I didn’t post on the shooting incident in Alexandria, Virginia yesterday in which several Congressmen and staffers were injured because I didn’t think that flash reactions were appropriate, that waiting until most of the facts were in was the best response. In my opinion Sen. Bernie Sanders, reacting to the news that the shooter had worked on his campaign, responded well:
“I have just been informed that the alleged shooter at the Republican baseball practice is someone who apparently volunteered on my presidential campaign. I am sickened by this despicable act. And let me be as clear as I can be. Violence of any kind is unacceptable in our society, and I condemn this action in the strongest possible terms. Real change can only come about through nonviolent action, and anything else runs against our most deeply held American values.
My hopes and prayers are that Representative Scalise, congressional staff and the Capitol Police Officers who were wounded make a quick and full recovery. I also want to thank the Capitol Police for their heroic actions to prevent further harm.â€
Those who went an inch beyond that statement to promote their own political agendas are contributing to a problem which is already, obviously, growing out of control. Angry, inflamed, inappropriate rhetoric should stop on all sides. We are not on a good path.
Here’s a post that conjoins two of the topics of recent posts: pensions and Medicare. Here in the United States and Europe we’re working as hard as we can to rack up bills and pass them along to the coming generations. Satyajit Das declaims at Bloomberg View:
This growing burden on future generations can be measured. Rising dependency ratios — or the number of retirees per employed worker — provide one useful metric. In 1970, in the U.S., there were 5.3 workers for every retired person. By 2010 this had fallen to 4.5, and it’s expected to decline to 2.6 by 2050. In Germany, the number of workers per retiree will decrease to 1.6 in 2050, down from 4.1 in 1970. In Japan, the oldest society to have ever existed, the ratio will decrease to 1.2 in 2050, from 8.5 in 1970. Even as spending commitments grow, in other words, there will be fewer and fewer productive adults around to fund them.
Budgetary analysis presents a similarly dire outlook. In a 2010 research paper, entitled “Ask Not Whether Governments Will Default, But How,†Arnaud Mares of Morgan Stanley analyzed national solvency, or the difference between actual and potential government revenue, on one hand, and existing debt levels and future commitments on the other. The study found that by this measure the net worth of the U.S. was negative 800 percent of its GDP; that is, its future tax revenue was less than committed obligations by an amount equivalent to eight times the value of all goods and services America produces in a year. The net worth of European countries ranged from about negative 250 percent (Italy) to negative 1,800 percent (Greece). For Germany, France and the U.K., the approximate figures were negative 500 percent, negative 600 percent and negative 1,000 percent of GDP. In effect, these states have mortgaged themselves beyond their capacity to easily repay.
In the United States statistically workers receive slightly less in benefits from the Social Security system than they pay in as payroll taxes. The situation is reversed for Medicare. We receive much more in benefits from the program than we ever paid in. Or, more precisely, our health care providers receive more in benefits than we paid in. Our own benefits vary widely.
One of the proposals for rectifying the problem, importing a labor force, is just another form of kicking the can down the road. Unless those foreign workers are here illegally and not paying into the Social Security or Medicare programs, eventually they’ll be eligible for benefits, too, saddling future generations with an ever-larger tab. There’s a better argument for legal workers who earn right around FICA max but that’s still problematic.
Sshhh! If we’re very careful, maybe the younger generation won’t notice.
Pennsylvania is ending defined benefit pension plans for public school teachers and state public employees. From CNNMoney:
Governor Tom Wolf signed a bill Monday, making it the ninth state to replace the pension with a “hybrid” retirement plan. It goes into effect in 2019.
The new plan combines elements of a traditional pension and a 401(k)-style account.
Overall, new workers will contribute more of their salary, work longer, and likely receive a smaller payout in retirement than under the current system, according to a report from the state’s Independent Fiscal Office.
But Pennsylvania’s pension system is currently one of the most underfunded in the country and is in need of reform. The bill had bipartisan support.
I presume I don’t need to tell you which state has the worst underfunded public pension fund. That only nine states have adopted these “hybrid” plans tells you how difficult they are politically.
