A City Overwhelmed by Scandals

Charles Lipson summarizes:

One reason it is so hard to follow the Washington/FBI/Intel/Congress/Trump administration scandals is that there are

  • So many players,
  • Several separate scandals, and
  • Very little public information.

The opposing parties emphasize different scandals

American citizens should be interested in all three as they unfold.

  1. Russian interference in 2016 election
  2. Team Trump’s Connections to Russians Before and After the Election
  3. Obama White House spying on Team Trump and “unmasking” secret name(s)

He goes on to analyze and discuss all three. Read the whole thing.

I haven’t remarked on any of these recently because I’m content to let the investigation work its way through. I would prefer a non-partisan investigation, by either a blue ribbon panel or a special prosecutor, and I suspect we’ll get their eventually.

24 comments

Make Your Arguments Carefully

I really ought to create boilerplate for this. I don’t support Donald Trump or his policies. Nothing I write should be construed as a defense of Trump. However, I do think that Christine Todd Whitman should rethink her Atlantic defense of the Environmental Protection Agency that she headed under the George W. Bush Administration:

Pollution poses an undeniable threat to public health, as the Supreme Court has validated. A 2013 Massachusetts Institute of Technology study reported that roughly 19,000 more people die prematurely from automobile pollution each year than die in car accidents. The same year, Harvard University researchers found that pregnant women living in areas with elevated levels of air pollution “were up to twice as likely” to have an autistic child, compared with women in low-pollution locations. And a new study released in January found that air pollution increases the risk and expedites the onset of dementia and other forms of cognitive decline.

The Clean Air Act of 1970 was designed to control air pollution on a national level by authorizing the development of comprehensive regulations to limit emissions. It has been extremely successful—between 1970 and 2015, “aggregate national emissions [of] six common pollutants alone dropped an average of 70 percent,” the EPA reports. A summary report of the benefits and costs associated with the act estimates that public and private spending to reduce pollution will reach approximately $65 billion annually by 2020. By contrast, the economic benefits are estimated to reach approximately $2 trillion dollars in 2020 alone. Yet under Trump’s proposed budget—despite the public-health and economic advantages—funding for the Clean Air Act would be cut in half.

The problem is that “controlling pollution” and the EPA aren’t synonymous. Not everything that the EPA does controls pollution and not everything that controls pollution was administered by the EPA.

The picture at the top of this post shows the results of the release of three million gallons of contaminated water from the Gold King Mine in San Juan County, Colorado into the Animas River. That’s a prima facie case for an agency that doesn’t just need reform or reining in but punishment.

9 comments

Amerisclerosis in Five Charts

I’m beginning to see a number of articles cropping up on economic stagnation in the United States. Between the two articles I’ve read today there are five charts: per capita health care spending, rent as a percentage of median income, changes in sales concentration from 1982 to 2012, corporate birth death rates, and share of employment by new firms. Here’s a snippet from the article by Charles Hughes at E21:

The American economy is stagnating. The creative destruction of old businesses exiting and new ones starting up has slowed. Fewer people are working at new companies. These trends have only accelerated post-recession. Many of the fresh new entrants hailed as disruptive startups, such as Uber and Facebook, have been on the scene for a decade or more.
This stagnation reduces the amount of competition and the rate that new ideas are introduced. Economic growth and individual workers both suffer as a result. How much have things slowed down, and can anything reverse it?

while here’s a sample of the article by Noah Smith at Bloomberg View:

What can be done about Amerisclerosis? There was hope in some circles that President Donald Trump would follow through on his campaign pledge to restore U.S. competitiveness and efficiency. It’s still early in his presidency, but so far little movement in that direction has materialized.

There is no obvious solution on the horizon. But as with Europe and Japan in the 1990s, the crucial first step is to recognize the severity of the problem. A general awareness of sclerosis is helpful in generating the urgency to find solutions at all levels of society — government, business and community.

