Would anyone care to take up Megan McArdle’s gauntlet, thrown down at Bloomberg View, at to whether the Affordable Care Act has been a net gain?
There’s a new paper out looking at how the Affordable Care Act has transformed health-care access, and in turn, what that has done for health. The authors’ first answer probably won’t surprise you: when millions more people became insured, more got checkups and primary care doctors. But it’s not obvious that these people got any healthier. As the paper puts it: “No statistically significant effects on risky behaviors or self-assessed health emerge for the full sample.â€
Other studies have found substantial effects on self-assessed health, but on the harder markers of health — like blood sugar, cholesterol and blood pressure — the famous Oregon Medicaid Study found no significant improvement when government gave people health care.
It turns out the link between “health care†and “health†is not as close as we would like. Health insurance is not magic. Insurance can give you access to a doctor, but it cannot make you take your medicine. An absolutely astonishing percentage of people don’t take their hypertension medication, even though the side effects are minimal, the medications are cheap generics, and the benefits are large; overall, about 50 percent of patients seem to fail to take their medicine as recommended. Insurance cannot make you stop drinking or smoking or overeating. Just ask the primary-care physicians charged with bullying people out of those behaviors. Yes, people with health insurance are more likely to be healthy. But people with good health insurance are also more likely to be successful folks who are remuneratively employed, which seems to be independently correlated with health, even when everyone is getting their health care through Britain’s National Health Service.
Even as some people use health insurance to get their blood pressure down or their lung disease treated, others will fail to comply with treatment regimens, or will get treatments that turn out in hindsight to have been a bad idea, or will spend money on unhealthy things now that they’re spending less on health care. Which effect ends up being larger in aggregate is an empirical question, even though individuals may be able to point to a very clear benefit or detriment to themselves.
That empirical answer ends up being … kind of cloudy. Some studies show large health benefits from health insurance, others little, none, or even negative effects.
Politically, it doesn’t matter whether it’s a net gain. It benefits some people and they’ll defend it to the death as will those who like the PPACA for political reasons.
My own concerns about the PPACA had nothing to do with whether it was a net gain or not but that it did little to address the issues we need to resolve so desperately or even sets the stage for addressing them in the future.
But back to her question. Make your case that the Affordable Care Act was a net gain or a net loss.