Not only is this an idea whose time has come it’s an idea whose time is long overdue. At this point only 4% of U. S. companies offer defined benefit pension plans only. Another 14% offer hybrids. The overwhelming preponderance of company pensions these days are 401(K)s.
The Illinois legislature has been raiding the public pension plans for decades. So has the Chicago City Council. That’s not the only reason that Illinois and Chicago are in such bad fiscal shape but it’s an important one. Politicians can resist everything except temptation and those pension funds were wearing such short skirts.
Expect more states to do the unthinkable and behave more like the private sector.
When I read this article at Reuters, reporting that President Trump had authorized the Pentagon to determine the troop levels necessary in Afghanistan:
U.S. President Donald Trump has given Defense Secretary Jim Mattis the authority to set troop levels in Afghanistan, a U.S. official told Reuters on Tuesday, opening the door for future troop increases requested by the U.S. commander.
The official, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said no immediate decision had been made about the troop levels, which are now set at about 8,400.
The Pentagon declined to comment.
The decision is similar to one announced in April that applied to U.S. troop levels in Iraq and Syria, and came as Mattis warned Congress the U.S.-backed Afghan forces were not beating the Taliban despite more than 15 years of war.
“We are not winning in Afghanistan right now,” Mattis said in testimony to the Senate Armed Services Committee earlier on Tuesday. “And we will correct this as soon as possible.”
it occurred to me that I couldn’t remember an instance of the Pentagon ever determining that more troops were being deployed than circumstances warranted. Can anyone? Presumably, we can expect more troops sent to Afghanistan soon.
It’s not merely that we’re not “winning in Afghanistan”. It’s that after fifteen years and several thousand U. S. casualties the situation in Afghanistan is actually deteriorating:
The Afghan government was assessed by the U.S. military to control or influence just 59.7 percent of Afghanistan’s 407 districts as of Feb. 20, a nearly 11 percentage-point decrease from the same time in 2016, according to data released by the U.S. Special Inspector General for Afghanistan Reconstruction.
I would be more comfortable with increasing troop levels in Afghanistan if I thought the counter-insurgency objective presently being pursued there were achievable. I don’t. I think it’s a fool’s errand.
Dog owners often say the best thing about dogs is their unconditional love.
But new research suggests there’s another benefit, too. Dog owners walk more.
In a study published Monday in the journal BMC Public Health, dog owners on average walked 22 minutes more per day compared to people who didn’t own a dog.
And they weren’t just dawdling.
“Not only did we see an increase in exercise, but also the exercise was at a moderate pace,” explains study author Daniel Mills of the University of Lincoln, in the United Kingdom.
I walk my dogs three to five miles a day, 365 days a year, regardless of snow nor rain nor heat nor gloom of night.
From time to time I’ve used the phrase “American civil religion” here at The Glittering Eye. If you’ve been curious or skeptical about the phrase, this piece by Walter A. McDougall at The American Interest puts the idea into some historical context and provides some intellectual heft:
Gorski labels its dominant strain “prophetic republicanism,†which he describes as a more nuanced version of what Bellah called civic republicanism or covenantal religion back in the 1970s. More nuanced because the loudest voices today no longer emanate from the “vital center†of ACR, but rather from two of its extremes. The first trumpets religious nationalism, a toxic brew of apocalyptic zeal, which idolizes the United States as a uniquely virtuous Christian nation endowed by Almighty God with a mission to battle falsehood and evil until the end times. The other trumpets radical secularism, a toxic blend of cultural elitism and militant atheism, which damns the United States as a deeply flawed nation that progressive politics can fix only if atavistic religion is driven from the public square. The upshot, Gorski contends, has been a polarizing culture war that has tormented Americans at least since the 1990s. In other words, the author does not see ACR declining so much as evolving, but also drifting ever further into polarized and polarizing heterodoxy.
If Chesterton was right and the United States is a “country founded on a creed”, without ties of blood or shared history we need that civil religion to bind us together and neither of those two polarized versions will do the trick.
