Agenda-Driven Analysis Strikes Again

At RealClearPolicy John R. Lott presents us the latest instance of agenda-driven analyses, this time directed at proving that the number of homicides in the United States isn’t a serious problem:

According to a 2013 PEW Research Center survey, the household gun ownership rate in rural areas was 111 percent greater than in urban areas. Suburban households are 28.6 percent more likely to own guns than urban households. Despite lower gun ownership, urban areas experience much higher murder rates. One should not put much weight on this purely “cross-sectional” evidence at one point in time. But it is hard to overlook the fact that so much of the country has both very high gun ownership rates and few, if any, murders.

To put it simply, murder isn’t a nationwide problem; it’s a problem in a very small set of urban areas.

If I use precisely the same approach as Mr. Lott does, I could demonstrate to you that homicide isn’t a problem in Chicago, despite the city having a higher homicide rate per 100K population than at any time in its history.

The demonstration would go like this. Chicago has 77 neighborhoods. Two-thirds of the homicides here take place in just four neighborhoods (5%) and 89% in just six (7.8%). Not a problem, right? But, as I pointed out above, the homicide rate is the highest in city’s history.

The United States does have a homicide problem and it’s concentrated in cities of over a half million people with 20% or more black population. Even within that group of cities there are exceptions. Rather than saying “there’s no problem” find out what they’re doing differently.

There’s one thing that I suspect Mr. Lott and I would agree on: the difference isn’t guns.

1 comment

The Decline of Black-Owned Businesses

The Great Recession was particularly hard on black-owned businesses. The National Black Chamber of Commerce, for example, points out that black-owned auto dealerships were severely affected:

Thousands of auto dealers were casualties of the economic crisis. But Lee is part of an especially vulnerable group: black dealers, whose businesses rose and fell with the domestic automakers.

Black dealers have taken a disproportionate hit — “drastic” in the words of one minority dealer spokeswoman — in the past three years. There are 261 black-owned dealerships in the United States today, half as many as three years ago. That’s a much sharper drop than the 18 percent decline in dealerships overall.

Those numbers reflect a seismic shift in the tradition of black business in this country. Just as a UAW factory job provided middle-class security for black workers, owning an auto dealership traditionally has been a path to wealth for black businesspeople.

while Black Enterprise points out that black-owned advertising agencies have suffered:

One devastated sector has been advertising. In fact, our BE Advertising Agencies roster, reeling from corporate clients shifting from targeted messaging to the so-called “total market approach” (see Advertising Overview, this issue), dropped from 10 to eight firms. Many among the Financial Services sector didn’t fare much better.

In that vein according to AfricanGlobe there are about half as many black-owned banks as there were in 2007:

The Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. counted 25 Black-owned banks remaining in the country last year, down from 48 in 2001. That decrease came even as the overall number of minority-owned banks increased slightly, going from 164 to 174. In addition, the majority of Black-owned banks that remain open are on shaky ground and struggling to hold on in the face of the economic devastation that has ravaged many of their customers.

A recent article at Atlantic charts how industry consolidation has affected black-owned businesses:

The decline of black-owned independent businesses traces back to many causes, but a major one that has been little noted was the decline in the enforcement of anti-monopoly and fair-trade laws beginning in the late 1970s. Under both Democratic and Republican administrations, a few firms that in previous decades would never have been allowed to merge or grow so large came to dominate almost every sector of the economy.

This change has hurt all independent businesses, but the effects have disproportionately hit black business owners. Marcellus Andrews, a professor of economics at Bucknell University, says that pulling back on anti-monopoly enforcement was a “catastrophic intellectual and political policy mistake,” and that for the black community, the “presumed price advantages of concentration often do not translate into better economic opportunities.”

I don’t know that I have any great point to make with this post other than to note that indifference to small businesses while catering to big businesses will inevitably be hard on black-owned businesses.

6 comments

Cognitive Dissonance

Americans suffer from a very bad case of cognitive dissonance and Robert Samuelson summarizes it well in his most recent Washington Post column:

Our wants and needs from government — the two blur — exceed our willingness to be taxed.

It isn’t a new phenomenon. Sen. Russell Long characterized the same phenomenon 40 years ago, saying: “Don’t tax you, don’t tax me, tax that fellow behind the tree!” I’ve called it the “roomful of money” hypothesis—the idea that somewhere there’s a roomful of money, all you need to do is find it, and all fiscal problems will be solved. That’s the theory behind the funding of the Chicago Public Schools.

