Millennial Debt Load

In response to a specific question about the debt load carried by millennials here’s what I’ve learned:

  • Millennials (defined as those born after 1981) carry a very heavy load of mostly educational debt:

    Our research using data from the National Financial Capability Study shows that two-thirds of millennials (those aged 23-35 in 2012) have at least one source of long-term debt outstanding—whether student loans, home mortgages or car payments—and 30% have more than one. Among the college-educated, a staggering 81% have at least one source of long-term debt.

    Not only do millennials carry debt, but they struggle with it. A majority report having too much debt, difficulty in making payments, and worries about it. Specifically, the ability to pay off student loans troubles more than half of millennials who have such loans. Low-income respondents tend to be more concerned than higher-income earners, but even 34% of millennials with annual household income above $75,000 doubt they will be able to repay their student loans. Moreover, even several years after college, the percentage of those worried about repaying student loans remains high. Fifty-four percent of millennials who are over age 30 and have student loans are worried about repaying them.

  • Millennials may not be carrying more debt than previous cohorts:

    A chart from Deutsche Bank Economist Torsten Sløk shows that millennials, ages 20 to 35, have less debt than the same age cohort did in 2003.

    “It is an urban myth that the young generation today is more indebted, it is the older generations that have higher debt levels,” said Sløk in a note. “The reason is that since 2009 it has been difficult for Millennials to get a loan. As a result, 25 to 35 year olds today have less debt than in 2003.”

  • Lack of credit-worthiness not preference is the main reason that Millennials have lower rates of homeownership than previous cohorts:

    Rising student debt — which results in a lack of available funds to put toward a down payment — is a primary factor in reduced homeownership among young people ages 25-34, according to Irene Lew, research assistant at the Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies. In addition, delinquency and default on those loans means debtors have trouble qualifying for low interest rates or a mortgage.

Whether millennials’ and their parents’ investment in education will prove to be a good one remains to be seen. My own opinion is that most people, not just millennials, seek higher education because of the competitive advantage it gives them in looking for jobs. That’s a mug’s game.

For a quick, shorthand explanation of why it’s a mug’s game, there are more Indians with college educations than there are Americans period. And there are a lot with post-graduate degrees as well.

1 comment

Four Cohorts

I don’t know that I’m trying to convey any particular message with this post other than that the life expectations of the last four cohorts of Americans are probably pretty different from one another. The graph above was taken from an excellent post by sociologist Lane Kenworthy who remarks:

The lower line shows median income among families with a “head” aged 25 to 34. The top line shows median income among the same cohort of families twenty years later, when their heads are aged 45 to 54. Consider the year 1979, for instance. The lower line tells us that in 1979 the median income of families with a 25-to-34-year-old head was about $58,000 (in 2013 dollars). The data point for 1979 in the top line looks at the median income of that same group of families twenty years later, in 1999, when they are 45 to 54 years old. This is the peak earning stage for most people, and their median income is now about $91,000.

In each year, the gap between the two lines is roughly $33,000. This tells us that the incomes of middle-class Americans tend to increase substantially as they move from the early years of the work career to the peak years.

Should this reduce our concern about the over-time pattern shown in figures 4 and 5 above? No, it shouldn’t. Look again at figure 6. Between the mid-1940s and the mid-1970s, the median income of families in early adulthood (the lower line) rose steadily. In the mid-1940s median income for these young families was around $27,000; by the mid-1970s it had doubled. Americans during this period experienced income gains over the life course, but they also tended to have higher incomes than their predecessors, both in their early work years and in their peak years. That’s because the economy was growing at a healthy clip and the economic growth was trickling down to Americans in the middle.

After the mid-1970s, this steady gain disappeared. From the mid-1970s to 2013 the median income of families with a 25-to-34-year-old head was flat. They continued to achieve income gains during the life course. (Actually, we don’t yet know about those who started out after the mid-1990s, as they’re just now beginning to reach age 45 to 54. The question marks in the chart show what their incomes will be if the historical trajectory holds true.) But the improvement across cohorts that characterized the period from the mid-1940s through the 1970s — each cohort starting higher and ending higher than earlier ones — disappeared.

I’ve annotated the graph to highlight the last four cohorts: Silent Generation, Baby Boomers, Generation X, and Millennials. I won’t belabor the point by explaining in tedious detail how very different the experiences of the four cohorts are. The graph really says it all.

I don’t believe that either demographics or economics are destiny but I do believe that they can tell you a lot. It’s too early to know what the courses of life for Millennials will be—they’re only represented by the very tail end of the chart. However, we can speculate, as this USA Today article suggests:

SOUTH MILWAUKEE, Wisconsin (AP) — Baby Boomers: your millennial children are worse off than you.

With a median household income of $40,581, millennials earn 20 percent less than boomers did at the same stage of life, despite being better educated, according to a new analysis of Federal Reserve data by the advocacy group Young Invincibles.

