In his column in the Washington Post summarizing how U. S. policy has failed in Syria, David Ignatius remarks:
In the annals of covert warfare, the CIA’s support for the Syrian opposition deserves a special, dark chapter. The effort began late — nearly two years into the war — after extremists had already begun to dominate the fight against President Bashar al-Assad. It was a hodgepodge of regional states and their pet fighters — nominally coordinated from operations centers in Jordan and Turkey but in reality controlled by more than 80 local militias whose commanders were often corrupt and proto-jihadists themselves.
The CIA and its partners were never willing to give the opposition the weapons — especially the shoulder-fired antiaircraft missiles — that could have won the battle. The agency did provide anti-tank weapons that were potent enough that Assad was rocked in the summer of 2015, and analysts began to worry about “catastrophic success,†with the regime collapsing and jihadists filling a power vacuum in Damascus. Soon after that, Russia intervened.
The CIA’s biggest problem was that its allies couldn’t stop the dominance of al-Qaeda’s Syrian affiliate, Jabhat al-Nusra. The “vetted†opposition groups might pretend otherwise, but they were fighting alongside Jabhat al-Nusra, which rebranded itself this year as Jabhat Fatah al-Sham. The extremists attracted the other opposition groups for a simple reason: Their fighters were the most willing to die for the cause.
U. S. policy in the conflict has been to oppose the Assad regime and support the rebels against him with money, equipment, training, and U. S. advisors.
What should U. S. policy with respect to Syria have been?
- Butt out.
- Publicly, butt out. Privately, discourage our allies in the region from helping the rebels and maintain negative reciprocity with the Russians.
- Support the Assad regime against the rebels.
- U. S. policy in the Syrian conflict has been perfect in every way.
- Do everything we’ve done plus establish a “no-fly” zone.
- Do more of everything we’ve done.
- Do more of everything we’ve done plus establish a “no-fly” zone.
- Full scale direct military intervention.
I am inclined to (B) with (A) my second preference and (C) a distant third. I believe that Mr. Ignatius’s preference was (G). Or maybe (H).







