Should the Fed’s Mandate Be Changed?

While I agree with the premise of a recent New York Times editorial—that federal government and Federal Reserve policies should do more to promote wage growth:

Cutting taxes on the wealthy, especially by rescinding health insurance for millions, and deregulating Wall Street — the centerpieces of the Trump agenda — help those who need no help while depriving the government of resources that could help create well-paying jobs and bolster people’s incomes. Such trickle-down economics encourages business polices that make the work force less secure.

At the same time, the Federal Reserve, apparently concluding that the economy is at or near “full employment,” appears ready to cool it down with still higher interest rates. The thought is that the jobless rate, 4.3 percent, cannot go any lower without causing excessive inflation — even though economic growth has been modest, job growth has slowed in recent months, and inflation remains below the Fed’s 2 percent target.

The upshot is that both fiscal and monetary policy are moving in ways to inhibit wage growth when it is desperately needed.

there are issues with the means that they advocate and with their criticism of the Federal Reserve in particular. The Federal Reserve has multiple mandates but raising wages isn’t one of them. What is generally called “the dual mandate” consists of maintaining stable prices and maximizing employment. Those objectives may be at odds but aren’t necessarily so.

Wages are the price of labor. Giving the Fed the mandate of raising wages would give the Fed the directly contradictory objectives of maintaining stable wage rates and increasing wage rates. I think there are very good arguments for changing the Fed’s mandate but that’s probably not the direction in which the mandate should be changed. For example, I wish the Fed would devote much, much more attention to regulating banks, something outside the dual mandate but part of its responsibilities nonetheless, than it does now. If the Fed hadn’t been asleep at the switch, the financial crisis might never have happened. A decade after the crisis how many banks remain insolvent? Insolvency is the dirty little secret of our banking system.

Will the NYT editors’ preferred strategy for increasing wages, raising the minimum wage to $15, increase aggregate wages? The argument that it will appears to be unique to the editors of the New York Times. The argument has been that it will benefit those who earn minimum wage, something that’s obviously true, but I don’t think it’s nearly as obvious that raising the minimum wage will increase aggregate wages. That depends on several factors including both employment effects and multipliers and I don’t believe that either I or the editors of the New York Times know.

About .7% of workers earn at or below minimum wage but 42% of workers earn below $15/hour. The employment effects of a $15 minimum wage would probably be negligible in San Francisco but it could throw thousands or millions of workers who don’t work in San Francisco out of work. I just don’t know.

2 comments

Wasn’t There a Television Series About This?

Imagine that there as a cyberweapon that could shut down the power grid. If this article at The Washington Post is to be believed, the Russians have one:

Hackers allied with the Russian government have devised a cyberweapon that has the potential to be the most disruptive yet against electric systems that Americans depend on for daily life, according to U.S. researchers.

The malware, which researchers have dubbed CrashOverride, is known to have disrupted only one energy system — in Ukraine in December. In that incident, the hackers briefly shut down one-fifth of the electric power generated in Kiev.

But with modifications, it could be deployed against U.S. electric transmission and distribution systems to devastating effect, said Sergio Caltagirone, director of threat intelligence for Dragos, a cybersecurity firm that studied the malware and issued a report on Monday.

And Russian government hackers have already shown their interest in targeting U.S. energy and other utility systems, researchers said.

“It’s the culmination of over a decade of theory and attack scenarios,” Caltagirone warned. “It’s a game changer.”

There are several things that should always be kept in mind about cyberweapons:

  1. Developing genuinely sophisticated cyberweapons is expensive. It’s not something that a clever kid will do in his spare time in his mom’s basement.
  2. That means it requires state sponsorship.
  3. Once you’ve released a cyberweapon into the wild, it’s in the wild. Your control over where it goes then and what may be done with it is greatly diminished.
  4. It’s a lot cheaper to reverse engineer a sophisticated cyberweapon than it is to develop one in the first place. It is something that can be done by a clever kid working in her spare time in her dad’s basement.