The analysis being released Friday gives concrete details about a troubling generational divide that helps to explain much of the anxiety that defined the 2016 election. Millennials have half the net worth of boomers. Their home ownership rate is lower, while their student debt is drastically higher.

It would be interesting to know what has happened over the last four or five years. My guess is that gap between the lines will narrow.

11 comments

Not to Use

A quote that has stuck with me through the years is something attributed to Morrie Mages, the founder of a small Chicago-area chain of sporting goods stores. In response to complaints about the quality of the goods sold in his stores he said “These aren’t sporting goods to use; they’re sporting goods to sell.”

I think there are quite a few valuable observations in Ian Bogost’s plaint in Atlantic that nothing works anymore:

What adult hasn’t suffered the pneumatic public toilet’s whirlwind underneath them? Or again when attempting to exit the stall? So many ordinary objects and experiences have become technologized—made dependent on computers, sensors, and other apparatuses meant to improve them—that they have also ceased to work in their usual manner. It’s common to think of such defects as matters of bad design. That’s true, in part. But technology is also more precarious than it once was. Unstable, and unpredictable. At least from the perspective of human users. From the vantage point of technology, if it can be said to have a vantage point, it’s evolving separately from human use.

But it’s something of a grab bag. It tangles true statements with misunderstandings.

From my point of view toilets stopped working when the federal government got into the act of determining how much water a toilet should use. It was well-intentioned as so many of the federal government’s ill-conceived schemes are but micromanagement is not the federal government’s forte. When the objective is to reduce water use, I believe that it’s reasonable for the Congress or even bureaucrats to set targets but should leave the details of implementation or how meeting the targets is accomplished to private companies and individuals. Taxes can be levied; penalties could be imposed (if they dare) on states and municipalities. Once you’ve gotten to the level of detail of how much water should be used per flush and, importantly, ignored actually reducing water utilization, you’ve entered the realm of fanaticism.

As to voice response systems, why do big businesses have phones at all any more? I know that some don’t. Phone systems used to be part of the entire customer relationship management systems of companies. Now they’re labyrinths with the presumed objective of losing customers in their twists and turns. That isn’t a technological problem; it’s a management problem and the sad reality is that good management is always in short supply.

This:

Digital distribution has also made media access more precarious. Try explaining to a toddler that the episodes of “Mickey Mouse Clubhouse” that were freely available to watch yesterday via subscription are suddenly available only via on-demand purchase.

is just a misunderstanding. Mass media targeted at children have never been public services. They now serve and always have served the purpose of making money in the present and in the future. I blame Howdy Doody.

If you want to keep your children from being trained to be good little consumers or dragoon their parents into ever-increasing consumption, throw out your television and homeschool them. Even then you’re merely fighting a delaying action. Otherwise be prepared to ante up or give explanations.

7 comments

The Game Changer

At Phys Org they explore a development that could be a game changer not just in agriculture but in the debate on immigration—a robot field hand that would cost less than a used car. The authors’ emphasis is on the use of such robots for research that would lead to improvements in crop breeding. I doubt that’s where the real utility will be.

0 comments

Assumptions

At Harvard Business Review Gautam Mukunda provides a strategic framework for actions by Democrats to try to emerge from what is possibly the party’s weakest position since it became a political party. His strategy has four distinct fronts:

  • Oppose Trump-supported popular measures, e.g. his infrastructure bill.
  • Support Republican elite-supported popular measures, e.g. increased defense spending.
  • Oppose Trump-supported unpopular measures, e.g. substantial decreases in legal immigration.
  • Oppose Republican elite-supported unpopular measures, e.g. Medicare privatization, and blame Trump for them.

I think it’s far more likely that Democrats will take a purely oppositional approach and oppose everything supported by any Republican, ignoring the political reality that Americans see the country as going in the wrong direction by substantial margins but less so that at any time in the last four years (and then only for a short period—the 4th quarter of 2012). In other words Americans still hunger for change.

I think there are two problems with Dr. Mukunda’s proposed approach. First, he assumes without providing evidence that marginal Trump voters are the same as independents in general. What if they aren’t? It’s the entire linchpin of the strategy.

He also assumes, without evidence, that the circumstances of Democrats and Republicans are symmetrical, i.e. similar strategies will have similar effects. But Democrats are the party of government or at least seen to be such and strident opposition to Trump and/or Republicans by bureaucratic Washington encourages that view. What if a federal government that continues in its dysfunction is blamed on the Democrats?

9 comments

Herd Mentality

As I read this post at Bloomberg on how the Netherlands has become increasingly anti-immigrant, this passage leapt out at me:

This being the Netherlands, a trading nation that prides itself on its ability to find a consensus, this tug of war will eventually result in some kind of compromise. Though Wilders probably won’t govern after the March election since no big party wants to form a coalition with PVV, Niemoeller expects his strong showing to shift the national consensus. “We have these almost mystical changes,” he says. “Our elite changed to a 60’s liberal mentality in one summer. We went from rejection to acceptance of euthanasia in one summer — nobody could see why. So maybe we’ll end up agreeing that Islam is a big problem in the same way.”

