It is not true that “no one saw it coming”. There were, in fact, economists who predicted the financial crisis that led to the Great Recession and
1) cited an actual economic model in support of their argument, 2) pointed to the specific set of forces that really did lead to the crisis, and 3) got the timing right
but those economists were not followers of a mainstream school of economics thought so their findings fell on deaf ears. Those are the messages of John T. Harvey’s post at Forbes.
Unfortunately, a shortcoming of Dr. Harvey’s post is that he neglects to tell us who those economists were or how their views diverged from economic orthodoxy. It took a certain amount of detective work but I managed to figure it out.
Dirk Bezemer, the author cited by Dr. Harvey in his post, had a post of his own at the portal of the Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR), “‘No one saw this coming’ – or did they?”. As it turns out the economists who successfully predicted the crisis were proponents of something called the “flow of funds” macroeconomic model:
The model is solved by imposing macro accounting identities and adaptive expectations rather than individual optimisation. There is a steady state but not equilibrium. One advantage is that growth paths can be identified as unsustainable given the existing “bedrock†accounting relations. This allowed Godley and Wray in 2000 to conclude that “Goldilocks was doomed†– with a government surplus and current account deficit, US economic growth had to be predicated on ongoing and unsustainably high rates of private debt growth.
Here’s Dr. Bezemer’s summary of the flow of funds model:
In “Flow of Funds†models, liquidity generated in the financial sector flows to firms, households and the government as they borrow. This may facilitate fixed-capital investment and production, but it may also feed asset price inflation, consumption, and debt growth. Liquidity returns to the financial sector as financial investments or in payment of debt service and financial fees. Key features of “Flow of Funds†models are thus bank credit flows, since “evolving finance in the form of bank loans is required if production is to be financed …†(Godley, 1999:405). Also, there are explicit payment flows such as interest, “not quite the same as in the national accounts, where it is standard practice… to ignore interest payments, although they are an inevitable cost given that production takes time†(Godley, 1999:405).
If Carmelo Saleo’s assessment is correct, the flow of funds macroeconomic model may not be particularly helpful from a policy standpoint:
So maybe the bottom line is that the quantity theory of money is still a solid intellectual framework to think about monetary economics, and a good starting point to understand the general dynamics of money. But as a simple direct policy tool its best days might be already behind us (which, by the way, is no news to central bankers…).
Or, said another way, neither Neo-Classical, Keynesian, Neo-Keynesian, monetarist, nor the model that actually predicted the financial crisis provides any particular guidance.