Remember that global ransomware attack that took place last month? Multiple reports say that that the malware used started out in life as something created by a government, assumed to be North Korea. It was then adapted by private individuals for their own nefarious purposes and the rest is criminal history.

That’s why I think that, although researching new, sophisticated malware techniques makes sense for us as well as for the Russians, actually using them borders them on the insane. By the very nature of our society we are extremely vulnerable to attack. Why give more people the weapons to do it with than is absolutely necessary?

1 comment

Replacing Old Technology With Worse Technology

Back in 2014 I purchased a Kindle HD color tablet/reader. I don’t recall the exact model number—I think it’s called a “Third Generation”. It’s given me excellent service; I couldn’t be more pleased with it.

As is generally the case with this sort of technology little by little its battery is holding a charge for an ever shorter period. Now it needs to be recharged roughly every other day whether used or not as long as it’s powered on which is most of the time.

I’ve looked at the successor products from Amazon and at every tablet on the market and I’m saddened to report that they’re all inferior. None of them have the screen resolution of my three year old Kindle. And it’s not a minor difference. Most of the tablets have screen resolutions half that of my old Kindle. The best have three quarters its resolution. It’s clear to me that keeping my old tablet is a better choice for me than replacing it with the latest and allegedly greatest.

I’m not sure what I’ll do when my Kindle HD nears the end of its battery life. I’ve looked at the instructions on Youtube for replacing the battery and, while I could do it, I’ll probably seek out someone more adroit than I to change it for me. It’s a tedious, involved, exacting process and one better suited for younger eyes than mine.

I’m not sure what the point of this post is. Maybe it’s just to air a grievance. Maybe it’s to disabuse any of you of the notion that technology is always replaced with better technology. That simply isn’t so. I could present a dozen examples of that. This is only the latest.

11 comments

What About Puerto Rico?

Over the weekend a handful of Puerto Rican voters bothered to show up at the polls and voted overwhelmingly for statehood. CNN reports:

(CNN)Puerto Ricans who voted for US statehood in a non-binding referendum Sunday are “claiming our equal rights as American citizens,” Puerto Rico’s governor says.

Ninety-seven percent of the votes favored statehood but voter participation was just 23% after opposition parties called for a boycott of what they called a “rigged” process in part over the ballot language.

Congress, the only body that can approve new states, will ultimately decide whether the status of the US commonwealth changes.

“It will be up to this new generation of Puerto Ricans to demand and claim in Washington the end of the current improper colonial relationship, and begin a transition process to fully incorporate Puerto Rico as the next state of the Union,” Governor Ricardo Rosselló of the pro-statehood New Progressive Party said in a statement Sunday.

This is obviously kabuki. Some of the Puerto Rican people are still hoping that the mainland will bail them out and if they make nice it will make it more likely. The rest know it’s not going to happen.

As a state Puerto Rico would make an uncomfortable fit. Most of its people are primarily Spanish-speaking. While its per capita GDP isn’t bad, its income inequality is such that the reality of life there is of a handful of wealthy and a lot of very poor people. Its Gini coefficient is much higher than that of any of the states. It’s more like Colombia than it is like Mississippi.

3 comments

Mounting the Tiger

I strongly recommend that you read this interview with Dani Rodrik at Talking Points Memo. Here are some little snippets from it:

Judis: During his campaign and presidency, Donald Trump has made a big issue of America’s trade deficit, and singled out China, Mexico, and Germany for blame. When Trump was in Europe recently, he attacked the Germans for having a trade surplus. He even threatened to block German car exports to the United States. Is there any basis for Trump’s complaints?

Rodrik: Like most everything with Trump, I think there is a significant element of truth in the causes that he picks up. He is addressing some real grievances. But then the manner in which he addresses them is completely bonkers.

I couldn’t agree with that more.

Judis: Are you saying that in the ‘90s, the United States should have been much more wary and cautious when it helped to found the main international trade group, the World Trade Organization (WTO), in 1995?