I oppose cuts in the personal income tax rates. I don’t believe they will stimulate the U. S. economy as much as its proponents do and I don’t believe it will spur domestic investment. I do believe that we should cut the business income tax so that it’s comparable to that of other OECD countries. When even Nancy Pelosi says that, as she did on the Sunday morning talking heads programs yesterday, it’s hard to claim that’s a far right wing position.

If you feel the need to maintain a balanced budget, introduce another tax bracket that will tax those in the top .01% of income earners. Or cut spending. The idea that in the half trillion annual Medicare tab there is absolutely no waste, fraud, or abuse doesn’t pass the smell test.

Or don’t balance the budget and just issue the credit. That level of money expansion won’t cause a run on the bank.

4 comments

Debt and the Health Care Industry

Despite its eye-catching caption, “The health care industry is bound to collapse soon, experts say”, this New York Post article is terribly short on details. Here are their main bullet points:

  • Health care company debt is up 308 percent since 2009.
  • The number of hospitals in health systems has expanded by 26 percent since 1999.
  • The yearly medical costs for a family of four have jumped 189 percent since 2002, from $9,000 to $26,000.

all of which I believe are true. I don’t see how that results in “a couple of big health care companies take the economy down”. To their list of factors I’d add that people in the health care sector both personally and professionally assume that prices in the sector can rise at a multiple of prices in the rest of the economy indefinitely.

Regardless of the risk to individuals and companies I still don’t think that it present systemic risk. Increasing health care costs could take out some state and local governments, however. That’s why I’ve felt that controlling costs is the single most important health care reform.

Well, now we can say with confidence that increasing coverage doesn’t necessarily of itself result in cost control so at least we have that.

11 comments

The Foreign Policy Consensus


If you had any doubt about it, the Chicago Council on Global Affairs documents the gap between the views of the foreign policy elite and those of ordinary Americans:

The 2016 election has been widely read as a populist revolt, with average Americans rising up to reject the political elite, particularly on issues of immigration and trade. As the Council’s parallel survey results show, there is an element of truth in this argument: the American public and opinion leaders are in fact divided over several key issues, including the importance of protecting American jobs, US immigration policy, and the importance of protecting US allies’ security. Perhaps not coincidentally, these areas where elite-public gaps exist are also the issue areas where Donald Trump’s message has resounded the loudest.

Is there a consensus? Not only do we have a consensus, we have two of them: a consensus among leaders regardless of party affiliation and a consensus among Americans also regardless of party affiliation. They are not the same.

So, what is to be done? As I see it there are several alternatives:

  1. Continue to follow the leaders.
  2. The leaders can change course to strike some middle ground.
  3. Leaders can do a much better job of persuading the people.
  4. Dump the leaders. Change course.

Keep in mind that the track record of our foreign policy leadership has been awful for a very long time. Depending on how you reckon it, we’ve been at war continually in the Middle East over the period of the last 25 years with very little to show for it.

7 comments

Analyzing Republicans and Democrats

I never thought I’d write this. The best analysis of both Republicans and Democrats I’ve read in a long time comes from AFL-CIO President Richard Trumka, reported here at the Daily Beast by Michael Tomasky:

His posture toward Trump is not one of total opposition. He’s skeptical and suspicious, certainly. In addition to thinking Trump has gone Wall Street as president, Trumka fears that Trump will gut labor safety regulations and thinks he probably can’t bring jobs back to the coal fields in huge numbers. That said, he’s mindful of the fact that Trump spoke compellingly to a portion of his rank and file, so he’s keeping a semi-open mind. “We’re just telling [members] every day what he’s doing to help them or hurt them,” he says. “If he does something to help ’em I say it. If he does something to hurt ’em I say it. They can decide for themselves who’s friend and who’s foe.”

and

“The Democratic Party quite frankly had no coherent economic message,” he said. “Workers have been facing stagnant wages, dropping benefits, and economic security being taken away from them over a 40-year period. Trump said a lot of stuff—hasn’t followed through on it, but said it, and they were willing to take a chance.”

The problems, he said, started under Bill Clinton. “I think that was the beginning of the schizophrenic days, when they needed workers’ votes but wanted Wall Street money, so they tried to serve two masters but were successful at neither,” says Trumka.
But didn’t Bill Clinton do a number of good things? I mean, 22 million jobs?
“People still weren’t getting wage increases,” he says. “The economy was still moving away from us.”

Read the whole thing. And I fully endorse this:

“The economic message should hold everybody together,” he says, “so that when you say ‘this person’s a Democrat,’ three or four things come to mind. And it shouldn’t be this or that social issue, it should be economics.”

