The end of an op-ed is a very strange place to put your premises but that’s what James Capretta and Scott Gottlieb have done in their Wall Street Journal op-ed sketching their proposals for the requirements of a program to replace the Affordable Care Act:
American health care is teetering because it relies too much on governmental coercion. A functioning marketplace can deliver high-quality care at lower cost. Now is the time to secure a system that empowers consumers to take command of their health care.
Those are actually six different premises and I’m not sure I agree with any of them. To restate they’re saying that
- The American healthcare system is teetering.
- Excessive government coercion is causing it to teeter.
- It is possible for the U. S. healthcare system to deliver high-quality care at lower cost.
- That can be effected by introducing a functioning marketplace.
- It is possible for ordinary Americans to “take command of their health care”.
- That can be done now.
What does it mean to say that “American health care is teetering”? If they mean that the present rate of cost increase cannot be sustained indefinitely, I’d agree. Otherwise I think I disagree. It’s certainly an idiosyncratic use of the word “teetering”.
The American health care system has never been larger, made more money, or been more effective. If that is teetering, I’ll have some. The present system has several defects:
- Too many people receive inadequate care.
- Others are over-treated.
- Between 50% and 70% of the present system is funded via tax dollars.
- The rate at which costs are increasing exceeds the rate at which the non-healthcare GDP is increasing, tax revenues are increasing, or non-healthcare income are increasing.
That’s simultaneously unjust, unhealthy, and unsustainable. You can prove the unsustainability part yourself by drawing some graphs on a piece of paper. Just assume that healthcare costs are presently about a quarter of total spending and that they’re rising three times as fast as revenues.
If the system isn’t teetering, it cannot be the case that government coercion is causing it to teeter. Even if healthcare is teetering and by “government coercion” they mean the Affordable Care Act, I challenge them to prove the claim. I think there’s a much better case that the rate at which costs are increasing is inducing the problems in our healthcare system.
I’m also skeptical of the claim that high-quality care can be delivered at lower cost. I’m confident that a uniform level of care could be delivered at lower cost. Would that uniform level of care be high quality? Would it even be adequate? What does “high quality” mean? I think it’s a campaign slogan rather than practical program.
Let’s jump to the “functioning market” point. What does that mean? It smacks of “no true Scotsman”. There has never been a national health care market and the very notion is nonsensical. There are actually thousands of little health care markets, none of them completely market-driven.
For our healthcare system to be completely market-driven we’d need to abandon government subsidies for healthcare, occupational licensing, government approval of treatments, procedures, and drugs, malpractice as the standard of medical misbehavior, and patents, just to hit the high points. Can you imagine our doing all of those? Me, neither.
I’m familiar with the studies that have shown that people can lower their healthcare costs by economizing. I’ve never seen a study that shows the ordinary people can economize and maintain a reasonable standard of health. Indeed, the studies I’ve seen suggest that people are as likely to economize on necessary care as on excessive care.
Rather than people taking control of their own healthcare, I think we’re stuck with letting professionals control their patients’ healthcare. The total volume of knowledge is just growing too fast for any other alternative. Professionals have considerable difficulty in keeping up with it.
Once you’ve accepted that, the opportunities become much more limited.