Rodrik: A lot of wrong turns were taken in the 1990s. The WTO had some good things in it, but as a trade regime, it exemplifies global overreach. It tries to fix global standards for intellectual property rights, industrial policies, and various health and safety regulations.

A key problem is that many of the countries in the world, notably China, simply do not have the civil infrastructure to regulate intellectual property rights. Believing that they could is an error of titanic proportions.

Read the whole thing. I think that he understates the degree to which large economies like Germany, China, and Japan maintaining mercantilist policies pose a problem.

4 comments

It’s Not a “Western Diet”

Chris Weller’s article at Business Insider on the changes in the way some of the Chinese eat illustrates a number of my pet peeves. Here’s the kernel of his thesis, the meat of it so to speak:

Over the past two decades, China’s prevailing diet has shifted away from grains like rice and wheat in favor of richer animal proteins and a wider variety of exotic vegetables. As Bloomberg reports, this change has left the country short of land on which to grow produce and raise livestock.

While the Western diet typically demands about one acre per person, China has only 0.2 acres to devote to feeding each citizen. Meanwhile, the country consumes 50% of the world’s total pork supply.

“The rapid rate of industrialization in China is really chewing up crop land at an alarming rate,” Lester Brown, founder and president of the Earth Institute, told Reuters. “China is now losing cropland.

He goes on to assert that from a global standpoint the only way to “ease the global burden” is to eat less meat.

Now I’ll air some of my pet peeves:

  1. Investigation of human settlements over the period of the last more than 10,000 years has demonstrated conclusively that human beings always and everywhere seek out the food source with the highest level of available fat in the environment. I don’t know whether characterizing that as the “Western diet” is simple lack of information, stupidity, or self-hate but there you have it. The notion that we will change what we have evolved to prefer through force of will is not well-founded.
  2. There is no such thing as a “Western diet”. For a pictorial illustration of that see this article. Thinking there is such a thing as a Western diet is either solipsism, ignorance, or agenda-driven.
  3. There isn’t even such a thing as the American diet. Over the period of the last 60 years there have been drastic changes in what Americans eat and those changes haven’t been in the direction of eating more meat. We consume much, much more sugar than we did 60 years ago, much more processed food, and much more hydrogenated fat.
  4. The changes in what the Chinese eat is being driven a lot more by what a relative handful of well-heeled city dwellers eat than what all of the Chinese eat. A little more than half of the Chinese for the first time in history are now urban.

There is such a thing as mass-produced and mass-marketed food. That’s what’s being turned to all over the world, not just here and in China.

I do think it’s a problem, not just for the “global burden” but for our health. I can think of any number of solutions but I can’t imagine any of their being adopted.

1 comment

Musing

I wonder if it’s occurred to those who saw the British election as the rejection of populism that the Tories joining with the DUP to form a government is the opposite of that. The DUP could be the most populist party in the United Kingdom.

0 comments

Kling on the Class War

Arnold Kling makes a prediction about the coming “synthesis” between the elites and the populists:

My first thought is national socialism. It needs another name, because of all the Hitler/holocaust baggage, but here is why it makes sense.

The nationalism would include immigration restrictions, protection of “culturally significant industry” (e.g., wine in France), and cultural pride. This would appeal to the anti-Bobos. The socialism part, which requires technocratic management of economic outcomes, would appeal to the Bobos.

To get to national socialism in the U.S., the left would have to give up its attachment to multiculturalism and the right would have to give up its attachment to free markets (which Alberto Mingardi says has happened). Right now, it is easier for me to imagine the latter than the former, but maybe if the left loses one more election that could change.

Two thoughts occur to me. The first is that there is no such thing as a “Hegelian synthesis”. The notion of thesis and antithesis leading to synthesis belongs to Kant. The Hegelian dialectic is something quite different and much more complex.

The second is that I think that Dr. Kling misunderstands all sides of the conversation. Among some of those in the conversation a rejection of American culture and society is not an incidental component of what they want to accomplish. It’s the heart of it. No compromise is possible on that.