I strongly suspect that he and I would differ on what those “three or four things” should be but I agree that they should all be economic policies.

My single greatest dissatisfaction with the Democrats under Barack Obama is that by March 2009 they had turned their focus away from the economy, never to return.

That the Democratic leadership has made some errors is a matter of empirical fact. It can be measured in the number of Senate seats held, the number of House seats held, the number of state legislative houses with Democratic majorities, and the number of Democratic governors. I think the gravest error is not focusing on the economy.

7 comments

An Innate Talent for Remembering Pain

Sci-News reports on a pair of studies that may have implications for a number of chronic auto-immune conditions, especially chronic pain conditions. It may be that some people have a heightened ability to remember “negative images” and there may be a connection between that ability and the immune system:

Researchers from the University of Basel, ETH Zurich, Ulm University, Max Planck Institute of Psychiatry, German Center for Neurodegenerative Diseases, University Medical Center Hamburg-Eppendorf, and Universities of Konstanz, Cologne, Bonn and Leipzig, have now carried out two studies that demonstrate that this link between the immune system and brain is more significant than previously believed.

In the first study, reported in the journal Nature Communication, the researchers searched for epigenetic profiles, i.e. regulatory patterns, in the blood of 533 healthy young adults.

In their genome-wide search, the authors identified an epigenetic profile that is strongly correlated with the thickness of the cerebral cortex, in particular in a region of the brain that is important for memory functions.

This finding was replicated in a sample comprising 596 participants. It also showed that it is specifically those genes that are responsible for the regulation of important immune functions in the blood that explain the link between the epigenetic profile and the properties of the brain.

In the second study, published in the journal Nature Human Behaviour, the team studied the genomes of healthy participants who remembered negative images particularly well or particularly poorly.

A variant of the TROVE2 gene, whose role in immunological diseases is currently being investigated, was linked to participants’ ability to remember a particularly high number of negative images, while their general memory remained unaffected.

This variant also led to increased activity in specific regions of the brain that are important for the memory of emotional experiences.

The researchers also discovered that the TROVE2 gene is linked to the strength of traumatic memories.

I’ve explained my own circumstances to people as remembering every injury I’ve ever received and it sounds like it’s possible that characterization isn’t far from the truth.

2 comments

Making the Grade

I have been asked to grade President Trump’s first 100 days as president. Most such assessments are the opposite of analysis. They take a gut feeling and back analysis out of it.

What criteria should I use in making my evaluation and how should I weight them? The criteria that occur to me immediately are foreign policy, domestic policy, managing the transition, unifying the country, more or less in order of weight.

What else should I take into account? And what should their relative weights be?

8 comments

Looking for the Real Killer

There has been almost no end of complaints about how awful a president Donald Trump is. Unqualified. An oaf. Conflicts of interest. Nepotism. Russian influence. He didn’t release his tax returns. At Bloomberg View, in his catalogue of how bad the first 100 days of the Trump presidency has been, Jonathan Bernstein includes an insightful observation:

Republican party actors should have done whatever it took to defeat his nomination when they had the chance. Nominations matter, and none more so than the presidential nomination, and they are worth fighting — hard — over.

I would agree with it except for one thing. Is there actually anything that Republican party leaders could have done to prevent Trump’s securing the nomination?

I think they could have dissuaded any of the members of the very large field of candidates they cared to. That would have required them to unify behind one candidate early on. Who?

More than any president of my memory, Trump has been a self-made candidate. He was largely self-financing. There was no rallying ’round by Republican leaders, many of whom openly disdained him. They didn’t “fall in line” as Bill Clinton put it.

What steps on the part of the RNC could have prevented Donald Trump from securing the nominations? What could have prevented him from being elected president?

11 comments

Mining the Dirt

Here’s an interesting story from Nature. Apparently, researchers are beginning to mine the dirt of ancient caves for human DNA:

Bones and teeth aren’t the only ways to learn about extinct human relatives. For the first time, researchers have recovered ancient-human DNA without having obvious remains — just dirt from the caves the hominins lived in. The technique opens up a new way to probe prehistory.

From sediments in European and Asian caves, a team led by geneticist Viviane Slon and molecular biologist Matthias Meyer, both at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, Germany, sequenced genomes of cell structures called mitochondria from Neanderthals and another hominin group, the Denisovans. Their work is published in Science.

That highlights a point I think I’ve made before about treasure-hunters. Schliemann wasn’t a scientist or a hero. He was a vandal.

1 comment