For now, Medicare is not part of the national conversation on health care. While campaigning, Donald Trump promised not to touch Medicare, and, in his first budget, he basically kept that commitment to voters. In addition, Congress and the new administration are consumed with rolling back key elements of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and replacing them with different provisions. Medicare does not feature prominently in that debate.
was to wonder what planet he’s been on? While it may be the case that the Congressional Republicans want to ignore Medicare because they don’t care to engage in failure-oriented activities, it’s certainly part of the “national conversation”. I suggest googling “Medicare for all” to get an idea.
That is not to argue that Medicare for all is workable or economically practical or even politically possible. But just because you don’t want to talk about something does not mean it’s not being talked about.
As students of Soviet naval doctrine, the Chinese People’s Liberation Army (PLA) and Navy (PLAN) have adopted an A2/AD [ed. antiaccess/area denial] approach to the United States in the Pacific (Chinese military strategists term the concept “counter-intervention doctrineâ€). 2 Following the success of the United States in Operation Desert Storm and advancements in precision strike by air and naval assets, China’s military strategy focused on preventing a similar scenario from playing out near its shores. Although China has drastically increased its navy’s blue-water capabilities over the past decade, the PLAN currently has no intention of facing the U.S. Navy in the open ocean. Recent developments in the South China Sea reveal the challenges the United States will face in any future conflict and the role naval intelligence must play to accurately assess the threat and provide creative and effective solutions.
His proposed strategy consists of the following bullet points:
Increase Maritime Domain Awareness.
Improve Regional A2/AD Capabilities.
Expand Intelligence Sharing with Key Partners.
I suspect he doesn’t realize how revolutionary that strategy would be. For the last 70 years we’ve pursued a strategy of carrying all the weight ourselves for weak allies. That worked as long as our economy was growing robustly. It doesn’t look nearly as sustainable now.
My questions are twofold. First, would it work? The Chinese have read Thucydides. They see themselves in the role of the rising power. They also appear to believe that foreign policy like trade are zero sum games, i.e. for them to win we have to lose.
Second, is it necessary? I think the Chinese are playing the world’s highest stakes game of brinksmanship. Maybe my knowledge is dated but I think the Chinese are punching above their weight. We should assess their actual capabilities and act appropriately.
While I have a great deal of sympathy with Jeffrey Harding’s conclusion, expressed in his post at An Independent Mind, that our infrastructure deficiencies and the prospects for an infrastructure-building program’s giving the economy a boost are grossly exaggerated:
Here is the reality: America’s infrastructure is not crumbling, massive spending won’t create any permanent jobs, and productivity is not suffering because of our infrastructure. These are economic myths that lobbyists, infrastructure contractors, and the ASCE perpetuate to get fat contracts.
and I find his method, pointing out the mismatch between the gravest problems and the supposed benefits, interesting:
If the ASCE’s assumption that poor infrastructure is impeding progress, then we should look at the LA metropolitan area where traffic congestion is the worst in the world to see if they are correct. Based on their logic, LA’s economy should be suffering. But it is not. In fact, if you compare LA’s GDP to the rise in total US GDP, LA’s upward trend is almost identical if not rising even faster.
Sadly, it suffers from a failing known as the tertium non datur fallacy. It fails to acknowledge that it is possible that Los Angeles has the worst infrastructure in the country but that it is growing rapidly economically due to other factors.
I think he’s tilting at windmills here. There’s a substantial fraction of Americans and also a substantial fraction of economists who believe that how you spend money is unimportant as long as you spend enough of it in terms of boosting the economy. They will not be dissuaded.
My own view is that when national economies were more like little islands, your income and mine were more closely linked, and the U. S. was a developing country rather than a developed one, the prospects for Keynesian stimulus being effective were much better. Now when a poorly constructed and dilatory stimulus bill finally passes the Congress it’s far more likely to crowd out private investment than should have been the case, because so much of what we buy comes from China or elsewhere, and because the spending tends to be concentrated in so few hands the best case is probably that fiscal stimulus in the United States will stimulate the economy in Shenzhen or Bangalore.