It’s All the Boomers’ Fault!

I found Jonathan Russo’s proposal at The Hill for dealing with the federal debt by imposing a wealth tax on members of the Baby Boom generation interesting:

To avoid shackling the post-Boomer generations with the onerous task of paying off the national debt, the Boomers’ wealth needs to be on the table.

In his book, “A Generation of Sociopaths: How the Baby Boomers Betrayed America,” Bruce Gibney argued that “generational plunder” was their economic legacy. Through tax cuts and deficit financing of several wars, the Boomers left America in shock. “Plunder” is a strong word. In the corporate legal world, it is enough to justify a clawback of the plunderers’ assets.

That the rich and powerful owe something to the government that gave them the ability to amass so much wealth is not unheard of. The group Patriotic Millionaires and its most visible member, Abigail Disney, argue that they themselves should pay more in taxes. They claim that American tax codes are riddled with loopholes that often make the rich pay lower average rates than working people — something Warren Buffet has spoken about for years and which was recently brought up in President Biden’s State of the Union speech.

I was unaware that the Baby Boomers had been conspiring to enrich themselves at the expense of the generations that preceded them and follow them. Or that they had used their control of the legislative and executive branches of government to do it.

As it turns out there has never been a time during which the Speaker of the House, the Senate Majority Leader, and the president were all Baby Boomers. Such a time may never come. Furthermore, the author is looking at a snapshot of national wealth when he should be looking at a movie. Courtesy of Statista here is a graph illustrating the distribution of wealth by age cohort over time:
Statistic: Wealth distribution in the United States from the first quarter of 1990 to the fourth quarter of 2023, by generation | Statista
Find more statistics at Statista
As you can see the Baby Boomers’ holding of the majority of national wealth didn’t start until 2005 and it’s already beginning to decline. Meanwhile the Silent Generation held the majority of national wealth for a full fifteen years (at least)—you can’t actually tell how long due to the limitations of the graph. Most of the debt has been racked up by the Silent Generation.

Shorter: as Willie Sutton put it he robbed banks because that’s where the money is. Don’t worry. The Baby Boomers won’t have their wealth for long.

5 comments… add one
  • steve Link

    Boomers have gotten a bad rap. I think some of that is people keep assuming that our leaders who were Silent Gen were Boomers. The other end of this is the assumption that Gen X and the Millennials are suffering badly. When looked at comparable periods to the Boomers they are actually doing pretty well.

    OT- Nice piece on Putin/Xi

    https://www.spytalk.co/p/dmitri-alperovitch-on-the-new-cold

    Steve

  • Drew Link

    Speaking of statistical bullshit.

    I couldn’t get past the notion of these monolithic descriptions being applied. I’m a baby boomer. My tax paid to government usage ratio is absolutely off the charts. So whether it’s really the Silent Gen or BBS, I don’t care. These broad generalizations are just clownish.

  • WRT the federal debt my advice is to consider the Rule of Holes.

  • Grey Shambler Link

    Nonsense.
    If the broad grouping of one generation, (assuming they can even be identified),
    appears to be wealthier than any other you can bet there is another generation with designs of inheriting that wealth.
    Try to find a consensus for taxing wealth of people by age bracket. LOL.

  • Millennials have outnumbered Baby Boomers since 2022.

    However, I suspect that a breakdown of registered voters by age cohort tells a somewhat different story.

Leave a Comment