The charts provide some hints on the contours of the “obvious solution”. They’re not that difficult to recognize:

  • We need more basic production in the U. S. not less. Too little basic production makes it very hard for the U. S. economy to recover after an economic downturn.
  • Stop subsidizing big companies. Help workers, consumers, and small businesses rather than big businesses. In particular stop subsidizing big banks and financial institutions. Break up monopolies.
  • Slow the subsidies to health care. The Congress knew that was necessary 20 years ago; they just didn’t have the guts to follow through.
  • Reduce the deadweight loss of government. That doesn’t mean a return to the world of The Octopus or The Jungle. It means distinguishing between the regulations that we want and need and those that aren’t working, aren’t necessary, or not wanted.

I also think it means less military adventurism but I appear to be in the minority on that.

Our present economic conditions are not laws of physics. They’re the results of decisions, of policies. In aggregate those decisions have resulted in an enormous concentration of wealth in very few hands and stagnation everywhere else. To change the present tack or, more accurately, doldrums, we’ve got to make some different choices.

9 comments

The Cunning Little Fox

From time to time I’ve written about the Russian program that’s been going on for the last sixty or so years in which they’ve been selectively breeding foxes for friendliness to human beings. The picture above is of one of the foxes produced under the program. The program resulted in some outcomes they didn’t expect. Not only did they get friendliness, they got some neotenous characteristics, white in the coats, and curly tails.

There’s an update on the program from PBS:

After the collapse of the Soviet Union, the domesticated fox experiment fell on hard times as public funding for the project evaporated. The researchers realized quickly that keeping more than 300 foxes is an expensive enterprise. In the 1990s, the lab switched to selling some of the foxes as fur pelts to sustain the breeding program.

“The current situation is not catastrophic, but not stable at the same time,” Institute of Cytology and Genetics research assistant Anastasiya Kharlamova told BBC Earth last year. Now, the lab’s primary source of revenue is selling the foxes to people and organizations across the globe.

One customer is the Judith A. Bassett Canid Education and Conservation Center, located near San Diego. The center keeps six foxes — five of which are domesticated — as ambassadors for their species, so that people can get an up-close-and-personal view of the animals.

“We have a fox whose name is Boris, and as soon as someone walks in, he’ll run up to them like a dog will,” said David Bassett, president of the Conservation Center. “He wants to be scratched and if you don’t scratch him he’ll make you.”

If you’ve been reading The Glittering Eye for a long time, very friendly canids with white in their coats and curly tails may sound familiar to you.

That’s Kara. The Samoyed dogs with which I’ve shared my life for the last several decades fit that description pretty well. Except that they were bred from wolves and over a period of thousands of years rather than just a half century or so.

Update

I have been asked to clarify something in this post. To date Kara has never peed in my coffee cup.

8 comments

Thinking About the Unthinkable

At The Week Harry J. Kazianis speculates about what would happen if North Korea actually attacked its neighbors:

First, North Korean armed forces would launch a massive assault on Seoul, firing hundreds of artillery shells that devastate the outskirts of South Korea’s capital. Caught off guard, the residents of Seoul would go into sheer panic. People would flee the city and head south by the millions. Train stations, airports, and roads would be overwhelmed.

Meanwhile, North Korea would launch a coordinated cyber-attack on the south’s top financial intuitions as well as Seoul’s power grid and waste-treatment stations. Millions of people would be without access to cash, power, and other critical resources. A state of emergency would be declared nationwide.

At this point, the conflict is only hours old.

Read the whole thing. This is one of the reasons I’m glad that I’m not president. I wouldn’t want to be in the position of needing to make decisions under circumstances under which practically any alternative is horribly evil.

9 comments

The Problems of the Rich

You might be interested in this post at Financial Samurai, “Scraping By On $500,000 A Year”. It illustrates how insidious lifestyle changes and the expectations that go along with them can be.

6 comments

The Trial of Sisyphus

In another of his typically opaque posts at RealClearBusiness Jeffrey Snider takes 1,000 words to say something that could be said in a few: as long as the unimaginably large China keeps exporting inexpensive goods and deflation European and American central banks will never get inflation back to what they consider normal.

He does make some interesting points, however, to the effect that economics has transmogrified from a descriptive science to an ideology and that globalization and free trade are not identical.

