That Word Does Not Mean What You Think It Means

I found one interesting fact in Aaron Blake’s Washington Post article on the selective use of statistics in discussing the 2016 election. As a percentage of the eligible voters the greatest victory of any president in the last century was Lyndon Johnson’s over Barry Goldwater. He got 37.8% of the votes of eligible voters.

The implication of that is that if your notion of presidential legitimacy is based on strict majority rule we haven’t had a legitimate president in the last century.

In Mexico just to cite one example of 22 countries in the world voting is mandatory. Should we go in that direction?

1 comment

More on That Russian Hacking

At RealClearPolitics Charles Lipson outlines what we know about Russia’s cyber-espionage with respect to the 2016 elections:

  1. According to U. S. intelligence agencies Russia engaged in widespread cyber-espionage.
  2. The objective of the cyber-espionage was to acquire “secret information” from political operatives.
  3. Disclosures hurt Hillary Clinton, not Donald Trump.
  4. There is no consensus about Russian intentions.

and calls for a bipartisan commission to investigate Russia’s hacking, a view that I fully endorse.

Read the whole thing. An important observation from Dr. Lipson: “There is zero evidence they changed any vote counts.”

3 comments

On That Russian “Meddling”

With respect to yesterday’s big news story, the report on Russian “meddling” in our recent election, while I definitely think we should investigate it I think the story to date is pretty weak tea. No actual evidence of anything has been shown to date other than the ineptitude of the Democratic Party organization with respect to data security.

I also think that it’s a bit amusing to see the consternation. I don’t recall anything like this level of dismay over U. S. meddling in Russian politics in the late 90s.

24 comments

And Then There’s Wealth Inequality

Recently, I’ve posted several times about income inequality but there are other sorts of inequality, including wealth inequality and social inequality. You might find Michael Heise’s observations on wealth inequality at Project Syndicate interesting. Among the points he makes are the difficulty of defining inequality:

Even the most basic question – how much inequality is too much – is virtually impossible to answer. There is no “natural rate of inequality” characterizing an economy in equilibrium, a level at which policymakers can aim. Instead, countries’ rates of inequality are measured against one another – a narrow approach that ignores everything from broader economic trends to differences in the impact of wealth inequality on populations in different social environments.

On the effects of central banks’ monetary policies:

On the national level, inequality is rising, but only in some places. In the emerging economies, the share of wealth owned by the middle class is increasing, indicating a drop in wealth inequality. It is primarily in the industrialized world that inequality is on the rise, with the share of wealth held by the top 10% growing the most.

This discrepancy may be explained partly by the fact that the global financial crisis was most painful for the advanced countries, especially in Europe. But the expansionary monetary policies that advanced-country central banks pursued after the crisis made a bad situation worse.

Those policies pushed up prices of assets – especially bonds and equities – that were held largely by wealthy households. At the same time, they hurt middle-class savers, who typically rely on duller savings instruments like bank deposits. With zero or, later, negative interest rates, those savers lost out. Though median households are generally benefiting from lower borrowing costs, wealthier households are benefiting much more, thanks in part to savings on mortgage loans, which are highest relative to income for the upper middle class.

But the impact of ultra-loose monetary policy extends far beyond today’s wealth and income effects. With advanced-country populations aging rapidly, saving for old age is more important than ever. With very low interest rates reducing the rate of accumulation of pension assets, all but the wealthiest households will probably have to boost savings and/or reduce consumption, now and in the future. The decline in lifetime spending will ultimately have a negative impact on growth and potentially generate social fault lines for the coming generations.

And the differences in the acceptability of wealth inequality between societies:

Complicating the inequality narrative further are differences across individual economies, including among those that, technically, have similar levels of inequality. Consider the disparities between the US, Denmark, and Sweden – all three of which are among the world’s most unequal societies, with respect to the distribution of wealth.

Denmark and Sweden are known for their well-developed social-welfare systems, free education, and high labor-market participation. Moreover, Denmark took the top spot in the United Nations’ World Happiness report last year, suggesting that wealth inequality does not trouble Danes too much.