I’ve written before about the differences between large, extremely diverse countries like the United States and small, homogeneous countries like some of the ethnic states of Europe. Sometimes whole countries aren’t unlike a large, extended family.

One of those differences is that opinion has tended to be uniform but that does not necessarily mean unchangeable. It means it can turn on a dime.

1 comment

Poor Nicholas Kristof

He may be finding himself without a political home. From his recent New York Times column:

Go ahead and denounce Trump’s lies and bigotry. Stand firm against his disastrous policies. But please don’t practice his trick of “otherizing” people into stick-figure caricatures, slurring vast groups as hopeless bigots. We’re all complicated, and stereotypes are not helpful — including when they’re of Trump supporters.

But what if the problem isn’t Trump but the 46% of voters who voted for him? And is it any wonder that I’m concerned that civil war is the logical outcome of our present political circumstances?

10 comments

Is NATO Obsolete?

At The National Interest there’s an interesting article on NATO from Belgian professor Tom Sauer. Here’s a snippet:

NATO’s post–Cold War track record is dismal, which is not surprising, given the nature of the beast. Apart from the Balkans, which are more or less stable (although tensions are flaring up again these days), the NATO military interventions in Afghanistan and Libya are a complete failure. Thirteen and six years after NATO’s intervention, respectively, these states have hardly stabilized. On the contrary, Afghanistan and Libya are breeding places for terrorists. Again, this should not come as a surprise, because collective defense organizations are not meant for carrying out peace-building operations.

The biggest mistake, however, was NATO expansion. It is hard to refute the thesis that the Ukraine crisis is the result of interference by NATO and the EU in Russia’s spheres of influence. A red line was crossed, in the eyes of Moscow, and Russia had repeatedly made that position clear in advance. NATO expansion also contradicted Western promises. On the basis of these oral guarantees, in February 1990, Mikhail Gorbachev gave the green light for German reunification talks. And what did the West do? Expand NATO. Not just once, but twice. At the NATO Summit in Bucharest in 2008, President Bush even pushed through (against the wishes of the Europeans) a third extension, namely the promise to include Georgia and Ukraine into NATO. What did he expect Russia would do? Just take notice and agree?

More fundamentally, the West made the mistake after the end of the Cold War not to include Russia into the Euro-Atlantic security architecture on an equal basis. Contrary to positive examples in 1815 and 1945, the loser of the Cold War was left alone. Instead of replacing NATO with a regional collective security organization, the West kept NATO artificially in existence—and Russia in the dark. Ironically, the Baltic states, which wanted to feel more secure by becoming NATO members, are now feeling less secure. All this was predicted in the 1990s by foreign-policy giants like George Kennan and Paul Nitze.

IMO we need to be able to consider NATO critically rather than in Aristotelian, black and white terms. A NATO in which the United States bears all the costs of an increasingly interventionist collection of countries with competing interests is not of infinite worth nor is it of zero worth.

We also need to do a cost-benefit analysis of Lord Ismay’s waggish description of NATO’s original mission—”to keep the Russians out, the Americans in, and the Germans down”. We’ve already abandoned the last of those objectives.

1 comment

The Deadly Equations

Brian Hamilton, co-founder of Sageworks, writes at USA Today:

The arrogance of the tech world (I’m in it) is that we believe we are immune from the basic laws of economics. We are physicists who have created our own world in which we jump off a building and expect not to fall or, if we do fall, we expect someone else to catch us. Moreover, we are enabled by others (like bankers) who ought to know better that we are not worth more simply because we are tech people or “cloud people” or people who wear Steve Jobs smart-guy glasses.

I have never heard a good argument as to why tech companies should be valued more than, say, a dry cleaner or a construction company.

I’ll offer him one. Tech companies are unlikely to see the expense side of their ledgers grow directly with their revenues. The real question is whether they have any prospects for revenues.

And those are precisely the reasons that as a society we shouldn’t be as interested in tech companies as we are. By concentrating wealth they aggravate our problems.

5 comments

The No-Brainer

You know, if you only count the income side of the ledger, as Kevin Shih does at The Conversation in his post in support of increasing immigration, the argument in favor will prevail every time.

As I have said innumerable times before I think we should have a skills-based immigration policy along the lines of those in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand. I also favor more federal oversight to ensure that importing workers is not used as a device for pushing domestic wages down. I also support greatly increasing the number of work visas available to Mexican citizens. “Comprehensive immigration reform” stands athwart such commonsense policies screaming “Stop!”

I wish that Dr. Shih would write another article on the net gains or costs of immigration looking solely at immigrants without high school educations or even moderate command of the English language. I suspect that I will never see it.

2 comments