably in honor of the fifteenth anniversary of the attacks on the United States of September 11, 2001, he muses over what the world would have been like if the attacks had never taken place.

That’s a tough one but I think his version of alternative history is almost entirely wrong. In order for events to unfold as they do you’ve got to assume that at least in some sense the attacks were a consequence of Bush Administration heedlessness and that could have been remedied somehow. Nearly everything in his scenario depends on some dramatic U. S. response that doesn’t involve invading either Afghanistan or Iraq.

Let’s list what we can reasonably say about the world without the attacks on 9/11 without assuming “Al -Qaeda is preemptively decapitated, its leaders rounded up in a series of covert operations and left to the tender mercies of their home governments.” Here’s what I can come up with:

  • We would not have invaded either Afghanistan or Iraq.
  • We would have continued preparing for major power war and continued the saber-rattling against China that was so persistent pre-9/11. And that was when China’s economy was much smaller and its actions less threatening.
  • We would not have spent trillions waging war in the Middle East.
  • Thousands of Americans would still be alive who are now dead.
  • Saddam Hussein would still be alive and ruling Iraq.
  • George W. Bush would have had considerably less political leverage in the 2002-2003 period than he ended up having.

So here’s how I think that events would have unfolded:

  • We would have continued to have episodic terrorist attacks in the U. S. but nothing as dramatic and motivating as 9/11.
  • John Kerry would not have been the 2004 Democratic candidate. That was one of the consequences of the war in Iraq. His having served in the military and being (belatedly) anti-Iraq war were seen as important credentials.
  • Hillary Clinton would have been the 2004 Democratic candidate.
  • She’d’ve lost.
  • If she hadn’t been the 2004 Democratic presidential candidate, she’d’ve been the 2008 presidential candidate, i.e. the Iraq War weakened her prospects.
  • The EGTRRA of 2001 (the first Bush tax cut) had already been enacted. The Republicans might have lost some seats in 2003. The JGTRRA of 2003 (the second Bush tax cut) would not have passed.
  • DAESH would never have developed.
  • We might have been much more oppositional to China than we have been.

I welcome other alternate history speculations. Keep in mind that at least from 2001-2004 and possibly from 2005-2008 the pre-9/11 George W. Bush, the “compassionate conservative” who pushed NCLB, would have been president.

3 comments

Ignatius Doesn’t Like Trump

If there’s one thing we can glean from David Ignatius’s most recent Washington Post column, it’s that he does not like Donald Trump one bit. Neither do I, so we have that in common.

Beyond that Mr. Ignatius’s column freely intermingles assessments, preferences, and nit-picking. I agree with Mr. Ignatius’s assessment of Mr. Trump’s remark about paying for the Iraq war:

Let’s start with Trump’s comment in an NBC forum that after invading Iraq, his policy would have been to “take the oil.” That’s what many Arabs, in their most extreme conspiracy theories, believe U.S. intervention was all about. His argument that seizing the oil would’ve stopped the Islamic State is probably backward. It would have been a recruiting tool.

I think the remark was bone-headed and short-sighted. But why stop there? The invasion of Iraq was bone-headed and short-sighted. There was no practical way to do it right and that was always the case. Statements about our invasion of Iraq should begin and end there.

Mr. Trump’s remark being a “recruiting tool” for extremists is a bit of a red herring. Intervening in Iraq would be a recruiting tool for extremists and failing to intervene in Iraq has been a recruiting tool. Having made the initial error, there’s nothing we can do that is not a recruiting tool.

Mr. Ignatius’s discursion on America’s generals suggests to me that he has a preference for permanent occupation. Maybe I’m misreading him. Is what has been accomplished in Afghanistan a success or not? Has it depended on a strong U. S. military presence there?

Possibly contrary to Mr. Ignatius and certainly contrary to Mr. Trump, my view is that there never has been a victory to be had in Afghanistan or Iraq or, heavens forfend, in Syria. There are only different kinds of failures and generalship won’t change that.

However, this:

Analysts do not make policy recommendations. It’s a violation of their basic tradecraft. What they do, at best, is offer honest, unsentimental assessments of whether policies are working. Over the decades, they’ve offered withering assessments of U.S. military involvement in Vietnam, Lebanon, Iraq and Syria, to name just a few. But that doesn’t mean they’ve offered policy direction.

is nitpicking. Analysts do in fact make policy recommendations. They just don’t like it when they’re called that and whether Mr. Ignatius believes it or not human analysts are incapable of making completely “honest, unsentimental assessments” by the very fact of their humanity. They come equipped with politics, preferences, and prejudices and those invariably leak into their assessments.

0 comments

Is “Normal” Good Enough?

I have a problem with the predicate of Jonathan Chait’s most recent New York magazine article, “Hillary Clinton Is a Flawed But Normal Politician. Why Can’t America See That?” By what definition of “normal” is Hillary Clinton a normal politician?