By contrast, in the US, which lacks many of the social protections provided by its northern European counterparts, inequality is very troubling indeed. The increase in wealth inequality there over the last decade has been the most pronounced of any country. Today, the US has the smallest middle class, holding just 22% of total net financial assets, half the average of other industrialized countries, and the highest concentration of wealth than in any other country.

I’m more concerned about the distribution of wealth or income within societies than comparing those distributions between societies. I think that there are just too many variables whose effects are not well understood to make meaningful comparisons.

I also think that a just income or wealth distribution should be thought of as a distribution, i.e. when income and wealth occur in distributions other than a normal distribution there are probably factors other than chance or even merit at work.

In the United States as I’ve shown before the distribution of wealth and income are somewhat weighted toward the richest five or ten percent. We should be thinking about the factors that produce that and the cost of addressing them.

1 comment

Refocusing the Healthcare Debate

At the RAND organization’s blog Jeffrey Wasserman brings up a too long overlooked point. Our healthcare system is far too focused on care and not focused nearly enough on health:

International comparisons of aggregate health outcomes provide additional evidence of the poor return America is getting for its national health expenditures. A 2015 report by the Commonwealth Fund, for example, found that the United States had the lowest life expectancy at birth and the highest infant mortality rate of the 13 high-income countries included in the study. The prevalence of chronic diseases was also highest in the United States. Ditto for the obesity rate.

It is important to recognize that even if the United States had a high-performing health care system, it is unlikely that it would improve aggregate health outcomes appreciably. This is because health care may account for as little as 10 percent of Americans’ overall health, with the balance due to social and environmental factors, individual behaviors and genetics.

Unfortunately, efforts to address some of these other factors, in particular social and environmental ones, have also come up short. The Commonwealth Fund report noted that the United States spent less on social services—pensions, employment programs, supportive housing, etc.—than the comparison countries. A similar result was obtained by a group of researchers from RAND Europe, which also found a high correlation between social service spending and key health outcomes.

Yet money alone is not the answer. In fact, the United States spends almost double the amount of the next highest-spending country (France) on health care. Instead, existing resources could be better targeted at high-value care and away from unnecessary and low-value care. This can be achieved through a variety of means that include improving the ways in which health care provider performance is measured and reported; creating user-friendly tools for consumers that enable them to make valid price and quality comparisons; and altering the financial incentives faced by health care providers in ways that reward providing high-value care.

How would a system in which the emphasis was on health rather than care be different from the present one? That’s a question. I’d really like to know the answer.

I suspect we’d be spending more on people from age 0 to 30 and spend less on those over the age of 65 but that’s just a guess.

1 comment

What Madigan Hath Wrought

In his last election Speaker of the Illinois House Michael J. Madigan received 17,155 votes in the primary and ran unopposed in the general election. He is the longest-serving speaker of any state legislature in the United States. He has become quite wealthy as a consequence of his elective office.

In Illinois state legislators do very little. Mostly they rubber-stamp the decisions of the leadership. Consequently, nobody is more responsible for Illinois’s fiscal mess than Mike Madigan, as this City Journal article by Daniel DiSalvo points out:

Illinois currently holds the dubious distinction of being the most fiscally derelict state in America. In 2015, Moody’s downgraded Illinois’ general-obligation bonds from A3 to Baa1, the lowest ranking among the 50 states. The state’s pension systems are only 40 percent funded, the worst ratio in the country. Forbes rated Illinois’ business climate 38th among states last year. Chicago, the state’s economic engine, has been cratering under the weight of huge pension costs, and had to enact a $500 million property-tax increase last year. In addition, Chicago’s schools are in crisis, and—most disturbing of all—the city has watched its crime rate explode. The migration rate out of Illinois over the last five years has been the highest of any state.

Digging so deep a fiscal and economic hole takes effort. Many people doubtless share some of the culpability. But if one person should be singled out as responsible for Illinois’ political and economic mess, it would be House Speaker Madigan. Unlike Rauner, who just arrived on the political scene, Madigan is at the heart of Illinois’ political establishment. Chicago magazine has long ranked him among the “most powerful” people in the Windy City.

