Floors, Ceilings, and Trends

Is it too early to start looking at presidential approval ratings? The graph above from RealClearPolitics depicts President Trump’s approval rating as determined by the RCP index of polls from the time he assumed office to the present. Here’s President Obama’s approval rating over the corresponding period of his presidency:

There’s obviously a stark contrast. President Obama’s approval rating outweighed his disapproval rating by a whopping 40 points or more at the outset of his presidency and he enjoyed a brief honeymoon period, as illustrated by this graph of his approval rating throughout his presidency:

President Obama clearly had a floor of approval of around 40% and a ceiling of disapproval of around 40%. Maybe that was partisan politics; maybe it was racism; maybe it was some of both.

It’s still early days in the Trump presidency (GHU) but at this point it seems to me that it’s likely that President Trump has a floor of support of around 40% and a ceiling of disapproval of around 48%. That might look familiar to you.

So here are my preliminary observations:

  • It’s still early days.
  • This might be President Trump’s honeymoon period and his approval rating could crash very soon. If that’s the case, he won’t be around for long.
  • If, on the other hand, President Trump won’t have a honeymoon period, his approval/disapproval right now could persist over a considerable period.
  • You can’t see it from the charts above but, remarkable as it might seem, President Trump’s approval rating today is higher than it was on Election Day. Most of the recent polls are of all Americans rather than likely voters.
  • My interpretation of that is that even some people who voted for Hillary Clinton want President Trump to succeed.
  • A lot of voters voted for Trump without approving of him.
  • Presently, Trump is doing very much what he said he would. That doesn’t suggest to me that an approval rating crash is imminent.
  • If there’s a trend in his approval rating, it’s a slight one.
5 comments

Confidence, Uncertainty, and Non-Predictiveness

There’s a nicely thought-provoking article at Ars Technica by Cathleen O’Grady that dips its toe into the waters of one of the thorniest issues in science. Just how confident should you be about any particular scientific finding?

And it should come as no surprise that the same people have funny ideas about which sciences are precise.

Uncertainty in science can creep in at different places. Perhaps the most obvious one is measurement error: how well-tuned are the instruments you’re using? But there are more complex areas of uncertainty, too: science generalizes from an observable sample of the data to entire populations; it draws on existing data to make projections; and there is often disagreement over how results should be interpreted.

Broomell and Kane surveyed 217 people online to find out how they perceived uncertainty in a range of scientific fields. People were given a brief description of each field and then rated each field for 14 different dimensions of uncertainty. The questions covered factors like expert disagreement, measurement accuracy, over-generalization of results, and amount of abstraction. People were also asked to rate how valuable they thought each field is using a seven-point rating of the field’s quality, social benefit, influence over their personal decisions, and how much funding it should be given.

The results suggested that the dimensions of uncertainty that had something to do with precision (like randomness and measurement accuracy) played the biggest role in people’s perceptions. The fields that were labelled as “least precise” were psychology and evolution. Also on this end of the scale were economics, climate science, and—wait for it—astrophysics. On the other end, forensics was perceived as the field with the highest level of precision, followed by aerospace engineering.

There are all sorts of other issues. For example, “science” (from the Latin word for “knowledge”) falls into two broad categories: the descriptive sciences and the predictive ones. Physics and chemistry are, broadly, predictive. Anthropology is descriptive. I’d generalize and say that all of the social sciences including economics are mostly descriptive.

Economics is an interesting case. It does provide some guidance on general propensities or tendencies but it can’t tell you whether the stock market will go up or down. Or what the unemployment or inflation rate will be next year.

One of the reasons for that is problems with observation. We don’t really know what the unemployment rate is now in the way we know, say, what the temperature of the liquid in a flask is now.

Or meteorology. Using the biggest, fastest supercomputers in the world our present models can tell you what the weather will be like in a particular location in a few hours or, with less confidence, in a few days. There’s much, much less confidence in predicting the weather a year or even a month in advance other than in the broadest terms. Or in predicting catastrophic events like tornadoes.

I definitely believe in evolution just as I believe in gravity but while I’m pretty confident about the effects of gravity if I step off the roof of a three story building I don’t have nearly the confidence level in the effects of evolution. A lot of that is because of the role of random variation in evolution.

Engineering on the other hand is heuristic. But that’s a subject for a different post.

13 comments

Praise for Trump from an Unexpected Quarter

At Bloomberg former Obama advisor Cass Sunstein praises President Trump’s proposal for regulatory reform:

The action took the form of an executive order, issued in late February, “on enforcing the regulatory reform agenda.” Its text is quite bureaucratic, but it’s likely to prove profoundly important.