2 comments

The Red Shoes

I was astonished that Michelle Chen could write about the problem of homelessness in Silicon Valley at The Nation without mentioning zoning ordinances or anti-development regulations once. She mentions lots of other things including low wages (other than in the tech sector), joblessness, rent controls, and unionization but not those.

9 comments

Those Jobs “Americans Won’t Do”

Daniel Gross has a post at Slate in which he outlines a point I’ve made here from time to time. Here’s the meat of his post:

There’s no such thing as a job an American won’t do. There are such things as jobs that Americans in your geographic area won’t do at the conditions on which you are offering them. At this point in the economic cycle, building homes in Denver now seems to be one of them.

When regional labor markets are tight, you have to send the price signal to potential workers that it will be worth their while to leave their current home or position in order to apply—that the job will pay well, that it will carry benefits, that if you get hurt or sick you’ll have good insurance, that there might be job security and prospects for training and development. That price might be closer to $100,000 than it is to $50,000. But that’s where we are in the economic cycle. And if builders prefer not to pay up to attract workers and are reluctant to try to charge more for their end products, they’ll muddle through at low volumes. That, alas, is also where we are.

The whole post is good and I encourage you to read it.

But it only tells half the story. In some sectors the availability of cheap labor, frequently illegal, has enabled, changed, or perpetuated certain business models. In agriculture, for example, in some parts of the country growers changed from using mostly black agricultural workers to mostly Hispanic agricultural workers practically overnight because black workers were beginning to organize and demand better conditions, terms, or pay. Illegal workers don’t have that option.

Now in many parts of the country agricultural workers are paid low wages, on terrible terms, in appalling conditions, largely to the absence of outrage. What would happen if there were strict enforcement of immigration laws and labor laws? Some growers would leave the business, some would invest in equipment to automate processes that are presently done by hand (that’s what’s meant by “increasing productivity”), and some would pay betters wages on better terms and offer improved working conditions.

9 comments

A Net Gain?

Would anyone care to take up Megan McArdle’s gauntlet, thrown down at Bloomberg View, at to whether the Affordable Care Act has been a net gain?

There’s a new paper out looking at how the Affordable Care Act has transformed health-care access, and in turn, what that has done for health. The authors’ first answer probably won’t surprise you: when millions more people became insured, more got checkups and primary care doctors. But it’s not obvious that these people got any healthier. As the paper puts it: “No statistically significant effects on risky behaviors or self-assessed health emerge for the full sample.”

Other studies have found substantial effects on self-assessed health, but on the harder markers of health — like blood sugar, cholesterol and blood pressure — the famous Oregon Medicaid Study found no significant improvement when government gave people health care.

It turns out the link between “health care” and “health” is not as close as we would like. Health insurance is not magic. Insurance can give you access to a doctor, but it cannot make you take your medicine. An absolutely astonishing percentage of people don’t take their hypertension medication, even though the side effects are minimal, the medications are cheap generics, and the benefits are large; overall, about 50 percent of patients seem to fail to take their medicine as recommended. Insurance cannot make you stop drinking or smoking or overeating. Just ask the primary-care physicians charged with bullying people out of those behaviors. Yes, people with health insurance are more likely to be healthy. But people with good health insurance are also more likely to be successful folks who are remuneratively employed, which seems to be independently correlated with health, even when everyone is getting their health care through Britain’s National Health Service.

Even as some people use health insurance to get their blood pressure down or their lung disease treated, others will fail to comply with treatment regimens, or will get treatments that turn out in hindsight to have been a bad idea, or will spend money on unhealthy things now that they’re spending less on health care. Which effect ends up being larger in aggregate is an empirical question, even though individuals may be able to point to a very clear benefit or detriment to themselves.

That empirical answer ends up being … kind of cloudy. Some studies show large health benefits from health insurance, others little, none, or even negative effects.

Politically, it doesn’t matter whether it’s a net gain. It benefits some people and they’ll defend it to the death as will those who like the PPACA for political reasons.

My own concerns about the PPACA had nothing to do with whether it was a net gain or not but that it did little to address the issues we need to resolve so desperately or even sets the stage for addressing them in the future.

But back to her question. Make your case that the Affordable Care Act was a net gain or a net loss.

10 comments