Madigan, 74, has been involved in electoral politics for 43 years and has served as speaker of the Illinois House for 31 of those—making him the longest-serving state house speaker in U.S. history. His duties hardly stop there. He is also the chairman of the state Democratic Party, a partner in Chicago’s most successful property-tax law firm, and—last, but not least—a committeeman for Chicago’s 13th Ward, a post he has held since he was 27. These four positions and their associated networks of patronage appointees, legislative staffers, corporate lobbyists, campaign donors, industry clients, and family members are what some in Illinois refer to as “Madiganistan” or the “Madigan industrial complex.”

Mr. Madigan has made his objectives quite clear:

  1. Maintain his own control over the state legislature.
  2. Maintain Democratic majorities in the state legislature.

Getting his daughter, presently serving as state attorney, elected governor might be in the mix there somewhere.

The citizens of Illinois, still predominantly Democrats, demonstrated their displeasure with “business as usual” by electing a Republican, Bruce Rauner, governor in 2015. Very little has been accomplished since then because of the stonewalling of the legislature. Lest one think that the problem is Rauner’s, can anyone seriously contend that we would have been better off if Pat Quinn had been elected?

Illinois presently has the highest net rate of domestic outmigration of any state. They’ve done what they can at the ballot box. Now they’re voting with their feet.

6 comments

Priorities

You know, with all of the concern or even dismay expressed about Trump’s nominations for Secretary of State, Defense, and the Treasury, it’s amazing that so little has been mentioned about what’s likely to be the single most influential cabinet officer of his presidency: the Secretary of Commerce.

0 comments

The Effects of Income Inequality

From Ben Casselman’s post at FiveThirtyEight on the “erosion of the American Dream”:

The researchers identify two main drivers of the drop in mobility. First, economic growth has slowed in recent decades. That means the economic pie is growing more slowly than it used to, which makes it harder for each generation to surpass the previous one — there is less new income to go around. Second, income inequality has risen, which means that fewer people are benefiting from any new income being generated. Chetty and his colleagues estimate that inequality is more than twice as important as slowing growth, accounting for more than 70 percent of the decline in mobility.

Here’s another effect of the change in income distribution. Much is being made right now about a plan to reform Social Security. Social Security’s gravest problem is that one of its assumptions has failed.

Forty years ago 90% of income was subject to the payroll tax that funds Social Security. Now 79% of income is. The simplest way to reform Social Security is to restore the assumptions and raise FICA max so that 90% of income is subject to the payroll tax again.

Here’s something else that present economic conditions have shown to be unworkable: eliminating Social Security. If you can think of a way that ordinary people earning ordinary incomes can save for their retirements with interest rates as low as they are now, I’m all ears. To accomplish that now, you’ve got to assume risk and as soon as you assume risk there’s a possibility of losing your principle. If saving for your retirement means you must be prepared to lose your principle, we still need a Social Security program.

19 comments

The Fed’s Balance Sheet

There’s an interesting summary of views on the Federal Reserve’s balance sheet and whether it presents a problem over at John Cochrane’s blog.

My own view is that some leakage from the Fed’s balance sheet into the real economy is inevitable and, indeed, unless there is the Fed’s strategy is nonsense. They’re assuming there is. It doesn’t a lot of billions worth of leakage to make a relative handful of bankers and financiers insanely wealthy, aggravating our existing problems with income inequality.

5 comments

Portland’s Excessive Compensation Tax

I found this article in Fortune on Portland’s new tax on excessive compensation for CEOs of companies doing business in Portland remarkably uninformative. Here’s what it said:

  • Portland has imposed a 10% surtax on companies that pay their CEOs more than 100 times the median employee pay and a 25% surtax on companies that pay their CEOs more than 250 times.
  • Businesses don’t like it.
  • The system can be gamed.

Where’s the beef? That’s a paragraph not an article.

4 comments