The order calls for the official designation of “Regulatory Reform Officers” and “Regulatory Reform Task Forces” within each department and agency of the federal government.

The reform officers are charged with carrying out three earlier executive orders. The first is Trump’s own requirement that agencies eliminate two regulations for every one that they issue. More surprisingly, the second and third come from Presidents Bill Clinton and Barack Obama. The Clinton order, issued in 1993, requires cost-benefit analysis of new regulations, along with approval by the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs.

The 2011 Obama order calls for “retrospective review” of existing regulations, with the goal of getting rid of those that don’t make sense. By requiring adherence to the Clinton and Obama orders, the Trump administration has signaled a degree of continuity with what came before. That’s a good idea (and it’s hardly deconstruction).

and

Because the White House itself lacks the capacity to scrutinize the stock of existing regulations, the Trump administration was smart to call for task forces within each agency to do that — and to require them to engage with the public to see which regulations are really causing trouble.

In addition, Trump’s emphasis on cost-benefit analysis is both welcome and hugely important. Some regulations impose significant costs, and the private sector really doesn’t like them. But they also create significant benefits, by helping consumers save money, preventing illness and saving lives. It would be a mistake, and it could be a tragedy, to repeal them.

It’s a fact that American businesses aren’t run the way they were 50 years ago but the sad truth is that the federal government largely is. Practical strategies like this are what we might hope for from an administration with experience outside government.

As I’ve said before I didn’t vote for Trump and would prefer that he not be president. I saw Mr. Sunstein’s post some time ago and thought about taking note of it at the time but didn’t want to be construed as praising Trump. I decided to try to make lemonade out of lemons and celebrate the good.

1 comment

Can We Or Can’t We?

In the light of our earlier conversation you might want to read this article by Thomas W. Overton at Power:

In 1950, the idea of powering an entire country with solar energy was science fiction. But in 2017, it’s become—paired with wind and other renewable generation—an idea many experts and policymakers are talking about as an entirely feasible goal. Municipalities around the world have made 100% renewables targets a matter of law, large corporations like Google and Amazon have declared intentions to source all their power needs from renewables (Figure 1), and even a few countries such as Denmark that currently rely on fossil fuels for a substantial portion of their power are targeting 100% renewable generation in the next few decades. Most recently, the COP21 Paris climate agreement set a target of 100% renewables worldwide by 2050.

It makes for interesting reading.

Update

The main academic spokesman on this subject seems to be the frequently cited Mark Jacobson whose summary paper on becoming oil-free by 2050 is here.

11 comments

The Inherent Contradiction of Wind Power

An article by Vaclav Smil at the IEEE Spectrum highlighted for me the contradiction inherent in the pursuit of wind power. Here’s his peroration:

Undoubtedly, a well-sited and well-built wind turbine would generate as much energy as it embodies in less than a year. However, all of it will be in the form of intermittent electricity—while its production, installation, and maintenance remain critically dependent on specific fossil energies. Moreover, for most of these energies—coke for iron-ore smelting, coal and petroleum coke to fuel cement kilns, naphtha and natural gas as feedstock and fuel for the synthesis of plastics and the making of fiberglass, diesel fuel for ships, trucks, and construction machinery, lubricants for gearboxes—we have no nonfossil substitutes that would be readily available on the requisite large commercial scales.

For a long time to come—until all energies used to produce wind turbines and photovoltaic cells come from renewable energy sources—modern civilization will remain fundamentally dependent on fossil fuels.

Not every location is good for using wind to produce electrical power but it takes a lot of fossil fuels to build every windmill made, regardless of whether its eventual placement will be good or not. And then there’s the issue of the backup generation you need when the wind doesn’t blow.

Phoenix, Arizona is a great place for solar energy but lousy for wind energy. A solar installation for the average home in Portland, Oregon might break even over the period of 20 years. Its 200+ overcast days per year makes it a poorer candidate than Phoenix.

There are also places in the U. S. where neither solar nor wind make economic sense. Nuclear or fossil fuels are those places’ best choice.

16 comments

Make It Too Embarrassing and Too Expensive

I found the remarks of the editors of the Wall Street Journal on the relationship between China and North Korea very interesting:

Is China greeting the Trump era by getting tough on North Korea? That may be the impression Beijing has tried to convey by announcing a suspension of coal imports from the nuclear-armed state. But there is less here than meets the eye.