I don’t believe that what Dr. Kling refers to as “national socialism” is the most likely outcome. I think that nihilism is the most likely synthesis

4 comments

Comparing Four Cities

You might mistake what Justin Fox’s recent Bloomberg View article is in reading its title, “The Stanley Cup and NBA Finals of Economic Performance”, thinking it’s an article about sports. It actually compares the performance of four U. S. cities, San Francisco, Nashville, Cleveland, and Pittsburgh, in three different regions of the country over the period of the last 20 years. Sports is just the “hook” of the story.

I found the graph above very interesting and puzzling. There’s a clear point of inflection for each of the cities in August of 2009. The reason for that is obvious enough: economic recovery. The recovery began in June and by August was well under way in all three regions (West, South or Mid-South, Midwest).

What interested me in that graph was two factors. First, the angles of the lines for San Francisco and Nashville are the same. Second, the angles of the lines for the other two cities, Cleveland and Pittsburgh, are different from the other two and from each other. Why?

The pat answer for San Francisco’s rapid growth in employment would be the tech sector but the growth rate being in lockstep with Nashville’s suggests that’s inadequate at the very least and likely to be just plain wrong.

I’m open to suggestions but the explanation that occurs to me is the increasing financialization of the U. S. economy. Both San Francisco and Nashville are major centers for the banking and financial services industries while Cleveland and Pittsburgh aren’t.

While the ongoing consolidation of the banking and financial services sector of the economy may be good for the top management of the sector and for a few places around the country, I don’t believe the country as a whole is well-served by it. I think we’d be better off with smaller, regional banks who focused on their own territories.

One thing to think about. Is that consolidation reacting to the growth of megalopolises or promoting it or both?

9 comments

Failed State

At Politico Natasha Korecki outlines the political malfeasance that has resulted in Illinois failing to enact a budget for the state in three years and Illinois’s having the worst credit rating of any state and a declining population:

What does the crisis all boil down to? It began with an ego-laden brawl between two powerful men: Rauner and Democratic House Speaker Mike Madigan. Rauner was elected in 2014 as the first Republican governor in Illinois in more than a decade, vowing to “shake up Springfield” in a campaign that demonized Madigan — the longest serving House speaker in state history — and targeted “corrupt union bosses.”

Upon taking office, Rauner, a multi-millionaire businessman, laid out a list of policy demands that initially included right to work elements, as a condition of signing a budget into law. Rauner wanted changes to laws affecting workers compensation, collective bargaining and state property taxes, among others. Democrats considered the agenda an attack on unions, which the governor had vilified, saying they had too much power in Illinois politics. Rauner called the measures pro-business, and necessary to address decades of financial mismanagement.

But Madigan, who has served as speaker under governors from both political parties, was loathe to condition the passage of a budget on the governor’s political agenda. Each side dug in, with unions rushing behind Madigan and Republicans, tired of being shut out for years by Madigan and thrilled to have a generous donor to their campaigns in the governor’s office, lined up behind Rauner.

Today, Madigan’s Democratic-majority House and the Republican governor remain entrenched in the war to end all political wars. The exception is the Democratic-controlled Senate, which ultimately voted on a tax increase before May 31 adjournment.

Both Rauner and Madigan counted on the other to cave. Neither has. Meantime, the state is drowning in debt, deficit spending and multiple bond rating downgrades.

Until November the Democrats controlled both houses of the Illinois legislature with veto-proof majorities. To blame the impasse equally on Rauner and Madigan or on Republicans and Democrats is sophistry, pure and simple. The Democrats have offered no solution to Illinois’s problems other than continued borrowing and higher taxes, the strategy that put us in our present situation in the first place.

What should happen is that Speaker Madigan should offer Gov. Rauner some face-saving concession, they should join arms, and start working to solve Illinois’s problems. Expecting Gov. Rauner to abandon any reform of Illinois’s system is simply unreasonable.

But that’s their strategy and their sticking to it.

0 comments