My definition of normal would be that it includes more than two-thirds of politicians, i.e. is plus or minus one standard deviation. Is it normal for politicians to run for president and, indeed, to be praised as highly as Sec. Clinton has in doing so?

Is it normal for a politician to be in the national spotlight for more than 25 years? Is it normal for politicians to earn $153 million for giving speeches? All politicians lie, indeed, all human beings lie. Is it normal for a politician to lie so flagrantly and routinely that a leading nationally-syndicated columnist characterized her as a “congenital liar” 20 years ago?

Is it normal for people with no previous electoral record to be elected to the U. S. Senate on their first outing? Is it normal for politicians to commit crimes, be discovered, and pay no penalty?

I think that the overwhelming preponderance of the evidence is that Hillary Clinton is an extraordinary politician and, as a matter of simple fact, is abnormal. If the American people don’t consider her to be a “normal politician”, perhaps it’s because they have a better handle on the facts than Mr. Chait does.

However, there’s a greater issue. Even if being a congenital liar, committing crimes, and raising ungodly sums of money doing things that feel corrupt whether they’re prosecutable or not is normal for a politician, are they acceptable? Is it good enough?

Whether Hillary Clinton is elected to the presidency or not, I think we need to start demanding a higher standard of conduct than that from our politicians.

7 comments

What Does “Accountability” Mean?

As I read this New York Times editorial, demanding that Donald Trump be held more accountable by future debate moderators:

There was not much of a contest in Wednesday night’s forum with Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump. Mrs. Clinton answered the questions of the moderator, Matt Lauer, in coherent sentences, often with specific details. Mr. Trump alternated between rambling statements and grandiose boasts when he wasn’t lying.

Mr. Lauer largely neglected to ask penetrating questions, call out falsehoods or insist on answers when it was obvious that Mr. Trump’s responses had drifted off.

If the moderators of the coming debates do not figure out a better way to get the candidates to speak accurately about their records and policies — especially Mr. Trump, who seems to feel he can skate by unchallenged with his own version of reality while Mrs. Clinton is grilled and entangled in the fine points of domestic and foreign policy — then they will have done the country a grave disservice.

as usual I was filled with questions. What does “accountability” mean? For what should politicians be held accountable? Is it the role of journalists to determine what the truth is or to report what their researches uncover? Are television news readers journalists? Editor of major newspapers?

However hard I tried to avoid it I caught the last few minutes of NBC’s “Commander-in-Chief Forum”. What I heard was mostly inoffensive and uninteresting.

So, for example, whether Putin is a better leader than Obama is purely a matter of opinion. It is not verifiable. Should Mr. Lauer have been the arbiter of whether that were true or not and held Mr. Trump accountable for Mr. Lauer’s assessment?

Which is more important? Whether Gary Johnson doesn’t know where Aleppo is (or, possibly, its significance) or whether Hillary Clinton doesn’t know what classified means? Is either important?

I’ve read a lot of criticisms of Matt Lauer’s conduct as “moderator” of the forum, most of which seems to me can be summed up as he wasn’t doing the work of the Clinton campaign effectively enough. Is that the job of the news media?

7 comments

What’s DC’s Police Problem?

The editors of the Washington Post lament Chicago’s “police problem”:

The violence, reminiscent of the crack-cocaine epidemic that drove murders in cities across the nation in the 1990s, seems to have left officials flummoxed. Chicago Police Superintendent Eddie Johnson said Tuesday that his department is doing all it can to combat violence. “It’s not a police issue, it’s a society issue,” he said, pointing the finger instead at “impoverished neighborhoods” where “people without hope do these kinds of things.”

That sounded like an evasion. No doubt the chief is right about the complexities that give root to crime and violence. But it is clear — as evidenced by the success New York and other cities have had in curtailing homicides — that Chicago has a unique set of problems in which the police play their part. Foremost among them are the tumult and distrust that pervade police-community relations in the wake of the fatal shooting of black teen Laquan McDonald by an officer in October 2014 and the belated release of a troubling video a year later. That the police union urged its members to refuse voluntary overtime over the recent holiday weekend — when they were most needed — suggests there may be a morale problem, the “Ferguson effect” of police not doing all they can.

That verges on being self-refuting. Was the “crack-cocaine epidemic” also a police problem? Or did it reflect a societal problem?

I look forward to an in-depth investigative report from the Post on the subject. Actually, it might be cheaper for the Post to investigate the District of Columbia Police Department. In 2015 DC experienced a more than 50% increase in the number of homicides over the previous year and 2016 is on track to approximate the same number of homicides as last year. The DC police attribute the problem to guns.