As is often the case regarding Beijing’s ties to Pyongyang, the details of the coal cutoff are murky. In the most generous telling, China has decided to squeeze North Korea’s key source of hard currency to punish it for acting in destabilizing ways—testing missiles, assassinating overseas enemies with VX nerve agent and the like. By this logic, Beijing is signalling a desire to work with the new U.S. Administration on the shared goal of denuclearizing the Kim regime. North Korean state media have pushed this line, slamming China for “dancing to the tune of the U.S.”

Yet Beijing has said that it had to cut off coal imports to comply with United Nations sanctions passed in November. According to the Foreign Ministry, Chinese imports in 2017 have already approached the U.N.’s annual value limit of $400 million. Beijing would hardly deserve applause for buying its full quota and then stopping to meet its legal obligations.

A year ago the Chinese also promised to comply with an earlier round of U.N. sanctions on North Korean mineral exports. But Beijing made sure those sanctions included a loophole exempting transactions for undefined “livelihood purposes.” It then proceeded to rack up record purchases of North Korean coal.

After November’s sanctions moved to nullify the “livelihood” loophole with hard caps, Beijing promised a cutoff—yet still imported more North Korean coal in December than in any previous month of the year. Its total coal imports for 2016, a year in which it twice voted for sanctions on such purchases, rose 14.5% from 2015 and totaled more than $1 billion.

Pyongyang can fund a lot of missile tests with that money. Then there is the unspecified sum China will soon begin paying for 4,000 metric tons of North Korean liquefied petroleum gas, an arrangement quietly announced this month and spotted by Victor Cha of the Center for Strategic and International Studies.

Beijing sustains Pyongyang in countless other ways, including access to Chinese oil, banks, trading firms, ports and front companies. Contrast this with China’s unofficial economic sanctions on South Korea merely for wishing to defend itself against North Korean nuclear missiles by installing advanced U.S.-made antimissile defenses.

I don’t think that it can be maintained any longer that China’s sole interest in North Korea is in preventing a catastrophic collapse of the regime with an attendant flood of refugees into China. For one thing many of those refugees are probably more likely to flood into South Korea where they might well advance one of China’s foreign policy goals—making a wedge between South Korea and the United States.

I can’t explain why China is supporting North Korea’s nuclear weapons development. They could stop it any time they cared to without causing the collapse of the regime just by preventing the transfer of materials the North needs for its weapons development into the country.

I still believe, however, that the relationship between China and North Korea still requires cost-benefit analysis on the part of the Chinese. In that light our preferred policy should be to make China’s continued support of the Kim regime costlier and more embarrassing. Simple risk mitigation practically requires it.

9 comments

Right-Sizing Regulation

There’s a good article by academics Jerry Ellig and Rosemary Fike on regulatory reform at RealClearPolicy:

Regulatory rollbacks are all the rage in Washington, from President Trump’s executive orders on regulatory reform to congressional resolutions disapproving major regulations issued by the Obama administration. But whether you think we have too much or too little regulation, reasonable people ought to be able to agree that we should have the right kind.

Unfortunately, it’s not at all clear that we do. One of us (Ellig) authored a study in 2016 revealing that less than half of the major non-budget executive branch regulations proposed between 2008 and 2013 were accompanied by evidence showing that the regulations addressed significant problems. And for about one-third of those regulations, regulators failed to consider the benefits or cost-effectiveness of alternative approaches.

I think that the policy that President Trump has announced, removing two regulations for every one introduced, while probably being well-intentioned is a brute force solution to a genuine problem. I prefer Canada’s rule in the Red Tape Reduction Act that requires that for every new regulation introduced by the Canadian federal government, one of equal burden must be removed from the books. The focus there is right. It’s on the burden imposed by regulation rather than on their number.

Not that number isn’t a problem. The present Code of Federal Regulations weighs in at more than 180,000 pages, seven times as long as it was in 1960.

I believe that the underlying problem is that there are just too many career bureaucrats in Washington who see their job in terms of producing new regulations. That’s completely consistent with Jerry Pournelle’s Iron Law of Bureaucracy:

Pournelle’s Iron Law of Bureaucracy states that in any bureaucratic organization there will be two kinds of people”:

First, there will be those who are devoted to the goals of the organization. Examples are dedicated classroom teachers in an educational bureaucracy, many of the engineers and launch technicians and scientists at NASA, even some agricultural scientists and advisors in the former Soviet Union collective farming administration.

