Delivering

There is one thing in Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders’s Fox News op-ed with which I agree wholeheartedly:

Democrats now have the votes to pass legislation that will greatly improve the lives of millions of working families. And that’s exactly what they must do. No more empty rhetoric and poll-driven messaging.

No more telling people, over and over again, how terrible Donald Trump and the Republicans are. No more excuses. The new Democratic majority must deliver for a long-neglected working class.

The balance of the op-ed consists of his agenda for Democrats. I agree with many of the objectives he outlines. Healthcare is very expensive. The gap between the very rich, the merely rich, and the ordinary person is too great. ICE’s enforcement practices have been quite harsh over the last several years and we need immigration reform.

There is one agenda item with which I completely disagree. We don’t need a moratorium on building data centers. There are legitimate questions about their electricity consumption, water requirements, siting, and effects on local infrastructure but a blanket moratorium is a remarkably blunt instrument for addressing those concerns and one that threatens a major engine of economic growth and jeopardizes an important American competitive advantage.

But there is a connecting thread linking his proposals for remedying the ills he identifies. They are mismatched. To cite some examples the ultra-rich didn’t become that way simply because taxes were too low. In at least one case they did so by exploiting the incentives that Congress gave them. Ordinary people’s incomes didn’t stagnate because the minimum wage was too low. Healthcare did not become expensive because of insurance companies. Not to mention that Congress’s track record on controlling the growth of healthcare spending is weak. Sen. Sanders’s “Medicare for All” depends on that control.

The message here isn’t “be careful what you wish for”. It’s “be careful how you try to get it”. Good intentions are no substitute for understanding incentives, anticipating consequences, and learning from experience.

2 comments… add one
  • Bob Sykes Link

    Sanders is an old school Marxist, and he focuses on workers and their needs, not woke nonsense or the “needs” of rich upper class white girls in elite private colleges. The Dims should enact a working class agenda, and force Trump to veto it. They can’t override a veto in either House, but they can accumulate issues for 2028. I’m not sure the woke wing will let that happen.

    While I support rounding up and deporting illegal immigrants, clearly the ICE field agents are poorly trained and undisciplined. That needs to change.

    I’m somewhat surprised that Sanders has not openly joined the DSA faction in the Senate. Perhaps his base is not as far left as often represented.

  • Drew Link

    Good luck, Bernie. And as a gesture of your sincerity, which of your three properties, not to mention your private jet rides, are you giving up?

    I dont even fly private………you disingenuous fuck.

Leave a Comment