The reality is actually pretty clear. The problem in both Chicago and the District is black street gangs. The factors that promote the growth in power of street gangs is one I’ll leave to those more expert than I. I doubt that either poor policing or guns are dispositive.

Here in Chicago it doesn’t help that politicians are in bed with the street gangs and that goes all the way to the top.

If you want to increase police accountability, it might help if the police were, well, accountable. Police officers who break the law and/or city policy still receive their pensions. The city pays the legal and court costs for offending police officers and on top of that pays damages to the victims of police misconduct. When police officers are violating the law and/or city policy, that Chicago’s taxpayers who by definition can have no impact on the misconduct (particularly when it’s been covered up for years or decades) is a cruel irony.

In the case of the Laquan McDonald case, despite video evidence of complicity on the part of a number of police officers, those police officers still hold their jobs quite literally years later and remain eligible for their pensions.

15 comments

It Isn’t Sleepwalking When You’re Awake

At Le Monde Diplomatique Michael Klare warns about “sleepwalking into a big war”:

Although military thinkers in the West have embraced the big-war approach with particular enthusiasm, this outlook has powerful advocates in Russia and China — actions on both sides tend to reinforce the arguments made by their military thinkers. It is clear that the problem is not East or West, but rather the shared assumption that a full-scale war between the major powers is entirely possible and requires urgent military preparations. Only by repudiating this assumption — by demonstrating how such preparations more often precipitate than discourage the outbreak of conflict — will it be possible to eliminate the risk of unintended escalation and improve the chances for success in overcoming other urgent dangers.

His article fills me with questions but I’ll limit myself to just a few. Can you imagine the U. S. going to war to defend Ukraine from the Russians? Why?

And how can you think of it as “sleepwalking” when Pentagon and Congressional leaders have been fomenting major power war for more than a decade? They’re fools but they’re wide awake fools.

7 comments

There’s Something Happening Here

I walk dogs in my neighborhood multiple times daily, 365 days a year. Doing that I walk between three and five miles every single day.

Each of the last several days I have been stopped on one of these walks by a neighbor to warn me of other neighbors being accosted, threatened, and occasionally robbed in our generally low crime neighborhood.

That’s a major change. It’s a big deal.

9 comments

Some Questions For Dr. Boudreaux


source: tradingeconomics.com

I’m not a Trump supporter and I support free trade but there’s something about Donald Boudreaux’s most recent post at TribLive that got my Irish up. In the post he asks a number of questions. Here’s the first:

If you’re like most Americans, you are descended from immigrants who arrived on these shores before Uncle Sam imposed annual quotas on the number of immigrants who could come here legally. Do you believe that America would be a better place today had your ancestors been kept from immigrating here by numerical quotas on immigration? If not, why do you believe that America in 50 or 150 years from now will be a better place if we today impose even tighter restrictions on immigration?

I can answer that. My most recent immigrant ancestors arrived here just about 150 years ago, disembarking at the Port Of New Orleans in 1865. The marginal product of labor in the United States was rising and would continue to rise along with incomes for more than a century.

That is no longer the case. Median incomes have actually decreased over the last ten years and marginal productivity has stalled. Conditions are different than they were 150 years ago and however they change in the future the way things look today it appears unlikely that the marginal productivity of labor will rise sharply. In short we don’t need more workers and bringing more in is more likely to depress the wages of the workers already here than it is to result in an improvement in the lives of those already here.

Additionally, I think I would claim that there is a cost to be associated with assimilating a new immigrant into a society. It’s cheaper to assimilate another English, Protestant immigrant into a society of mostly English Protestants than it is to assimilate an English-speaking Irish Catholic and it’s cheaper to assimilate that Irish Catholic than it is to assimilate a non-English speaking Italian Catholic or a non-English speaking Eastern European Jew. It’s cheaper to assimilate an Italian Catholic or Eastern European Jew than a non-English speaking illiterate Muslim Somali. And so on. There is a point at which the cost exceeds the benefit and I think that the empirical evidence supports the idea that we passed that point long ago.

I’d like to ask Dr. Boudreaux a few questions.

  1. Assume completely free trade and free-floating exchange rates. How do you explain the graph at the top of this post? If you can’t, then you can’t defend our present trade on the basis of free trade. How can such an imbalance persist indefinitely?
  2. Aren’t the net effects of such a persistent trade deficit that we export jobs and import deflation? Is that good?
  3. Three merchants are shipwrecked on a desert island. All they have to trade is their hats. In the absence of borrowing and lending or the discovery of some other resource, how can one merchant run a persistent deficit with another?
  4. Imagine an economy in which there are just two jobs. Entry into one job is limited by law and the number of people holding it is capped and the wage is subsidized by the government while there is free entry into the other job, no cap, and no subsidy. All other things being equal wouldn’t you expect wages in the first job to rise and wages in the other job to fall?
13 comments