Secondly, there will be those dedicated to the organization itself. Examples are many of the administrators in the education system, many professors of education, many teachers union officials, much of the NASA headquarters staff, etc.

The Iron Law states that in every case the second group will gain and keep control of the organization. It will write the rules, and control promotions within the organization.

In addition regulatory capture practically guarantees that some of level of federal regulation is less directed at providing for the health, safety, or welfare of the American people and much more targeted at helping certain preferred companies or individuals.

Note that I’m not claiming that regulation is unnecessary or that in some cases it doesn’t make us better off. I’m merely pointing out what is obvious to just about anyone who deals much with the federal goverment: a lot of what the federal government requires can’t stand up to a cost-benefit analysis.

3 comments

Succinct

In the Denver Post (via RealClearPolitics) Froma Harrop presents a succinct summary of my own views on immigration:

But that doesn’t give Democrats a free pass to fudge on the issue of illegal immigration. They need to say, “We support a generous immigration program, but people without the proper papers cannot come here and take jobs.”

Such a policy would not turn this country into a xenophobic police state. It would make the U.S. more like Canada and Australia, two pleasant democracies that take in large numbers of newcomers but don’t tolerate illegal immigration.

The basic question is what do Democrats believe? I don’t believe the Democratic leadership has any fixed principles other than the urge to power any more than the Republican leadership does. Any statement of principles by them is merely rhetorical.

What do progressives believe? If they believe in an inalienable right to immigrate as many of them seem to, the policy articulated above by Ms. Harrop would not only be intolerable it would be reprehensible, heresy.

Are Democrats merely wed to the status quo with its bizarre and antiquated system of quotas? Diversity quotas, refugee quotas, skilled worker quotas, family reunification quotas, etc.?

The Orwellian language that’s used might be a clue. Under U. S. statute all of those migrants who cross the border from Mexico guided by coyotes are illegal immigrants. They have broken U. S. law. If they have returned to the U. S. illegally after having once been deported, they are committing felonies, serious crimes.

8 comments

Varieties Rather Than Species

Speaking of confirming something I’ve been saying for some time, this article at Live Science on early human fossils:

These new fossils suggest that far-flung groups of ancient humans were more genetically linked across Eurasia than often previously thought, researchers in the new study said.

“I don’t like to think of these fossils as those of hybrids,” said study co-author Erik Trinkaus, an anthropologist at Washington University in St. Louis. “Hybridization implies that all of these groups were separate and discrete, only occasionally interacting. What these fossils show is that these groups were basically not separate. The idea that there were separate lineages in different parts of the world is increasingly contradicted by the evidence we are unearthing.”

confirms what I’ve been saying about early hominids. Anatomically modern Humans, Neanderthals, Denisovans and who knows how many other early humans aren’t different species; they’re different varieties. The relationships between them are more like the relationship between Golden Retrievers and German Shepherds than are like the relationship between, say, lions and tigers.

The really big question is whether erectus was a different species or not. I know that Leakey thought it was but I’m not so sure and to the best of my knowledge nobody has succeeded in extracting Homo erectus DNA yet.

5 comments

The Problem With Off-loading Training Costs

I do not for one second believe that high U. S. corporate tax rates (and the depreciation schedules) are impeding American businesses’ propensity to invest, as claimed by Alan Daley in his post at RealClearPolicy:

If President Trump and the Congress move forward with tax reform, U.S. businesses stand to gain trillions of discretionary dollars from lower tax burdens, repatriation of their net profits held overseas, and incentives that would permit the expensing of capital investment.

which is sophistry. Increasing the incentives is not identical to effecting. I think the primary effect of those taxes is to impede the companies ability to “repatriate” foreign earnings to distribute them as executive compensation in one form or another.

However, rather than fisking the entire post, I want to draw your attention to these observations:

It must be emphasized that we do not have a headcount shortage of willing workers; we have a skills shortage. Unfortunately, a “can-do” attitude is no substitute for the right skills.

and

Outside of STEM, however, there are tight markets for qualified physical and occupational therapists, nurses, machinists, electricians, and welders. Most of these jobs require that a suitable candidate have at least a post-high school certification and supervised experience or apprenticeship.

which support a point I’ve been making for decades and at The Glittering Eye for more than a decade. If there are no jobs for American junior engineers or apprentice welders or electricians, eventually there will be no senior American engineers or master welders or electricians.

The real underlying problem is the unwillingness of American companies to bear the training costs that were once assumed to be a cost of doing business. I believe that lack of willingness derives from their conviction that they can get the people they want by importing them from abroad.

6 comments